Skip to main content

Employment of Alien Workers – Update

We previously reported on the employment of alien workers in two Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP Legal Alerts.  

The first report1 discussed the New York Court of Appeals ruling in the Balbulena Case 2, where the court ruled that an injured undocumented alien worker, who did not tender false work identification documents to obtain employment, could sue for lost wages under the state Labor Law.  The employer in that case failed to verify whether the worker had any work authorization documentation. We posed the question to our readers whether they knew if their general liability insurance policies would cover them in an injured undocumented alien worker situation.  

The second report3 discussed the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (“IRCA”).  The IRCA prohibits employers from knowingly hiring non-citizens who are not authorized to be in the U.S.  Employers are required to verify the identity and work eligibility of all employees, including U.S. citizens, by completing Department of Homeland Security Form I-9.  Workers who fail to comply with the instructions on Form I-9 cannot be hired.  Employers who do not comply with IRCA are subject to administrative fines and criminal prosecution.  I-9 forms are available on the internet.  Once completed, I-9 forms are kept by the employer and must be made available for inspection by authorized government officials from the Department of Homeland Security, the Department of Labor, and the Office of Special Counsel for Immigration-Related Unfair Employment Practices. Employers may but are not required to photocopy the identification document(s) presented by the worker when the I-9 form is completed.  If photocopies are made they must be kept by the employer with the I-9 form.

More recently the courts have considered what happens when an employer hires an alien worker who submits false identification and work eligibility documents and is injured while working.  

In New York, a worker’s submission of false documentation is sufficient to shield the employer from the injured workers claim for lost wages provided the employer was induced by the false documentation to hire that worker.  

In the Coque Case4, the injured worker submitted a false social security card to the employer, who accepted the document and hired the worker.  The employer, however, did not follow the instructions accompanying the I-9 form.  Where a social security card is offered by a worker, the  I-9 form instructions require a second valid form of identification.  Because the employer failed to ask for the second form of identification, the Court ruled that the employer had not fulfilled its duty to verify the employee’s documentation and therefore the employer was not falsely induced to employ the worker despite the submission of false documentation.  Thus, the illegal alien worker could recover damages for lost wages resulting from the workplace injury. 

In the Macedo Case5 a worker presented the employer with a driver’s license, a union card, a tax ID card and what turned out to be a false social security card.  Months after the worker was injured while working, the employer completed the I-9 form.  Because of the employer’s tardiness in completing the I-9 form, the Court ruled that the employer was not induced to hire the worker by his presentation of a false social security card and the injured worker could recover damages for lost wages.

These court decisions send a clear message to employers. For an employer to avoid liability for lost wages sought by an injured illegal alien worker, the employer must show that it was induced to hire that worker based upon his or her presentation of false identification and work eligibility documents.  To do that the employer must establish that when it hired the worker it promptly completed the I-9 form and that it followed all of the instructions describing the type of documentation that must be presented.  The employer should also consider keeping a copy of the document(s) presented when the I-9 form is completed.  

Further, as demonstrated by the Macedo Case where the worker presented a union card, just because you may run a union shop, don’t think you are immune from verifying the worker’s eligibility for employment.  Check your Collective Bargaining Agreement.  Does the union verify the work eligibility of the workers it sends to your projects?   

So what should you consider doing to protect your business?

First, develop an employee identification and work verification program and include it as part of your overall employment manual – and follow it.  Your attorney can help you put together an employment manual if you do not already have one or need to update it.  Also, promptly verify the eligibility of all your employees by completing an I-9 form for each and be sure to follow the instructions specifying the identification documents your workers are required to present to establish identity and employment authorization.  Maintain the I-9 form and copy of the identification documents in your file for that employee.  

Second, speak with your insurance agent about your general liability insurance policy.  Find out whether it covers you against alien workers lost wages claims.  Find out whether your general liability policy has requirement(s) for completing I-9 forms for your workers and fulfill the requirements of your policy.

This alert provides general information only.  It is not intended to provide legal advice.  We encourage you to contact an attorney should you desire to discuss specific situations for which you may need legal advice. 

1 Legal Alert ” Volume 1, #4 (Found at Welby Brady & Greenblatt, LLP’s website, www.wbgllp.com)
2 Balbuena v. IDR Realty LLC, 6 N.Y.3d 338, 812 N.Y.S.2d 416 (2006)
3 WBG Legal Alert – Volume 1, #8 (Found at Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP’s website, www.wbgllp.com)
4 Coque v. Wildflower Estates Developers Inc., 58 A.D.3d 44, 867 N.Y.S.2d 158 (2nd Dept. 2008)
5 Macedo v. J.D. Posillico Inc., 68 A.D.3d 508, 891 N.Y.S.2d 46 (1st Dept. 2009)

Greener, Greater Buildings Plan: Benchmarking, Lighting Upgrades, and Sub-Metering Requirements

As part of the “Greener, Greater Buildings Plan” legislation, the New York City Council adopted two new laws aimed at reducing the energy used in buildings.  The Council found that non-residential lighting is responsible for about one fifth of the energy used in New York City’s buildings and of the carbon emissions from buildings.  In light of recent improvements in technology, the Council found that energy use can be reduced if data is made available to tenants for comparison and by requiring the installation of lighting upgrades.  The new laws require building performance benchmarking, lighting upgrades, and sub-metering as part of a comprehensive plan to reduce the consumption of energy.  

With some exceptions, these laws apply to “covered buildings” which are defined as: 

i. a building that exceeds 50,000 gross square feet (4645 m2),  

ii. two or more buildings on the same tax lot that together exceed 100,000 gross square feet, or  

iii. two or more buildings held in the condominium form of ownership that are governed by the same board of managers and that together exceed 100,000 gross square feet. 

Generally, the laws do not apply to one, two, and three family residential properties.1   

Benchmarking Energy and Water Use (Administrative Code of the City of New York § 28-309.1 
e t a l . )  

This law became effective immediately and requires benchmarking of energy2and water use in city buildings3 and “covered buildings.”  Benchmarking is accomplished by inputting and submitting into an internet-based database system the total use of energy and water for a building for the previous calendar year and other descriptive information for the building4 Owners of “covered buildings” who must request energy use information from tenants of separately-metered, non- dwelling units. Starting with the second calendar year of benchmarking data, the Department of Finance must make the following information, generated by the benchmarking tool, available to the public on the internet: (i) the energy utilization index, (ii) the water use per gross square foot, (iii) where available, a rating that compares the energy and water use of the building to that of similar buildings, and (iv) a comparison of data across calendar years for any years such building was benchmarked. 5   

The benchmarking and disclosure requirements commence on the dates listed in the following table:   

Annual Benchmarking and Disclosure Requirements  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  City Building Covered Building
Benchmarking For Previous Calendar Yr. No later than May 1, 2010 and no later than May 1st thereafter No later than May 1, 2011 and no later than May 1st thereafter
Period to Request Information from Separately-Metered Tenant5    January 1, 2011 to January 31, 2011 and every January 1st to January 31st thereafter
Deadline for Tenant to Provide Information    February 15, 2011 and every February 15th thereafter
Disclosure by the Department of Finance of the Previous Calendar Year’s Benchmarking
No later than September 1, 2011
If Primary Use is not Residential: No later than
Data  and no later than every September 1st thereafter September 1, 2012  and no later than every September 1st thereafter If Primary Use is Residential: No later than September 1, 2013  and no later than every September 1st thereafter


Owners of “covered buildings” must maintain records including energy and water bills and reports or forms received from tenants for a period of three years.  The legislators envision that some or all of the reporting will eventually be uploaded directly by the utility companies or the Department of Environmental Protection (“DEP”).  An owner and/or tenant may not be required to request and report benchmarking information where information is uploaded directly to the benchmarking tool by a utility company or other authorized source.  The DEP must upload directly to the benchmarking tool information on water use at all buildings that are equipped with automatic meter reading equipment by the DEP.    
Lighting Upgrades and Sub-Metering  (Administrative Code of the City of New York §§ 28-310.1 et al. and 28-311.1 e t a l .)   
This law requires that lighting systems of “covered buildings” be upgraded to comply with the standards for new systems set forth in § 805 of the New York City Energy Conservation Code on or prior to January 1, 2025.  The necessary upgrade includes the following elements:  lighting controls (interior lighting control, light reduction controls and automatic lighting shutoff), tandem wiring, exit signs, interior lighting power requirements and exterior lighting.  No upgrade is required for certain lighting systems including, among others, systems within certain dwelling units or common spaces of certain dwelling units (i.e. hallways, 
laundry rooms, or boiler rooms).   
The law also requires that electrical consumption of each covered tenant space must be measured by one or more sub-meters on or prior to January 1, 2025.  No sub-meters are required for certain buildings including, among others, dwelling units classified in occupancy groups R-2 and R-3.  
An owner or lessor must install these sub-meters on or prior to January 1, 2025 and thereafter as new tenant spaces are created within the building.  
Covered tenant spaces include: 
i. A tenant space larger than 10,000 gross square feet (929 m2) on one or more floors of a covered building let or sublet to the same person, or  
ii. a floor of a covered building larger than 10,000 gross square feet (929 m2) consisting of tenant spaces let or sublet to two or more different persons. 
If the covered tenant space is a floor with multiple tenancies, each tenancy that is 10,000 gross square feet (929 m2) or less shall  
i. have a separate sub-meter,  
ii. share a sub-meter with other tenant spaces on the floor, or  
iii. share a sub-meter covering the entire floor. 
Each tenant or subtenant within a covered tenant space that has a sub-meter or sub-meters to measure electrical consumption must be provided with a monthly statement showing the amount of electricity measured by the sub-meter.    
The owner of the building is required to file a report prepared by a registered design professional or a licensed master or special electrician certifying that the electrical upgrade and sub-metering has been completed and complies with § 805.   
The “Greener, Greater Buildings Plan” aims at reducing the consumption of energy by taking advantage of rapid improvements in lighting technology and providing data on electrical energy use to tenants.  Giving building owners almost 
fifteen years to upgrade lighting systems and electrical metering seems reasonable and should avoid any hardship on owners who are required to install the new systems.   
This Legal Alert is supplied for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. You should consult competent legal counsel depending on the specific issues of your matter.  
1Consult Real Property Tax Law § 1802(1) (Class One) for a full definition of exempt property.  
2 “Energy” is defined as electricity, natural gas, fuel oil, and steam. 
3 With some exceptions, a “city building” is a building that is more than 10,000 square feet that is owned by the city or for which the city regularly pays all or part of the annual energy bills.   
4 The United States Environmental Protection Agency’s Benchmarking Tool is described at http://www.epa.gov/eeBuildings/benchmarking/detail/index.html#tool (last viewed March 26, 2010) and available at https://www.energystar.gov/istar/pmpam/ (last viewed March 26, 2010). 
5 Ratings generated by the benchmarking tool for a covered building that contains a data center, television studio, and/or trading floor that together exceed ten percent of the gross square footage of any such building shall not be disclosed until the office of long-term planning and sustainability determines that the benchmarking tool can make adequate adjustments for such facilities. 
6 Not applicable to separately-metered dwelling units.  

Construction law involves the unique application of many different general bodies of law to solve industry specific challenges. In today’s market, virtually all complex construction projects are affected by legal challenges.

CONSTRUCTION LAW & LITIGATION  

Construction law involves the unique application of many different general bodies of law to solve industry specific challenges. In today’s market, virtually all complex construction projects are affected by legal challenges. Efficient and experienced legal guidance assists all phases of any successful project.  

Our comprehensive construction law services include:  

    * Drafting and review of contract documents

    * Preparation of Project Specific Manuals to ensure timely compliance with contractual and statutory requirements  

* Representation in bidding & other procurement disputes  

  * Consultation on claims and claim avoidance techniques

    * Establishment of strong offensive and defensive positions in anticipation of litigated claims  

  * Development of innovative negotiation strategies for project completion and minimize claims exposure    

* Consultation on job-related problems, workouts, liens and default situations  

  * Navigation of OSHA-related issues including OSHA citations, informal conferences, notice of contest, expedited proceedings, administrative hearings and appeals  

  * Assisting clients pursue payments due by, for example, making bond claims and filing Mechanics’ Liens  

  * Assistance in selection and supervision of outside technical consultants to evaluate claims    

* Representation in trials, appeals, mediations, arbitration proceedings, contract responsibility determinations and debarments  

REAL ESTATE & LAND DEVELOPMENT  

The Tri-State area’s real estate landscape has become increasingly more complex through the implementation of new laws and regulations. We recognize these challenges and understand that personal attention is the cornerstone to navigating the New York real estate market.  

Our real estate development team handles:  

    * Sales, purchases, leases & option agreements involving shopping centers, apartment and office buildings, homes, cooperatives and condominium apartments  

  * Counseling in all areas of real estate financing    

* Preparation of construction-related contracts, both for private & governmental projects    

* Representation in trials, appeals, mediations and arbitrations concerning real estate controversies, rent escalation disputes, electrical auditing, eviction proceedings & other landlord-tenant issues  

EMPLOYMENT & LABOR PRACTICE GROUP  

Our Employment & Labor Practice Group works interactively with each of our other practice areas to advise our clients on a wide array of labor and employment matters. We are able to offer a full range of legal services that are integrated and tailored to meet the needs of each client.  

Our experience with labor & employment law includes:  

    * Day-to-day advice and counseling covering employee discharge & discipline, whistleblower claims, preparation of employee handbooks, preparing & negotiating employment agreements and collective bargaining  

  * Traditional labor-management relations including collective bargaining, union campaigns & strike preparation and union organizing  

  * Reviewing regulations concerning employee health & safety  

MEDIATION & ARBITRATION  

Mediation and arbitration are often less time-consuming, more cost-efficient dispute resolution tools. Our attorneys are trained in and have extensive experience as Mediators and Arbitrators for construction disputes.  

Our attorneys are qualified to handle private mediations and arbitrations as well as dispute resolution for the American Arbitration Association.  

About Welby, Brady & Greenblatt LLP Welby, Brady & Greenblatt LLP represents a wide range of entities within the construction and real estate industries including general contractors, subcontractors, sureties, developers, owners, suppliers, engineers, and home owners with core competencies, such as construction law and litigation, real estate development, labor law, OSHA compliance and mediation and arbitration. The firm is headquartered in White Plains, New York with offices in Cranford, New Jersey and Stamford, Connecticut. The firm’s website can be found at www.wbgllp.com.   

New EPA Rule Will Affect Owners and Contractors Performing Renovation, Repair or Painting Work.

New EPA Rule Will Affect Owners and Contractors Performing Renovation, Repair or Painting Work  

Alert:  

The EPA has issued a new rule which will affect owners and contractors performing renovation, repair, or painting work on housing, schools, or child-occupied facilities constructed prior to 1978.  Under the rule, which is aimed at minimizing lead exposure, certification must be obtained from the EPA prior to starting the work.  Certification involves an application process and requires a demonstrated understanding of lead-safe work practices.  Violators of the rule are subject to civil penalties of up to $25,000 per day and criminal sanctions of up to a year in prison.  

Summary:  

The EPA has issued a new rule, 40 C.F.R. §745.80 et. seq., effective April 2010, which will affect owners and contractors performing renovation, repair or painting work on housing, schools, or child-occupied facilities constructed prior to 1978.  Under the rule, which is aimed at minimizing lead exposure, certification must be obtained from the EPA prior to starting the work.  Certification involves an application process and requires a demonstrated understanding of lead-safe work practices.  Upon receipt of the certification application, the EPA has ninety (90) days within which to approve or reject the application.  

The applicability of the rule is presumed for each targeted project (i.e. the renovation, repair or painting of housing, schools, or child-occupied facilities constructed prior to 1978).  Accordingly, the need for certification is presumed for each targeted project.  However, the presumption can be rebutted by an inspector’s written determination stating that the components affected by the renovation are free of paint or other surface coatings containing lead.  The rule will also not apply to “minor maintenance or repairs,” which are defined as projects where less than six square feet of lead-based paint is disturbed per room on the interior of the building, or where less than 20 square feet of lead-based paint is disturbed on the exterior.  Notably, under the rule’s express terms, window replacement is not a “minor maintenance or repair.”  

The consequences of non-compliance can be severe.  Under the rule, the EPA Administrator is authorized to impose civil penalties of up to $25,000 per day and criminal sanctions of up to one year in prison for violations of the rule.  Contractors and owners engaged in renovating, repairing, or painting any of the targeted projects should 
take steps now to ensure compliance with the new rule prior to April of 2010.  

About Welby, Brady & Greenblatt LLP Welby, Brady & Greenblatt LLP represents a wide range of entities within the construction and real estate industries including general contractors, subcontractors, sureties, developers, owners, suppliers, engineers, and home owners with core competencies, such as construction law and litigation, real estate development, labor law, OSHA compliance and mediation and arbitration. The firm is headquartered in White Plains, New York with offices in Cranford, New Jersey and Stamford, Connecticut. The firm’s website can be found at www.wbgllp.com. 

The construction contracts act – 2009 amendments

The Construction Contracts Act (hereinafter the “Act”) went into effect on January 14, 2003.  On September 8, 2009 amendments to the Act became effective which will significantly impact the Act’s utility within the construction industry (hereinafter the “2009 Amendments”). Under the Act, all private construction contracts entered into after January 14, 2003, whether oral or written, where the aggregate amount of the construction project was $250,000.00 or more were subject to the Act. This threshold amount was reduced to $150,000.00 by the 2009 Amendments for private construction contracts entered into after September 8, 2009. Public works projects and contracts for the performance of work on public works projects will continue to be exempt from the Act’s provisions. In addition, certain residential projects and projects arising out of the events of September 11, 2001 are exempt from the Act.  

The intent of the legislature in passing the Act was to prevent unjust delays in payments to contractors and subcontractors working on private construction projects. The Act establishes remedies for the benefit of contractors and subcontractors if payments are not timely made in accordance with the Act. The bulk of the Act’s original provisions could be bypassed by carefully drafted contract provisions.  However, the 2009 Amendments strengthened the remedies set forth in the Act by voiding any contract provision affecting a construction contract which: (1) provides for payment provisions that are more stringent than those established in the Act or (2) bars one or both parties from the expedited arbitration remedy created by the 2009 Amendments.  The rights to interest payments, to suspend performance and to have New York Law govern the obligations of the parties and designating New York as the forum for any and all disputes continue to be requirements for all contracts subject to the Act. Notwithstanding the requirements of the Act, contracts/purchase orders with material suppliers may contain provisions requiring the application of the laws of another State or venue for disputes in a jurisdiction other than New York.  

The Act authorizes contractors and subcontractors to invoice for interim payments on a monthly basis. The party being invoiced, whether it is the owner, contractor or subcontractor, is required to approve or disapprove the invoice within twelve (12) business days of receipt of the invoice and all contractually required documentation, including partial waivers of lien. A party rejecting an invoice or any portion thereof must prepare a written statement outlining the item(s) which are rejected, the reasons why and 
the amount(s) being withheld because of the rejection. The Act recites a list of grounds that a party may raise when rejecting an invoice or any portion thereof. The sum of the withholdings are limited to amounts sufficient to cure and/or correct the defects and capped by the line item amount in the schedule of values, if previously submitted. In essence, the withholdings must be reasonable and can be based on contract provisions such as the owner’s rights to liquidated damages if the contract is not performed on time. However, the Act also provides that delays by anyone other than the invoicing party and/or its subcontractors and material suppliers shall not be a basis for withholding approval and payment of an application for payment.  

Payments are due no later than thirty (30) days from approval of an invoice or requisition. Per the 2009 Amendments, the timing for payment may no longer be altered in construction contracts covered by the Act. In situations involving subcontractors, payment is due, from the party with which it subcontracts, within seven days of that party’s receipt of good funds. Although not discussed here, the reader is also alerted to the fact that the Act contains provisions for situations when a lender is involved in financing all or part of the contract.  

A contractor or subcontractor must disclose to a subcontractor of any tier the dates when payment is expected or contractually mandated from the owner or contractor. If the contractor or subcontractor fails to furnish the required notice, then it will be concluded that the due dates or time periods adopted by the Act were complied with and payment will have to be made according to these adopted dates or time periods. Additionally, upon a written request from the subcontractor and within five (5) days of the request, the owner must provide the subcontractor with written notice of making any payments to the contractor.  

If payments are made beyond the due date, the party who owes the monies must pay interest at the rate of one percent (1%) per month or at a higher rate, if previously negotiated by the parties. In addition, the contractor may suspend performance without being in breach of the contract if a ten (10) day written notice is provided to the owner with an opportunity to cure, and the notice outlines the contractor’s intention to suspend performance because payments were not timely approved or made.  The subcontractor has the same remedy available to it when approvals and payments are unreasonably withheld, however, it must provide the ten (10) day written notice with an opportunity to cure to both the owner and contractor. In addition to or instead of suspending performance, the subcontractor may also try to resolve the matter in compliance with the Act’s new arbitration provisions.  

In the event a contractor or subcontractor suspends performance, the time frames established within the remedies section of the Act are extended for the length of the suspension. The costs incurred for re-mobilization, however, can only be collected if negotiated by the parties. The Act provides that the suspending party must be permitted a reasonable opportunity to remove its materials, equipment, tools and/or machinery from the job-site.  

The 2009 Amendments authorize binding expedited arbitration between the parties to resolve alleged violations of the Act as an additional remedy. Prior to referring the matter to arbitration, the aggrieved party must provide written notice of the complaint to the party or parties in violation of the Act. Upon receipt of this written notice of complaint, the parties should attempt to resolve the matter giving rise to such complaint. If the parties cannot resolve the matter within fifteen (15) days of the receipt of the complaint, the aggrieved party may refer the matter to the American Arbitration Association for an expedited arbitration. The 2009 Amendments also explicitly prohibit any agreement collateral to or affecting a construction contract which would make these arbitration provisions unavailable to one or both parties.  

Despite slight adjustments by the 2009 Amendments, the definitions enumerated in the Act remain very far-reaching, including how the terms “Construction Contract”, “Contractor”, “Subcontractor” and “Owner” are defined. The definitions, subject to the exemptions mentioned above, were intended to encompass most, if not all, contracting entities working on private construction projects greater than or equal to $250,000.00, as of January 14, 2003, or $150,000.00 for those contracts entered into after September 8, 2009. Hopefully, the legislative intent of protecting contractors and subcontractors from unscrupulous payment practices will prevail. If you would like more information on this or any other construction issue, please feel free to contact Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP.  

This Article is supplied for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. You should consult competent legal counsel depending on the specific issues of your matter.  

About Anthony P. Carlucci, Jr., Esq., Attorney, Welby Brady and Greenblatt, LLP Anthony P. Carlucci, Jr. represents owners, general contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers in disputes arising from public and private construction projects.  He is experienced in contract negotiations, the prosecution and defense of claims, mechanic’s liens, surety law, and alternative dispute resolution. Mr. Carlucci is an active member of the Builders and Remodelers Association of Northern New Jersey, the New York State Bar Association, the New Jersey State Bar Association and the Putnam County Bar Association. Mr. Carlucci received a Bachelor of Science Degree in Business Administration from Marist College and a Juris Doctor Degree from Pace University.  He is admitted to practice law before the State and Federal Courts in New York and New Jersey.  

About Ana C. Cruz, Esq., Associate, Welby Brady and Greenblatt, LLP Prior to joining Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, Ms. Cruz worked at a construction litigation firm focusing on construction and land use law.  At her prior firm, Ms. Cruz represented owners, contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers in lien foreclosure and breach of contract actions.While in law school, Ms. Cruz completed four legal co-ops including a judicial internship with a federal district judge in the Southern District of New York.  Her other co-ops focused on labor law, non-profit law, and general litigation. Ms. Cruz received her Bachelor of Arts degree from Boston University and her Juris Doctor degree 
from Northeastern University School of Law.  

About Welby, Brady & Greenblatt LLP Welby, Brady & Greenblatt LLP represents a wide range of entities within the construction and real estate industries including general contractors, subcontractors, sureties, developers, owners, suppliers, engineers, and home owners with core competencies, such as construction law and litigation, real estate development, labor law, OSHA compliance and mediation and arbitration. The firm is headquartered in White Plains, New York with offices in Cranford, New Jersey and Stamford, Connecticut. The firm’s website can be found at www.wbgllp.com.   

Court Rejects Contractor’s Delay Claim


The “no-damages-for-delay” clause found in many public construction contracts and some private contracts continues to vex contractors. New York courts generally bar a contractor’s delay claim where the contract contains a so-called no-damages-for-delay clause. This provision bars claims by the contractor for damages due to delay caused by the owner.

There are recognized exceptions, however, to the no-damages-for-delay clause. It will not be enforced against the contractor where (1) the delays are caused by the owner’s bad faith or willful, malicious, or grossly negligent conduct, (2) the delays are uncontemplated, (3) the delays are so unreasonable that they constitute an intentional abandonment of the contract by the owner, and (4) the delays resulted from the owner’s breach of a fundamental obligation of the contract.

In the recent case of Dart Mechanical Corp. v. City of New York, the contractor attempted to prove that the project’s 32-month delay fell within at least one of the exceptions to the enforceability of the no-damage-for-delay clause. 

Background 

In June 1999 Dart Mechanical Corp., a prime contractor, entered into a $3,637,000 agreement with the New York City Department of Sanitation to provide HVAC work at the construction project known as New Annex Building, Queens Sanitation District 7. The project was delayed 32 months beyond the originally scheduled 36 month completion period. At the end of the project the contractor submitted a $1,300,000 delay claim to the City, consisting of summaries of additional costs, charts, and tables relating to delay and wage escalation analyses. In rejecting the contractor’s request for additional compensation, the City relied on the no-damages-for-delay clause contained within the parties’ agreement. The clause stated, “The Contractor agrees to make no claim for damages for delay in the performance of this Contract occasioned by any act or omission to act of the City or any of its representatives, and agrees that any such claim shall be fully compensated for by an extension of time to complete performance of the work as provided herein.” 

The contractor argued that this provision was inapplicable since (1) the City’s failure to timely terminate the project’s general contractor who was primarily responsible for the delay amounted to gross negligence and demonstrated willful misconduct; (2) the delays were uncontemplated; and, (3) the City breached a fundamental obligation of the contract by failing to timely terminate the general contractor. When the City refused to pay, the contractor sued. The City moved for summary judgment, relying on the contract’s no-damages-for-delay provision. The trial court awarded summary judgment in favor of the City and the contractor appealed.

Decision

The appellate court affirmed the trial court’s decision, relying on well established case law upholding the validity of no-damage-for-delay clauses. According to the court, the delay did not fall within one of the four exceptions to the enforceability of the no-damages-for-delay clause. 

The court rejected the contractor’s claims that the delays were caused by the City’s gross negligence, or bad faith, and that the City’s failure to timely terminate the general contractor amounted to a breach of a fundamental obligation of the contract. The court noted that the City retained a construction manager and scheduling consultant to set and maintain a schedule for project completion, that regular progress and scheduling meetings were held, that the City and their representatives repeatedly requested that the delinquent general contractor adhere to the schedule, and that the City had no affirmative obligation to terminate the general contractor. Under those circumstances, the court stated that it could not see any evidence of gross negligence, willful misconduct or any breach of a fundamental obligation of the contract on the part of the City.

In rejecting the contractor’s claim that the delays were uncontemplated at the time the contract was entered into between the parties, the court pointed out that the contract recognized that delays may be caused by other contractors for which the City would not be responsible. The contract contained an exculpatory clause which recognized the fact that delays may be caused by other contractors. The contract provided that the City is relieved from liability for such delays of other contractors. The court also noted that when an owner uses multiple co-prime contractors, as in this case, the risk of delay by the other co-primes is foreseeable, and therefore cannot be considered uncontemplated. 

Finally, although the contractor never argued that the delay was an abandonment of the project by the City, the court also noted that the evidence did not demonstrate any action by the City to suggest that it had any intention of abandoning the project.

Comment 

Comment This case demonstrates the heavy burden a contractor must overcome to establish an exception to the no-damage-for-delay clause. It appears that this contractor at the time of contract did not foresee or contemplate that the project would be delayed 32 months beyond the 36 month contract completion period. It seems unfair for a contractor to be saddled with the heavy cost of such an unforeseen delay caused by others. 

Amendments to The New York City School Construction Authority Act Allow Subcontractors to Elect a Remedy for Nonpayment

I. Background  
Section 101 of the General Municipal Law, also known as the Wicks Law, sets forth requirements for public construction contracts.  The Wicks Law requires public works owners to prepare separate specifications and award separate contracts for general construction, plumbing, HVAC, and electrical work when the total value of the contract exceeds three million dollars for public construction within New York City.  

The Wicks Law provision was preempted by Section 1735 of the New York City School Construction Authority Act (“Act”) for contracts awarded by the New York City School Construction Authority (“Authority”) between July 1, 1989 and June 13, 2014.  Unlike Wicks Law contracts, the Authority can award one contract.  Contractors submitting bids with the Authority during this time period must identify the names of the subcontractors they intend to use for the performance of the plumbing, HVAC, and electrical work.    

Contracts that come within the Act are also subject to its payment protection clause.  Under Subsection Six of the Act, contractors are required to pay subcontractors within seven (7) days of receiving payment from the Authority.  The contractors must pay their subcontractors the portion of the proceeds of the payment they receive representing the value of the work performed by their subcontractors which has been approved and paid for by the Authority.  Contractors may hold back an amount necessary to satisfy any claims, liens or judgments against the subcontractor which have not been suitably discharged and they may hold retainage.  Retainage is set at either five or ten percent depending on whether the subcontractor has posted a performance and/or a labor and material payment bond.   

If a subcontractor notifies the contractor and the Authority that the contractor failed to make a required payment, the contractor must provide the Authority with either proof of the payment to the subcontractor or a notice that the amount claimed by the subcontractor is in dispute.  The contractor must do so within five (5) calendar days of receiving the notice of nonpayment from the subcontractor.  If the contractor fails to respond to the subcontractor’s notice or notifies the Authority that the payment to the subcontractor is in dispute, the Authority withholds money from the contractor’s payment.  If the contractor disputes the payment owed to the subcontractor, the Authority deposits the amount withheld into an interest bearing account.  Any amounts owed together with interest will be paid to the party ultimately determined to be entitled to payment.  The Act also contains provisions for determining priority and distribution of amounts withheld in the event of multiple withholdings.  
Amendments to the Act became effective on September 17, 2010 (“Amendments”).  The purpose of the Amendments the Amendments will significantly impact the amounts withheld from contractors by the Authority, contractors’ ability to bond the payment amounts disputed by subcontractors, and subcontractors’ remedies for payment protection.   

2   
Pursuant to the Amendments, the Authority will now withhold one hundred fifty percent (150%) of the portion of the Authority’s prior payment to the contractor which the subcontractor claims to be due from the contractor.  Notably, the amendment does not alter that portion of the statute that provides that if the contractor fails to dispute the withholding the Authority will remit the amount withheld (i.e. the 150%) to the subcontractor and deduct such payment from the amounts then otherwise due and payable to the contractor.  Such payments by the Authority are deemed a payment by the Authority to the contractor.  Prior to the Amendments, the Authority held an amount equal to the prior payment to the contractor which the subcontractor claimed to be due from the contractor.  

To avoid the Authority’s one hundred fifty percent (150%) withholding, the contractor can file a bond or undertaking in the amount(s) withheld by the Authority.  This remedy was added by the Amendments and is new to the Act.  

The Act was also modified so that subcontractors must now choose between filing a lien or seeking payment protection from the Authority under the one hundred fifty percent withholding clause of Section 1735.  Going forward, a subcontractor can file a lien for the amount disputed in the event the Authority does not withhold the required amounts within sixty (60) days after the Authority’s receipt of written notification from the subcontractor of the contrator’s failure to make a payment.  Significantly, such a lien will be the subcontractor’s sole remedy in lieu of the remedies provided by the Act.  This election of remedies clause was added to avoid the financial burden placed on a contractor when the Authority withheld a percentage of the amounts owed to a subcontractor in addition to one hundred fifty percent of its lien amount.  The Authority will stop this double withholding by limiting the amounts withheld to either one hundred fifty percent of a subcontractor’s lien or one hundred fifty percent of a subcontractor’s claim under the special payment protections of section 1735.  

These provisions do not apply to subcontractors acting as primes (i.e. subcontractors whose contract is limited to the performance of a single scope of the plumbing, electrical or mechanical work for the project). These Amendments are already effective and certain contractors and subcontractors currently performing work for the Authority are already subject to these provisions if their contracts come within the Act rather than the Wicks Law. 

If you would like more information on this issue or any other construction issue, please contact Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP. 

This Legal Alert is supplied for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. You should consult competent legal counsel depending on the specific issues of your matter. 

The New New York City Energy Conservation Code

On December 28, 2009, New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg signed comprehensive 
legislation dubbed the Greener, Greater Buildings Plan. The purpose of this legislation is to 
reduce New York City’s carbon footprint by five percent. In the first of this three part series, we 
will discuss several important provisions of the new New York City Energy Conservation Code 
(the ANYCECC), and what means to property owners and builders. 
 
The enactment of the NYCECC is intended to close what was perceived to be a loophole in the 
Energy Conservation Construction Code of New York State (the State Code), adopted in 2007. 
The State Code applies only to new construction and renovation work where more than half of a 
building’s systems of subsystems were replaced. Thus, everything from simple remodeling work 
to extensive renovations and additions (provided that the new work used more than half of the 
building’s existing systems) were exempted from compliance with the State Code. As a result of 
the enactment of the NYCECC, now any1
 construction which requires a building permit 
including residential construction must be analyzed for energy efficiency to the standards set 
forth under the State Code. 
 
In order to comply with the NYCECC, an applicant for a building permit must have the lead 
design professional submit three items along with the permit application: 1) a statement that to 
the best of the design professional’s knowledge, belief and professional judgment; the plans and 
specifications submitted are in compliance with the NYCECC, or that the project is exempt from 
its requirements; 2) the results of an energy analysis (which must include the building’s 
envelope, its service water heating, lighting and power systems, and its mechanical systems) 
comparing the proposed project to the requirements of the NYCECC and setting forth how the 
project meets the NYCECC; and 3) construction drawings which demonstrate conformance with 
the NYCECC. It is important to note that this submission is an ongoing process. The analysis and 
construction documents must be updated to account for any substitutions and changes made 
during the course of construction. 
 
 
1The following buildings are exempt from the NYCECC: buildings which use small 
amounts of energy; buildings which contain no conditioned space; buildings which receive all of 
their from renewable energy sources; historic buildings; and nonresidential farm buildings. The 
following construction work is exempt from the NYCECC: installation of storm windows; the 
replacement of glazing in an existing sash and frame; exposing existing ceiling, wall or floor 
cavities during construction, provided that such cavities are filled with insulation prior to 
reclosure; and any construction where the existing roof, wall or floor cavities are not exposed. 

Incorporation of a Prime Contract Into a Subcontract by Reference: What Comes Over?

Alternative Dispute Resolution (“ADR”), including mediation and arbitration, is an 
efficient way of resolving disputes at an early stage, without the need for an expensive and costly 
litigation. This is particularly true in the construction industry, where the disputes are often 
technical and require the involvement of persons with specialized knowledge or training. Aside 
from its cost and time benefits, ADR offers the participants the opportunity to place their dispute 
before a neutral who has experience in the construction industry, rather than 6 random people 
from the community whose excuses for getting out of jury duty weren’t acceptable to the judge 
that day. 
 
 In electing to go the ADR route, it must be noted that parties are giving up their 
Constitutional rights to bring their dispute to the Courts, and to have the substantive and 
procedural laws of the state (or nation) applied. Accordingly, it has long been settled that any 
agreement to arbitrate must be clear, explicit and unequivocal. This is normally not an issue 
where parties to an existing dispute agree to go to arbitration. However, many cases which are 
ultimately resolved by ADR were designated to be sent to that forum long before any dispute 
arose; they were sent to ADR pursuant to agreements which were made months, or perhaps years 
ago. 
 
 In the subcontracting context, many contractors see the expediency in signing a short 
agreement between the subcontractor and the general contractor (which contains specific clauses 
relevant only to those parties, such as the value of the subcontract), and incorporating the general 
contractor’s prime contract for the remaining provisions. Well, what happens when that prime 
contract contains an ADR provision? The Appellate Division, Second Department, in Navillus 
Tile, Inc. v Bovis Lend Lease LMB, Inc. (74 AD3d 1299, 1302, 904 NYS2d 207, 211 [2010]), 
reminds us that: 
 
“Under New York law, incorporation clauses in a construction subcontract, 
incorporating prime contract clauses by reference into a subcontract, bind a 
subcontractor only as to prime contract provisions relating to the scope, quality, 
character and manner of the work to be performed by the subcontractor.” 
 
 Because an ADR provision in a contract does not relate to the “the scope, quality, 
character and manner of the work to be performed by the subcontractor”, and, more importantly, 
because an ADR provision involves the waiver of significant, Constitutional rights (to proceed 
before a Court of Law), a subcontract incorporating a prime contract with an ADR provision 
must be clear that the parties are specifically intending to incorporate that ADR provision, and 
that they specifically intend to arbitrate or mediate their disputes. 
 
 Examples of other clauses of prime contracts which do not relate to the “the scope, 
quality, character and manner of the work to be performed by the subcontractor”, and, 
accordingly, are not incorporated by reference absent a specific indication of the intent to be 
bound by such provisions are: specific record keeping requirements (see Navillus Tile, supra); 
indemnification requirements (see Waitkus v Metro. Housing Partners, 50 AD3d 260 [1st Dept 2008]); obligations to procure insurance (see Bussanich v 310 East 55th Street Tenants, 282 
AD2d 243 [1st Dept 2001]); clauses setting forth a specific forum in which to bring a lawsuit (see 
George Hyman Construction Co. v Precision Walls, Inc. of Raleigh, 132 AD2d 523 [2d Dept 
1987]); and provisions relating to the termination of the contract (see Gulf Ins. Co. v Fidelity & 
Deposit Co. of Maryland, 16 Misc3d 1116[A][Sup Ct, NY Co. 2007]). 
 
 In closing, contractors and subcontractors should be reminded that not every provision of 
a prime contract will make the jump over to the subcontract, despite a clause in the subcontract 
purporting to do exactly that. 

Court Allows Recovery For Verbal Extra Work Claim.

Most construction contracts have a standard provision requiring changes in the work or directions to perform extra work to be made in writing.  Courts generally hold that a contractor who fails to obtain the required written authorization will not be paid for such work.   

 However, a contractor or subcontractor who performs extra work will not automatically lose his extra work claim just because he failed to follow the contract provision requiring written authorization.  Courts are hesitant to deny a just claim for extra work and have found that contractual requirements for written orders can be waived under certain circumstances.   

 In the recent case of Penava Mechanical Corp. v. Afgo Mechanical Services, Inc., an appellate court ruled on whether recovery may be had for orally directed extra work despite the contract provision that an extra work claim must be supported by written authorization.  

Background  

Absolute Electrical Contractors, Inc. entered into a subcontract with general contractor Richter & Ratner Contracting Corp.  The parties’ subcontract contained a so-called “no- oral modification clause.”  Pursuant to the clause, all changes in the work or directions to perform extra work were to be made in writing or were otherwise not compensable.    

During the course of construction, representatives of the general contractor verbally directed the subcontractor to work overtime.  The representatives also orally agreed to pay for this premium time over and above the contract price, as they had previously paid for other overtime work throughout the project.

 The promised overtime payment was in lieu of an extension of time to finish the work.  In addition, the general contractor’s project manager testified that he instructed the subcontractor not to bother with the “tickets” that were usually prepared by the subcontractor for such extra work and formed the basis for change orders issued, but rather directed the subcontractor to “just get the work done.”  The subcontractor sued when the general contractor refused to make payment for the subcontractor’s overtime.   
In defense, the general contractor argued that the subcontract’s no-oral modification clause barred any claim by the subcontractor, since the direction to perform overtime work and promise to pay at a premium rate were made orally, and were not in writing.  In addition, the general contractor argued that the subcontractor had waived any claims to the overtime pay pursuant to the express language of the lien waivers signed by the subcontractor.    

The general contractor moved for summary judgment, which the trial court granted.  The subcontractor appealed.  

Decision  

The appellate court reversed the trial court, denying the general contractor’s motion for summary judgement and directing a trial on whether the subcontractor had been paid in full for the overtime work performed.    

According to the appellate court, under New York law, oral directions to perform extra work, or the general course of conduct between the parties, may modify or eliminate contract provisions requiring written authorizations or notice of claims.  The appellate court relied heavily on the verbal directions by the general contractor to the subcontractor to perform the overtime work and verbal promises to pay the subcontractor.

 The court also relied on the general contractor’s verbal direction that the subcontractor not bother with the work tickets that would form a written basis for a formal change order.  Under these circumstances, the court held that the general contractor cannot argue that it did not have to pay for the overtime.    
As to the general contractor’s argument that the claims had been released, the appellate court held that since the subcontractor was required to sign these waivers whenever it received partial payment, and since payments were made after waivers were given, the parties treated the waivers as mere receipts of the amounts stated in the waivers, not as complete waivers of all claims to that point.  

Comment  

While courts routinely seek to enforce the express terms of an agreement that was freely negotiated, courts also seek to prohibit bad-faith dealings.  Here, where the general contractor verbally promised payment, and verbally stated that written work tickets were not necessary to protect the subcontractor’s right to payment, the court would not allow the general contractor to rely on the subcontract’s provisions to the contrary.     

A prudent contractor or subcontractor, however, should not ignore the contractual requirement for written extra work orders in the hope that a court may make an exception and find a waiver of the contract provisions under particular circumstances.  He should insist on a written order in the form specified by the contract provisions before he performs any extra work.  A written extra work order will ensure his right to be paid for performing such work.    

About the author:  Mr. Miuccio is a partner of the law firm of Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP and General Counsel to the Construction Industry Council of Westchester & Hudson Valley, Inc.  Adam W. Downs, an associate with the firm, assisted with the preparation of this article.