Skip to main content

Court Enforces Waiver of Lien Against Unpaid Contractor

One of the most effective ways to protect an owner from liens is to require as a precondition to payment that the contractor execute an affidavit and waiver of lien which states that it has been paid to date for work performed at the project. But what if the contractor has not received all the money it is due through the date on the lien affidavit and waiver? Is the lien affidavit and waiver a complete bar to the contractor’s right to file a mechanic’s lien and sue the owner for monies owed for work performed through the date on the lien affidavit and waiver?

The court addressed the enforceability of the lien affidavit and waiver in the recent case of Atlantic Line Construction LLC v. Marsten Development Corp., et al.

Background 

Argyle Development LLC, as owner, hired Marstan Development Corp., as general contractor, in connection with a construction project located at 753 St. Nicholas Avenue in Manhattan. The general contractor subcontracted the project’s carpentry work to Atlantic Line Construction LLC.

On June 9, 2009 the general contractor provided the owner with an “Affidavit & Waiver of Lien”, in which the general contractor acknowledged receipt of all sums due from the owner for all work performed and materials furnished through May 29, 2009. On June 11, 2009, the subcontractor filed a mechanic’s lien against the project, alleging that $82,300 was past due to it for labor and materials supplied to the project. The subcontractor thereafter attempted to enforce the mechanic’s lien by commencing a foreclosure action. The owner moved to dismiss the lien claim, arguing that it had paid the general contractor in full and that the general contractor’s own statement contained within the lien affidavit and waiver confirmed full payment. The owner also presented cancelled checks and wire transfers to show that all monies were paid to the general contractor. In opposition, the general contractor argued that, notwithstanding the terms of the lien affidavit and waiver, money remained due from the owner, and that the lien affidavit and waiver had been obtained through fraud.

Decision

The court ruled in favor of the owner, dismissing the mechanic’s lien foreclosure action. The court noted that mechanic’s lien rights are derivative. As stated by the court, “The principle is well settled that the rights of a subcontractor are derivative of the rights of the general contractor and a subcontractor’s lien must be satisfied out of funds due and owing from the owner to the general contractor at the time the lien is filed.” Since the general contractor provided the owner with a lien affidavit and waiver stating that it had been paid in full, the court ruled that no monies were due from the owner to the general contractor. Accordingly, there was no lien fund from which the subcontractor could recover.

The court further ruled that no evidence was presented to find that the lien affidavit and waiver was procured through fraud.

Comment 

This case follows the general principle that courts will enforce an affidavit and waiver of lien provided by a general contractor to the effect that the contractor has no existing claims and has paid all of its subcontractors and suppliers on the project. These affidavits and lien waivers may be problematic for contractors where the owner relies on them to reject a contractor’s legitimate claims, such as extra work claims, arising before the affidavit and lien waiver was signed. As this case demonstrates, the owner is entitled to rely on the clear and express terms of the affidavit and lien waiver to reject such claims.

Does the identification of a single address in liens result in a blanket lien so that Owner can seek discharge and cancellation of liens as “blanket liens” improperly filed against the entire property?

Question. Owner is the sponsor and developer of Condominium’s residential and commercial units. Plumbing performed work on the condo under three contracts, and filed three separate mechanic’s liens regarding the work performed and materials furnished. The liens clearly identified the individual units Plumbing sought to encumber, satisfying Lien Law ¬ß9(7). Liens included 36 residential units Owner did not own at the time the liens were filed. At least 26 of the 243 lots originally owned by Owner were sold and recorded before the liens were filed. Does the identification of “100 XYZ Avenue” in the liens result in a blanket lien so that Owner can seek discharge and cancellation of the liens as “blanket liens” improperly filed against the entire property?

Answer. No.

BACKGROUND

Owner can move to discharge and cancel three notices of mechanic’s liens filed by Plumbing against the subject property but because the liens substantially complied with the law, an amendment of the liens nunc pro tunc (pursuant to Lien Law ¬ß12-a ) to eliminate the lots conveyed before the filing would not prejudice any existing lienor or purchaser and Owner’s petition to discharge and cancel the liens should be denied.

Owner is the sponsor and developer of the Condominium which includes 239 residential apartment units and four commercial units (“Condominium”). According to the declaration establishing a plan for the condominium ownership, the street address of the property is 150 XYZ Avenue, (“Condominium Property”). Plumbing performed work on the Condominium Property pursuant to three separate contracts between Plumbing and Owner’s contractor.

Plumbing filed three separate notices of mechanic’s (“Liens”) with respect to the work allegedly performed pursuant to each of the contracts. The Liens claim a total amount of approximately $715,000.00. In all three Liens, the property subject to the Liens is identified as, “Premises known as 150 XYZ Avenue, more particularly described and as set forth in Exhibit “A” attached and Exhibit “B” pages 1-18 attached.” Exhibit “A” of the Liens identifies two commercial units in the Condominium by block, lot, and unit number while exhibit “B” of the Liens identifies the two remaining commercial units and each of the block, lot, and unit numbers associated with the residential condominium units followed by the description, “SINGLE RESIDENTIAL CONDO UNIT.” Exhibit “B” of the Liens also includes the prior lot number which has been superseded by the Condominium declaration, and is followed by the description, “APARTMENT BUILDING.”

Prior to Plumbing’s filing of the Liens, 36 of the residential units had been sold by the Owner. Owner argues that because the Liens specify the address “150 XYZ Avenue”, the Liens were not limited to specific condominium units in which Owner retained an interest and were therefore “blanket liens.”

A “blanket lien” is created with respect to a condominium development when the description of the property subject to the lien is not limited to the particular units of a condominium which are owned by the party liable to the lienor, thereby creating a lien on the entire property. A blanket lien, which is not valid as against the individual units, including the unsold units retained by the Owner, or the common elements of the condominium, should be summarily canceled pursuant to Lien Law ¬ß19(6) since it fails to adequately describe the property pursuant to Lien Law ¬ß9(7) in conformity with Real Property Law ¬ß339-l. However, as the Liens here clearly identify the individual units Plumbing sought to encumber, Owner’s argument that the identification of “150 XYZ Avenue” resulted in the formation of a “blanket lien” is unavailing.

Where a lien description includes too much property, but nevertheless includes and identifies all the property on which the lien could properly be claimed, the defect is not fatal, as the lien would be limited and restricted only to that part against which it could properly be enforced.

Here, although Plumbing did file each of the Liens against the entire superseded lot number, Plumbing also identified the individual condominium units in the Liens and thereby sufficiently identified the property properly subject to the Liens so as to satisfy the requirements of Lien Law §9(7)

While at least 26 of the 243 lots originally owned by the Owner had been sold and recorded prior to the filing of the Liens, the Liens substantially complied with Lien Law §9(7) and the amendment of the Liens, nunc pro tunc, so as to eliminate the lots conveyed prior to the filing of the Liens will not prejudice any existing lienor or purchaser.

It seems clear from the language in [Real Property Law §339-l(2)] that the Legislature has chosen to distinguish between the rights of those performing labor on or furnishing materials to individual unit owners in a condominium, and the rights of those performing labor on or furnishing materials to the common elements of a condominium. In the case of labor performed or materials furnished to any unit owner, there can be no lien unless the unit owner expressly consents to the lien or unless the lien is for emergency repairs to such unit. As a number of the condominium units were transferred by the Owner prior to the filing of the Liens, and there are no allegations that the new owners consented to the Liens, the work was for emergency repairs, or that the labor and services allegedly provided by Plumbing were requested by the new owners, the Liens may not encumber the units transferred prior to the filing of the Liens even where the recording of the transfers occurred after the filing of the Liens.

Safety Policy: OSHA Campaigns Against Heat-Related Illness

In many parts of the United States, July 2011 was the hottest July on record. It’s quite appropriate, therefore, that heat-related illnesses are one of the hazards currently receiving heightened attention from (federal) OSHA and state OSHA agencies around the country.

Each year there are several dozen workplace fatalities due to heat stroke and other heat-related illnesses. Such deaths are most common in agriculture, mining, foundry work, and construction. Probably the construction trades most at risk are roofers – working with no shade with buckets of hot tar – and workers in highway construction.

Too much heat exposure makes employees listless, unproductive, and more prone to accidents. Heat stress can result in dehydration, heat rash (“prickly heat”), and muscle cramps. Most seriously, heat stress can lead to heat exhaustion and heat stroke.

The signs of heat exhaustion are headache, nausea, dizziness, weakness, irritability, confusion, thirst, heavy sweating, and a body temperature over 100.4° F. First aid for heat exhaustion includes removing the worker from the hot area, giving water or other (non-alcoholic) liquids, and the removal of unnecessary clothing (shoes and socks included).

Workers with heat exhaustion should be treated promptly, with cold compresses to the head, neck and face (or washing those areas with cold water). Frequent sips of cool water should be taken. Since heat exhaustion usually is associated with the loss of electrolytes, sports drinks containing potassium, calcium, and magnesium salts should be given if available.

Workers suspected of having heat exhaustion should be taken to an emergency room or similar facility for evaluation, and should not be left alone while awaiting transport or medical attention.

Heat stroke is a life-threatening condition, of which the symptoms are mental confusion, delirium, loss of consciousness, convulsions or coma; a body temperature over 104¬∫ F.; and hot dry skin, which may be red, mottled, or bluish. If heat stroke is apparent, summon emergency medical assistance at once. While awaiting medical help, remove the victim to a cool area, soak the victim and his clothing with cool water, and fan the victim vigorously to increase cooling. These measures should not be neglected; they may make the difference in preventing permanent injury to the brain and other vital organs.

Heat cramps and heat syncope (a/k/a fainting) are other heat-related conditions. Heat cramps generally result from the overuse of tired muscles in a hot environment without replacing electrolytes. Large quantities of water generally do not help, but often make the situation worse. Rest, sports drinks or – in unusually severe cases – the intravenous administration of saline solution by a medical professional are the usual treatments.

Fainting occurs most often when the worker is not acclimated to the hot environment and stands still in the heat. Moving around will usually help the individual avoid passing out, and most who do faint recover after a brief period of lying down.

Engineering measures should be considered (especially where work is to be done in elevated temperatures indoors). These include, among other things, general ventilation and local exhaust ventilation at points of high heat production; shielding from radiant heat sources; the use of air conditioning and/or dehumidifiers, if practicable; cooling fans; and the elimination of steam leaks.

The ready availability of drinking water is indispensable to preventing heat stress illnesses, and workers should be instructed to drink some water every 15 minutes in hot temperatures, even if they do not feel thirsty.

Regular breaks are also vital, and if your site is not convenient to a shaded area out of the sun, consider a small investment in an open canopy (these are much used in agricultural settings) to provide a shaded rest area. A few chairs and a water cooler can be placed beneath the canopy, and this will be much appreciated by your employees.

While hard hats are of course usual in construction work, employees not required to wear hard hats should be instructed to wear a hat when temperatures are high, and all workers should be told to wear lightweight, light-colored clothing. Workers required to work in protective gear should, of course, be given extra breaks, and efforts should be made to perform such work outside the hottest hours of the day.

Individuals vary widely in their ability to handle hot work environments. Age, obesity, fitness, medical conditions such as high blood pressure, drug and alcohol use etc. all figuring in a person’s sensitivity to heat. These are matters for discussion with supervisors and employees in allocating work assignments.

As always, it’s important to know where your employees are working, and the location of the nearest emergency room or other urgent care facility.

As with most safety practices, training supervisory and rank-and-file employees to recognize and to call attention to symptoms of heat stroke in themselves and others is critical. When temperatures are high, productivity is going to slip somewhat. But encouraging your employees to get out of the sun, drink water, and take rest periods will put less of a dent in production than having employees removed to hospital (or worse) due to heat exhaustion or heat stroke.

Training on this topic should include warnings about the use of alcohol and drugs in hot work environments. Workers who take prescription medications should be strongly encouraged to consult their medical professionals concerning the possibility that their medication, or the underlying condition, may make them more susceptible to heat-related illness.

As with so many health and safety issues, your leadership is important. In difficult economic times, especially, most employees want to “progress the work” (and to keep their jobs). Those, obviously, are good things – but not at the cost of heat stroke! Make sure your employees know, therefore, that they should look out for one another, do what they need to do to avoid (especially) heat stroke and heat exhaustion, and alert supervisors if they, or co-workers, exhibit symptoms of heat-related illness.

Encourage employees, also, to suggest practical means (such as adjusting work schedules or means and methods) to minimize heat exposure, especially on very hot days.

While at present OSHA does not have regulations directed specifically to heat stress hazards, this is an obvious area for application of the “General Duty Clause,” which requires employment and a place of employment free from recognized hazards, causing or likely to cause death or serious physical harm. Certainly, heat-related illness is a recognized hazard in construction, and one amenable to mitigation.

As temperatures break records around the country, heat stress is also a condition that OSHA has squarely in its sights, so this “word to the wise should be sufficient.”


Contractor May Be Personally Liable for Diversion of Trust Funds

The trust fund provisions of New York’s Lien Law provide that monies received by an owner, such as a building loan, and monies received by a contractor or subcontractor are trust funds to be held by them as trustees for payment to those performing work and supplying materials on their behalf for the project. The statute is intended to prevent owners, contractors and subcontractors from diverting trust monies from a project to pay creditors on other projects or keeping the monies for themselves.

Where there has been an improper diversion of trust monies, a corporation’s officers may be personally liable for the unpaid project debts of the corporation, even though the officer was acting for the corporation. In the recent case of Ippolito v. TJC Development, LLC, the appellate court ruled on whether a corporate officer could be personally liable for diversion of trust funds.

Background 

TJC Development, LLC contracted to substantially renovate a residence located in Babylon, New York. A dispute arose between the contractor and the homeowners, and the homeowners ultimately terminated the contractor. In addition to claims against the contractor for defective work and performance, the homeowners also sued the contractor and the contractor’s principals for trust fund diversion under the Lien Law. According to the homeowners, the contractor received payments from the homeowners for work performed, but the contractor failed and refused to pay the project’s subcontractors and suppliers. Since the contractor’s principals directed the distribution of funds received from the homeowners, the homeowners argued that the principals were personally liable for trust fund diversion.

The contractor argued that the homeowners’ trust fund claims were improper and should be dismissed. According to the contractor, its principals were not personally liable since the homeowners contracted with a company and made payments to that company, and therefore only the company was a trustee of funds received by the homeowners. In addition, the contractor argued that the homeowners did not have any right to claim against the contractor for trust fund diversion. Rather, according to the contractor, such a claim would only belong to the contractor’s subcontractors and suppliers, not the homeowners.

The contractor made a motion for summary judgment, requesting that the trust fund diversion claims against it and its principals be dismissed. The trial court ruled in favor of the contractor and its principals. The homeowners appealed.

Decision

The appellate court reversed, ruling in favor of the homeowners. In its decision, the court stated that Article 3-A of the Lien Law creates trust funds out of certain construction payments or funds to assure payment to subcontractors, suppliers, architects, engineers and laborers. The purpose of Article 3-A is to ensure that those who actually perform the work and furnish materials are paid. The court noted that upon receipt of payments from the owner, the contractor is required to pay its subcontractors and suppliers for work performed. According to the court, the funds remain the property of the owners until the proper distribution of the trust funds by the contractor. Accordingly, the court held that the homeowners had the right to maintain trust fund diversion claims against a contractor who diverted funds.

In addition, the court noted that officers and directors of a company are guilty of the crime of larceny if they divert trust funds. Since a company’s officers and directors can be charged criminally, the court reasoned that they may also be held personally liable for the money damages caused by their diversion of trust funds. Accordingly, the court held that the homeowners could claim against the contractor and its principals, personally, for misappropriation of the trust funds.

Comment 

The construction trust fund statute is a valuable tool for collecting money for labor performed or materials supplied. This may be the only source of recovery where mechanic’s lien rights have expired, the claimant is not protected under a labor and material payment bond or where the project debtor is bankrupt. Personal liability of corporate officers for diversion of trust funds is not dischargeable in bankruptcy. It is only fair that project claimants, who have provided the wherewithal that made possible the construction of the project, should be allowed to sue corporate officers for personal liability where they direct trust funds for purposes other than paying the claims of unpaid material suppliers or subcontractors on that project.

The Perils Of Doing Business With DBES On A Cost Plus Basis

On March 10, 2011, following a four-week criminal trial, a federal jury found Zohrab B. Marashlian, the former President of Perini Corporation’s Civil Division (“Perini”), guilty of fraud and conspiracy to launder money. Two days later he took his own life. What led to this sad and unfortunate outcome? Based on information obtained from the U.S. District Court’s file in United States v. Zohrab Marashlian, Docket No. CR-08-900, I will attempt to answer this question.

Personal History:

Mr. Marashlian was President of Perini’s Civil Division from 1997 to 2007. He was born in Aleppo, Syria in 1944 to an Annenian family. He earned his civil engineering degree from the American University of Beirut, Lebanon, and immigrated to the United States in 1971. He later earned an MBA from Columbia University. Shortly after arriving in America, he was employed by Perini as an office engineer, and through hard work and ambition rose to President. Zohrab Marashlian was responsible for constructing and rehabilitating many high profile projects including highways, bridges, subways, tunnels, and waste water treatment facilities. By all accounts, he was a wellrespected executive, and a friend to many in the heavy construction industry.

The Criminal Charges:

The criminal charges against Mr. Marashlian arose out of representations, made to government contracting agencies on certain federally-funded projects, that Perini would use disadvantaged business enterprises (“DBEs”)1 to perform certain percentages of work, as required under the public contracts awarded to and performed by Perini. Instead of having the DBE subcontractors perform the specified work, however, the jury found that Zohrab knowingly used the DBE subcontractors as “fronts” for non-DBE companies, which actually performed the work set aside for the DBE companies.

The Indictment against Mr. Marashlian, which included numerous counts of mail fraud, wire fraud and money laundering, stated in pertinent part as follows:

The defendants Zohrab B. Marashlian and … others devised a scheme to defraud government contractirig agencies … by falsely representing in proposals and other documents submitted by Perini to those agencies for public works contracts … that DBE subcontractors would perform commercially useful functions in satisfaction of the DBE requirements of those public works contracts.

Contrary to the representations made by Perini, when Perini was awarded the public works contracts, Marashlian … and others did not have the DBE subcontractors perform commercially useful functions on the public works contracts. Instead Marashlian . . . and others used non-DBE subcontractors to perform work on the public works contracts that should have been performed by the DBE subcontractors.

It was part of the scheme to defraud that the defendants Zohrab B. Marashlian … and others caused non-DBE subcontractors to list their employees and supervisors on the payrolls of the DBE subcontractors, and order supplies and materials through the DBE subcontractors, to create the appearance that the DBE subcontractors were performing commercially useful functions on the public works contracts. Marashlian …further caused Perini to falsely certify to [public contracting agencies] that the DBE subcontractors performed DBE subcontract work on the public works contracts when, in truth and fact, as Marashlian … well knew and believed, the DBE subcontract work on the public works contracts was performed by non-DBE subcontractors (¬∂¬∂ 13-15 of the Indictment, filed December 18, 2008).

According to the government, Marashlian’s false representations induced, aided and abetted the award of more than $284 million in public contracts to Perini2 During the performance of these contracts, Zohrab and others took steps to maintain the illusion that the DBE subcontractors were actually performing the work, by arranging financing and laundering payments through the “front” companies. The progress payments from the public contracting agencies to Perini were deemed by the government to be financial transactions, with proceeds from a specified unlawful activity (i.e., money laundering), because, but for the fraud committed by Mr. Marashlian, Perini would not have been awarded the contract, and would not have received the progress payments. The tainted monies were then paid out, to the supervisors, workers and/or non-DBE subcontractors actually performing the work after a fee for processing the payments was deducted by the DBE (i.e., the DBE subcontractors received a fee or markup ranging from 3% to 5% of their costs). As a result of these frauds, the prosecution pointed out, Mr. Marashlian individually benefitted from the receipt of substantial payments, in the form of increased corporate salary and bonuses, totaling $14 million from 1994 through 2007. There was, however, no indication in the court papers that Mr. Marashlian personally received kickbacks from the DBE or non-DBE subcontractors or their principals.

The “Commercially Useful Function” Requirement:

In order to receive Federal highway funds, New York was required to have a DBE Program meeting Federal requirements and has done so by adopting them under 17 NYCRR35.3.

Under the relevant DBE Programs established by New York State and City agencies (the ”NY-DBE Programs”), general contractors are permitted to count toward the attainment of their DBE percentage goals only funds paid to DBE companies that perform a “commercially useful function” in the performance of a contract. Under such NY-DBE Programs, and the associated federal regulations, a DBE company performs a “commercially useful function” when it: (a) is responsible for the execution of a distinct element of the work of a contract; (b) carries out its responsibilities by actually performing, managing and supervising the work involved; and (c) furnishes all supervision, labor, tools, equipment, materials and supplies necessary to perform that distinct element of the contract work. Pursuant to federal regulations, a DBE does not perform a “commercially useful function,” if its role is limited to that of an extra participant in a transaction, contract, or project, through which funds are merely passed in order to obtain the appearance ofDBE participation in a contract.

In order to participate in the NY-DBE Programs, a minority and/or female owned company has to be certified as a DBE by the NYSDOT or the City of New York. “DBE certification” means that a general contractor can receive credit toward the attainment of its DBE percentage goals, by subcontracting work to the certified DBE company. However, the DBE company still has to perform a “commercially useful function” in order for the general contractor to receive credit; and, as you might guess, the general contractor is responsible for making sure that the DBE subcontractor performs a “commercially useful function.”

Furthermore, pursuant to New York law and federal regulations, a DBE subcontractor is prohibited from subcontracting work it is awarded in connection with its DBE status.

The Criminal Conduct:

This is where Mr. Marashlian made a serious mistake that mushroomed into criminal conduct. The prosecuting attorneys claimed, that for over a decade, Mr. Marashlian, and others working under him, repeatedly met with specialty subcontractors, and told them that in order to be awarded work by Perini, they had to bill their work through a DBE company’s name so that Perini could receive “DBE credit”. According to government witnesses, sometimes Mr. Marashlian would dictate which DBE the subcontractors should use as a “front,” and sometimes he did not care what DBE was used, as long as Perini could claim the subcontract work for DBE credit. Whether or not Mr. Marashlian was simply trying to shift the headache of complying with the DBE program away from Perini to Perini’s subcontractors, the jury was convinced that he committed fraud, by directing or causing the specialty subcontractors to transfer their management and workers to the books of DBE companies, and having those DBE companies pass on fraudulent invoices to Perini.

Recommendation:

Any person or company, when selecting a DBE subcontractor to perform a certain scope of work on a public contract, should avoid doing business with DBE subcontractors on a ”time and material” or “cost plus” basis, unless the DBE can demonstrate a history of performing the subcontract work and managing its own work, including supervising, hiring and firing of employees, and the performance of all administrative functions.

Doing business with certified DBE subcontractors that have nothing more than an office and a handful of clerical employees to run a payroll, purchase materials and pay project related invoices is clearly not enough to meet DBE requirements, and will likely draw the scrutiny of government investigators. Everyone in the heavy construction industry should recognize by now that a DBE subcontractor does not perform a “commercially useful function,” if its role is limited to that of an extra participant in a transaction, contract or project, through which funds are passed in order to obtain the appearance ofDBE performance of work on a project. The u.s. Attorney clearly stated in a memorandum filed in the subj ect case that

DBE companies who agree to act as a ”hilling” or ”payroll” service for a fee, generally cease to operate as legitimate contracting companies. The DBE company that acts as a “front” for a legitimate subcontractor or the subcontractors’ employees have the effect of gutting the DBE, reducing or eliminating the need for most employees from the DBE and preventing the company from developing contract experience and increasing in size – all goals ofDBE programs.

If you can’t find a capable DBE subcontractor to meet the contract’s DBE requirements, disclose that fact to the public contracting agency at the outset, and request a reduction of the DBE goals set by the agency. Where the public agency determines that “good faith efforts” have been made by the general contractor, and competent DBE subcontractors are not available, the agency should waive compliance with the DBE goal. For example, according to the government’s court papers, during the time frame involved in Mr. Marashlian’s case, State agencies often reduced DBE “goals” by up to 50% or more, at the request of general contractors, who had attempted, unsuccessfully, to comply.

Shifting the Risk of Doing Business with DBE Subcontractors back to the Government:

The time may have also come for contractors to decline taking on the risk associated with these government set-asides. Besides the mistakes made by Mr. Marashlian and Perini, a number of other well-known and reputable heavy construction contractors have reached multimillion dollar civil settlements for doing business with DBE companies that failed to perform a “commercially useful function”. In competitively-bid construction contracts, why should a contractor be asked to take on the added risk of having to find competent DBE subcontractors, and then hope that such companies are capable of fully performing their scope of work on schedule, and in accordance with plans and specifications? In order to level the playing field among all general contractors bidding the work, perhaps the United States Department of Transportation (i.e., the federal agency responsible for issuing the regulations governing the DBE Program) should make the local governmental agency responsible for selecting one or more competent DBE subcontractors to perform a defined scope of work as separate prime contractors, and then have the government agree to assume the risk that the DBE prime contractor may fail to perform. The government could select the appropriate DBE contractors through a separate request for proposal (“RFP”) or competitive bidding process, and define the scope of work to be performed by the DBE companies in the main prime contract. This type of arrangement would enable the general contractor to focus on what it does best – – managing, scheduling and constructing the Project, without the worry of trying to increase the participation of competent DBE’s in federally-funded public construction contracts. Although this could cause some of the problems that are commonly associated with “Wicks Law” projects in New York, it would eliminate the risk, now faced by general contractors, of being criminally prosecuted for intentionally or unintentionally crossing over the line in order to meet the requirements of the Federal DBE Program.

Hopefully, every executive in the construction industry wi11leam a lesson from the above story, and pass that lesson on to younger members of our industry in order to prevent a similar occurrence in the future.


1 A DBE is a small, for-profit business concern that is at least 51 % owned and controlled by socially and economically disadvantaged individuals. The firm must be operational, independent and operate in a selfsufficient manner. The owners must meet the federal definition of “socially and economically disadvantaged” (Women, minorities, or individuals who can document their disadvantage; all must also demonstrate that their adjusted personal net worth is no more than $1.32 million). Owners must possess the power and expertise to control the daily operations and management of the firm, and be able to establish at least 51 % ownership through real and substantial investments of capital. If anyone of these conditions is not met, the company does not qualify as a DBE. (49 C.F.R. 26)

2 On October 30, 2009, Perini Corporation entered a civil settlement with the government in connection with the contract frauds outlined in the indictment. Perini paid $9.75 million in settlement, to the government to avoid any actions against Perini Corporation, including actions for false claims against Perini. These monies eliminated any profit from the four contracts referenced in the Indictment. Perini also agreed with the USDOT to take steps to insure compliance with the DBE program on future public works contracts.

Is Consultant’s claim for breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing duplicative of his breach of contract action?

Question. Consultant seeks to recover damages from Client in connection with the collapse of their business relationship, alleging breach of contract and breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing. Is Consultant’s claim for breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing duplicative of his breach of contract action?

Answer. Yes.

Consultant brought an action against Client for its alleged failure to pay various fees to which Consultant was entitled under their agreement. Alleging claims for breach of contract and breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing, Consultant seeks “recovery of money damages in connection with the breach of a binding, valid and enforceable contract, and a declaration of its future rights under the contract.”

The covenant of good faith and fair dealing “embraces a pledge that neither party shall do anything which will have the effect of destroying or injuring the right of the other party to receive the fruits of the contract.” The covenant is implied in every contract governed under New York law. Accordingly, a “breach of the implied duty of good faith is considered a breach of the underlying contract.” For this reason, “a claim for breach of the implied covenant [of good faith and fair dealing] will be dismissed as redundant where the conduct allegedly violating the implied covenant is also the predicate for breach of covenant of an express provision of the underlying contract.”

Consultant cannot sustain both claims because they are premised on the same set of facts, and “a party may maintain a claim for breach of the implied covenant only if the claim is based on allegations different from the allegations underlying the accompanying breach of contract claim.” Because the success of either claim is dependent upon a finding that Client violated the terms of the contract, the claim for breach of the implied covenant is redundant.

Power NY Act of 2011

On June 22, 2011, the New York State legislature passed the Power NY Act of 2011 (“Act”) and it was signed by Governor Cuomo on August 4, 2011. This Act is meant to further the Green Jobs, Green New York Act that was passed in 2009. The Act amends the Public Service Law, the Public Authorities Law, the Real Property Law, the State Finance Law, and the Environmental Conservation Law to (1) establish a procedure for administering the existing revolving loan fund, (2) create an on-bill recovery program, (3) enact a simplified procedure for the siting of new major electric generating facilities and for increasing the capacity of existing electric generating facilities, and (4) mandate a study with respect to increasing energy generation from photovoltaic devices (i.e. solar energy generation).

The Green Jobs, Green New York revolving loan fund provides loans to finance the cost of approved qualified energy efficiency services for residential structures, multi-family structures, and non-residential structures. With a few exceptions, the loans are capped at $13,000 per applicant for residential structures and $26,000.00 per applicant for non-residential structures.

The on-bill recovery program is a billing and collection service that will be operated by large electric and gas companies as a way to recover the re-payment of its customers’ revolving loans. Under this program, a charge will be collected on the customer’s monthly utility bill. The electric corporation will collect such charges unless the qualified energy efficiency services at that customer’s premises result in more projected energy savings on the customer’s gas bill than the electric bill. In that case, the charge will be collected by the gas company. The program is set up such that the monthly bill payments will be less than the energy cost savings associated with the efficiency upgrades.

With on-bill recovery, the charge stays with the meter upon transfers of the property so that the efficiency measures are paid over the useful life of the equipment and customers can pay for the cost of the loan through reductions in energy bills. Prior to accepting a purchase offer, a seller of real property that is subject to an on-bill recovery charge has to provide the prospective buyer with a notice stating (1) that the property is subject to an on-bill recovery charge, (2) the total amount of the original charge, (3) the payment schedule, (4) the approximate remaining balance, (5) a description of the energy efficiency services performed, including improvements to the property, and (6) an explanation of the benefit of the qualified energy efficiency services.

The law also enacts a simplified procedure for the siting of new, major electric generating facilities and for increasing the capacity of existing electric generating facilities pursuant to the new certification process outlined in the new article 10 of the Public Service Law. Lastly, the Act calls for a study with respect to increasing energy generation from photovoltaic devices (i.e. solar energy generation) including an analysis of the net economic and job creation benefits of achieving increased development and usage of photovoltaic devices.

These changes are expected to develop the state’s clean energy economic sector including the creation of jobs for construction professionals in the energy retrofit industry business and new high technology jobs related to increasing energy from photovoltaic devices. The Act is also expected to spur the construction of new electric generation including commercial wind facilities.

If you would like more information on this issue or any other construction issue, please contact Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP at (914) 428-2100. 

Second Circuit clarifies the standard for reversal of an arbitral award in connection with an arbitrator’s alleged manifest disregard of the law:

STMICROELECTRONICS, N.V.,
Petitioner-Appellee,
v.
CREDIT SUISSE SECURITIES
(USA) LLC, Respondent-Appellant.

In June 2011, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit clarified the standard for reversal of an arbitral award in connection with an arbitrator’s alleged manifest disregard of the law.

STMicroelectronics, N.V. (“ST”) manufactures semiconductors. Due to be cyclical nature of its business the company is required to have large amounts of cash or cash equivalents on hand to meet its needs. In April 2006, Credit Suisse Securities (USA) LLC (“Credit Suisse”) approached ST offering a type of investment called auction rate securities which are debt instruments whose interest rates are reset by auctions at periodic intervals. Credit Suisse explicitly proposed, and ST explicitly accepted investing only in auction rate securities backed by federally guaranteed student loans.

Credit Suisse adhered to this plan for only a few days. Almost immediately Credit Suisse began buying other securities which carried a higher yield and a higher average commission for Credit Suisse. Those other securities had no government guarantee. By November 2006, the account contained no government-backed securities. After January 2007, none of Credit Suisse’s purchases for ST involved student loans at all. Instead, Credit Suisse bought securities backed up by a wide variety of the assets, some of which turned out to be risky. Credit Suisse brokers responsible for the account sent false email confirmations in which they replaced the names of securities with neutral terms like “funding”.

In July 2007, an ST employee noticed that Credit Suisse had purchased securities that deviate from ST’s instructions and asked Credit Suisse to “stick to the mandate to buy only at Student Loan” securities. In August 2007, the auction rate securities market began to fall apart. By September 2007, all of the securities in ST’s portfolio – worth over $400 million – had failed at auction.

In February 2008, ST filed an arbitration claim against Credit Suisse. In February 2009, after four days of pre-hearing conferences, fifteen days of hearings, and voluminous briefing, the arbitration panel ruled unanimously in favor of ST. The arbitrators’ award undid the trades: ST would return the failed securities (with a par value of $414,975,000) to Credit Suisse upon the payment by Credit Suisse of $400 million in compensatory damages, plus $1.5 million for financing fees, $3 million to cover ST’s attorneys and expert witnesses, and interest. These figures, though substantial, were all lower than the amounts ST had requested in each category.

Naturally, ST quickly petitioned to confirm the award in the Southern District of New York. Credit Suisse opposed ST’s petition and sought to vacate the award in connection with the arbitrators’ alleged “manifest disregard of the law.”

The basic purpose of arbitration is to dispose of disputes quickly and avoid the expense and delay of extended court proceedings. A searching review by the Court would make an arbitration award the commencement, not the end, of litigation. A Court will not vacate an award because of “a simple error in law or a failure by the arbitrators to understand or apply it” but only when a party clearly demonstrates “that the panel intentionally defied the law.” Consequently, where the arbitrators do not explain the reason for their decision, the Court will uphold it if it can discern any valid ground.

In prior decisions the Supreme Court of the United States had basically dismembered the concept of “manifest disregard of the law” in connection with arbitration awards. This decision puts the final nail in the coffin, at least in connection with arbitration awards in New York.

Credit Suisse made a tactical error in attacking only the fraud-based claims of ST, while ignoring the other claims which ST raised, including breach of contract, breach of fiduciary duty, breach of the duty of good faith and fair dealing, unjust enrichment, and failure to supervise. The Second Circuit has stated that, “where an arbitral award contains more than one plausible reading, manifest disregard cannot be found if at least one of the readings yields a legally correct justification for the outcome.” Because ST’s award does not specify claim or claims upon which it rests, Credit Suisse must show manifest disregard of the law for all the claims.

To demonstrate manifest disregard, Credit Suisse must first point to law that is “well-defined, explicit, and clearly applicable” to the case. While Credit Suisse pointed to two different lines of precedent it claims were disregarded, those precedents are inherently fact bound. While broader principles may be extrapolated from similar cases, it does not follow that all cases dealing with similar issues must reach the same result. In reviewing an arbitration award, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals does not require that a distinction be correct, only that it be at least “barely colorable”.

The Second Circuit Court of Appeals easily concluded that the arbitrators did not manifestly disregarded the law.

THE BASIS OF THE DECISION:

WHERE AN AWARD CONTAINS MORE THAN ONE PLAUSIBLE READING, MANIFEST DISREGARD WILL NOT BE FOUND AS LONG AS ONE READING YIELDS A LEGALLY CORRECT JUSTIFICATION FOR THE OUTCOME.

If you would like more information on this issue or any other construction issue, please contact Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP at (914) 428-2100. 

Safety Policy: Making Sure That Prompt First Aid Treatment is Available at Your Worksite

The first few minutes can be critical in cases of serious injuries involving stopped breathing, cardiac arrest, or uncontrolled bleeding. While large-scale, well-planned construction projects will have made provisions to comply with OSHA standards that require that prompt first aid be available, if (for example) yours is a follow-on trade, and you work on a lot of smaller, non-union projects, it would be easy to overlook that, quite possibly, one or more of your current jobsites is not in compliance with this potentially life-or-death requirement.

While of course the lives and the safety of your employees ought to be your paramount concern, yes, even if you’re a follow-on trade, and the general contractor has primary responsibility to ensure compliance with the first aid requirements, if your workers happen to be onsite when the OSHA inspector happens by, you will probably be cited based on OSHA’s multi-employer policy, and be liable for violations and penalties as an “exposing employer.”

The basic first aid requirements can be found in 29 C.F.R. Sec. 1926.50. The employer is required to “insure the availability of medical personnel for advice and consultation on matters of occupational health,” and to make provisions, “prior to commencement of the project, for prompt medical attention in case of serious injury.”

Sub-paragraph (c) of the standard provides:

In the absence of an infirmary, clinic, hospital, or physician, that is reasonably accessible in terms of time and distance to the worksite, which is available for the treatment of injured employees, a person who has a valid certificate in first-aid training from the U.S. Bureau of Mines, the American Red Cross, or equivalent training that can be verified by documentary evidence, shall be available at the worksite to render first aid.

While the standard does not define the key term, “reasonably accessible in terms of time and distance to the worksite,” OSHA interprets that as requiring that emergency medical care be available no more than 3-4 minutes’ travel time distant from the workplace, at least in workplaces where falls, suffocation, electrocution, or amputation are possible. (Longer response times are permissible in less hazardous workplaces, such as offices).

The better practice is, if you are a subcontractor sending employees to work on a site in an urban area, have your office make its own inquiry as to whether there is a proper facility (such as an emergency room or infirmary) within 3-4 minutes’ driving time from the job site. While, obviously, every GC running a job should have the location and directions to the nearest emergency care at its fingertips, even if you’re not the GC, make sure your foreman has that information.

The standard requires that a communication system for contacting an ambulance service be provided, and (in areas not served by “911”) that the telephone numbers for the ambulance service, hospitals, or physicians be conspicuously posted.

The more rural or remote the job site is, unless (obviously) the site happens to be near to a known emergency care facility, the more critical it will be that someone with the proper credentials, and truly competent to render first aid, be on the site.

The surest way to guarantee that on-site first aid will be available, should your employee be injured, is to hire employees who can document American Red Cross or equivalent first-aid training, or to make an investment in providing such training to some of your more trusted employees.

As for the first aid kit, while there is no one-size-fits-all prescription for what must be included, an appendix to the standard references ANSI Standard Z308.1-1978, “Minimum Requirements for Industrial Unit-Type First Aid Kits.” OSHA recommends, also, that your local Fire/Rescue Department, medical professional or emergency room be consulted, concerning additional items to include, and that employers periodically assess the specific needs of their worksite.

Also, if it’s anticipated that employees using first-aid supplies will be exposed to blood or other potentially infectious materials, suitable PPE (gloves, gowns, face shields, masks and eye protection) should be provided, and kept together with the first aid kit.

Note also that the first aid kit must be in a weatherproof container, with individual sealed packages for each type of item, and must be checked by the employer before being sent out on each job, and at least weekly during each job, to ensure that items expended are replaced. A form enclosed in a plastic sheet should be kept in the kit, for the recording of each date and the signature of the person performing each check of the kit as required.

Also included in the first aid standard is the requirement for facilities for quick drenching or flushing of the eyes and body, where these may be exposed to corrosive materials.

If you’re a general contractor, since, under the standard, provisions for prompt medical attention are to be made “prior to commencement of the project,” clearly you have the responsibility to take on a leading role.

Among other things, if you will not have employees of your own with first-aid training and certificates on the job, that needs to be a consideration in choosing and engaging subcontractors.

As GC, you certainly ought to identify the nearest emergency room or similar facility, ensure that the phone numbers are posted, and provide and check regularly the required first-aid kit (and, if applicable, the eye/body washing facility).

At the outset of the job, and again on the arrival of each new subcontractor, efforts as necessary should be made to ensure that every trade knows where the emergency room (infirmary, clinic, or physician) is located, and how to make contact; who the qualified first-aid providers on-site are, and where the first aid kit is maintained. As always, it’s not only good to do these things, but you are wise to document having done them as well. Your safety director or other senior employee should prepare a memo including such information, have each subcontractor countersign the memo to acknowledge its receipt, and retain in a safety/OSHA file for the project the countersigned copy.

These particular OSHA standards arguably should not be necessary. A basic understanding of construction hazards, minimal concern for the lives and the safety of the men and women who work at construction sites, and a modest dose of common sense should suffice to make the required practices a matter of course.

It is not unheard of, unfortunately, that serious accidents occur, followed by the discovery that there is no trained first aid giver at hand, or that no one knows where the first aid kit is stored. Precious time is sometimes lost, because no one had the forethought to identify in advance the nearest hospital or other suitable facility.

It’s counter-productive, obviously, to observe the most highly technical construction safety standards, while neglecting the basics. OSHA’s first aid standards are among the easiest to comply with, as well as the most important. It’s well worth double-checking, to ensure that your company is in compliance.