Skip to main content

Mechanic’s Liens – Lot Retitling & Subdivision

In a recent New York construction law case an issue arose when a Mechanic’s Liens was placed on retitled/subdivided lot. New York State Lien law Lien Law ¬ß 9 requires “that the notice of lien shall state…the property subject to the lien, with a description thereof sufficient for identification; and if in a city,…, its location by street and number, if known.” This case highlights the need for an experienced attorney to draft Notice of Mechanic’s Liens to avoid the potential that the lien be discharged, and further to avoid costly litigation over potentially defective liens.

HAI MING CONSTRUCTION CORP., Plaintiff, v. 258 DEVOE LLC, Defendant
2011 WL 5041802 (N.Y.Sup.)
October 19, 2011

The Supreme Court, Kings County, denied the motion by a general contractor seeking discharge of record of Notice of Mechanic’s Lien, dismissal of lien foreclosure action, cancelation of the Amended Notice of Pendency, and request for costs and expenses for the action.

In HAI MING CONSTRUCTION CORP., v. 258 DEVOE LLC, defendant, 258 Devoe LLC was assigned rights under a general contractor agreement with plaintiff, Hai Ming Construction Corp. Pursuant to the agreement, plaintiff demolished and constructed three new buildings on Lot 9 (Block 2920) located at 258 Devoe Street.

On March 15, 2007, defendant requested that Lot 9 be subdivided into Lots 15 – 18 with new addresses of 260, 264, and 268 Devoe Street. On October 24, 2007, plaintiff filed a Mechanic’s Lien for alleged non-payment under the general contractor agreement for the claimed amount of $386,614.48. The lien was subsequently renewed on October 17, 2008, and further extended by Notice of Pendency filed on September 29, 2009.

Defendant contended that plaintiff’s lien was invalid, it toto, because it did not comply with the provisions of Lien Law ¬ß 9 since it failed to adequately describe the property. Defendant contended the lots subdivision existed as on March 15, 2007. In support, defendant referred to the New York City Department of Finance “alteration book,” which reflected the subdivision into separate lots beforeplaintiff filed the lien on October 24, 2007. Plaintiff countered that the subdivision was not effective until December 5, 2008 supported by a certified copy of the Digital Tax Map which indicated the effective date was December 5, 2008.

The sole issue for the Court was whether the inclusion of the superseded Lot 9, and the omission of the new Lots 16-18 and the new street addresses of 260, 264, and 268. The Court found adequate precedent to determine that if a description that identifies the property is “in substantial compliance with the provisions of the statute sufficient to provide jurisdiction to the courts to enforce it.” The Court referenced SGS Assoc., LLC v. R.A. German Constr. Corp. (15 Misc.3d 1135) where an architect and a contractor were allowed to amend their Notices of Lien when property owner filed a declaration of condominium and subdivided three lots into nine new tax lots prior to the filing of a Notice of Lien.

The Court was unconvinced by defendant’s reasoning noting that while a search of the New York City Department of Finance Automated City Register Information System (ACRIS) would have shown, under a single Lot 9, a April 20, 2007, mortgage against 258, 260, 264, and 268 Devoe Street the search provided insufficient notice as to the existence of a subdivision. The Court ultimately determined that the superseded lot numbers were nevertheless sufficient to identify the property and was not fatal to the validity of the liens. A fair and liberal reading of the lien law required the finding that the description of the property was in substantial compliance with Lien Law ¬ß 9.

While the plaintiff was granted leave to amend its lien, nunc pro tunc, it is important to remember to take the time to verify information in a Notice of Mechanic’s Lien, and search all available databases. Title work is easily performed by a competent lien company or attorney, and is well worth the money. As the Court pointed out a search of the proper database would have provided forewarning of the mortgage and pending address change so plaintiff could add specific language to account for these changes. This would have precluded that defendant from bringing the proceeding in the first place. Further, it is important to remember that the stakes are high because an incorrect address in your lien is usually a fatal defect that will result in the discharge of the lien.

If you would like more information on this issue or any other construction related issue, please contact Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP at (914) 428-2100.

Safety Policy: Know All off the Elements of an OSHA Violation

Avoiding OSHA violations and related penalties is not the number one priority of your health and safety program. What you should be really trying to accomplish is to protect your employees, livelihood and bottom line, by your best efforts to reduce jobsite dangers.

If you’re in construction, from time to time you will be inspected by OSHA, and issued a citation. The silver lining is that a citation issued before anyone has been injured can be seen as a useful alert, and an opportunity to demonstrate to OSHA (who will be back around next year) that you are a safety-conscious employer.

Chances are good, though, that one of these days you will be issued an OSHA citation that should be vacated, because the cited standard doesn’t apply, or the condition existed only in an inaccessible location, or based on some other defect. In many such instances, a contest can be successful, even where the employer’s efforts fell short of perfection.

As an employer, in addition to being familiarity with the substantive standards that affect your trade, you should have a handle on the basics of what constitutes a violation, and what the Secretary of Labor is going to have to prove if you choose to contest your citation.

As an attorney whose firm represents employers in OSHA matters, I don’t want to dissuade you from consulting with experienced counsel concerning any OSHA citation. There are practical and economic reasons to pick your fights carefully, however, in deciding whether to contest a given citation.

For one thing, unless it’s a multi-item citation, or one that involves Willful or Repeat violations, the amount of money at stake is likely to be small. Unless (for example) your current citation may debar you from bidding on public jobs, and put you out of business, incurring thousands in legal fees, to contest a much lesser amount in OSHA penalties, will rarely be money well-spent.

A further consideration, among others, is that a decision to devote time and money to contesting an OSHA citation will seldom make sense, unless chances are good that you can have the citation (or many of the items, if it’s a multi-item citation) vacated.

There are three further things to keep in mind, when considering having an attorney represent you in an OSHA citation contest. First, there are not a lot of generalists with relevant OSHA experience. Because most citations are well-supported, and the penalties are (usually) modest, relatively few are contested and taken through trial. There’s just not enough volume to enable a private attorney to build a practice around fighting OSHA citations. Accordingly, excepting a few in-house lawyers at larger companies, nearly all lawyers who regularly handle citation contests are employed by the U.S. Department of Labor (or a state agency, in states having a “little OSHA” program).

Second, although self-representation will seldom be ideal, under the rules you can contest a citation without an attorney. The employer (or an officer of the employer) can appear and take part in a hearingpro se.

Third, beware the lawyer seeking to impress you with “scorched earth” aggressiveness. A measured approach generally works better with OSHA. Remember, if you stay in business, you can look forward to a future OSHA inspection. No offense will be taken at a contest having a reasonable basis, but taking a weak case to trial, with “guns blazing,” squanders goodwill as well as money. If the only bullets you have are specious arguments and far-fetched contentions, you will be better-advised to pursue settlement, or even to accept the citation, pay the penalties, and move on.

Sound decision-making requires some knowledge of the fundamentals.

First comes jurisdiction. To be cited for violating (federal) OSHA (which oversees private employers in New York, Connecticut, and New Jersey) you must be (1) an employer; (2) engaged in a business affecting interstate commerce.

As a practical matter, if you are in the construction business, you can forget defending based on a lack of effect on interstate commerce. While I have seen statements in the cases suggesting that Congress can regulate anything it likes (a questionable proposition from a Constitutional standpoint) in construction, it’s safe to assume the necessary nexus with interstate commerce. It’s pretty hard to imagine a project not using equipment or materials brought in across state lines.

A defense that occasionally finds some basis, although infrequently, is that the party cited must be an “employer.” Remember, under the “multiple employer policy,” you may be liable, even if none of youremployees are exposed to the violative condition. You can be liable if your control over the worksite was sufficient to make it reasonable to expect you to prevent or detect and abate violations. Plus, if you havecreated a violative condition, you can be held responsible, even if it is only employees of another employer who are exposed.

Nevertheless, to have OSHA liability you do need to be “employer,” which is to say a “person (including a corporation, LLC or other entity) engaged in a business affecting commerce who has employees.” While principals of the company may be deemed to be “employees” while providing services to the company, occasionally there are facts allowing this defense to succeed.

The elements that the Secretary must prove to establish any OSHA violation are: (1) the applicability of the cited standard; (2) noncompliance; (3) employee access to the condition; and (4) actual or constructive knowledge on the part of the cited employer.

Secretary v. Chenal Valley Construction involved a general contractor on a residential project who visited the site 3 times a week, but had no full-time presence. It was cited for violative conditions (involving fall protection and, mostly, scaffolding violations) created by Red Construction, its masonry subcontractor.

Chenal Valley, the GC, did not create the hazards, expose its own employees to them, or control thespecific hazards. It did control the overall worksite by reason of its supervisory authority, and thus had an obligation to inspect the work area, anticipate hazards, and take measures to prevent or correct them.

The administrative law judge found that Chenal Valley had fulfilled these obligations, albeit minimally, and vacated all of the citation items, based on a lack of knowledge of the conditions.

The ALJ declined to find actual knowledge, where the Compliance Officer could only speculate that the conditions had been in place long enough for the GC to have seen them two days before OSHA’s inspection. More convincing, the ALJ found, was the testimony of the GC’s witness, who pointed out from long experience that the scaffolds would have been moved from hour to hour, making it entirely plausible that the defects the inspector saw had not been seen by the GC during its last preceding site visit.

The ALJ also rejected the Secretary’s argument that “constructive knowledge” should be found, based on contemporaneous violations at different Chenal Valley worksites employing a different subcontractor, doing a different type of work.

Chenal Valley’s safety oversight was probably less than ideal, but it nevertheless succeeded in having all items on the Red Construction job vacated. If you have a command of the basics of what needs to be proved, whether you are assisted by an attorney or not, you will make better decisions to assess your prospects, and better chances of success if you elect to contest a given citation.

Entitlement of Lender to Recover on a Promissory Note and Individual Guaranty

Question. Is a lender entitled to recover on a promissory note and individual guaranty in connection with an acquisition loan where the existence of the note and guaranty is undisputed as well as the failure of the borrower and the guarantor to make payments according to the terms of those documents but lender failed to provide subsequent construction financing?

Answer. Yes.

Lender provided land acquisition financing to borrower, a limited liability company. The loan was personally guaranteed by borrower’s members. There were some discussions between borrower and lender concerning a subsequent construction loan being issued but there were never any formal documents prepared concerning construction financing. Borrower and guarantors question their obligation to repay the acquisition loan since construction financing was never provided.

Lender demonstrated its entitlement to judgment by establishing the existence of the note and the guaranty, and the Borrower’s and guarantors’ failure to make payments according to the terms of those documents (hereinafter the loan documents). Failure to issue subsequent construction financing is not a defense to that claim.

Borrowers may have a claim of promissory estoppel, (a theory under which the Lender would be compelled to abide by its “promise” to issue construction financing) but only to the extent that the claim is premised on conduct occurring after the execution of the loan documents. To the extent that the claim was premised on conduct occurring before the execution of the loan documents, there could be no reasonable reliance on any promise to provide a subsequent construction loan in light of the merger and waiver-of-defense (i.e. all prior negotiations, promises, etc. “merge” into the loan document) provisions in the loan documents. However, these contractual provisions do not preclude reasonable reliance on promises made after the loan documents were executed. Also, potentially available is a claim alleging fraud, but only to the extent that the fraud claim was premised on conduct occurring after the execution of the loan documents.

Safety Policy: First Principles of Fire Safety in Construction

Buildings undergoing demolition, renovation, or construction are particularly susceptible to fire. Construction sites are typically rich in combustible materials and, once started, fires often spread with extraordinary speed, putting lives in danger as well as the work in progress.

It’s a good idea to have a fire protection engineer involved with any substantial construction project from the design phase forward. This is required in some instances, and the benefits multiply as the project in question is large, complex, or unusual. Also, the expense of using a fire protection engineer may be cancelled out by insurance and other savings.

It’s highly beneficial, also, to involve local code and fire department officials in your project from the outset. Code enforcement authorities can assist your design team in incorporating required fire protection measures from the design phase onward – the most efficient and cost-effective time to do so – and to plan code compliance, both as to construction operations and the finished building.

Fires in partially-completed structures can be extraordinarily dangerous. Sprinkler systems and fire walls may not be in place. Portions of the construction may be inaccessible. Hazards obvious under normal conditions may be undetectable or unnoticed during an actual fire. By definition, buildings under construction are changing constantly. If responders have never before seen the jobsite, their task becomes all the more challenging.

Perhaps the most perilous situation can arise where a project is being occupied in phases. Obviously, in a fire situation, it’s critical to know which portions of a partly-completed project are occupied and which are not. In the planning phase, water lines, control panels and fire pumps can be located logically, to support the sequence in which portions of the project will be occupied. Locations for the unloading of materials and (especially) the storage of flammable materials, can be strategically placed, as well as means of egress, fire extinguishers, etc.

Once site work begins, an onsite command post should be established, and a fire protection program manager designated. The command post should have the drawings and plans for construction, emergency information, means of communications, keys and equipment for use by the program manager and emergency responders. This is the time to establish, and ensure compliance with, rules requiring the regular disposal of waste, and the safe storage of materials (especially combustible materials) in locations equipped with fire extinguishers and remote from operations, or local conditions such as wildfires that could increase the risk of combustion.

Formal pre-incident plans are highly desirable, and are required for some projects (whether by code, or as part of an insurance and risk-management program). While permission from the owner will usually be required, providing construction plans to local fire responders can aid them in their pre-fire planning. Data from construction plans can be stored electronically, and retrieved during an actual incident, to aid in dispatching resources in response.

In all events, frequent site visits by the fire department are invaluable in aiding both your fire program manager and emergency responders in developing and updating response plans, and creating a basis for more rapid and effective decision-making, should a fire occur.

The sitework phase is usually the best time, also, to plan for water supply and access, sufficient all-weather roads, and adequate means of escape ? not only from the building being constructed, but from the surrounding site. Multiple exits from the site perimeter are desirable, if practicable.

As construction proceeds past the sitework stage, progressively there will come onsite a host of fire hazards, for which precautions must be planned. These typically include welding operations, temporary heating equipment, electrical equipment, flammable and combustible liquids and gases, explosives, combustible materials such as formwork, and even things such as employees smoking.

One critical need is to properly store and label explosives and other highly hazardous materials. Firefighters may be killed or injured if unable to identify, quickly and reliably, where such materials are present. This should be coordinated with local authorities, as permits are often required, and measures taken to secure hazardous materials against terrorists, juveniles, disgruntled employees, and aspiring arsonists. Here again, a fire protection engineer can help reduce these hazards through planning, coordination, and liaison with code officials and emergency responders.

During building erection, additional considerations come into view. A lighted stair must be constructed for use by construction workers and emergency responders. It should have identification signs, and fire extinguishers on each level.

Functional standpipe systems are also essential in buildings under construction. In the case of taller buildings, local codes may require the availability of an elevator or hoist for fire services.

Another area of concern during erection is the combustibility of materials, notably formwork (which may be limited by code, or restricted to lower elevations) and materials used in erecting temporary enclosures. Non-flammable or fire-resistant materials should be used whenever practicable, and care taken to keep these items away from sources of ignition, and to ensure that they will not obstruct exits in the event of fire.

<p.as always,="" of="" course,="" during="" erection,="" plans="" must="" be="" reviewed="" frequently="" and="" kept="" current,="" to="" permit="" employees="" other="" occupants="" alerted="" in="" case="" emergency,="" allow="" them="" escape="" the="" structure,="" afford="" access="" emergency="" responders.

As construction advances to the upper stories, care must be taken to secure materials on upper floors which, in addition to posing hazards to construction employees, could be blown onto firefighters during a fire in windy conditions. Also, roof operations often present fire safety issues – such as where torch-applied roofing, or tar kettles, are employed.

Once interior trades are at work, and the building is to be enclosed, one critical coordination issue is that whereas the required stairway must be enclosed when the building exterior walls are in place, some jurisdictions permit the stairway to be enclosed in tandem with the exterior walls, on a floor-by-floor basis. Others require the stairway to be fully enclosed first.

Part of this phase will be the installation and testing of alarm, detection, sprinkler, standpipe and other fire protection systems. This generally requires coordination with items that must be installed and inspected before they are concealed, such as electrical work and fireproofing.

As work approaches the punch-list phase, special attention may be required to detect and to ensure safety, where alarm, sprinkler, or other fire safety installations remain incomplete, or may be inoperable.

Partial occupancy may also present issues governed by local codes, such as provisions governing what levels of completion other conditions will permit occupancy of building levels above and below levels still under construction.

Another key element in partial-occupancy situations is the completeness of exit enclosures and parts of the building required to gain access to them from the occupied portions.

The keys to success in minimizing risks from fire during construction are:

  • communication among all participants;
  • input from an experienced fire protection engineer, and local code and emergency response personnel;
  • integrating fire prevention into all phases of construction; and
  • keeping abreast of progress in the construction of the project, and updating your pre-incident planning accordingly.

Court Rejects Claim for Loss of Profitability

In a recent New York Court of Claims case, Liddell v. The State of New York, a contractor made a novel claim for breach of contract. The contractor sought compensation based on the unanticipated increase in the cost of materials. Notably, the claim to recover the increase in the cost of materials was not caused by any delay by the State in the completion of the project.

Background 

Liddell Brothers, Inc. contracted with the State of New York to upgrade the Intelligent Transportation System on the Northern State Parkway in Nassau and Suffolk Counties. Part of the contractor’s work included the installation of copper cable. Between the contract signing and the contractor’s purchase of the copper cable, the cost of copper materials increased. The contractor claimed that the price increase was unanticipated and requested additional compensation from the State. The State denied the request on the grounds that it was not contractually or statutorily required to pay the contractor for the increased cost of the copper cable. The State’s representatives also noted that under the contract, the contractor was entitled to purchase and stockpile the copper cable once the contract was signed, and invoice the State for the materials purchased, which the contractor did not do.

After the contractor’s request for additional compensation was denied, the contractor sued the State. The State moved for summary judgment, dismissing the contractor’s claims.

Decision

The court ruled in favor of the State, granting summary judgment and dismissing the contractor’s claims. The Court based its decision on the plain terms of the parties’ contract. Although the parties’ contract included provisions for an increase in the cost of steel, iron, asphalt and fuel, it did not include any provision for increases in the cost of copper. Additionally, the court noted that the contract provision addressing unanticipated price increases related to delays caused by the State. This was not a delay claim. Here, the contractor acknowledged that there were no delays caused by the State, so the contract provision that the contractor was attempting to rely upon was inapplicable.

According to the court, “the mere fact that a contract becomes economically unprofitable is insufficient reason to relieve a contracting party from its contractual obligations.” Further, the court stated “there is no moral obligation to give public money to disappointed contractors.” Based on the plain terms of the parties’ contract, the court dismissed the contractor’s claims.

Comment

With limited exceptions, courts will enforce contract terms that are clear and unambiguous. Here, there was simply no contractual basis for the State to provide the contractor additional compensation for the increased cost of copper cable. Nor would the contractor have been required to provide the State a refund if the cost of copper had gone down. The court system does not exist to rewrite the terms of the parties’ contract. Courts will not substitute for an agreement reached by two parties the court’s view of what the agreement should have been. The court’s role is to interpret and enforce the agreed-upon terms. Contractors should keep this in mind when negotiating a contract and performing their work.

Question of Intrepreting a 90 Day Cancelation Policy in a Service Contract

Question. Owner executed a 10 year service contract with Elevator Contractor, and notified them, a year later, Owner was cancelling it. Elevator Contractor alleges the cancellation could only occur 90 days before the expiration of the contract term. That would mean the anticipated cancellation date was the same as the end of the contract. Was Owner’s cancellation proper?

Answer. Yes.

Elevator Contractor’s reading of the contract is improper. The contract did not state such, and such condition was not agreed to by the parties. The contract was mutually cancellable, but Elevator Contractor had a viable claim for 90 days worth of unpaid services from the date of Owner’s notice.

In relevant part, the contract provides that it may be cancelled as follows:

THE SERVICE IS FURNISHED FROM 10/1/08 FOR THE PERIOD OF TEN (10) YEARS AND WILL BE RENEWED FOR THE SAME PERIOD OF TIME UNLESS CANCELLED BY EITHER PARTY ON NINETY DAYS WRITTEN NOTICE PRIOR TO THE END OF ANY CONTRACT TERM AND ANY AND ALL OUTSTANDING INVOICES MUST BE PAID BETWEEN THE TIME THE NOTICE OF CANCELLATION IS RENDERED AND THE ANTICIPATED CANCELLATION DATE.

By letter dated September 24, 2009, Owner notified Elevator Contractor that it was cancelling the contract “effective today.” Elevator Contractor’s wrote back on September 25th that the cancellation letter was a “nullity” and that it was rejected because the contract was effective until September 30, 2018. According to Elevator Contractor, the cancellation could only occur “at least 90 days prior to the expiration of the contract term.”

Whereas Elevator Contractor claims the contract is unambiguous, Owner contends it makes no sense that an elevator service company would want to tie itself down to one client at an unfluctuating monthly rate for ten (10) years. Thus, Owner contends the cancellation clause has been misconstrued by Elevator Contractor, there is an ambiguity in the contract and it should be construed against Elevator Contractor since Owner had no part in authoring the document. According to Owner, the contract can be “CANCELLED BY EITHER PARTY ON NINETY DAYS WRITTEN NOTICE” at any time “PRIOR TO THE END OF ANY CONTRACT TERM…” Owner argues that if Elevator Contractor intended that this “could only be” cancelled “PRIOR TO THE END OF ANY CONTRACT TERM” it should have contained such language.

The terms of a written contract between the parties should be enforced in accordance with its terms. The interpretation by Elevator Contractor of the contract provision at issue is not supported by the very words in that particular provision or when examining the contract as a whole.

The cancellation clause indicates the contract is for a period of 10 years. It also states that it will automatically renew for another 10 years “UNLESS CANCELLED BY EITHER PARTY ON NINETY (90) DAYS WRITTEN NOTICE PRIOR TO THE END OF ANY CONTRACT TERM…” The contract does not state it can “only be cancelled on ninety (90) days written notice prior to the end of any contract term.” Adopting Elevator Contractor’s interpretation would mean that the “ANTICIPATED CANCELLATION DATE” is the exact same thing as the “END OF THE CONTRACT.” The contract does not state this and it is not a condition agreed to by the parties in writing.

The contract also has a separate provision dealing with payment of invoices. It states that:

THE COMPANY RESERVES THE RIGHT TO SUSPEND OR CANCEL THIS CONTRACT UPON FAILURE TO MAKE PAYMENT OF ANY OUTSTANDING INVOICES OVER 120 DAYS, SUCH SUSPENSION OR CANCELLATION TO BE EFFECTIVE UPON THE MAILING OF NOTICE THEREOF…

Consequently, the contract is cancellable at other times and for other reasons.

Arguments by Elevator Contractor, that it fully intended to be bound for the entire 10 year term of the contract and it could not be terminated sooner than that, only identify their misconception of what the contract stands for. The condition Elevator Contractor claims to have bargained for is simply not evident in the plain language of this agreement. Evidently the parties agreed they could mutually terminate the contract on notice. Elevator Contractor’s argument that it expected the contract to last a “minimum of 10 years” is easily reconcilable with the terms of the contract. It would have lasted 10 years, but for the decision by Owner to cancel it. It could also have been cancelled by Elevator Contractor, however, for non-payment and also on 90 days notice.

Since Owner gave Elevator Contractor notice of the Owner’s intention to terminate the contract, but stated it was effective “today,” Elevator Contractor has a viable claim for 90 days worth of unpaid services from the date of the notice. The notice was not rejected by Elevator Contractor because it failed to give 90 days notice, but because it was not 90 days before the end of the contract term.

Safety Policy: Bureau of Labor Statistics Reports Progress in Reducing Construction Fatalities

Each year, the federal Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) issues a “Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries.” The preliminary numbers are out for 2010, and there is some good news to report.

That good news is that, nationwide, construction fatalities were down sharply from 2009 to 2010. And, although much of the drop in fatal occurrences must be attributed to the “bad news” that construction employment also continued to fall, the number of deaths fell more than employment did. Thus, it appears that there have been modest, but significant, reductions that may be attributable to increased safety efforts.

The preliminary death count for all U.S. workers was almost unchanged from 2009 to 2010, as was the rate of 3.5 fatalities per 100,000 “full-time equivalent” workers in all occupational classes.

The gross total of fatal work injuries in the private construction sector declined by 10 percent in 2010, a rate roughly two-thirds higher than the drop in the number of hours worked, of about 6%. Fatalities in 2010 totaled 751, according to BLS’s preliminary figures, down from 834 in 2009, and 1,239 in 2006. The number of deaths has decreased every year since 2006-07, and last year’s number was the lowest overall total in 18 years. There were reductions in residential, commercial, civil and heavy highway work, and in most trades.

Construction deaths from falls numbered 260 in 2010, a 42% decline from 447 in 2007. “Struck-by” incidents accounted for 112 deaths; contract with electricity, 76; and trenching and other deaths from being caught between objects 39.

Trade groups were quick to applaud the continued reduction in jobsite fatalities, with many crediting a strengthened commitment to hazard identification and proactive training. While poor economic conditions, and perhaps reductions in employment that have fallen disproportionately upon the less-skilled, less-experienced, and less-conscientious employees who swelled payrolls during the construction boom, account for much of the diminished carnage, it’s undeniable that most people in construction are more safety-conscious than in even the recent past. Safety planning is now a given on most significant projects. While I have questioned the efficacy of employee safety training, certainly there’s a lot more training today than there was ten or twenty years ago. Many employers have gone from grudging efforts to keep OSHA at bay, to more earnest efforts to surpass minimal compliance, and to focus less on avoiding penalties, and more on actually keeping employees safe.

While construction-industry employment fell less last year than in either of the preceding two years, obviously there is far less work at present than in 2006-07. And, for all that the number of deaths has gone down even more than hours worked, or dollars expended, in the construction sector, construction still produces more fatal accidents than any other U.S. industry.

Plainly, while the safety results over the last few years are a silver lining of sorts in what has been, and continues to be, a very challenging environment for the industry, much remains to be done.

And, as the King said to the White Rabbit, it’s necessary to start at the beginning, which in construction isfall protection. Not only are fall hazards the #1 killer overall, but they are a hazard too often shown insufficient respect, with lethal results.

Whereas, certainly, there are facets of OSHA compliance that are technically challenging, and require considerable sophistication to detect, correct, or avoid, by and large fall protection (and associated OSHA standards) are pretty straightforward.

For example, the number of deaths from falls resulting from experienced, amply-equipped workers simply failing to tie off is dismaying. Gravity, and the effects on the body of hitting asphalt from 12 stories up, are understood by just about everyone. This cause of death and injury isn’t primarily a matter of training – as attested by the number of victims who hit the ground wearing serviceable harnesses, but did not bother to tie off. It’s primarily a matter of leadership, which is largely about communicating to your employees that you care sufficiently for their lives, and the well-being of their families, that small losses in productivity are meaningless, and not tying off completely unacceptable.

Of course, there is more to fall protection than personal fall arrest systems, and yes, training is required for employees to know how to use equipment properly, inspect it, and to understand its limitations.

But the list of the conditions in violation of OSHA (and the New York Labor Law) that lead to most fall-related accidents is not a long one. It includes, certainly, the following:

  • Improperly-erected scaffolds;
  • Defective, damaged, or improperly-used ladders;
  • Leading edges of steel-deck construction;
  • Holes in floors and working or walking surfaces;
  • Missing guardrails;
  • Open edges on floors;
  • Rooftop operations;
  • Open elevator shafts;
  • Skylights;
  • Fall arrest systems not used, or used improperly.

In addition to fall hazards being viewed too casually, a major element of the danger associated with fall hazards is the nature of the multi-employer jobsite: one employer may create a hazard, intending to correct it promptly, only to have the hazard remain in place, uncorrected, long enough for another contractor’s employee (for example) to fall through an uncovered hole in a floor or other surface.

Thus, guardrails around skylights, guardrails on scissors lifts, covers over floor openings, and restricted zones in roofing operations are examples of fall prevention measures that are governed by design requirements which, if requiring some homework in the OSHA regulations, are not among the most complicated of the construction standards.

There are, in life, problems that can be definitively solved, sometimes with the application of technology, and problems that never get fully solved, but must be wrestled with. While technology certainly has some role in improving construction safety, overall the problem is one I regard as falling within the latter category. We can’t eliminate all dangers, or reduce the serious accident rate to zero, but efforts made over the last few years are having a real, positive impact.

Are we at, or even near, the place where we might believe that increased efforts would produce little if any added benefit? Almost certainly not. But if the progress has been modest, it ought to be enough to convince us that the efforts made have been worthwhile.

Showing of Actual Supervision Required Before a General Contractor must Indemnify an Owner for Damages Paid to an Injured Person

Construction site accidents and related injuries are a constant concern to contractors and owners, as are the lawsuits that may follow. A general contractor's agreement with a property owner may provide that the general contractor supervise and direct work. But what happens when the owner seeks to be indemnified by the general contractor for injuries a worker sustained at the site? Must the general contractor indemnify the owner where they have contractual authority to supervise and control work? Does the answer change if the general contractor has contracted the work out to someone else and didn't actively supervise and/or direct the work?

The New York Court of Appeals has provided an answer in McCarthy v. Turner Const., Inc., 17 N.Y.3d 369,953 N.E.2d 794 (2011).

Boston Properties and Times Square Tower Associates, LLC (the "Owners") own retail space at7 Times Square. Ann Taylor, a non party to this action, leases space from the Owners for its clothing store. In December of 2004, Ann Taylor contracted with John Gallin & Son, Inc. ("Gallin") to expand its retail space. The contract with Gallin required that Gallin "supervise and direct the [w]ork, using [its] best skill and attention[, and] be solely responsible for and have control over construction means, methods, techniques, sequences and procedures for coordinating all portions of the [w]ork." Id. at 372, 796. Furthermore, Gallin was required to take "reasonable safety precautions to protect the workers from injury." Id.

Gallin then engaged Linear Technologies, Inc. ("Linear") to install phone and data cables, via a purchase order. Linear subsequently subcontracted its work out to Samuels Datacom, LLC ("Samuels") to perform all of the installation. The plaintiff, while performing electrical work for Samuels, failed to defy Newton's law and fell from a ladder, sustaining injuries. Id. at 372, 796-797.

The plaintiff brought a personal injury action against the Owners and Gallin, asserting common law negligence and violations of Labor Law § 200, 240(1) and 240(6). Id. at 372, 797. The Owners cross-claimed against Gallin for, in relevant part, common law indemnification. Gallin then implead Linear, who implead Samuels. Id.

The plaintiff moved for summary judgment, and the Owner's cross-moved, seeking contractual indemnification against Gallin. The Supreme Court refused to require Gallin to indemnify the owners, finding that Gallin did not have supervisory authority over Samuel's work and did not provide any tools or ladders to the subcontractors, nor would Gallin have directed Samuel on how to perform its work. Id. The Owners and Gallin then settled with the plaintiff for $1.6 million, contributing $800,000 each.

The Owners then moved for summary judgment on common law indemnification against Gallin, which was likewise denied due to their failure to establish Gallin's direct control over the work. This denial was affirmed by the Appellate Division, First Department. Id.

The case reached the Court of Appeals, who likewise affirmed the lower courts' decisions. The Owners argued that Gallin did not need to directly supervise and control plaintiff's work, because Gallin's contract with Ann Taylor assumed sole responsibility and control, and likewise provided Gallin with the authority to exercise same. Id. at 374, 798.

The Court of Appeals refused to require that every general contractor owe a common law duty to indemnify the owner, where they aren't actively at fault. Id. New York case law does impose such a duty on ''parties who actually supervised and controlled the injury-producing work." Id. at 376, 799. However, the Court held that a contractual responsibility to supervise, ''where another party, with authority engaged in actual supervision of the injury-producing work", is insufficient to create such a duty. Id. at 377,800.

Therefore, "if a party with contractual authority to direct and supervise the work at a job site never exercises that authority because it subcontracted its contractual duties to an entity that actually directed and supervised the work, a common law indemnification claim will not lie against that party on the basis of its contractual authority alone." Id. at 378, 801. In conclusion, Gallin did not have to cover the Owners' $800,000 share of the settlement.

The take away lesson here is that if you are going to subcontract your authority to supervise, control and direct work at a site, do so completely. Do not subsequently engage in such supervision and direction if you want to avoid common law indemnification for sustained injuries, which in this case, is a savings of $800,000. Of course, the wording of your subcontract will control.

 

Dispute resolution procedure making contractor the sole arbiter of all claims and disputes under the subcontract was void for illegality under the law of trusteeship and was unenforceable

The facts of the case start out in a fairly common fashion. General Contractor, entered into a prime contract with the Dormitory Authority of the State of New York (DASNY) with respect to a public improvement construction project. General Contractor, then entered into a written subcontract agreement (the subcontract), with Subcontractor for the project.

The subcontract contained a not so uncommon “Dispute Resolution Procedure,” which made the General Contractor “the sole arbiter of all claims, disputes, and questions of any nature” subject only to limited judicial review if “the determination by the sole arbiter was made in bad faith or fraudulently.”

Subcontractor began its performance of the subcontract, and timely completed its installations. During the course of the project, General Contractor requested and directed Subcontractor to perform additional work, which was beyond the scope of the subcontract. Subcontractor alleges that despite due demand, General Contractor has failed and refused to pay it this outstanding subcontract balance in breach of the subcontract. Subcontractor also asserts a delay claim against the General Contractor. Subcontractor sued the General Contractor for breach of contract, to foreclose its mechanics’ lien, to enforce the Lien Law Article 3A Statutory Trust, and the General Contractor’s surety as a beneficiary of the statutory payment and performance bond.

The Subcontractor was able to overcome the General Contractor’s and Surety’s motion to dismiss by arguing that the Dispute Resolution Procedure in the subcontract is void for illegality under the law of trusteeship and is unenforceable as a matter of law. Under Lien Law ¬ß3-A, General Contractor, as a general contractor on a public improvement construction project, is a statutory trustee with respect to all funds it received from the owner, DASNY, for work performed on the project and that, as a subcontractor to General Contractor, Subcontractor is a statutory beneficiary of that trust. The Subcontractor noted and the Court agreed that the Dispute Resolution Procedure runs afoul of the General Contractor’s obligations to Subcontractor as a statutory trustee because it creates a conflict of interest in permitting General Contractor to determine whether to retain public trust funds for itself or compensate Subcontractor for work performed.

The Dispute Resolution Procedure was also found to run afoul of the Subcontractor’s mechanics’ lien rights. The Dispute Resolution Procedure creates three conditions precedent to the subcontractor’s right to recover compensation to which it would be entitled under the Lien Law: exhaustion of the described alternative dispute resolution procedure before an arbitrator controlled by defendant contractor; the filing of a notice of claim with the contractor; and the pleading of compliance with the preceding procedural requirements, without which the subcontractor is deemed to have waived the right to recover, all of which violate the public policy reflected in the Lien Law by providing for a waiver by the subcontractor of “all rights and remedies against the Contractor which are not expressly provided for by the said [Dispute Resolution Procedure]”, including “any claims of breach of contract or other alleged bases for damages or relief against the Contractor”.

Subcontractor’s claims against the surety bond also survived the motion to dismiss as the General Contractor’s attempt to apply the notice and alternative dispute resolution procedures contained in the subcontract to defeat Subcontractor’s rights under State Finance Law ¬ß137 is clearly in contravention of the public policy reflected in the statute and repeatedly recognized in the caselaw.

Subcontractor’s breach of contract claims were dismissed as the Court found the Dispute Resolution Procedure to be enforceable as it pertains to those specific causes of action. That portion of damages asserted for delay, as contained in the payment bond claim was also reduced on similar grounds.

It is important to note that the Court specifically found that the Subcontractor in this case had substantially complied with the Notice of Claim provisions in the agreement.

This case like others before it serves to highlight a contracting party’s need to consult experienced construction attorneys in negotiating and understanding their agreements and to then be vigilant in following the provisions of the contract. If those prerequisites are met you will have provided your construction litigation attorney with the ammunition needed to fight for your rights.

If you would like more information on this issue or any other construction issue, please contact Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP at (914) 428-2100. 

Recent Statutory Amendments Expand the Remedies Available for Non-Payment on Both Public and Private Construction Projects.

Two recent statutory amendments have expanded the remedies available for non-payment on both public and private construction projects. Consequently, owners', sureties', and contractors' exposure has been likewise expanded.

Lien Law Section 10 has been amended by adding a provision that states "and provided further where the notice of lien is for retainage, the notice of lien may be filed within 90 days after the date the retainage was due to be released." [A05022 / S. 3179]. Lienors on private projects now have up to 90 days to file a mechanics' lien after their retainage was due to be released. Prior to the amendment, lienors had as little as four months to file a lien "dating from the last item of work performed or materials furnished". Previously, lienors were arguably unable to file a lien for their unpaid retainage where the contract did not make retainage due until sometime after the old deadline to file a lien.

Section 1. Paragraph (b) of subdivision 4 of section 137 of the State Finance Law has been amended to read as follows: "b) Except as provided in section two hundred twenty-g of the labor law, no action on a payment bond furnished pursuant to this section shall be commenced after the expiration of one year from the date on which the public improvement has been completed and accepted by the public owner." [S. 3182 / A. 5025] Prior to the amendment the statute of limitations for initiating public work payment bond claims was measured from the date on which final payment under the claimant's subcontract became due. Very often an early completing trade found that its time for commencing an action on a payment bond had expired even though the project had not been completed. The amendment makes the date for calculating statute of limitations periods uniform for all claimants on any given project.