Skip to main content

Adequate Training, Experience and Equipment are Necessary When Working Near Energized Lines

Secretary of Labor v. The L.E. Myers Co. shows the importance of adequate training, experience and equipment when working near energized lines. This matter arises from an unfortunate and tragic work-place accident involving a journeyman lineman for an electrical utility sub-contractor, L.E. Myers Co. (LEM) in Florida. On November 15, 2019, LEM assigned a four-man crew to transfer electrical distribution lines from an existing utility pole to a new utility pole. Due to the live electrical current, OSHA requires employers to determine the minimum approach distance (“MAD”) before its employees work near energized lines at a worksite. The MAD is the closest distance an employee may approach an energized or grounded object without taking specific safety precautions. At this site, the MAD was determined to be 2 feet, 2 inches.

The four-man crew arrived at the worksite around on the incident date and began to discuss their respective assignments. The crew consisted of the Foreman, two journeyman lineman (inclusive of the Decedent), and an apprentice. The Foreman conducted a pre-job briefing and had everyone sign a Daily Pre-Job Brief document. This document listed the steps for this assignment and included a checklist of the tools required. The document stated the assignment as “Move wires to new pole and hang arms and mac” and had a checklist for “PPE/Tools Required”. The Foreman checked of all tools on the required list including rubber insulating gloves and rubber insulating sleeves. The crew had two bucket trucks and one smaller “backyard machine”. The apprentice and Decedent were in these buckets, the JL in the backyard machine and the Foreman on the ground to observe.

The incident occurred when the Foreman called to the Decedent to lower his bucket to hand him a mac (a flexible wire with clamps at either end, used to bypass an area of an energized line so work can be done in the bypassed area). When the Foreman handed the mac to the Decedent, he did not notice whether or not the Decedent was wearing rubber insulating sleeves. The interaction was a couple of seconds and Decedent immediately raised his bucket back up to the height needed to determine if the mac length was acceptable. The Foreman, as the only eyewitness testifying, stated after he gave the Decedent the mac, the Decedent elevated his bucket and screamed down something along the lines of “that’ll work.” As the Foreman started to walk away to collect other macs just in case, the Foreman heard sizzling, popping and the jerking of the bucket. He looked up to realize Decedent was slumped over in his bucket. After cutting the mac, it was safe for Decedent to be lowered and receive medical attention. However, the electrocution resulted in Decedent’s death. The Decedent was found to be only wearing his rubber gloves, but not his rubber insulating sleeves. Two of OSHA’s compliance officers investigated the scene that same day, taking photos and interviewing individuals, but they did not conduct any measurements or simulations. LEM’s Foreman was discharged in December 2019. OSHA eventually cited LEM for three serious violations arising from the incident.

The ALJ found the Foreman’s testimony regarding the rubber insulating sleeve was sufficient as the Foreman was close enough to detect, with reasonable diligence, whether the Decedent was wearing the sleeve or not. In terms of assignment, the Foreman testified that he only wanted the Decedent to get close enough to measure the mac, which did not require the Decedent to breach the MAD. The Foreman explained that the task could have been done by not elevating the bucket to the height, however it probably would have been more difficult. He did not ask for the Decedent to install the mac, as installation would require all three crewmembers in position.

Item 1 of the Citation pertained to the Decedent not being trained or competent in the MAD skills and techniques in order to maintain a safe distance. Although recordkeeping of employment records is one way to keep track of an employee’s demonstrated proficiency, the ALJ here found that in fact the Decedent did have adequate training and proficiency by the evidence submitted and vacated this portion of the citation. Although, the Decedent had only worked with LEM for about two months, he had over 15 years of prior experience (via the apprenticeship and journeyman system) in his previous jobs, which required MAD training. Upon hiring, LEM provided the Decedent a New Hire Orientation Outline, which included the MADs and Decedent had received a copy of the Safety Manual which also addressed MADs. Furthermore, LEM’s Safety Engineer testified how they provide orientation and safety training for newly hired employees, periodic safety training, crew visits and onsite audits. Here, the Safety Engineer had interviewed the Decedent during his orientation to determine his knowledge and understanding of safety-related work practices, including MADs. Moreover, LEM’s supervisors including the Foreman were trained to closely observe new hires to ensure their proficiency, including on safety.

The other items of the Citation were based upon Decedent breaching the MAD without appropriate precautions and failures by LEM to ensure that no employee approaches or takes a conductive object closer to the exposed energy parts than the established MAD. LEM even had a “cradle to cradle policy” that stated that both the rubber insulating gloves and sleeves were to be worn when working on energized equipment on an aerial platform. However, the Foreman’s instruction to the Decedent was to perform work at a height not within the MAD. Only when the Decedent elevated his bucket to the height of the distribution lines and connected one end of the mac to the line did he breach the MAD. Since this occurred within mere seconds, the ALJ found that this fleeting moment did not establish a failure on the part of the Foreman to exercise reasonable diligence and supervision. The Foreman had worked with the Decedent for two months prior to the incident and never noticed any conduct that would alert him to heightened monitoring of Decedent’s safety practices. Therefore, these items of the Citation were also vacated.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Companies Should Always Conduct Careful Pre-Planning of All Hoisting Operations

Secretary of Labor v. S&R Enterprises, LLC demonstrates the importance of adequately pre-planning all hoisting operations especially in the realm of steel erection, preferably in writing and with clear instruction to all involved employees to avoid accidents. This matter arose in Savannah, Georgia in June 2019 involving the hoisting of a grappler (a giant steel claw) that weighed 10,500 lbs., which was intended as a decorative element for a hotel lobby that became displaced, causing serious injuries to three workers on site.

S&R Enterprises, LLC (“S&R”) is a steel erection contractor who had been a subcontractor on a renovation project for roughly two years prior to the incident. The project was to re-purpose a decommissioned power plant and transform it into a luxury hotel. S&R was asked by the hotel owner to hang an industrial grappler (a giant steel claw) to the new hotel’s atrium lobby, as a decorative element. This request was not a part of S&R’s original scope of work, but they agreed to do so. S&R determined it would not be possible to position a crane in the area to perform a conventional lift. Instead, they decided to use an air tugger consisting of a drum and cable. To perform the lift, a padeye (a steel plate with a hole in it used as an attachment point) was welded to the east and west girders. The grappler was supported by these two girders. The plan was to run the wire rope from the padeye of the east girder to the rigging attached to the grappler, up to the padeye on the west girder and down to the air tugger which would pull the rope to raise the grappler.

Prior to the commencement of the lift, S&R’s vice-president prepared a written, activity hazard analysis (AHA) based upon the assistant superintendent’s drawing of the proposed plan. The AHA identified the job steps, hazards and controls of the operation with numbered instructions. It specifically mentioned how no workers were to be under the suspended load at any point during the lift. During the operation, the padeye on the west girder tore away causing the weight of the grappler and rigging to fall. The weight of grappler dragged the wire rope against the personnel basket of the aerial lift, damaging the basket and injuring two employees and another employee who was struck by a wire, while supervising the lift. The fall resulted in serious injuries and hospitalization of three workers.

After the incident, OSHA’s compliance officer came to inspect the site. Upon investigation he determined that the assistant superintendent had done no metallurgical testing to ascertain the strength of the girders. The compliance officer believed the measurement could have been taken prior to the lift to get a better calculation of the load of the girders. His opinion resulted in a two-item citation of two statutes. The first statute cited was for failing to adequately determine the lift, thickness, and strength of the steel erection hosting operation given that “all hoisting operations in steel erection shall be pre-planned to ensure that the requirements” of the applicable standard are met. The second statute cited was for not adequately rigging the hoisted material (the grappler) to prevent displacement. The matter was brought before an ALJ for OSHA’s Review Commission. Here, the facts were not in dispute but rather the interpretation of the steel erection standard’s requirements and definitions.

Whether the cited statutes applied depended first upon whether S&R engaged in “steel erection” when it attempted to raise the grappler to the overhead crane hook. By definition of the subpart of the cited statute, steel erection is the “construction, alteration or repair of steel buildings, bridges and other structures, including the installation of metal decking and all planking used during the process of erection.” Steel erection activities include installation of miscellaneous metals, ornamental iron and similar materials. Therefore, the ALJ determined S&R’s activities fell within this standard.

Although S&R at the time was deemed to be engaged in “steel erection” activity, the Secretary failed to establish S&R was noncompliant with the cited statutes. Even though there was no written requirement to have a pre-plan of the hoisting, in writing, S&R had developed a written activity hazard analysis prior to the lift. The failing of the girder to sustain of the weight of the hoisted load was not considered/planned for by S&R. Although the failure to calculate load capacity was a significant omission, it was not addressed by the cited standard which required an employer to preplan the route of the suspended load so that no employee was required to work under it. Here, there were specific instructions in S&R’s AHA to not be under the load, but employees acted contrary to this instruction. How the lift was preplanned and how the lift actually transpired were separate issues and the ALJ found that the Secretary failed to establish that S&R violated the applicable standard and thus vacated this citation.

As to the second citation, in terms of failing to prevent displacement of the hoisted material, here the grappler, the ALJ inquired about the definition of “load” in this context and found that the structure that supports the weight being hoisted cannot, by definition, be a part of the load. Therefore, the west girder which caused the fall was not part of the materials being hoisted. Although S&R failed to accurately assess the load capacity of both east and west girder, that is not detailed in the cited statute for this violation and the “failure of the lift is not enough…to establish S&R violated the standard the Secretary chose to cite.” Evidence was not presented showing S&R rigged the load incorrectly or the equipment it used was faulty and therefore this citation was vacated as well.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Companies Should Maintain Safety Programs and Work Rules that are Adequately Communicated and Enforced to Prevent Fall Hazards

Secretary of Labor v. Miller Insulation is an instructive case showing the need for safety programs that include proper training, guidance and communication for fall protection. This matter arose from an accident and tragic death of an employee of Miller Insulation, on April 19, 2019, in North Dakota, who fell from the edge of a mezzanine floor where the wooden floor met a drop ceiling with a nine-foot height differential.

Miller provides insulation services with approximately 600 employees. Here, Miller was to repair insulation on piping and valves and replace stained ceiling tiles at a school. Approximately, a month prior to the accident, Miller’s superintendent conducted a walk-through of the worksite with the superintendent of the general contractor. They both reviewed the punch list of items to be completed and took photographs. During the walk-through they climbed a ladder to enter a mechanical room on a mezzanine floor, above. The mezzanine had wood flooring that did not extend all the way to the walls at each end of the floor. Between the end of the wood floor and walls were thin tiles placed on metal grid, which served as drop ceiling for the hallway below. The superintendents spent about five minutes and did not identify a clear hazard, but Miller’s superintendent requested that the overall area have better illumination.

On April 19, 2019, Miller’s superintendent met with Miller employee, Mr. Andrade, and two workers to discuss the repairs and reviewed the punch list items and photographs. The superintendent could not go the site that day but rather instructed Mr. Andrade to meet with the GC’s superintendent to also go over the work and two look after the two employees. They arrived at the site, Mr. Adrade met and discussed the work with the GC’s superintendent and then directed the two employees to only complete the repair work depicted in the pictures. They were not to look outside this original scope and were to call a supervisor for permission to conduct additional work. After commencement of their work on the mezzanine, Mr. Andrade heard one employee yelling that the other employee had fallen and was injured. This employee would ultimately be taken to the hospital and would unfortunately pass from his injuries. Miller’s subsequent investigation revealed that Mr. Andrade had only partially completed a Job Hazard Assessment (“JHA”) before starting work because he “spaced out on it”. He was subsequently disciplined suspended. Accident reports were completed, photographs were taken, and it was determined that there was adequate lighting on the mezzanine, including in the area, where no work was scheduled to be performed and the deceased employee had been working. OSHA conducted their own investigation and determined that employee had been exposed to fall hazard next to an un-protected edge that had at least a nine-foot height differential from floor to the drop ceiling below and issued a citation for an OSHA violation. The matter was brought before an ALJ for OSHA’s Review Commission.

The cited standard required Miller to ensure that each of its employees on a walking/working surface with an unprotected side or edge, 6 feet or more above a lower level, were protected from falling by use of guardrail systems, safety net systems, or personal fall arrest systems. Here the record was clear that Miller’s repair work fell under OSHA’s definition of “construction work” and that Miller violated the applicable safety standard and that its employees had been exposed to a fall hazard.

However, Miller raised the “employee misconduct” affirmative defense and the ALJ found that the evidence showed that Miller did not have actual or constructive knowledge of the hazardous condition of the victim working from the mezzanine’s un-protected edge without fall protection. Miller’s superintendent nor Mr. Andrade had knowledge of the hazard as neither identified a clear hazard while either observing or working at the site. The fall area had no scheduled work, was 20 feet away, and partially barricaded by pipes from the work he was instructed to complete. Mr. Andrade’s never directed the deceased employee to work in the fall area since no work was required there.

Miller established that it had work rules and policies that communicated fall protection for employees working at or above a height of six feet, including in a safety handbook (providing specific fall protection rules and guidance), an employee handbook, a Work-Place Accident and Injury Reduction Act Program, a Risk and Hazard Assessment Program, Safety Manuals, all distributed to, and available to employees. They also conducted toolbox talks (including 30 in the prior incident year on fall protection alone), employee orientation tests, and provided safety handouts. Miller’s safety program required use of guardrails and barricade warning tape, along with fall protection while working near unprotected sides/edges. Miller adequately communicated its rules on fall protection through orientation videos, its work rules and distributed literature, as well as making its employees receive training through OSHA 10/30 trainings. Here, the record showed that both the deceased employee and Mr. Andrade were well aware of the work rules and Mr. Andrade had even provided the deceased employee hands-on training included direction to tie off any time when working six feet above ground away from an edge. Miller took reasonable steps to discover safety violations, employed six safety coordinators who consistently audited jobsites while safety superintendents would also visit jobsites at least once per week. Miller also incentivized employees to identify safety violations under a “good catch program”. Lastly, Miller took reasonable steps to enforce violations to its fall-protection rules that included write-ups and terminations for repeated failures. Here, Mr. Andrade’s failure to fully complete a JHA led to disciplinary action for his failure to follow the work rules and ultimately his termination. The ALJ found that Miller had met its burden of proof regarding the affirmative defense of unpreventable employee misconduct and vacated the OSHA citation.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Companies Must Maintain Proper Work Rules and Processes for the Loading and Unloading of Materials

Secretary of Labor v. 84 Lumber Company shows the importance and need to have proper Work Rules in place that are adequately communicated to and known by employees for their safety and the safety of others, in the loading/unloading of building materials. Despite the tragic outcome and death of a truck-driver on November 19, 2019 during the loading of lumber bundles on a trailer-bed, the ALJ in this Texas case, found that the no OSHA safety standard was violated in this instance where the lumber company had in place proper work rules that had been communicated to its employees to never allow people to work under elevated loads or pass under the elevated loads of forklifts given the substantial evidence of employee training and the facts in this matter.

The Respondent, 84 Lumber Company (“84 Lumber”) was a vendor of building materials, primarily lumber, to contractors for construction projects, with multiple stores nationwide. 84 Lumber’s store (the “store”) in Houston, Texas, contracted with BLS Trucking (“BLS”) for the delivery of this store’s customer orders to respective jobsites. The same BLS drivers, approximately, seven to ten, generally were assigned to work at store. 84 Lumber had a “Work Rule” in place that instructed and communicated to its employees to not let anyone ever work under the elevated loads or pass under the elevated loads of forklifts.

84 Lumber employees would prepare and assemble the order into different bundles/loads of lumber. The next phase would involve an employee known as the dispatcher who would operate a forklift to load the lumber bundles onto the BLS trailer. At the time of the accident, BLS’s drivers were instructed to remain at the side of the truck, away from the operating path of the forklift, while the dispatcher operated the forklift and thus well outside the 180-degree radius comprising the “zone of danger” of an active forklift. Once a bundle was loaded onto the dispatcher’s forklift, the dispatcher would approach the BLS truck trailer and lower the bundle down to approximately four inches above the truck bed. At this point, the dispatcher would put the forklift in “neutral” and activate the safety brake. Following this, either the dispatcher, or the dispatcher with the assistance of the BLS driver, would, if necessary, place wooden dryers (to make it easier to insert the forks of the forklift under the bundle) under the slightly elevated bundle. The workers placed the dryers while standing on the ground to the side of the truck bed by sliding them under the slightly elevated bundle. Given the location of the bundle over the bed of the truck trailer, the workers passed behind the stationary forklift to place the dryers on either side of the bundle. Thus, at no point would the placement of dryers cause the dispatcher or the BLS driver to pass under either the forks of the forklift or the slightly elevated bundle (of about four inches) over the truck bed.

The circumstances leading to the underlying accident involved a BLS driver who after waiting between the semi-truck and the truck’s trailer while bundles were being loaded, approached the dispatcher and asked him if he could move a bundle to the other side of the truck bed so that the “strap c[ould] match up.” At this point in time, the BLS driver was standing in front of the front wheel of the trailer. The dispatcher obliged and loaded the requested bundle onto the forklift and then began to back away from the trailer. As the forklift was about two to three feet from the trailer the BLS driver “out of nowhere” ran underneath the forks of the forklift and the elevated bundle and told the dispatcher to get another “bite” on the load. The dispatcher yelled at the driver at least three to four times get out from underneath the elevated bundle and also honked the horn, but the driver did not listen and instead kept telling the dispatcher to back-up. The dispatcher continued backing up fearing that an abrupt stop would cause the bundle to fall or forklift to topple. After a matter of seconds, the bundle fell off the forklift onto the BLS driver, killing him. OSHA investigated and issued a citation based on the belief that 84 Lumber did not have a process in place to inspect or enforce its Work Rule. During the proceeding, BLS’s supervisor acknowledged that BLS trained its drivers to never work under a forklift’s forks or suspended loads and both BLS’s supervisor and 84 Lumber’s manager stated this Work Rule was common in the industry because of the obvious dangers.

Given the Work Rule in place and circumstances, there was no explicit permission for the BLS’s driver to have stood under the elevated load. However, the Secretary argued the practice of placing dryers under elevated loads as evidence of 84 Lumber’s implicit permission to walk under them. The ALJ disagreed as the evidence showed that the policy in place was that BLS drivers had to wait outside the zone of danger for an active forklift and dryers were only placed under the load when it had already been lowered three to four inches from the truck bed and from standing on either side of the now inactive forklift, and not on top or below the elevated load. Although workers were close, in proximity, to the load they were not implicitly permitted to be under it. Following the accident, BLS also instituted a new policy requiring drivers to now stand in a designated “muster area”, further away from the loading area.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Adequate Protective Systems Must Be Present During Excavations at All Times

The Decision in Secretary of Labor v. Petrongolo Contractor’s Inc. is an instructive case for contractors especially those involved in excavation and highlights multiple issues regarding the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission (the “OSH Commission”) process, the burden of proof and severity of penalties and the considerations made by the Administrative Law Judges who hear these matters.

Petrongolo Contractor’s Inc. (“Petrongolo”) is a public utility contractor primarily engaged in excavation work. On January 27, 2020 it was excavating a trench in a city street in Philadelphia to access a sewer line owned by the Philadelphia Water Department (“PWD”). Petrongolo had to remove the existing manhole and replace it with a larger precast manhole for its subcontractors to be able to access the sewer for relining. Petrongolo removed the existing manhole and dug a trench which was about 10 feet deep from street level to the top of the sewer pipe and the footprint of the trench was 10 x 6 feet. The gas utility, Philadelphia Gas Works (“PGW”) had its own gas main running parallel to the sewer line, and it became concerned that Petrongolo’s excavation would compromise the integrity of its gas main, and its employee caused Petrongolo to stop work, in the early evening on January 27, 2020. PGW’s employees took pictures of the trench in the evening of January 27 and the morning of January 28 and contacted OSHA to report a hazardous excavation. OSHA sent one of its Compliance Safety and Health Officers to the site on January 28, 2020 which led to the issuance of two citations under Safety and Health Regulations for Construction’s Requirements for Protective Systems under 29 C.F.R. § 1926.652(a)(1) and (c)(1).

Citation # 1 alleged a serious violation of Design Support Systems utilizing published appendices for the design of timber shoring in trenches with a proposed penalty of $3,393. Citation # 2 alleged a repeat violation “for failing to ensure that each employee working inside an excavation of approximately twelve (12) feet deep were protected by cave-in protection” and proposed a penalty of $29,687. To establish a violation of such standard, the Secretary (of Labor) must prove by a preponderance of the evidence (the legal standard where a party is able to convince a fact finder that there is a greater than 50% chance that their claim is true) the following: (1) the cited standard applies; (2) there was non-compliance with its terms; (3) employees had access to the violative condition; and (4) the cited employer had actual or constructive knowledge of the violative condition.

The matter was brought before the Commission with remote hearings and submissions before the Administrative Law Judge (“ALJ”) who decided that the Secretary failed to prove by a preponderance of the evidence (a legal standard where a party is able to convince a fact finder that there is a greater than 50% chance that their claim is true) that Petrongolo failed to obtain the soil type in determining the proper configuration of timber shoring that was installed on January 28, 2020. Consequently, Citation # 1 was vacated.

However, the ALJ found that the Secretary proved (by a preponderance of the evidence) that Petrongolo employees were working in a trench that lacked an adequate protective system and that Petrongolo had knowledge of it. Further, Petrongolo failed to rebut the Secretary’s showing that this violation was similar to Petrongolo’s prior violations of the same standard and thus constituted a repeat violation warranting a $22,000 penalty.

Citation # 1 alleged that Petrongolo failed to obtain the soil type to determine the proper configuration when using timber shoring in accordance with the conditions and requirements set for in appendices A and C of § 1926.652(c)(2). Appendix A requires a “competent person” to perform at least one visual and one manual test on the soil to determine soil type and it sets for a series of acceptable visual and manual tests. Petrongolo’s president who was a registered professional engineer with years of experience in testing soil and performing excavations in the local area was deemed a “competent person” and his manual and visual test of the soil were in conformance with the requirements. Even if Petrongolo’s president had failed to conduct the visual and manual tests, the determination that the soil type was “Type C” (the least stable soil type as per the classifications under Appendix A), pursuant to the OSHA’s own interpretations, made “soil testing … superfluous and not required” if the protective system is adequate to protect against cave-ins in Type C soil.

Citation # 2 alleged that Petrongolo failed to provide adequate safety devices for cave-in protection to workers inside an excavation of approximately twelve (12) feet deep. The trench was over five feet deep and constituted as hazard for as long as it was open and lacked an adequate protective system from the time the steel plates covering it were removed up until the time Petrongolo’s crew completed installation of the timber shoring. The photographs taken by PGW’s workers showed workers inside the trench and the fact no other contractor or subcontractor had been working in the trench area provided sufficient circumstantial evidence that Petrongolo’s own employees were working in that area. Moreover, the ALJ found that since Petrongolo’s foreman was present at the site, and gave directions to the employees, he would have had actual knowledge of the of violative condition, or at minimum, based on the weight of the evidence, he could have discovered or prevented the employees’ violative conduct so as to impute constructive knowledge on Petrongolo.

Petrongolo had been previously cited for violations arising from failures to provide adequate protective systems for which it had entered into settlement agreements. Here, the ALJ found that the Petrongolo employees had been exposed to substantially similar, although not identical [cave-in] hazards that led to those two prior violations.

In assessing penalties, consideration is given to four criteria 1) The gravity of the violation; 2) The size of the employer’s business; 3) The employer’s good faith; and 4) the prior history of violations. Gravity (of risk) is the primary consideration and determined by factors such as the number of employees exposed, duration of the exposure, precautions taken against injury and likelihood that an injury would result. Here, the gravity of the violation was considered high, and coupled with two similar prior violations for the same standard within two years clearly constituted a prior history and lack of good faith. However, the business’ small size was also considered. In light of all these circumstances, a $22,000 penalty was assessed.

This matter shows that adequate protective systems must be in place during excavation work when it is contemplated that workers will be present within a trench, as it is an open hazard, even during the interim. In this case, the timber shoring protective system that was ultimately installed was proper but adequate protective systems had not been installed throughout the entire time that employees actually worked in the trench as documented by photographs taken by PGW’s employees, creating a cave-in hazard and leading to the citations. Moreover, a contractor’s prior violation history for substantially similar violations will be considered during the assessments any penalties.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Court Permits Fraudulent Inducement Claim To Proceed

When a construction contractor egregiously fails to perform its obligations under a contract, it is easy for one’s mind to turn to fraud. First, it’s a provocative claim to make, given its quasi-criminal nature. Next, it’s a natural human defense to believe that one could not have erred in the selection of such a bad contractor without some untoward input. Either way, it also has the benefit of bringing a corporation’s principal into a lawsuit that they may otherwise not have been brought into. However, while it’s an easy claim to want to make, a court, in the recent case of Hunter Roberts Construction Group LLC v Vector Structural Preservation Corp., reminds us that the claim is not an easy one to assert.

Background

In early 2017, Hunter Roberts Construction Group entered into a general contract with RXR Realty for the construction of a project known as Garvies Point in Glen Cove. Hunter Roberts, like many larger general contractors, maintains a subcontractor default insurance program, and it requires the enrollment of all subcontractors. As a part of this process, Hunter Roberts uses a third party subcontractor qualification and risk mitigation agency to perform risk assessments of subcontractors who are to be enrolled in the SDI program. Vector Structural Preservation Corp. submitted a bid to Hunter Roberts for the masonry scope of work for the project, and it was required to submit a response to a questionnaire for enrollment in the SDI program. Hunter Roberts alleges that the responses Vector’s principal, Vassilios Handakas, provided to the questions about prior criminal investigations and ongoing legal matters were patently false. Based on the determination that Vector was the “lowest responsible bidder” (which was based on the false response to the questionnaire), the subcontract was awarded to Vector.

As the job progressed, Vector delayed the project, and was delinquent in paying its vendors and employees. In March of 2019, Hunter Roberts defaulted Vector based on these shortcomings and, ultimately, terminated the contract. In addition to suing Vector based on the claimed breaches of contract, Hunter Roberts sued Handakas, personally, for fraud, and to hold him liable for Vector’s debts, alleging that he abused the privilege of doing business in the corporate form (“piercing the corporate veil”). As to the fraud claim, Hunter Roberts alleged that if it had known that Handakis was previously convicted of money laundering and other financial crimes, and that Vector was the defendant in numerous lawsuits brought by suppliers and subcontractors alleging non-payment, it never would have awarded Victor the subcontract. Handakas moved to dismiss the corporate veil claims, arguing that the allegations did not rise to the high level required to hold him personally liable for the corporation’s debts, and both Vector and Handakas moved to dismiss the fraud claim, arguing that the fraud claim (and damages) were simply duplicative of the contract claim, and did not rise to the level required to establish a claim for fraud. Handakas further argued that his representations could not have been reasonably relied upon because his criminal past was easily discoverable with a simple google search.

Decision

The court split its decision. First, it dismissed the “corporate veil” claim to hold Handakas personally liable for the corporation’s debts, finding that there were no specific allegations which would meet the high burden required to set aside Vector’s corporate form and hold Handakas personally liable for its debts. However, the court denied the motion insofar as the fraud claim and permitted it to proceed. In doing so, the court held that Hunter Roberts sufficiently alleged that it relied on Handakas’ false representations to its detriment when it rejected other subcontractors and awarded the contract to Vector. The court also held that Hunter Roberts sufficiently alleged that it incurred specific damages as a result of the fraud which were distinct from the breached contract, to wit: the damages incurred to clean up the aftermath of Vector’s failures, such as paying Vector’s suppliers. As to Handakis’ argument that the reliance could not have been reasonable when a google search would have turned up the information on his past, the court, following well settled case law, held that in the absence of “hints of falsity”, the party to whom the representation was made has no heightened burden of investigation. As such, the question as to whether the reliance was reasonable would have to be determined by a jury, and could not be determined upon a motion to dismiss. Finally, as to the fraud claim against Handakis himself, as opposed to Vector, it permitted the claim to proceed because “a corporate officer who participates in the commission of a tort can be held personally liable even if the participation is for the corporation’s benefit”.

Comment

A popular strategy in litigation is to figure out a way to sue (and keep in the case) a corporation’s principals. This has not only the practical effect of providing another pocket from which to recover (in the not unheard-of event that the corporation is insolvent), but it also may give the principal an extra incentive to resolve the case. A popular way to accomplish this is to level a fraud claim against the principal; another way is to claim that the corporation’s principal abused the privilege of doing business in a corporate form. As Hunter Roberts shows, while these are high burdens, they are not impossible to meet. As can be seen from the split decision here, the crucial difference was the specificity of the allegations in support of each claim. The allegations made in support of the claim to disregard the corporation were conclusory and generic, so they were not sufficient to meet the high burden required to support that claim. However, the allegations made in support of the fraud claim were detailed as to the scope of the fraud, and its results. Accordingly, because the allegations were specific enough to allege a tort committed by Handakis individually, the claim was allowed to proceed to discovery.

The lesson here is that in discussing your matter with construction counsel, do not feel that any detail is too small, as detailed allegations can potentially be helpful in drafting a claim which is sufficient to bring in a corporation’s principals into a lawsuit—and keep them there.

About the author: Thomas H. Welby, an attorney and licensed professional engineer, is General Counsel to the Construction Industry Council of Westchester and the Hudson Valley, and is the Founder of, and Senior Counsel to the law firm of Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP, with offices located throughout the Tri-State/Greater Metropolitan Region. Gregory J. Spaun, General Counsel to the Queens and Bronx Building Association, and an attorney and a partner with the firm, co-authors this series with Mr. Welby.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Thomas H. Welby at twelby@wbgllp.com or call (914) 428-2100

Respondent in Citation Contest Proceeding Scores Rare Win Via Summary Judgment

Citation contest proceedings before the OSH Review Commission, while subject to specialized procedural rules, for the most part are litigated under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, as govern civil lawsuits in the U.S. District Courts.

Thus, while the same is infrequently resorted to, contest proceedings are subject to the summary judgment procedures of the FRCP.  For you nonlawyers, summary judgment permits courts to better manage their dockets, curtail proceedings, and avoid trials, in the limited class of cases in which either side can show convincingly that there are no “material facts” (i.e., facts on which the outcome of the suit depends) as to which there exists a genuine dispute requiring a trial.

While summary judgment is to be employed sparingly, it is appropriate where all of the facts that will determine the outcome are admitted, or the evidence concerning them is so one-sided that it is obvious that the party moving for summary judgment must prevail as trial.

The party deeming itself entitled to summary judgment presents a motion to the court, annexing evidence (transcripts of pretrial deposition testimony, probative documents, etc.) and a legal memorandum explaining the basis for the motion. In assessing whether genuine fact issues exist, the court must resolve all ambiguities, and draw all reasonable inferences, in favor of the nonmoving party.

In my many .years of experience litigating in federal and New York state courts, I have observed that, while judges look with favor on opportunities to pare their trial dockets, they are aware that appellate rulings overturning orders granting summary judgment greatly outnumber those reversing denials of summary judgment.  Where the issue is doubtful, therefore, such a motion is unlikely to succeed.

In my extensive review of decisions in citation contest proceedings, I have seldom seen summary judgment attempted .by employers, no doubt in large part because preparing papers, and arguing such a motion, is labor-intensive on the part of the respondent’s counsel (which is to say, expensive).  In the usual case, the penalty amounts at issue are often far less than in federal civil lawsuits, and the legal costs to be saved by a successful motion are often not enormous (.as pretrial discovery procedures are less extensive than in regular lawsuits, and lengthy trials are uncommon).

However, as illustrated by Secretary v.  Harvestland Constructors, Inc,,  a garden-variety fall-protection case, it may be worth asking your attorney to ponder whether the Secretary’s case has an ”Achilles’ heel,” that could make it susceptible to a summary judgment motion.

Harvestland involved a single-item citation, alleging that the employer had violated the OSH Act, by exposing employees to falling through holes in elevated working/walking surfaces by the nonuse of personal fall arrest systems, covers, or guardrail systems erected around such holes.

Most of the relevant facts in this case were undisputed.  An experienced, 66-year-old carpenter, had a continuing assignment to identify and cover uncovered holes in the flooring on a project in Georgia.  Most of these “penetrations” had been created to allow equipment to be passed from one level of the floor to another.  When a hole was observed, this individual, named in the decision as “Carpenter NM,” would cover it with ¾” plywood, and secure the plywood sheeting with cleats, nailed in to prevent slippage.

On the afternoon of the day in question, Carpenter NM, who had been performing this work on the project for about 3 weeks, was working alone (as he usually did) on the second floor of the structure.  

All Harvestland employees were required to use fall protection when working 4’ or more above ground level, supervisors inspected the site several times daily for compliance, and an outside consulting firm performed monthly safety inspections. This employer had a site-specific safety plan, conducted weekly safety meetings, and sent home workers observed to be in violation of safety rules.

Carpenter NM was up-to-date in his training, had been supplied with a personal fall arrest system, and had often been observed utilizing fall protection.  In five years of employment with Harvestland, he had never been cited for safety violations.

On his last afternoon, Carpenter NM covered and nailed down the cleats on nine of thirteen openings existing on the second floor.  About ten to fifteen minutes after returning from a break, he fell through an  uncovered hole, and plunged 38 feet to his death.  For reasons unknown, he was not wearing fall protection at the time.

Of the four elements constituting the Secretary’s burden in order to prove the violation, three were open-and-shut in favor of the government.  Since Carpenter NM was working on a surface with openings far above the floor below, the necessity for fall protection was clear.  Two additional elements — namely, a failure to comply with the fall protection standard and employee exposure — were established beyond question by the fact that Carpenter NM was not using fall protection when he fell 38 feet.

However, three elements out of four will not do, and on the fourth element — actual or constructive knowledge of the violative condition on the employer’s part — Harvestland prevailed, winning summary judgment and the vacatur of the citation.

The Secretary, as the Court found, had to prove either that the employer (through a supervisor) had actual knowledge of the infraction, or that its inadequate safety program was such that a finding of constructive knowledge could be made, based on the conclusion that had the employer exercised due diligence, the violation would have come to a supervisor’s attention.

In a detailed analysis set forth in her decision, the ALJ ruled for Harvestland, because there was no triable issue that it had actual or constructive knowledge that the decedent had been working around openings in the floor without fall protection.  The judge cited facts (many of them corroborated by the testimony of the Compliance Officer) concerning (among other things) the employer’s work rules, and its generally praiseworthy safety training, surveillance of its workforce, and rule enforcement.  Since these factors disproved constructive knowledge, and no basis existed to find actual knowledge, the citation had to be vacated.

The ALJ rejected, as immaterial, the Secretary’s contention that the arguably defective condition of a nylon strap on the harness that Carpenter M was not wearing established the violation.

Not many contests will present a strong case for summary judgment, but given the unpredictably of trials generally, and what witnesses will testify to in particular, your case should be carefully analyzed to determine if summary judgment might offer prospects of success.

Geoffrey S. Pope, an attorney practicing construction law and commercial litigation, after many years with Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP, is joining the firm of Cermele & Wood, LLP, in White Plains, New York.  .The articles in this series do not constitute legal advice, and are intended for general guidance only.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

ALJ Vacates Citation for Failure of Proof Despite the Employer’s Failure to Protect Its Workers

When a client is cited for alleged OSHA violations, it’s a perennial — and often difficult — question as to whether, or in what circumstances, all or some of the  items should be contested.

While it’s rumored that penalties for OSHA violations may be increased (as much as tenfold) in the near future, historically the penalties have been sufficiently small, that the disproportion between the legal fees and expenses involved in litigating a contest proceeding before the OSH Review Commission, and the penalties at stake, has usually counseled in favor of striking a quick compromise, if one is to be had, and moving forward.

In addition to the Secretary’s advantage of having at his disposal a corps of specialized lawyers paid by the taxpayers. (and the dearth of private attorneys experienced in handling such matters) there are technical and procedural advantages favoring the government in citation contest proceedings. 

Of course, OSHA infractions are a blemish on an employer’s safety record, and “Willful” and “Repeat” violations (in addition to carrying penalties that can run into six figures per item) can impair an employer’s ability to win contracts. (So, too, can an accumulation of “Serious” infractions). Every employer likes to be seen as safety-conscious.  Many business owners take citations very personally, and it’s irksome to be slapped with a substantial monetary penalty, due possibly to a lapse on the part of a careless employee.

But while the OSH Review Commission is no “kangaroo court,” and its Administrative Law Judges, in my opinion (based on having read hundreds of published opinions over the years) .are knowledgeable and conscientious, I have perceived some reluctance to discount the testimony of OSHA inspectors. My belief is that a defense based on legal grounds offers the respondent better chances than one that would require the ALJ to discredit the testimony of an OSHA Compliance Officer.

I believe the most fertile grounds for success in an OSHA contest proceeding are a thorough understanding of the elements of the Secretary’s case, and (if the case goes to trial) close attention to the proofs. If the attorney representing the employer is both attentive and well-prepared, an argument to the ALJ that the Secretary has failed to prove any element of his case by a preponderance of the competent and admissible evidence, will often win the day.

It sometimes comes as a surprise to an employer that the ALJ, where warranted, will vacate a citation, even where there was an injury (actually, an injury, even a fatality, is legally irrelevant) and despite the employer’s conduct having been less than exemplary. However, the Secretary’s failure to prove even a necessary element of his case is probably the most common basis for citation items being vacated.

A striking example of this is the case of Secretary v. George Weis Co. The employer in that case was a family-owned drywall, ceiling, and plaster contractor, working as a subcontractor on a hotel construction project in Missouri.

The employer had a two-man crew installing soffits underneath a sun deck about 26 feet above grade.  The foreman installed the soffits from the bucket of an aerial lift located just below the sun deck, while the second worker knelt on the edge of the sun deck, just inside the wire rope guardrails, and handed materials to the foreman.

The worker on the roof, intending to rise to his feet, grabbed the mid-rail and pushed down, in order to support himself. The mid-rail gave way, and as it did so, the worker fell headfirst through both the mid-rail and top-rail onto the aerial lift.  Although the worker, fortunately, did not plunge to the ground, he was badly injured when he tumbled into the bucket.

Subsequent inspection by OSHA showed that the c-clamps, which allowed the wire ropes to loop around the stanchions and clamp back onto themselves, had not been adequately tightened. The OSHA inspector determined that a contractor had removed the guardrails from the sun deck to deliver materials, and failed to re-set them properly. Although the employer proffered testimony that it had inspected the guardrail, such inspection, if it occurred at all, was merely visual, and neither the employer nor the general contractor, following the removal of the guardrail to allow the materials delivery, had physically tested it to ensure that it met the standard requiring that it be capable of withstanding a force of at least 200 lbs., applied within 2 inches of the top edge, in any outward or downward direction.

The employer was cited under 29 CRF 1926.502(b)(3) and timely contested the citation. The Secretary had the obligation to prove at trial (1) the applicability of the standard; (2) that the standard was violated; (3) employee access to the cited condition; and (4) the employer’s actual or constructive knowledge.

Following trial, the administrative law judge, in his decision, had no difficulty in finding that the standard applied, and that the employer had a duty to provide fall protection to the injured employee. Since the guardrail was the sole means of fall protection deployed, the ALJ found that both the top-rail and the mid-rail needed to satisfy the 200 lbs. of force requirement.

Employee exposure was obvious, the ALJ ruled, as the injured employee had been working next to the guardrail for about two hours when the mishap took place. Plainly, given that the fall occurred upon the employee having grabbed the guardrail to support himself as he stood up, he was exposed to the allegedly defective condition.

The complainant had established constructive knowledge, the Court also found, as (notwithstanding some inconsistent testimony on this issue) the respondent had failed to discharge its obligation to perform a “careful and critical examination” necessitated by the location of the work, the potential gravity of injury, and lack of any additional means of fall protection. The foreman’s claim of having tugged and pulled on the rope, the ALJ found, was unconvincing and. in all events, insufficient.

Despite the foregoing, and while emphasizing that he was not finding that the employer had acted properly, the ALJ vacated the citation for lack of testimony or documentary evidence that a man of the injured worker’s height and weight, performing the activities engaged in at the time of the accident, would not have imposed more than 200 lbs. of force on one or more of the wire guardrails. The ALJ distinguished several cases cited by the Secretary, finding that in the case before him, unlike the cases cited, there was lacking “objective and  patently obvious reasons” why the guardrail could not support the required force.

“This case,” the ALJ concluded, “highlights the importance of the Complaint’s burden of proof, and the distinction between failing to prove a violation and whether a violation, in fact, existed.”  The employer in Weis “failed to take appropriate steps to ensure its employees were not exposed to hazardous conditions,” but while it was likely, even probable, that the guardrail could not have met the specific terms of the standard, the Secretary failed to prove it, wherefore the citation had to be vacated.

Geoffrey S. Pope, an attorney, is Of Counsel to the construction law firm of Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP, with its main office in White Plains.  The articles in this series do not constitute legal advice, and are intended for general guidance only.

Reducing Hazards Associated with Manual Handling of Materials in the Construction Workplace

This month’s column is inspired by materials I found online, published by the European Agency for Safety and Health at Work.  OSHA’s construction standards do not have a subpart dedicated specifically to ergonomic approaches to prevent or ameliorate lower back pain (which, in Europe, is said to be the #1 item among reported work-related disorders).

Although apparently this isn’t an OSHA compliance issue, your company would do well to carry out assessments of how tasks are performed, provide training to your employees, and act to protect employees from cumulative harm to the musculoskeletal system over months and years of repetitive lifting and handling activities on the jobsite.

Generally described, your company should be doing the following:

  • Designing and organizing tasks to avoid, or limit, the handling of materials manually;
  • Employing automation and lifting devices;
  • Where repeated lifting and manual handling cannot be avoided, organizing the work in a safe way, by dividing larger loads into smaller ones, providing rest periods, etc.;
  • Training employees in the correct handling of materials, including the opportune use of equipment, and how frequently-.required tasks should be performed.

“Manual handling” can be defined as supporting or transporting a load by lifting, holding, putting down, pushing, pulling, carrying, or moving it.  In the EU at least, just under two-thirds of  all workers spend at least a quarter of their working hours performing such tasks, and (in addition to fatigue) two varieties of injuries may result.  One includes sudden events, such as cuts, bruises, fractures, and the like, and the other variety involves damage to muscles, tendons, ligaments, bones, joints, bursa (the small, fluid-filled sacs that reduce friction between moving parts in the body’s joints), blood vessels and nerves.

What are referred to as musculoskeletal disorders are divisible into three groups: neck and upper limb disorders; lower limb disorders, and  back injuries and back pain.  Most people experience lower back pain to some extent by age thirty, and between one-quarter and one-half of construction workers complain of it.

The factors that make manual handling more or less hazardous fall into four groups:  the load, the task, the environment, and the individual.  The risk of back injury increases if the load is too heavy (20-25 lbs. is heavy for most people, especially if the load must be handled repeatedly), too large, difficult to reach or to grasp, unbalanced, or contains items within that move around.  A basic rule is that items should be lifted and carried as close to the body as possible.

Pushing and pulling generally impose fewer stresses on the body than lifting and carrying. Unbalanced loads are difficult to support, and sudden movement can throw the bearer off-balance.  Gloves, handles, or other aids for gripping can make it easier to maintain one’s grasp.  Loads that can only be reached with outstretched arms, or by bending or twisting the torso, may harm the spine, and carrying loads with sharp edges or dangerous materials is also to be avoided.

As for “the task,” the same can be very rigorous, if carried out over and ever for too long a period, or at a tempo that cannot be varied by the worker, or without sufficient rest periods.

The “environment“ means factors such as the space available to carry out the handling, the condition of the floor or working level, climate, and illumination.  If a large load must be hefted in a tight space, awkward body postures may be required, which can require joints to be held close to their maximum range of movement, or result a heavier load on the joints and spine and increased fatigue.

If the flooring is wet, uneven, or subject to moving (e.g., the deck of a fishing boat) handling materials becomes more difficult, and accidents more likely. Temperature, humidity, and ventilation affect a worker’s ability to carry out handling operations, especially if the same are to be repeated over the course of the workday. Poor lighting may increase the risk of an accident, or require the employee to work in awkward positions.

Naturally, individual factors also affect the likelihood of back injuries or other bad outcomes from handling operations.  An employee’s size, fitness, strength, lifestyle, age, medical history, experience, training, familiarity with the job and the tasks to be performed, and willingness to use personal protective equipment all affect his or her ability to perform handling operations, and prospects of avoiding injury while doing so.

Your company should carry out a risk assessment, or examination of potential hazards from manual handling operations,  Consider carefully tasks, and locations where they are performed, that could produce accidents, injuries, or poor health. Evaluate whether procedures and precautions in place are sufficient to minimize risks of harm, and what additional measures might be taken.

Among other things, you should consider the practicability of eliminating the “manual” element of at least some manual handling, and reduce or avoid altogether employees having to lift, carry and move things, by instead using devices such as conveyor belts, lift trucks, electric hoists, or a gravity-powered roller track.  Due consideration should be given to the potential downside, however (e.g., possible noise or hand-arm vibration hazards) from any alternatives being considered.

If the elimination of manual handling is not possible, or technical measures are ineffective in reducing the risks, you should next consider organizational or administrative measures.  For example,   heavier items could be lifted or carried by two people instead of one, or amounts to be handled could be reduced, or loads split into two or more smaller ones.

The pace of manual handling should not be set by a machine, supervisor, or co-workers.  The time for performing manual handling tasks should be extended by providing for breaks, or by alternating such tasks with other tasks, to allow muscles time to recover.

Pretty much all construction employees, even those who infrequently have to perform manual handling, should be trained in the correct techniques for lifting and carrying, and for pushing and pulling devices such as barrows and trolleys.

If your company has employees who must frequently perform manual handling, I commend to you NIOSH Publication No. 2007-131, “Ergonomic Guidelines for Manual Material Handling,” which you can download online.  It contains a wealth of information that will make their lives easier, more productive, and less painful.

I conclude this month’s installment .on .a personal note.  After 15 years of working on these articles, next month’s column will be my last for Construction News.  My deep thanks to my readers, and to George Drapeau and John Jordan, my editors.  Stay safe, everyone!

Geoffrey S. Pope, an attorney, is counsel to the construction law firm of Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP, with its main office in White Plains.  The articles in this series do not constitute legal advice, and are intended for general guidance only.

Using Near-Miss Reporting to Prevent Future Accidents

It’s important to fully exploit every accident-prevention strategy at your company’s disposal. Unfortunately, some construction employers have no near-miss reporting system in place, or neglect to put the necessary energy into convincing employees to faithfully report near-miss occurrences (or to follow-up with training, when near-misses are reported).

A near-miss, narrowly defined, is an occurrence that could have produced an injury (or property damage or other loss) but did not. If reported to management and investigated, often a near-miss will lead to changes in procedures, greater training emphasis, or stricter enforcement of company safety rules, and prevent a recurrence that could result in serious injury or other harm. In investigations if fatalities or other cases involving serious bodily harm, it is frequently found that the occurrence was preceded by prior incidents in which safety rules were ignored, and a near-miss occurred, but through dumb luck, usually, with no injuries.

Since effective harm prevention, although involving the rank and file, requires leadership usually from the top down, if you are an owner, officer, safety manager of field supervisor in a construction enterprise, you want every near-miss to be reported. The point must not be to identify and punish offenders — persons reporting near-misses should be allowed to do so anonymously. Instead, the point is to identify the weak spots in your procedures, or equipment, or training, or supervision, so that today’s near-miss doesn’t become tomorrow’s fatality, mass casualty event, or life-changing injury.

Of course, every report of a near-miss should bring about an appropriate level of investigation, and an analysis of what you can do to improve safety systems, better control hazards, reduce risks and reduce risk-taking among employees.

Company-wide, in addition to a top-down commitment from ownership and management, effective safety policy requires the company to hire, train and retain sober, safety-conscious workers, but especially field supervisors who know all of the applicable rules, don’t cut corners, and won’t overlook violations when seen to occur. Frankly, it is challenging indeed to train every construction worker in the full range of standards that apply to their jobs. Conscientious, thoroughly trained field supervisors are probably your best bet to minimize both OSHA citations and injuries to employees.

In addition, of course, time and money must be devoted to training and the provision of adequate and well-maintained equipment.

At the individual level, once a construction worker has developed the necessary adult attitude about risk-taking, safety is in large measure a matter of paying attention. Once the individual moves beyond seeing safety (beyond the necessity of avoiding the most obvious and serious risks to life and limb) as primarily a matter of avoiding getting called out by management, he or she can develop the habit of casting vigilant eyes on the workplace environment (and their own and co-workers’ conduct).

If your company implements a well-designed program of reporting not only obvious near-misses (e.g., an unsecured object falling from a scaffold, but by good fortune not striking anyone) but hazards or conduct that are nonetheless accidents waiting to happen if continued or repeated, that will be a great benefit. It’s been shown that most serious or calamitous events at jobsites are usually preceded by near-misses or situations that, if noted, could have served as warning. Generally, without encouragement, whether workers will report things that haven’t produced a frightening, although harmless incident, is largely a function of whether the situation was observed by others, such that failing to report it would be conspicuous.

Workers, lacking encouragement, are not avid to report as “near misses” things they may deem to be less than potentially life-threatening hazards, in part because it can be time-consuming, but also because the perception is often that reporting will get the reporter, or one or more other employees, in trouble.

It’s important, therefore, to give assurances that prevention, and not punishment, is the objective in urging the reporting of all “near misses” (broadly defined) and not just those that came really close to producing real harm. You might stress, also, that not only are employees answerable to the company, but the company is responsible to employees (as well as to OSHA) and employees are answerable to one another, too.

Workers, studies have found, are more inclined to speak with management about near misses than about incidents actually resulting in injuries. Employers should provide incentives to report near misses (although quotas are usually counter-productive) and allow occurrences to be reported anonymously. Discretion is called for in determining the level of investigation and documentation required. Reporting is something employees don’t want to spend a lot of time doing, and reporting could be deterred by an inquisition not commensurate with the situation. Selected near miss reports should become the subjects of periodic near-miss training sessions.

Examples of what should be seen as near-miss situations are where equipment remains in use despite damage or excessive wear, or there exist hazards such as holes in the floor, crumbling stairs, or nonconforming scaffolds, or whenever employees take risks, such as disconnecting one’s harness to retrieve a dropped tool on a roof, entering an unshored trench “for just a few minutes.” or operating equipment while impaired. Especially given that jobsites often involve vehicles, multiple employers, heavy equipment, temporary structures, a dizzying variety of activities (many of them inherently dangerous), and abrupt changes in the environment as the job progresses, it’s unrealistic to think that detecting and correcting hazards can be effective, without the participation of everyone onsite.

At training sessions, employees should be invited to bring up additional near misses they know of or have seen, and if a hazard in a particular work area or operation has been mentioned, to imagine what else might go wrong in that environment.

If you gain employees’ cooperation, the benefits of individual workers having paid attention can be spread company-wide, reducing significantly the possibility that the recurrence or continuation of hazards seen, but not reported, will result in serious physical harm. Near miss reporting, and the use of information obtained for training, is a proven method of reducing both near misses and actual incidents.

Geoffrey S. Pope is Of Counsel to the construction law firm of Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP, with its main office in White Plains. The articles in this series do not constitute legal advice, and are intended for general guidance only.