Skip to main content

HAVS: A Key Construction Peril Lacking Its Own OSHA Standard

You may be surprised to learn, as I was, that a hazard described by one expert as “probably the No. 1 neuromuscular disorder in the world in manufacturing and construction environments, the most costly, and underappreciated,” is not the subject of its own OSHA construction standard.

I am referring to “Hand Arm Vibration syndrome,” also known as HAVS (and formerly known as “vibration white finger,” as a prime symptom of its circulatory and neural effects includes the blanching — pale and ashen appearance — of the fingers).

This malady, although identified by industrial physicians more than 100 years ago, is severely under-reported by workers and health professionals.  Perhaps two million workers in the U.S.  are at risk, of which as many as half will develop HAVS.

The syndrome is defined as a type of industrial disease that produces symptoms in the arms and hands, and damage to blood vessels, nerves, and other musculoskeletal structures, usually from the prolonged use of vibrating power tools in the workplace. Working in a cold climate, and smoking (which impairs circulation to the extremities) are additional risk factors.

Devices linked to HAVS include grinders, riveters, drills, jackhammers, chipping hammers, jigsaws, sanders, vibrating pokers and compactors, scabblers,  and chainsaws.  Of course, any kind of hand-held vibrating tool can contribute to HAVS, and regardless of whether the tool is powered by electricity, gasoline, or air.  However, while the frequent use of vibrating hand tools having a frequency range between 8 Hz and 1500 Hz is problematic, the most hazardous frequency range is 100-150 Hz.  In addition to construction and maintenance, workers in the mining and forestry industries are also very much at risk.

Initially, nerves are irritated by the vibration, resulting in tingling and numbness in the hand and fingers.  At first, symptoms are most likely to be noticed while working in cold conditions.  Blood vessels may become irritated and spastic,  causing the fingers (and especially the fingertips) to feel cold and painful.  Over time (the syndrome typically takes between 6 months and 6 years of frequent exposure to develop) the attacks of pain, blanching and numbness usually become more frequent, although often they subside during warmer weather. 

Symptoms of HAVS may also include loss of feeling in the hand and fingers, a progressive decrease in hand strength, reduced dexterity, and arm muscles that tire easily.

In the most severe cases, individuals may experience atrophy of the muscles in the hand, and even gangrene.

Treatment usually consists primarily of reducing work exposure to vibration.  Perhaps half of affected individuals experience a return to near baseline within 5 years after the elimination or sharp reduction of exposure.  As the syndrome advances, however, often from the time that blanching of the fingers appear, the nerve damage may become irreversible.

Thus, prompt detection, and reducing or eliminating the exposure, is critical.

While, surprisingly, HAVS is not addressed by a specific OSHA standard, it may be addressed under OSHA’s General Duty Clause, which requires each employer to provide a safe and healthful workplace.

Compliance with acceleration levels and exposure duration guidelines established by the American Conference of Government and Industrial Hygienists is suggested, both as a means to limit your employee’s exposure, as well as a means of demonstrating compliance with the General Duty Clause, should you be cited based on one or more employee’s exposure to vibration.

You need to know the vibration rating of all equipment used by your employees, and to calculate the safe time exposure for each item.  Make sure that you know for how long employees can use particular tools, and if you don’t know, you need to inquire of the manufacturer, or get the various tools assessed.

Naturally, you should be discriminating in selecting equipment.  Look for low-vibration items, or tools incorporating built-in features that absorb a significant amount of the tool’s vibration.  Make sure employees use the correct tool for the job, and consider possible alternative means to accomplish tasks that will reduce employee exposure.  It may be possible, also, to alter the job to reduce the grip or pressure necessary.

Frequent breaks should be scheduled to avoid long periods of vibrating tool use, and you should try to minimize the use of vibrating tools in cold weather conditions.

Other practices users of vibrating equipment should be trained to observe include the following:

  • Abstain from smoking;
  • Keep one’s hands dry and warm;
  • Grip tools as lightly as possible (while keeping control of the tool);
  • Keep tools in good working order;
  • Keep one’s hands away from cold exhaust air from pneumatic tools;
  • Rest for at least 10 minutes each hour;
  • Alternate, whenever practicable, between vibrating and non-vibrating tools;
  •  Wear gloves that cover the fingers, and are certified by ISO 10819;
  • Seek medical attention, if HAVS symptoms appear.

As PPE is usually the least-preferred control measure, anti-vibration gloves are at best moderately effective.  They  protect the palm more than the fingers, and are of little use at frequencies lower than 25 Hz.  Gloves may actually amplify vibration from low-frequency tools.  Damping techniques (e.g., wrapping tool handles in viscoelastic material tape), or using vibration isolators on equipment provide more effective protection.  While some prefer the greater tactile “feedback” into the fingertips that fingerless gloves provide (and may cut the fingers of the gloves off, leaving only the palm area covered) that should be forbidden, if the user works with vibrating tools.

HAVS is a debilitating, life-changing affliction, and by the time symptoms become pronounced, they will likely be irreversible.  Workers must be trained about vibration hazards, early signs and symptoms of HAVS, and best practices to limit exposure.  Indeed, they should be cautioned that it is better to change jobs, rather than permitting HAVS to progress beyond its earliest stages.

PPE, the Hierarchy of Controls, and Covid Recovery Safety Planning

As the sun seems to be peeking out from behind the clouds of the Covid-19 pandemic, a semblance of normalcy has returned to some construction activities at least.  Still, we are by no means “out of the woods,” infections and deaths continue to occur and to spike around the country, and various experts are cautioning that variants of the original virus, or the need to vaccinate and keep vaccinating everyone, leaves us open to successive waves of infections and deaths.  So, I’m sure that nearly all construction employers are continuing to take special precautions, and striving to calculate how the unknowable course of Covid over the next year or two might impact the industry, generally, and day-to-day construction tasks in general.

PPE, as most readers know, is “personal protective equipment” worn on construction sites to reduce exposure to hazards that cause serious injuries and illnesses. Generally, it must be provided at employer expense.  It must be designed and constructed per ANSI or other industry standards, be regularly inspected, cleaned, and maintained, taken out of use when damaged or worn out, and fitted properly.  Users must be trained to know when and what kind of PPE is necessary; how to put it on, adjust, wear and remove it; its limitations, proper care, maintenance, useful life, and disposal of each item.

Some items (the hard hat, safety glasses, study work shoes or boots, high-visibility shirts with sleeves, long work pants) must be worn by all while onsite.  Other items, such as high visibility safety vests with reflective striping, must be worn in proximity to vehicular traffic.  Protective gloves are usual, but the material will vary, according to what is being handled by the wearer.  Full-face shields are necessary when cutting, grinding or chipping; splash goggles are needed to protect against harmful chemicals.  Respiratory protection is needed to work to avoid the inhalation of harmful substances.  Welders must wear welding leathers, and electricians must wear rubber gloves, with leather protectors, shock and slip-resistant boots, flame-resistant clothing and face shields, and insulated sleeves, in addition to the hard hat.  Anyone working on a surface elevated by 6 feet or more must (in the absence of other fall-protection measures) wear fall protection — usually, a harness to be fastened to a safety line.  The foregoing are common examples, not a comprehensive list.

NIOSH prescribes what it calls its “hierarchy of controls,” whereby it ranks the effectiveness of five means of controlling hazards.  The best way of reducing a hazard (if available) is to eliminate the hazard, by physical removal. Next-best is substitution, or replacing the hazard.  Number three is engineering controls, to isolate people, to the extent it be possible to do so, from the hazardous condition.  Number four is administrative controls, or changing the way people work.  Fifth (and last) is sole reliance on PPE.  While face coverings and gloves are high on the list of anti-Covid precautions, you want to steer away from over-reliance on these items.

Of course, in fighting Covid contagion, as in many other contexts, approaches in combination will often prove to be beneficial.  One illustration is that a major risk factor for contracting Covid-19 is close exposure to infected individuals, their exhalations, and their droplets (especially in poorly-ventilated, indoor spaces).  Infected surfaces are also thought to be a risk factor (although a less important one than was thought early in the pandemic).  Naturally, PPE (gloves and face coverings) have a role to play, but the masks in particular are far from sure protection.  So you will want to add administrative controls, such as limiting the sharing of items such as respirator masks and hand tools, and requiring that they be diligently cleaned and sanitized between uses.  “Social distancing,” and planning the scheduling of tasks to be performed in indoor spaces so as to permit distancing and, more generally, reduce the number of people present in indoor work areas simultaneously, are further administrative controls that should be helpful in curbing transmission.

Yet another administrative measure you might consider where, for example, you learn that symptomatic individuals have recently been present in an area, especially a closed, indoor space, where work is needed is to postpone that particular work, and deploy those forces elsewhere.

Of course, while limiting proximity (and crowding) as among employees is part of this equation, so, too, do you want to reduce potential worker exposure to occupants of building areas not under construction, customers, inspectors, visitors, or other outside individuals, as may enter or be present in the work area.  As you probably can’t prevent entirely the entry onto your site, or even into an enclosed area, of all who might possibly be infected (e.g., by testing all comers for the virus) this is a further administrative measure to implement.  Specifics to consider are placing plexiglass or other barriers to ensure that outside individuals cannot come closer than 6 feet to your workers; restricting access, or the numbers of individuals who can be present in proximity to your employees at any given time, or requiring that entrants be masked.

So, while basic PPE is a routine daily requirement, and special-purpose PPE is useful or indispensable for certain tasks, masks and gloves (even coupled with general exhortations to socially distance and wash one’s hands a lot, which may be difficult, or impossible to carry out) are by no means a sufficient ongoing response to Covid.  From today forward, a more attentive, analytical, well-organized and coordinated approach to integrating health and safety concerns is going to be required.  Consulting services from an industrial hygienist are also something you might consider.  Distancing, job hygiene (particularly with respect to PPE and tools that may be shared) and other Covid-specific measures now or hereafter recommended are likely to be leading priorities, but other perennial or job-specific hazards will also benefit from more attention, and better planning, the necessity for which needs to be seen as a fact of life going forward.  Consideration of the “hierarchy of controls” offers construction employers .an important analytical tool.

Whither Construction Safety in an Era of Massive Technological Change?

This series dates back about 14 years, and has always had OSHA compliance as a primary focus.  While the OSH Act, soon to be fifty years old, has never quite reached its stated goal of providing all workers in America with workplaces free from health and safety hazards, it has achieved much in reducing on-the-job mayhem.

If you are a construction company owner, executive, or field superintendent, you probably view OSHA as a welter of rules, some simple, but many of them complicated, and so numerous that few — if any — employers truly fulfill the mandate to train field employees, not only in all the OSHA rules that pertain closely to your company’s trade, but, in addition, hazards they might encounter, due to work being performed on the site by other trades.

While, increasingly, owners (and government bodies) are requiring OSHA cards for construction workers, I recall reading, just a few years ago, of a study at Tulane University, in which graduate students of engineering were given the OSHA 10-hour course and then (with dispiriting results) quizzed on how much of the material they had retained.  OSHA training is rich in jargon, buzzwords and acronyms.  Few of your rank-and-file workers have engineering degrees, and many have a first language other than English.  They may understand English poorly, or scarcely at all.

Supposedly, all are entitled to receive safety training in a language they understand.  Safety manuals are widely available in Spanish, but written materials (or competent construction trainers) can be hard to come by in Albanian, Somali, Gujurati, the dozens of African dialects widely spoken in the Bronx, or most of the 140 or so languages spoken in Queens County.

In short:  OSHA courses don’t hurt, and may be mandatory, but you’re kidding yourself if you think that OHSA 10- or 30-hour courses guarantee more than a rudimentary level of OSHA literacy in your workforce.

We have come to see construction safety as a set of rules, many of them supplied by OSHA, but others coming from New York’s Industrial Code and other sources.  In recent years, however — and this trend is likely to continue its sharp acceleration — sweeping changes in construction technology and practices have changed tremendously how projects, large and small, are carried out.

Here’s a partial list of things that have become widespread in just the last few years:

  • Onsite robots;
  • Drones, including drones integrated with software and hand-held devices to monitor workers, detect problems, and allow instantaneous communications, and on-the-fly changes;
  • 3-D printing technology;
  • Augmented and virtual reality;
  • “Green” technologies and materials (notably, “greener” asphalt);
  • Solar installations in roadways;
  • Modular construction, including very large projects.

While no doubt it’s thrilling, and potentially hugely profitable, if you happen to be on the bleeding edge of bringing these new technologies to construction sites, it should be sobering that, even as many tasks are, increasingly, being performed by smaller crews (and robots) the construction sector continues, alas, to account for approximately one-fifth of all occupational fatalities in the United States.

Tech changes bring both opportunities and challenges in terms of construction safety, but in years to come, the checking-off-boxes approach will likely be insufficient to get the job done, as additional, as-yet-unheard of technologies arrive on the scene and gain acceptance,

OSHA has resource (funding) as well as technical challenges facing it, but isn’t about to close up shop.  You will continue to have a legal duty to train and to enforce safety standards, even if the latter may struggle to keep pace with the sweeping technological changes in the industry.

Consider, as a basis for comparison, how in most localities in the U.S. and elsewhere in the developed world, roadway fatalities fell steadily for half a century, due to enforcement and other efforts to curb drunk driving, the required use of seat belts and child safety seats, better-designed cars, roads, lighting and signage systems, driver’s education programs, etc.

As you’re probably aware from daily alarms in the media, however, distracted drivers texting and talking on cell phones have given back a significant part of the gains realized over decades in reducing roadway fatalities.

Surviving the Interstate is, I believe, relatively easy, compared with going from ground-breaking to final completion on a large construction project.  Such projects typically involve multiple employers, diverse operations being carried out simultaneously, and rapid changes in tasks being performed as the project unfolds.

Construction operations involve tremendous numbers of moving parts, people working in trenches and hundreds of feet above grade, the use of heavy equipment and cranes, and delivery and other vehicles coming and going.  You drive your car in heated and air-conditioned comfort, but construction work may be performed in blistering heat, and sub-freezing temperatures.  Many projects — consider, for example, the construction, or the rehabilitation, of bridges, dams and other infrastructure — present tremendous public safety implications.  Work on highways and bridges is carried out in close proximity to traffic, often during nighttime hours.

  For years after the advent of cell phones, many construction employers forbade their use on the job.  Today, however, hand-held devices are increasingly indispensable for purposes of monitoring, transmitting images, and instantaneous communication, but not without risk of being a distraction.

How to confront the oncoming wave of safety challenges?

There isn’t a simple answer.  I do believe it’s going to require leadership, a collaborative and nimble approach, and — while you probably can’t give your workers a Ph.D. in construction safety, or OSHA compliance — you can give them the beginnings of wisdom, including that construction work is a fast-changing environment, and safety a shared responsibility.  You can demonstrate top-down commitment to avoiding injuries, and — this, I think, is critical — establish lines of communication (with workers, other trades, and vendors of new technologies).  When practical changes become desirable, in light of changes in technology, solutions must be devised and implemented among all stakeholders.

While new technologies often require fresh approaches, when knowing what to do to avoid perennial dangers such as falls is well-known, you’ve just got to do it.  Supervisors shouldn’t look the other way when, for example, if someone isn’t tied off while working on an elevated surface, or is working too close to live wires, or in an unshored trench.

Today, career success is not so much based on credentials, but increasingly a matter of flexibility, self-confidence, resilience, and a collaborative spirit.  Similarly, ensuring the safety of your workers, and the success of your business, will likely depend on attentiveness, persistence in communications, and doing whatever is needed to create a safe working environment.

Can You Avoid Liability for OSHA Violations by Calling Your Workers Independent Contractors?

Since OSHA protects employees, companies sometimes try to avoid its reach by depicting workers as independent contractors.  In Secretary v. Fama Construction, OSHA issued citations for multiple violations (including “Repeat” and “Willful” items) and recommended almost $200,000.00 in penalties. 

In contesting the citations, Fama’s primary defense was that its roofing crews were not Fama employees, but subcontractors.  Fama claimed it merely secured roofing contracts, and that the work crews were employees of subcontractors, which were solely responsible to comply with OSHA’s standards.

After trial, the Administrative Law Judge held, in a 29-page decision, that the workers exposed to the violative conditions were Fama’s employees.  Even if they were not Fama’s employees, the ALJ found, Fama was a ”controlling employer” at the worksite and was required to inspect the worksites to satisfy its duty of reasonable care.  Over $280,000.00 in penalties were assessed accordingly.

It weighed against Fama that the inspections before the ALJ were not Fama’s “first time at the rodeo,” and the same Compliance Officers kept encountering the same workers, some of them for the third or fourth time.  Worse, most of the workers unhesitatingly described themselves as Fama employees.

According to Fama’s sole owner, Francisco Martinez, Fama had no employees, other than 3-4 home office employees.  Martinez testified that Fama worked mostly with four building companies, which gave it contracts for roofing work.  Martinez testified that Fama subcontracted the roofing work, for lump-sum prices, to one or more of a roughly stable collection of four work crews, about 12 to 15 workers in all.  Additional crews, for brick flashing work, were sometimes supplied by Francisco’s brother, Daniel Martinez.  Francisco testified that he came to the jobsites before work began, and after it was completed, but did not direct the crews as they did their work.

Francisco’s daughter testified that she had worked for Fama for 15 years, throughout which the roofers  were paid weekly, with the price of tools and supplies bought on Fama’s credit being deducted.  A company rule against hiring new, inexperienced roofers, somebody “from the street or from Home Depot,” was not always observed.  Safety training was provided every 4-5 months, and, assertedly, crews failing to attend, or whose persistent violations came to Fama’s attention, were given less work (one crew being cut off entirely).  Fama forbade its workers to use their cell phones while working on roofs, or driving company vehicles.  Its solicitude for worker safety, Fama claimed, was not in furtherance of an employment relationship, but was based on friendship, and concern for the roofers.

Daniel Martinez claimed that while he considered himself semi-retired, “it’s Fama I work for” in directing the flashing crews (generally, Daniel plus a single helper).  Daniel never formed a company, but contacted Fama whenever in need of work.  Fama paid Daniel, based on the number of linear feet of flashing installed, and Daniel shared the money paid to him with his helper.

Roofer Antonio Cardenas, although testifying that he had worked for Fama for approximately 15 years (in addition to sporadic “temporary work” for an unrelated individual) did not consider himself an employee.  He worked together with Carlos Galicia, and stated that, while previously the two men were issued separate weekly paychecks, since about 2014 Fama issued but a single check (for a non-negotiable fixed price for each job).  A single 1099 form was given to Cardenas, who would then give Galicia a share of the money.  At times, and for various reasons, Cardenas’s two-man crew turned down Fama projects.  Fama supplied Cardenas with safety glasses and a fire extinguisher, and safety kit for his truck.  Cardenas attended mandatory safety training sessions, although there were no morning toolbox talks, or safety inspections, performed by (or on behalf of) Fama.  Cardenas’s testimony about the two men who were on the roof with him and Galicia at the time of the OSHA inspection was that they were friends, hired on a casual basis, to help on a handful of occasions.  Galicia denied knowing these “helpers’” names.

Ultimately, however, when a Form 1099 for 2016, in the total sum of $220,667, was introduced, Galicia admitted that the latter sum (minus expenses) had been split four ways, to include the two “helpers” — who, it turned out, had worked on Fama jobs for “probably” ten years.  Each of them had performed a share of the overall work in 2016 equal to that performed by Cardenas and Galicia, and had each received one-fourth of the money.  The ALJ found that Cardenas and Galicia had deliberately misled the Court, under oath.

Standards that courts use to distinguish between employees and independent contractors are not uniform nationwide.  However, well-known standards were enunciated in the Darden case, an ERISA matter decided by the U.S. Supreme Court in 1992.

The ALJ in Fama found that, while on the evidence presented, certain factors mentioned in Darden (the skill required to perform the job, the location of the work, and the extent of the workers’ discretion over when and how long to work) were neutral,  three of the Darden factors favored Fama’s claim of a contractor-subcontractor relationship) and five (as well as additional factors) favored finding that the workers were Fama employees.

The factors that favored Fama’s argument that the workers were subcontractors were the hired party’s role in hiring and paying assistants; that the men were not provided with any vacation, health, or retirement benefits, and that 1099 tax forms (and not W-2s) were given to Daniel Martinez, Cardenas, and Galicia.

To the contrary, factors weighing in favor of the conclusion ultimately reached by the ALJ — that the roofers were Fama employees — were the 5 remaining Darden factors.  These were:  the provision of instrumentalities and tools; the long-standing relationship between the parties; that Fama had the right to assign the crews additional projects; the issuance of paychecks (and that at least one member of each crew was required to pick the paychecks up at Fama’s office); and that the roofing work performed by the crews was Fama’s chief line of business.

A further, non-Darden factor stressed by the ALJ was the high degree of control that Fama exercised over the roofers.

The violations were all affirmed, and penalties exceeding over $230,000.00 were imposed.

While the status of your workers (for OSHA purposes) as employees or independent contractors depends on multiple factors, you should be aware that the definition of “employee” for OSHA is broader than under the common law.  You can’t dodge OSHA responsibilities simply by paying workers on 1099s.  Flimsy arguments on this point are likely to fail, and you should not want to risk being seen by OSHA as a company that cares little about the safety of those who perform its work.

Get Ready for Winter: Severe Weather Precautions for the Construction Jobsite

Summer has flown by and away, and already Halloween stuff is appearing in the stores.  Before you know it, the year-end holidays will be upon us.  If your field operations involve outdoor work over the winter, you need to do some advance planning, to avoid being left unprepared.  Even if you have experience working in snow and very cold temperatures, it’s a good idea to work with your supervisors, and your rank-and-file employees, to do the planning and refresher training needed to minimize the risks associated with working under wintry conditions.

Primary hazards. obviously, include hypothermia and frostbite.  These are invisible, but potentially lethal, dangers.  To avoid them, work only during the warmest hours of the day.  Wear warm, layered clothing (with synthetics that wick away perspiration closest to the skin).  Warm gloves, hats and hoods are essential, and footwear should allow for one thick or two thin pairs of socks.  PPE should also include eye protection, as ice and snow produce excessive ultraviolet rays.  Job tasks should be planned to as to break them down into component parts, to allow frequent breaks to be taken.  Hot foods and drinks (but not caffeinated beverages) should be consumed.  With appropriate caveats for any who are diabetic, or have high blood pressure (most prepared soups are loaded with sodium) caloric foods, such as pasta and hot soups, are recommended. Heated, sheltered warm-up/break areas should be provided, and a “buddy system” implemented.  It’s important to avoid having workers off by themselves, working alone. 

All should be trained to recognize the following as symptoms of hypothermia, and emergency responders summoned at once if they are detected:  cool skin, slow, irregular breathing, reduced pulse, uncontrollable shivering, severe shaking, rigid muscles, drowsiness, exhaustion, slurred speech, and memory lapses.  As on any job, supervisors should know where the nearest medical facilities are located, and should have the numbers of emergency responders on their cell phones.

Similarly, the following are symptoms of frostbite, which should be taught to all:  paleness of the skin, sensation of coldness and pain that subsides as the tissues freeze, and increasing whiteness and hardness of the skin.

Generally, workers who have hypertension, diabetes, or cardiovascular disease are at greater risk of experiencing cold stress.  Any who are ill, or taking medication, should be directed to consult a medical professional.

Supervisors should walk the site before the start of each shift, and problems requiring immediate attention addressed at once.  Snow shovels and gloves must be kept convenient to where they will be needed.  Snow and ice must not be permitted to accumulate on surfaces, especially walkways, entrance steps, scaffolds, and roofs.  Snow and ice must be cleared off at once (or work suspended if it’s coming down too fast to be cleared without delay, or if visibility drops below acceptable levels) and sand or salt applied.  In addition to removing snow and ice where it could produce falls, it’s necessary to ensure that accumulated snow — and icicles — be kept off overhead areas.  Footwear must be non-slip or non-skid, and hard hats should always be worn.  The use of ladders should be kept to a minimum; and, if used, they must be free of ice, snow, and other materials that may cause slips or falls.  If temperatures are to fall below freezing, ladders should be stored indoors, or covered at the end of the shift.

If portable heaters are employed, care must be taken to ensure electrical safety or adequate ventilation, as applicable.  Heaters must be placed on fire-resistant surfaces, and their hoses must remain clear and unobstructed.  Combustible materials must be kept at a safe distance, as well.

Falls are the #1 cause of fatalities (and OSHA citations) on construction sites.  Neglecting fall protection is always a bad idea, but to do so in winter weather is simply insane.  Consider a “belt and suspenders” approach, requiring the use of both individual fall arrest systems and safety rails (especially if work must be performed on elevated surfaces for extended periods).  

Snow shoveling is itself a hazardous activity, and poses risks of exhaustion, dehydration, back injuries, and heart attacks.  Workers should be required to warm up before shoveling, to scoop snow in small amounts, and to push instead of lifting to the extent possible.  This is generally not a task for older workers, and workers of all ages should “lift with their legs,” and take frequent breaks while performing it.

If you use electric snow blowers, make sure that they are properly grounded.  Users must be trained not to clear jams while the equipment is powered on.  Fuel should be added before using the equipment, not when the engine is running or hot.

Vehicular safety and work zone traffic control require extra attention under winter conditions.  OSHA has a “Safe Winter Driving” page you should consult, but particular attention should be given to vehicular and equipment maintenance, hazards associated with driving on snow-covered or icy surfaces, and deploying signs, cones, barrels and barriers to protect workers.  Workers commuting to and from the jobsite in their cars should have blankets, water, food and emergency equipment in their vehicles, and be instructed to remain in a disabled vehicle (unless help is visible within 100 yards) and to ensure that the exhaust pipe is kept clear of snow, and a downwind window cracked slightly for ventilation.  Of course, work zones where vehicles or equipment are operated in proximity to persons on foot must be well-lit, and high-visibility vests should be worn.

Work in harsh winter weather is very challenging.  Some measures required are obvious as a matter of common sense, but advance planning and training are essential nonetheless.

Fall Protection Citations Vacated Due to Lack of Proof of the Employer’s Knowledge of the Violations

Every OSHA violation has four necessary elements, each of which must be proved by the Secretary, by a preponderance of the evidence, if the employer contests the citation:  (1) the applicability to the facts of the standard cited; (2) the employer’s failure to comply with the standard: (3) employee exposure or access to the hazard: and (4) the employer’s actual or constructive knowledge of the violative condition.

 “Constructive knowledge,” a sufficient substitute for actual knowledge of the violation, means that, if the employer exercised reasonable diligence, it could have resulted in the employer learning of the violation.

In Secretary v. Bergelectric Corp, the employer was engaged in installing the electrical system for the renovation of a 20,000 square foot casino on tribal lands in California.  One of its employees, while installing conduit above the ceiling, fell 24 feet to the casino floor, and suffered broken ribs and fractures to his spine.  It was federal OSHA (and not California’s state-administered “little OSHA”) that investigated, as federal OSHA has jurisdiction where the alleged violations occur on tribal lands.

Following its inspection, OSHA tagged the employer for a single, “Other Than Serious” paperwork violation (for failing to correctly document the worker’s fall on an OSHA 300 log) and three “Serous,” fall-protection violations.  The three items were (1) failure to protect the employee by the use of guardrail systems, safety net systems, or personal fall arrest systems, while he was working at a height of six feet or more; (2) two workers having connected their lanyards to a single anchorage connector while installing conduit; and (3) a worker having tied off by wrapping his lanyard around a structural member of the building, and then using a non-locking snaphook to hook the lanyard directly to itself.

The fall-protection citation items were “grouped” for adjudication, it being uncontroverted that all three related standards applied, had been violated, and that the respondent’s employees had been exposed to the hazard of a fall of 24 feet or more.

The fall had occurred on the third day of a three-day period, during which there occurred several disconcerting incidents, in which employees were at risk of falls.  On the first day, an employee assigned to hang conduit below the hard lid was instructed to use a scissor lift to access the ceiling, and string the conduit from the bottom.  Instead, the employee opted to use the lift to go above the hard lid and, while walking the beams above the hard lid, he slipped, and his foot broke through the drywall.  Fortunately, this employee, because he was equipped with appropriate fall-arrest equipment, fell no further.  The errant employee had not installed decking prior to working above the hard lid, but the foreman remedied that, by having the decking installed later on the same day.  The employee was reprimanded for working above the hard lid without permission, and a “tailgate talk” was directed for the following day.

At the trial of the citations issued two days later, the Secretary sought to characterize the foregoing incident as a “near miss” (and violative conduct) but the ALJ viewed it as an incident not involving any fall protection violations.

On the second day, two employees – Ron Castro, and “R.S.” (the employee who would be injured on the following day) were instructed to stage conduit and materials above the hard lid for installation the following day.  This involved putting all the necessary materials into the lift, unlading them onto the beams just above the lid and next to the scissor lift, and securing them to the framework.  The testimony was that neither Castro nor “R.S.” needed to exit the lift the complete the tasks assigned.

However, Castro did get out of the lift to install a beam strap at a location close to where work would be performed on the following day.  To do this, Castro attached a lanyard to his harness, looped the lanyard around a beam, and attached the slip back onto itself.   Castro then crawled along the beams above the hard lid, attached the beam strap, and returned to the scissor lift.  Castro spent about 5 minutes outside the lift, and affixed his lanyard in a manner forbidden by one of the standards that would be cited on the following day, but he completed his task without incident.

On the day of the accident, per the trial testimony of Pete Evans, a foreman, Evans was checking on various crews at work at about 7:45 A.M., when he viewed R.S. crashing through the hard lid, and falling 24 feet to the casino floor.  R.S. and Castro had been above the hard lid for approximately one hour.  Post-accident investigation revealed violations of both the project’s Activity Hazard Analysis, and three OSHA fall-protection standards.  R.S. and Castro had connected their lanyards to the same anchor point, no plywood decking had been installed in the work area above the hard lid, and R.S.’s lanyard was found hanging from a notice in an angle beam, indicating it was neither attached to the beam strap, nor to the D-ring on the back of R.S.’s harness.

The foreman testified he had not completed his “competent person” inspection of the decking and fall protection being used, because he had awaited Castro’s call to go up in the lift to do so, but Castro never called.

Since all of the other elements of the violations were conceded, and actual knowledge of the hazard was not alleged, constructive knowledge became the determinative issue.  The Secretary argued that respondent’s foremen should have been aware of the violations occurring above the hard lid, because employees broke fall protection rules on three consecutive days.  This, the Secretary concluded, proved that Respondent had failed in at least one of:  clearly defined rules, adequate training, timely and thorough inspections, or a progressive disciplinary program.

The respondent countered by arguing that it could not have known about the violations committed by R.S. and Castro, because they were out of view while above the hard lid, its foremen provided frequent fall protection training, and it had a documented history of progressive enforcement of its safety rules.

In deciding whether the employer had exercised reasonable diligence, the ALJ engaged in a detailed examination of the evidence.  Ultimately, he vacated all three fall-protection citation items. 

The Court was unpersuaded that the incidents of the preceding days established deficient work rules and training.  The ALJ found that R.S. and Castro could not have been observed from the ground 24 feet below, through a hole in the ceiling, with a view obstructed by the scissor lift.  The ALJ found Bergelectric’s training regime to address the violations cited, and overall to be “thorough in terms of its content, regularity, and utilization of classroom and on-the-job, practical training.”

Following a detailed examination of the evidence concerning both the inspections performed by Bergelectric (which the ALJ found to be “thorough and responsive to the hazard present”) and its disciplinary program.  As to the latter, the ALJ set Bergelectric apart from the many employers who have an admirable “paper policy,” but seldom act upon it, and concluded that the respondent’s disciplinary program was “thorough and well-implemented.”

You should not be liable for an OSHA  violation, if you neither knew, nor could reasonably have been expected to know of it.  You must keep in mind, of course, that actual knowledge, including that of any supervisory personnel, will support a violation, and it is imperative that the employer exercise, at all times, reasonable diligence, directed to discovering and correcting safety and health violations.

While defenses such as a lack of constructive knowledge (and the “unpreventable employee misconduct” are easy to assert, but challenging to establish, you should discuss with counsel whether they are realistic grounds for a contest proceeding, anytime your company is cited for an alleged OSHA violation.

Key Elements of a Health and Safety Program for Demolition Operations

In Miami, a condominium building being demolished collapsed suddenly, and a construction worker had his leg severed when he was struck by a “boulder” the size of “the front end of an SUV.”

In New Jersey, a construction worker was trapped and killed, when the last remaining wall of a building under demolition collapsed on top of him.

In Philadelphia, OSHA attributed the unexpected collapse of a four-story building that killed six, and injured fourteen, to the removal of structural supports early in the demolition.  The contractor was charged with third-degree murder and involuntary manslaughter.

In Connecticut, a contractor was hit with almost $200,000 in penalties, when OSHA found it had failed to brace the building’s walls while removing flooring on the upper levels of a building being demolished, had exposed workers to falls of up to 36 feet due to unguarded wall openings, and had taken inadequate measures to protect employees from lead.

Building demolition is not for the careless or the unskilled.  Its perils include collapses, falls, dust, hazardous materials, and dangerous levels of noise.

Before undertaking any demolition operations, you must, first, become thoroughly familiar with subpart T of 29 C.F.R. 1926, “Demolition” (and train your employees correspondingly).

Additional OSHA construction standards that must be integrated into your health and safety program and training for demolition include all or the applicable parts of the following:

  • Subpart D, Occupational health and environmental controls (especially the section on lead);
  • Subpart E, Personal protective and lifesaving equipment (especially the sections on head, hearing, eye and face, and respiratory protection);
  • Subpart J, Welding and cutting (especially the section on gas welding and cutting);
  • Subpart K, Electrical (especially the sections on wiring methods and components (temporary power), general requirements for safe work practices, and lockout and tagging of circuits);
  • Subpart L, Scaffolds (general requirements);
  • Subpart M, Fall protection (duty to have fall protection, systems criteria and practices, and training requirements);
  • Subpart P, Excavations (scope, application and definitions; specific requirements, and requirements for protective systems);
  • Subpart Z (Toxic and hazardous substances (in particular, asbestos); and
  • Subpart CC (Cranes and derricks in construction).

Another key resource is “Safety and Health Program Requirements for Demolition Operations,” ANSI/ASSP A10.6-2006 (R2016) which, while lacking the legal force of OSHA standards, is still authoritative.  (Available for purchase and download on the American Society of Safety Professionals website.) 

By far the most frequently cited OSHA violation relating to demolition is failure to comply with § 1926.850(a), which mandates that, before employees may be permitted to begin demolition operations:

. . . an engineering survey shall be made, by a competent person, of the structure to determine the condition of the framing, floors, and walls, and possibility of unplanned collapse of any portion of the structure.  Any adjacent structure where employees may be exposed shall also be similarly checked.  The employer shall have in writing evidence that such a survey has been performed.

The required pre-demolition survey must also ascertain the presence and location of lead, asbestos, and other hazardous substances.

Rounding out OSHA’s “Top 5” citation items relating to demolition are inadequate fall protection, the improper shoring or bracing of walls, insufficient inspections of stairways and ladders, and the failure to test for, and remove, hazardous materials.

If “any type of hazardous chemicals, gases, explosives, flammable materials, or similarly dangerous substances” has been used on the property, or is suspected of being present, testing and purging must precede demolition.  All utility service lines must be shut off, capped, or otherwise controlled, and the service providers notified.  If any utilities are to be maintained during demolition, the lines must be temporarily relocated and protected.

Another key preparatory step is the erection of an overhead shed or canopy, to provide safe ingress into the structure to be demolished, and protection from falling objects. Any multistory building must be protected for a minimum of 8 feet from the perimeter.  Canopies must be at least two feet wider than the building entrance, and capable of sustaining a load of 150 pounds per square foot.

Employees on walking/working surfaces must be protected by covers, guardrail systems capable of withstanding a force of at least 200 lbs., or personal fall arrest systems against falls through holes six feet or more above lower levels.  There must also be installed covers to protect against objects falling through holes.

Wall openings must be protected to a height of 42 inches, wherever there exists the danger of employees falling through them.

Floor openings not used as material drops must be covered with material substantial enough to support the weight of any foreseeable load, the covering to be secured to prevent accidental movement.

Access ways to the building interior must be kept closed at all times, excepting designated stairways, passageways and ladders.  These must be periodically inspected, and maintained in a clean safe condition.  Where a stairwell is being used in a multistory building, it must be well-lit, and completely and substantially covered over at a point not less than two floors below where work is being performed.  Access to the floor where demolition is in progress shall be via a separate, protected, and well-lit passageway.

Where chutes are employed, openings must be protected by a guardrail 42” above the floor, and gaps between the chute and the edge of openings in the floors solidly covered over.  Except at ground level, chute openings must be kept closed when not in use.  Nothing may be dropped to any point lying outside the structure’s exterior walls, unless the area is effectively protected.  A toeboard or bumper, at least 4” thick and 6” high, must be securely installed at each chute opening at which material will be deposited into chutes by wheelbarrows or mechanical equipment.

Where debris is to be dropped through holes in the floor without the use of chutes, the area onto which material is to be dropped must be completely enclosed, with barricades not less than 42 inches high, and not less than 6 feet back from the projected edge in the opening above.  Signs warning of the hazard of falling materials must be posted at each level.  Debris must not be removed from the lower area, until debris handling above has come to a halt.

At or near the discharge end of each chute, a substantial gate must be installed, and monitored by a competent employee

Except for work such as cutting holes through which to drop materials, the demolition of exterior walls and floor construction shall proceed downward from the top of the structure, work on each story to be completed, before work on the next floor below begins.

Where floor arches are being removed, the area directly below must be barricaded against access, and employees kept out of it.  Notwithstanding the closing-off of the lower level, it’s still necessary to verify that no one is present there, before the arch removal proceeds.

As demolition proceeds, “continuing inspections by a competent person shall be made to detect hazards resulting from weakened or deteriorated floors, or walls, or loosened material.  No employee shall be permitted to work where such hazards exist until they are corrected by shoring, bracing, or other effective means.”

In addition to all OSHA requirements, demolition work in New York City is subject to all requirements under the City Council’s 2017 enactments requiring a “primary construction superintendent” and “site safety plan,” and OSHA training and Site Safety Training cards for employees.

The foregoing is not a complete list of elements that need to be in your planning and safety program for demolition operations, but it covers much of the ground.

Divided OSH Review Commission Reverses Affirmance of General Duty Clause Citation Following Heat Stroke Fatality

A 2-1 decision by the OSH Review Commission recently reversed an Administrative Law Judge decision that had affirmed an OSHA citation alleging a violation of the General Duty Clause (“GDC”), based on employee exposure to working on a commercial roof in direct sunlight.  The citation followed the death, due to heat stroke, of a 60-year-old temporary worker, supplied by a staffing agency, who had multiple pre-existing conditions.   The case, while obviously a sad one, is instructive on several levels.  One is that the OSH Review Commission (in reversing the ALJ decision) rightly cautioned against reasoning backward, from an unfortunate outcome, to conclude that there must have existed a hazard “likely” to cause death or serious physical injury.

A second lesson from Secretary v. A. H. Sturgill Roofing, Inc., is that the ALJs and the OSH Review Commission do not “rubber stamp” citations.  In Sturgill Roofing, in addition to the initial ALJ decision, each of the three commissioners took the trouble to write a separate opinion on the appeal, and while there were conflicting viewpoints, all of the opinions (55 single-spaced pages in all) reflect solid legal scholarship, and an obvious determination to apply the OSH Act correctly.  The facts in your particular case may be hopeless, or the economics of litigating your citation may be unfavorable.  You should not, however, base a decision to forego contesting a doubtful citation on a perception that, as an employer, you will not receive a fair hearing.

The Sturgill Roofing case is also cautionary, in that while common sense might call into question whether 60-year-olds with multiple health conditions should be working on roofs in direct sunlight, care must be taken to observe the mandates of the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) and the Americans with Disability Act (ADA).

The employer in Sturgill Roofing had an 11-member crew removing a rubber membrane and Styrofoam roof of a bank building on an August day in Ohio.  Three crew members performing this work, including “M.R.,” had been supplied by a temporary staffing agency.  It was M.R.’s first day on the job, and he was 60 years of age, with health issues, including congestive heart failure and Hepatitis C.

The temperature when the workday began at 6:30 A.M. was 72 degrees Fahrenheit, with 84% relative humidity.  M.R., who had been questioned within the limitations imposed by the ADEA and ADA (essentially, “can you do the job?”) was given the task of standing near the edge of the roof, and pushing off the edge, into a dumpster below, cut-up pieces of roofing material brought to him in carts by other workers.  It was undisputed that the workers were all encouraged to utilize access to ice, water, rest, and shade.

At about 11:40 A.M., by which time the temperature and humidity had risen to 82 F. and 51%, M.R. was seen to “walk clumsy,” and collapsed.  He was taken to hospital, where his core temperature was found to be 105.4 F.  He died of complications from heat stroke three weeks later.

Following an inspection, OSHA cited the employer for a violation of the GDC (and a related, failure-to-train item).  Both citation items were contested, and affirmed following a trial before an Administrative Law Judge.

The elements of a violation of the GDC are (1) a hazardous condition or activity in the workplace; (2) that the hazard be one recognized by the employer, or in the industry; (3) that the hazard was causing or likely to cause death, or serious physical harm; and (4) the existence of a feasible and effective means to eliminate, or materially reduce, the hazard.  As with any violation, the Secretary must also prove that the employer knew, or with the exercise of reasonable diligence could have known, of the violative condition.

 On review, a 2-1 majority of the Commission voted to vacate both citation items, finding (with respect to the GDC violation) that the Secretary had failed to prove at least two elements (the existence of a hazard, and a feasible means of abatement).

The majority found fault with the ALJ’s reliance on a National Weather Service Heat Advisory chart.  The chart indicates levels of caution when temperatures are accompanied by “prolonged exposure” or “strenuous activity” (but fails to define these terms, which were not otherwise established at the trial).  In addition, conditions on the day of M.R.’s collapse were generally only in the “caution” range for perhaps two hours, but (without sufficient grounds in the record) the government’s expert opined that 7.5 degrees should be added to the heat index, to reflect likely conditions on the roof.  The ALJ, going even further, added 15 degrees (because the work was being done in direct sunlight).  The Commission found the expert’s testimony deserving of little weight, and that the ALJ had set forth no basis to add 15 degrees for full-sun conditions.  The Commission concluded that, since absolute safety surpasses the OSH Act’s requirements, conditions in the “caution” range, for part of the morning, did not rise to the level of a hazard, within the meaning of the GDC.

The ALJ also improperly “reasoned backward,” the Commission majority found, in essentially concluding that, since a 60-year old man with multiple health issues was hospitalized and ultimately died from heat stroke, the hazard was established.

In her separate, concurring opinion, Commission Chairman MacDougall proposed that “excessive heat” is a risk inherent in the performance of outdoor work, and one that only presents a possibility for harm.  Whereas, to qualify as a “significant risk” in violation of the GDC, the hazard must be more likely than not to cause death or serious harm.

Chairman MacDougall disapproved, also, of the vague, “sliding scale” of how much heat on the roof might qualify as “excessive,” the Secretary’s expert witness at trial having spoken of a heat-related risk that could “lead to heat exhaustion for a younger person up to heat stroke for an older person,” and the ALJ having tacked 15 degrees onto the ambient temperature.  The alleged hazard, the chairman observed, was a poorly-defined “moving target,” far too attenuated and broad to establish a breach of the GDC.

The majority stressed also that the employer had lacked both actual and constructive knowledge of those aspects of M.R.’s physical condition that might have made him especially vulnerable to heat stroke.  Sturgill Roofing did not know M.R.’s age or his health status and was, indeed, forbidden by the ADEA and the ADA from seeking that information (although limited health-related inquiries are allowed, if job-related, and consistent with business necessity).  At least one federal Court of Appeals case has held that compliance with the General Duty Clause “cannot be used as justification for conducting medical inquiries that screen out an individual because of a disability,” the standard for proving the “business necessity” defense under the ADA being “quite high.”

Finally, Chairman MacDougall observed in her concurring opinion, an employer’s obligation under the GDC extends not “to any employee,” but to his own employees only, and analyzing personal risk factors (such as a single employee’s age, or underlying health conditions) magnifies the concept of a recognized hazard for all employees to mandate recognition and provision for employee-specific hazards.

M.R.’s case stirs pity, as his ailments seem to have been results of long-term alcohol and drug abuse and he could only have been on that roof out of dire economic necessity.  Even so, however, the employer was given a fair hearing and,  ultimately, a decision that fairly interpreted the governing law. If your company is cited under the OSH Act following a fatality, you should not assume that the citation will necessarily be upheld, merely because an employee died.  It is exposing employees to hazards covered by the OSH Act, not the severity of any injury as may result, that governs.  Even where there has been a death or serious injury, with competent legal advice you may be able to successfully contest all or some of the citation items, or negotiate for fewer/less serious citation items, and a reduction in the monetary penalties assessed.

Worker Safety in an Industry on the Brink of a Technological Transformation

Since World War II, productivity gains in construction have lagged far behind those in American industry, generally.  Construction has generally not fared well, either, in attracting “Millennials” (the youngest of whom are now in their mid-20s) to work in the industry, and one of the industry’s greatest problems at the moment is a persistent shortage of skilled labor.

Construction also continues to be near the top — up there with mining and logging — as one of the most perilous occupations.

While we can’t predict exactly where the industry is headed over the next few decades, we know for sure that there are major technological advances, already in varying stages of making themselves felt, that will grow, probably very quickly, in their impact on the industry.  While disruption is always part of the story when vast technological changes affect an industry or economic sector, for the most part we can be optimistic that, within years, current trends will produce opportunities for widespread innovation, higher-quality construction, big cost savings — and substantial reductions in construction injuries and fatalities.

Of all of the burgeoning new technologies, construction insiders expect that VDC tech (virtual reality, augmented reality, artificial intelligence, building information modeling) is likely to have the greatest overall impact as to how projects are designed and constructed.  BIM has already arrived as a potent force, so much so that, in the near future, with the aid of AI-led design, building design will be less about drawing than about refining algorithms to successfully incorporate a potentially vast set of project requirements.  AI will do much of the conceptual heavy lifting — at a cost that will no doubt drop, with improvements in the technology over time — in determining (or presenting choices) as to how the project can be built to best fulfill its intended use, within the constraints of size, budget, and the site’s peculiar environmental, regulatory, and engineering characteristics.

While the construction-safety impact of BIM might not be great in the near term, there will likely be an appreciable impact, as the process will lead to the more accurate integration of building systems in project design, and a concomitant reduction of field changes — that, often, being on-the-fly improvisations, present increased risks of injuries to employees.  Eventually, modes of design will  no doubt be evaluated using AI to promote safety considerations, both in construction and in the use of the finished product, and those parameters will find their way into the AI algorithms that tie together all of the design considerations.

Augmented reality is another technology that is finding a place on construction sites, in a growing variety of applications.  “Augmented reality” means an interactive experience of a real-world environment, in which existing objects are "augmented" by computer-generated visual, auditory, or other perceptual information.  Its use in construction is still in the early stages, but will probably expand greatly combination with drone technology and artificial intelligence.  One way in which these technologies is already being used together to enhance project safety is that visual images from drones (plus cameras and sensors placed around the jobsite) can instantaneously be processed, with information selected by AI being made available to field supervisors and the rank-and-file via headsets, cellphones, and tablets.  Building defects, hazards, and employees failing to observe safety standards can more readily be identified, and AI can be utilized to select and report problems, and swiftly recommend remedial measures.

Detecting and disciplining safety infractions is essential to minimizing jobsite injuries (and OSHA citations).  A great many injuries and deaths in construction occur when workers have a momentary lapse in concentration, or cut corners, and fail to tie off, or go down into an unshored trench “for just a couple of minutes,” or overestimate the difference between the bucket lift and an energized high-voltage line.

Drone technology, those nifty flying robots with high-resolution cameras, are in widespread (and rapidly-expanding) use on construction sites.  They should prove to be a godsend in avoiding both injuries and OSHA citations, as the employer no longer has his internal enforcement eggs in the basket of a foreman walking the job once or twice a day, and peering up to see if everyone has his lanyard connected far above him.

Drones can now be deployed to survey, continuously, more or less the entire worksite.  They enable supervisors to not only keep an eye on employers to ensure that they’re observing safety rules, but to detect pretty much the gamut of OSHA violations as can be observed by a Compliance Officer happening to drive by.  The mere presence of drones (but only if coupled with some firmness in disciplining safety infractions) is a powerful deterrent to inattention, or “just this once” disobedience of safety rules, on the part of construction employees.

Robotics is another tech field already making a big impact on construction operations.  One use is that robots are part of the mix in integrated systems using rovers, drones, AI, LiDAR (which uses pulsed laser light and sensors to measure distances precisely) to survey jobsites, assess progress, and identify and report errors.

Robots are currently being used, among other uses on a constantly-growing list of applications, to guide equipment in excavating construction sites, move materials around the site, lay bricks at ten times the speed of a human mason, and even to tie rebar.

While, to be sure, there are concerns that the deployment of robots on construction sites will reduce employment opportunities, there are indications that robots will often be used to supplement human workers, and will work in tandem with them, often performing heavier, repetitive and hazardous tasks.  That, of course, will spare construction workers many injuries, as well as wear and tear on their bodies, and potentially extend their working lives.  Having robots to perform the heavy lifting may also increase female participation in the construction workforce.

Offsite building and the growth of modular construction is another trend that is re-shaping the industry, with significant implications for worker safety.

Naturally, to the extent that construction takes place indoors, and in a factory environment (rather than outdoors and twenty or thirty stories aloft) risks from falls, weather-related conditions, vehicular traffic, conditions that vary from site to site (e.g., the presence of high-voltage lines overhead) and chaotic conditions on a constantly-changing outdoor jobsite are reduced appreciably.

Yet another technology in limited use now in construction, but with vast potential for the future, is 3D printing.  Soon, it may become possible to “print” onsite much of the material going into a structure under construction.  Early successes on residential and smaller-scale projects are being built upon, to bring about onsite printing of progressively more, and larger, building elements.

The full range of safety implications of 3D printing may be hard to foretell, but since the transportation, storage, hoisting, and installation of building elements are all hazardous operations, printing materials closer to where they are to be installed has some promise of yielding appreciable safety advantages.

As tech transforms the construction workplace, there are grounds to hope that “Generation Z” workers, born after 1995, will be attracted to the industry in greater numbers than their older “Millennial” brethren.  “Generation Z” are looking for careers with good pay and advancement opportunities, and many are wary of incurring crushing debt for college, such debt being a major cause of pessimism amongst Millennials.

While Millennials as a group are certainly more tech-savvy than most of us Baby Boomers, Generation Z are even more so and, as tech transforms the construction workplace, there is potential for many younger workers to want to be a part of the industry.

Construction, after decades of stagnation in terms of productivity, technological advancement, and safety engineering, is about to make giant leaps forward.  It’s a great time to be a “tech geek” with a serious interest in construction.

Safety & Health Law Judge: Fall Protection Required When Employees Are Walking Across the Roof

Year after year, falls are the #1 cause of fatalities in construction, and fall protection violations are the single largest basis for OSHA citations in the industry.

This month’s lesson underscores that employees must be protected against falls at all times, whenever the danger is present.  In Secretary v. Ontario Exteriors, Inc., a roofer on a job replacing the roof of a two-family residence in the Finger Lakes region, fell from the roof, and suffered permanent, disabling injuries.  His employer’s unusual work rules regarding fall protection while entering and exiting the roof area were found to violate OSHA’s fall protection standard.

The eave of the roof at issue in Ontario Exteriors was about 18 feet above ground level, and the pitch of the roof was 9 in 12 (vertical to horizontal).  The roof had unprotected sides, and lacked guardrails and a safety net.

The rope that served as a fall arrest lifeline hooked into a D-ring anchorage point at one end, and was hooked onto the employee’s personal fall arrest harness at the other end.  At the end of each workday, the employees stored their fall arrest rope system (the rope itself with a 6-foot shock cord, and the clasp for hooking onto the roofer’s harness) not close to the eave as is customary, but at the roof’s peak.

On the day of the mishap six Ontario employees were stripping shingles near the roof’s peak.  One of them moved his rope from one D-ring anchorage point to another, but, as was determined afterward, failed to affix it properly.  This employee slipped, slid down the roof, fell 18 feet to the ground, and sustained permanent, disabling injuries, including spinal fractures.  OSHA cited Ontario for a “Serious” violation of the standard applicable to fall protection in residential construction, and the employer contested the citation and proposed penalty.  The matter was litigated under the “Simplified Proceedings” rules, and was tried before an Administrative Law Judge.

Typically, roofers and others working on elevated surfaces have their harness, lanyard, and the rope grab attached to the end of the lanyard on and ready, before climbing a ladder (or ascending on a lift) to the roof eave, or other elevated surface.  Ordinarily, the procedure is that, upon reaching the roof eave or edge of the elevated surface, the worker will attach his rope (that should be attached at the other end to an adequate anchorage point) to his harness immediately upon stepping onto the roof or other elevated surface.

At most residential worksites, the fall protection ropes are left at the roof eave, or hanging over the eave, at the end of the day.  On the site where the injury described took place, management dictated a different procedure.  Ontario’s employees were ordered to store their ropes at the roof’s peak at the end of each shift.

The ropes used were of sufficient length that they could have remained attached to the anchorage point at one end, and coiled at the roof eave at the other end, for the roofers’ use immediately upon reaching the top of the ladder at the beginning of their next shift.  Despite this, it was Ontario’s standard practice, and one enforced by the company’s officers, safety director, and project supers, that roofers be required to climb the ladder to the eave, step off the ladder onto the roof, walk to the roof’s peak, straddle the roof ridge, find the appropriate safety line, and only then hook the clasp onto the safety harness.  This sequence was reversed at the end of each shift.

Thus, although Ontario’s employees were directed not to perform any “roofing work” while moving between the eave and the roof peak without fall protection, their employer imposed a policy that forbade them from being tied off, at least twice each day, while moving between the ladder and roof eave, and the roof peak (where the ropes were required to be stored).

Ontario contended that the safety rationale for its policy was that assertedly it was easier to get on and off the ladder while unhooked; that it was cumbersome to climb the ladder while tied off; that it was too difficult to hook the rope to the harness’s D-ring with just one hand (the other hand being needed to hold onto the ladder) and that the anchorage point, and the attached rope, could not be inspected for security from the top of the ladder.

According to testimony by the injured roofer’s fellow employees, the employer’s true reason (or, perhaps, a reason in addition to those mentioned) for its unorthodox policy requiring not being tied off while moving between the eave and the peak, was that the employer, or possibly some clients, deemed storing the ropes at the eave to be unsightly, or that it posed a risk of damage to the structure’s siding.

At the trial of the contest proceeding, the OSHA Compliance Officer who had conducted the post-accident inspection testified he had never encountered an employer insisting that workers wait to reach the roof’s peak before securing their lanyards.  From his own experience, he testified, attaching the rope to the harness, while at the top of the ladder, takes just seconds.  Alternatively, if he hooked onto the fall arrest system before starting up the ladder, he just moved the rope grab with his left hand as he climbed the ladder.  It is very easy, the C.O. testified, to keep three points of contact, while repeatedly sliding the rope grab, thus achieving fall protection while climbing a ladder.  This, the C.O. maintained, was safer than simply climbing the ladder, stepping onto a roof, approaching and then straddling the ridge, and only then hooking the lanyard onto the harness.

The exemption applicable where all fall protection and anchorage points have been removed at the completion of a job, the C.O. insisted, did not apply in Ontario’s case, as the company was still actively engaged in roofing work, and fall protection was available and functional.

The ALJ affirmed the citation (although he assessed a smaller monetary penalty than the Secretary had recommended).  He rejected the employer’s argument that the employees were not “at work” while moving between the eave and the peak, or performing “roofing activity” before they had tied off to the anchorage points at the roof peak.

Ontario’s employees, the ALJ found, were subject to fall protection requirements at all locations on the worksite where they were exposed to a fall of more than 6 feet.  Exposure was not limited to the time an employee was engaged in a specific roofing activity, as the assigned workplace was the entire roof.  It was not the activity being performed, the ALJ found, that mandated fall protection, but the workers’ exposure to the hazards of falling from an elevated surface.

Ontario’s related  argument — that employees were not yet at work, until they reached the peak and tied off — was also rejected.  During the approximately one minute spent crossing the roof between the eave and the peak, employees were engaged in assigned work duties, and since they were exposed to a fall from a height greater than 6 feet, they were required to have fall protection.  “That it takes only a second for an employee to lose his footing and fall pointedly illustrates the rationale behind the [OSH Review Commission’s] refusal to negate a violation because of the brevity of employee exposure,” the ALJ observed.

The moral of this story goes beyond the teaching that employee exposure can occur whenever employees are “in the course of assigned working duties, personal comfort activities while on the job, or their normal means of ingress-egress to their assigned workplaces.” Nor is it solely that brief duration of exposure to a fall hazard does not negate the violation or its seriousness.

The main lesson here is that falls occur suddenly, and lives can be changed, or lost, in an instant.  If your employees work on elevated surfaces, they need to be protected from falls at all times.  You need to furnish them with adequate equipment.  You also need work rules, but rules are insufficient, unless they are communicated.  So, you need to be persistent in training.  Plus, you can have all the training in the world, but if workers are casual about tying off, and supervisors look the other way, your company is courting disaster — and we don’t mean just a citation, and a $12,000 penalty.  Don’t let that happen.