Skip to main content

Construction Companies Have an Up-Hill Battle in Proving Employee Misconduct Defense with OSHA Violations

OSHA violations are issued from the observation of unsafe practices at jobsites regardless of whether an accident has occurred. Typically, these violations arise from employee(s) not following a company’s own safety rules. However, the burden to prove the employee misconduct so as to dismiss an OSHA violation is generally high and the recent decision in Secretary of Labor v. Elmer W. Davis, Inc. is informative as to the extensive policies and procedures a construction company has to have in place to successfully argue it.

Elmer W. Davis, Inc. (“EWD”) is a commercial roofing contractor based in Rochester, New York and employes approximately 150 to 300 persons, varying with seasonal needs. On April 30, 2021, EWD assigned two employees, Ory Leach and Cody Pritt, to repair seams on a low-slope roof of a one-story commercial building in Rochester, New York. The roof to be repaired was rectangular and not more than 50 feet wide, and its slope was less than 4 in 12 (vertical to horizontal); the roof’s edge was unprotected and three of its four sides were about 15 feet above ground level. Upon arrival the employees decided that the roof’s configuration permitted them to solely use a safety monitoring system and did not require implementation of further fall protection based on EWD’s work rules. Leach was the designated foreman of the two-person crew based on seniority, and as crew foreman Leach decided he would act as the safety monitor for Pritt while Pritt performed the repair. EWD’s work rules for safety monitoring prohibited Leach from engaging in any roofing work while he was acting as safety monitor for Pritt, and Leach was aware of this rule. While Pritt did the roofing work, Leach held a hand trowel Pritt had been using and he began to do some roofing work himself thus performing work while simultaneously acting as safety monitor for Pritt. Leach’s action of simply holding the trowel violated EWD’s own work rule that safety monitors engage in no activity other than monitoring.

As Leach and Pritt were on the roof, an OSHA Compliance Officer (“CO”) that was driving by noticed them working near the roof’s unprotected edge without using any fall protection and began taking multiple photographs showing Leach standing near the unprotected edge with his back to the edge facing away from Pritt, and the hood of Leach’s sweatshirt pulled fully over his head, limiting his peripheral vision. After observing and photographing the employees for approximately 10 minutes, the CO identified himself to them and asked them to come down from the roof. CO briefly interviewed the employees. EWD’s safety director, Tim Crumb, had also been called by Leach and arrived at the site. After discussion with the CO, Crumb summoned the employees over in which it was established that the employees partook in safety training on fall protection that Tuesday, and EWD established that employees must always have a monitor. The next day, on May 1, 2021, Crumb sent the CO an email stating that “no doubt that a violation occurred” that “this is a case of misconduct”. On May 3, 2021, EWD formally disciplined both Leach and Pritt for their conduct on the roof, the disciplinary notices of each employee imposed a one-week suspension in accordance with EWD’s progressive discipline policy.

Subsequently, OSHA issued a Citation that alleged one serious violation asserting a violation of the standard which prescribes permissible fall protection systems and practices for “roofing work on low-slope roofs” with the alleged violation description providing that “On or about 4/30/2021,… the employer did not enforce the use of fall protection for employees engaged in roof work …Employees were exposed to falling 15 feet to lower levels while working near the roof edge with no fall protection.”

Following the hearings, the Administrative Law Judge (“ALJ”) found that the Secretary (of Labor) had proven by a preponderance of the evidence (i.e., that it was more likely than not) the employee’s conduct was in violation of the applicable standards, which provides that employees working on low-slope roofs with unprotected sides and edges 6 feet or more above lower level shall be protected by implementing a guardrail system, safety net system, personal fall arrest system, warning line system and safety monitoring system. As set forth in the standard, a compliant safety-monitoring system shall conform to criteria that a safety monitor shall be on same walking/working surface and within visual sighting distance of employee being monitored, be able to communicate orally with the employee and that the safety monitor shall not have other responsibilities which would take the monitor’s attention from the monitoring function. The acting foreman violated these rules when he began to do some roofing work which would have reasonably taken his attention away from his monitoring function.

However, EWD was successfully able to prove the affirmative defense of unforeseeable employee misconduct and overcome the “substantial evidentiary hurdle”. To establish this affirmative defense an employer must prove the following evidence by a preponderance of the evidence: 1) it established work rules to prevent the violation; 2) these rules were adequately communicated to the employees; 3) it took steps to discover the violation; and, 4) it effectively enforced the rules when infractions were discovered. Under the first element it was found that EWD’s work rule prohibited safety monitors from engaging in any activity other than monitoring employees and if Leach had complied with this company’s rule his conduct would have conformed to the mandate that a safety monitor have no “other responsibilities which would take the monitor’s attention from the monitoring function.” EWD’s work rule was adequate because it is both “effectively implemented the requirements of the standard” and was “designed to prevent the cited violation.” Under the second element, adequate communication of a work rule may be accomplished through training and here EWD adequately communicated its work rule. EWD’s written “Corporate Safety Program” addresses the role of a safety monitor in fall protection and is covered during orientation of new employees, in addition to annual training on fall protection training for its employees, and alongside regular participation by its field employees in toolbox talks and on-the-job training. Additionally, Leach and Pritt’s attended refresher training on the use of a safety monitoring system three days before the violation occurred. Under the third element of effective implementation, a safety program requires diligent effort to discover and discourage violation of safety rules by employees, and one of the factors used to determine whether employer effectively enforced its safety rules are the efforts it takes to monitor adherence to those safety rules. EWD established this element by showing it had a designated foreman who is responsible for worksite safety; a separate safety director who devotes much of their time visiting jobsites monitoring compliance with work rules, alongside another member of EWD’s safety department who also conducts worksite inspections. Furthermore, EWD also hires outside safety consultants to conduct unannounced inspections and requests that its insurance carriers conduct their own unannounced inspections. As to the last element it must be shown that an employer effectively disciplines employee misconduct. Pre-inspection and post-inspection disciplinary measures may be considered in determining whether an employee has effectively enforced its work rules. EWD’s progressive discipline policy prescribes an oral warning, as the sanction for first-time rule violations, but an employee’s first-time failure to use required fall protection is an exception, warranting the more severe sanction of a one-week suspension, or at the option of the sanctioned employee, in lieu of suspension, completing an OSHA-authorized training course on their own time. Since 2013, EWD had formally disciplined employees on 83 occasions including for violations of fall protection violations. The two employees here were similarly disciplined with one-week suspensions. Therefore, this affirmative defense was established, and the Citation was vacated.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Construction Companies Must Take Proper Precautions to Protect Workers from Heat Hazards

With summer approaching and temperatures beginning to rise, construction companies must take every reasonable precaution to protect their workers from potential hazards, including heat-related illnesses. The Occupation Safety and Health Review Commission’s recent decisions in Secretary of Labor v. United States Postal Service, show the importance of providing adequate heat safety training to employees.

In the summer of 2016 two letter carriers in Des Moines, Iowa were hospitalized due to “excessive heat” hazard. The first incident occurred on June 9, 2016, in which the first carrier began texting her supervisor on how she was not feeling well and she was trying to finish her run. The supervisor encouraged her to do as best as she could and offered to provide ice but was unable because she became preoccupied with work, as well. The temperature surpassed 90 degrees Fahrenheit during this period. As the letter carrier felt too ill to continue working, she began to drive back to the station when she vomited out the window of her vehicle. Upon the carrier’s arrival to the station three other letter carriers described her appearance as “extremely red”, “dazed”, and “shaking”. The supervisor acknowledged that the carrier looked “flushed” and noted her collar was wet with sweat and instructed her to sit down and proceeded to call the station manager. The station manager instructed the carrier to finish her route. The letter carrier refused and proceeded to “storm out” and talk to her union representative, and then proceeded to visit an urgent care facility.

The second incident occurred on July 21, 2016, as the second letter carrier, classified as a City Carrier Assistant (a “CCA”), a non-career employee, was delivering mail on-foot, she began to experience a headache, nausea, and memory loss. A supervisor came to the carrier’s truck and the carrier informed the supervisor of her symptoms. The supervisor provided the carrier with three water bottles and left, but as the carrier continued her route, her symptoms began to worsen. Eventually the carrier called her son who called 911 and the carrier was subsequently transported to the hospital.

As a result of these incidents and other related incidents, OSHA issued a Citation alleging repeat violations of the general duty clause of the Occupational Safety and Health Act in which the Postal Service exposed its employees “to recognized hazards related to working outside during periods of high heat levels while delivering the … mail.”

The supervisor from the first incident testified that she had never been trained by the Postal Service on heat-related illnesses prior to this incident, apart from sometimes receiving emails with heat safety information and seeing a poster on heat safety in the breakroom. On the second incident, although, The Postal Service completed an accident report claiming that this carrier had failed to “comply with the rules”, the second letter carrier, a non-career employee, testified that no one at the Postal Service told her what rules she had failed to comply with and during the course of OSHA proceeding her testimony was deemed more credible than that of her supervisor’s.

The Commission found that this evidence had shown the training was deficient and that adequately training supervisors on heat safety would have materially reduced the risks posed by excessive heat. Moreover, safety talks were held when employees such as CCAs were not present. Adequate training requires attendance of all supervisors of safety talks, including ones addressing heat stress safety when all supervisors and employees, including CCAs, are present. Safety talks should not be conducted before certain employees are required to report to work.

The dangers of heat illness had been further discussed in the ALJ’s decision in this matter. The most serious illness caused by heat stress is heatstroke, which causes a dysfunction of the brain. Symptoms include slurred speech, disorientation, confusion, unconsciousness, or coma, and death. Symptoms of heat exhaustion include headaches, nausea, vomiting, dizziness, and profuse sweating but does not result in an elevated body temperature or brain dysfunction. It is important that employers and employees recognize these symptoms to prevent “excessive” heat hazards. Moreover, it is vital to implement a heat acclimatation program for employees who are returning to work due to personal or health reasons. In A.H. Sturgill Roofing Inc., the Commission vacated citations that had been issued following an incident where employee who collapsed at a worksite and subsequently died from complications of heat stroke after working on a roofing project. The deceased employee had various pre-existing medical conditions. The employee’s assignment was to stand near the edge of the roof where other employees brought him a cart full of cut-up pieces of roofing. The assignment was intentionally made by the foreman because it was the employee’s first day on the project. All employees were encouraged to utilize the immediate access to ice, water, rest, and shade, without fear of reprisal.

Construction companies should have in place a proper heat illness prevention program that is communicated with all their employees, permanent and temporary, and that ensures adequate safeguards such proper supervision, acclimatizing workers, providing water, and managing work and rest cycles.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Subcontractors Must Ensure Compliance with Relevant OSHA Standards and Keep All Workers Safe at a Jobsite

The Occupation Safety and Health Review Commission’s recent decision in Secretary of Labor v. A Crane Rental LLC shows that subcontractors on a construction jobsite must ensure proper compliance with relevant safety standards especially the specific standards applicable to their work. Although a subcontractor might not control or supervise the employees of other contractors on a site, if they in any way violate applicable safety standards and create an unsafe situation, they can be held responsible.

A Crane Rental LLC (“ACrane”) provides cranes, lifting equipment and operators for general contractors. ACrane was among multiple companies working on a communication tower in Norcross, Georgia on March 21, 2019 when another company’s employee fell from ACrane’s personnel platform. ACrane had been contracted to provide a crane, an operator, a personnel basket, and a rigging system to lift to a subcontractor, Superior Broadband Towers’s (“Superior”) workers onto the communications tower. The personnel basket was rated to carry only up to two persons. Superior’s foreman at the site was the Lift Director responsible for determining what and who would be lifted. ACrane’s operator, an employee whose name had been redacted from the record indicated that his responsibilities included crane assembly, determining the location of the crane at the site, and rigging the personnel basket. He had no supervisory job functions but was rather supervised by ACrane’s operations manager, although she had not visited the site until the accident. On the first day, ACrane’s operator hoisted two of Superior’s employees on the personnel platform, while on the second day he hoisted he hoisted one or two Superior employees. However, on the third day, March 21, 2019, Superiors’ foreman, loaded the personnel platform with equipment and three Superior employees. ACrane’s operator testified that due to the platform’s location he could not see it until the personnel platform had been lifted about halfway up the communications tower, at which point he decided it was safer to take three workers to the top of the tower rather than lower them to ground. As one of Superior’s employees attempted to tie off to the tower, he tragically fell 105 feet and succumbed to his injuries.

During OSHA’s subsequent investigations, ACrane’s operator admitted questioning that he had determined the best location for the crane to be set-up and that he could see the personnel basket from the ground to the whole tower. However, based on the submitted evidence, it was shown that the operator was unable to see the personnel platform until it cleared the trees about halfway up the tower at the time of this accident.

ACrane’s written procedures for Crane Hoisted Personnel Platforms required that “workers to be hoisted” must attend a pre-lift meeting. On the day of the accident, Superior’s foreman, in his capacity as the lift director, held a lift meeting with ACrane’s operator. However, the operator did not know which Superior employees would be hoisted that day and he had no knowledge whether the foreman briefed the Superior employees to be hoisted separately, except for observing the foreman walked towards Superior’s crew after their meeting.

OSHA investigated the tragic accident and subsequently issued a two-item citation to ACrane alleging violations of OSHA’s Cranes and Derricks in Construction standard. Under the Item #1, OSHA alleged that when a “two person personnel basket was utilized by the crane operator to hoist the…crew consisting of three employees to heights above 90 feet from ground level… the maximum capacity of the personnel basket was exceeded exposing employees to fall and struck-by hazards” given that the cited OSHA standard mandates that the “number of employees occupying the personnel platform must not exceed the maximum number the platform was designed to hold or the number required to perform the work, whichever is less.” Under Item # 2, it was alleged that ACrane committed a serious violation of OSHA’s standard when it did not ensure that “employees hoisted in a personnel basket attend the pre-lift meeting with the crane operator and competent person responsible for the communication tower work” as the cited standard requires that the pre-lift meeting must be attended by “the equipment operator, signal person (if used), employees to be hoisted and the person responsible for the task to be performed.”

The Secretary established that cited standards applied to the cited conditions and that they were violated since A.Crane’s operator could not identify anyone else besides the foreman/lift director who had attended the pre-lift meeting and he did not know whether Lift Director had separately briefed the workers to be hoisted. However, the Administrative Law Judge found that ACrane did not have its own employees exposed to the violative conditions, and it was not a “controlling employer” under OSHA’s Multi-Employer Citation Policy (which provides that an “employer who… controls the cited hazard has a duty… to protect not only its own employees but those of other employers engaged in the common undertaking”) and therefore vacated the Citation.

The Occupation Safety and Health Review Commission disagreed and reversed the ALJ. The Commission found that although ACrane was not a “controlling employer” it rather was a “creating employer” (which as defined by relevant precedent provides that an “employer who creates a violative or hazardous condition is obligated to protect its own employees as well as employes of others who are exposed to the hazard.”) Therefore, the ALJ should reconsider their legal analysis accordingly, to determine ACrane’s noncompliance and knowledge elements with respect to the Citation.

Even if a subcontractor lacks authority to direct other contractors’ employees at a site, it must still take “effective steps” to keep all workers safe, and, especially from any dangers and hazards associated with its own work.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Construction Companies Must Timely Comply with Deadlines to Challenge OSHA Violations

The Administrative Law Judge’s decision in Secretary of Labor v. Rene Silverio Gonzalez/RG Roofing shows the importance for a construction company not to neglect but rather timely respond to any OSHA citation(s) and file a written notice of contest within 15 working days of receipt of the citation to preserve its ability to defend and challenge its merits.

Upon receipt of a citation, a company can chose to engage in an informal settlement process, and the documentation included with the OSHA citation typically outlines those procedures. However, should the matter not be resolved, and if the company does not accept the citation (and its corresponding fine(s)), in order to ensure its rights to challenge, it must send a written Notice of Contest within 15 work-days of receipt of the citation, or else risk having the citation and any corresponding fine/penalty become final, and the last word.

In this underlying matter, following a November 12, 2020 OSHA inspection at a worksite in Hitchcock, Texas, the Secretary of Labor issued a Citation alleging three serious violations on safety standards in relation to the RG Roofing’s operations at the site and a proposed penalty of $8,097. The Citation was mailed on December 28, 2020. Upon receipt of the Citation, RG Roofing’s owner, Rene Silverio Gonzalez, attempted to contact the local OSHA office but he could not offer any details as to when or the exact number of times he called the office and he never left any voicemails. RG Roofing never filed a written notice of contest and the Citation became a final order on January 27, 2021. OSHA thereafter sent a payment demand letter to RG Roofing. As payment was not received, the matter was referred to the respective debt collection office in May 2021. The local OSHA office on July 9, 2021 received a voicemail in Spanish from Mr. Gonzalez and the call was returned on July 12, 2021, and which point it was explained to him that the matter had been referred to debt collection and their office could take no further action.

On January 19, 2022, OSHA conducted another inspection of RG Roofing’s worksite in Texas City, Texas and based on the inspection, issued a Citation, alleging repeat violations of the same regulations as those cited in the December 2020. RG Roofing filed a timely notice of contest for this latter Citation and thereafter its representative, made an application for RG Roofing to be relieved from the final judgment arising from the December 2020 Citation.

The ALJ denied the motion on both procedural and meritorious grounds. The motion was procedurally untimely (as it was late by two months) and RG Roofing had not demonstrated excusable neglect. The ALJ, citing to applicable case law, “takes account all relevant circumstances surrounding RG Roofing’s failure to file a timely notice of contest, including the danger of prejudice to the Secretary, the length of delay and its potential impact on the judicial proceedings, the reason for delay and whether RG Roofing acted in good faith.” Here, the record showed little evidence of how RG Roofing handled its mail. Mr. Gonzalez testified that he receives his business mail at his home, the Citation was properly addressed, and although he does not read or write English, he engages his son when receiving mail in English. No other evidence of its mail handling procedures were offered. Although, Mr. Gonzales testified that he had resolved prior OSHA citations by calling the area office, and he attempted the same process unsuccessfully here but since he could not offer any details as to these attempts, this was given little evidentiary value.

Moreover, the ALJ found that RG Roofing had not acted in good faith in that it only sought to contest the Citation only after it had received a subsequent citation and the negative consequences of failing to challenge the initial Citation became evident.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Construction Companies Will Now Face Drastically Larger Criminal Penalties for Serious Work-Place Accidents Under Carlos’ Law

Governor Kathy Hochul recently signed legislation known as Carlos’ Law, which amends New York’s Penal Law and increases the penalties for criminal corporate liability for the death or serious physical injury of an employee, a felony or misdemeanor, by fines of up to $500,000, as per the Governor’s press release. The legislation is named after Carlos Moncaya, a 22-year-old construction work who died at a construction site in New York City in 2015. Harco Construction, the company overseeing the construction site where Mr. Moncaya was killed, had been convicted of manslaughter and ordered to pay maximum penalty, which was $10,000 at that time. The construction site had been repeatedly cited for safety violations.

The new law drastically increases the potential criminal fines that construction companies could potentially face. According to the Governor’s press release, under the newly signed legislation, “a corporation is guilty of criminal corporate liability for the death or injury of a worker when it negligently, recklessly, intentionally, or knowingly causes the death or serious physical injury of its employees while they are on the job”.

Pursuant to the statutory language, the legislation increases the fines from a felony conviction from $10,000, to a minimum of $500,000 and a maximum of $1,000,0000, while raising the fine for a misdemeanor conviction from $5,000 to a minimum of $300,000 and a maximum of $500,000. These drastic increases are meant to have a strong deterrent effect on construction companies to ensure the safety of its workers and of construction sites.

The law goes into effect on January 23, 2023. We will continue to monitor and report of developments as to this law’s implementation.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Construction Companies Must Ensure Employees Are Trained In The Use Of Heavy Equipment And Of Known Hazards

As has been previously shown in this safety series, Labor v. Sentinel Systems, LLC emphasizes the need for construction companies to provide proper instruction and training to their employees in the proper use of heavy equipment so as to avoid hazards associated with their use, in this instance the use a utility vehicle on paved surfaces with tires designed for off-road use, only.

Sentinel Systems, LLC (“Sentinel”) was one of the contractors involved in the construction of the American Dream Mall complex in East Rutherford, New Jersey (the “Project”). Its scope involved applying resinous floorings in the indoor amusement park and installing epoxy flooring in a parking garage. It had about 100 employees working on the Project.

On October 9, 2019, a Sentinel employee was driving a Bobcat Utility vehicle (“UTV”) when he fatally crashed into the front end of an empty flatbed semitrailer in a parking structure. The accident occurred at around 2:15 pm, in a parking structure that was used as a staging area for construction materials. A semitruck dropped off the flatbed for the offloading of material. The front end of the flatbed was exposed and was supported by front landing gear. This portion of semitrailer did not have any reflective materials and its location was not demarcated by traffic cones. Although the artificial light was sporadic, there was enough ambient natural light that the front end of the semitrailer would have been properly observable a reasonably attentive driver. The decedent employee was last seen by the GC’s superintendent driving the UTV about 10 mph, and in the parking structure when he struck the flatbed. It was inferable form the circumstances that the decedent did not discern the presence of the parked semitrailer before striking it.

After an investigation, OSHA issued a Citation with a single violation of construction industry standards titled “Safety training and education” which provides that “The employer shall instruct each employee in the recognition and avoidance of unsafe conditions and the regulations applicable to his work environment to control or eliminate any hazards or other exposure to illness or injury” and that Sentinel violated the standard by not providing “the Bobcat operators instruction on operating a Bobcat utility vehicle on pavement with tires that are designed for off-road use only”. The Citation proceeded to quote two provisions from the manufacturer’s Operation and Maintenance Manual (“Manual”) for this equipment: 1) “AVOID INJURY OR DEATH. Read this…Manual. Understand all…precautions and operating procedures before operating this vehicle.”; and 2) “This vehicle’s tires are designed for off-road use only, not for use on pavement. Operating this vehicle on paved surfaces…can alter the vehicle handling and may cause loss of control. Avoid operating the vehicle on pavement. If it is unavoidable, travel slowly and avoid sudden turns or stops.” The Recommended Abatement Action, included with the Citation, re-quoted the same 2 Manual provisions indicating OSHA’s Compliance Officer’s (“CO”) position that had Sentinel provided its operators with instructions that conformed to the two referenced provisions, the accident could have been avoided.

The Citation focused on two issues. 1) What instructions and training did Sentinel provide if any to driving the Bobcat UTV on paved surfaces when the tires were designed for off-road use only; and 2) Whether the Secretary met its burden to show that a “reasonably prudent employer” under the same circumstances would have done more to instruct its authorized operators on driving the Bobcat UTV on paved surfaces with tires that were designed for off-road use. Here, the record showed that Sentinel met its burden while the Secretary did not.

Sentinel was able to show that it had authorized only 9 managerial employees to operate the Bobcat UTV and that each authorized operator had prior experience operating similar vehicles. Sentinel had established that it had instructed each employee to review the Manual and had instructed each to drive no faster than 15 mph at the site, and it had assessed the knowledge of competence of each employee in individual test drives at the site. The Bobcat UTVs had been delivered to Sentinel at the Project and its president and Director of Field Operations (“DFO”) were present to accept them. The president had advised the DFO that he would be responsible for employee training. The equipment dealer representative trained both the president and the DFO and tailored the training to the conditions at the Project site. The surfaces for vehicle traffic at the Project were in constant flux and included gravel, earthen and paved surfaces. The dealer advised the president and DFO that the UTVs must not be driven at speeds of more than 10 to 15 mph, specifically on paved surfaces and advised them that operators not familiar with the vehicle should read the Manual. Only nine management level employees were authorized to operate the UTV, including the president and DFO. These seven employees including decedent had informed the DFO that they had experience operating similar vehicles. Moreover, the DFO provided one-to-one training on the operation of the UTV especially since Sentinel recognized that operators may encounter the hazard of losing control of the UTV when operating on paved surfaces. The training including the instruction of not driving faster than 10 to 15 mph at the Project and to drive in two-wheel mode when driving on paved surfaces for better handling. The DFO also rode with each of the seven employees on test drives at the site. After the training and test drive, each employee expressed confidence to the DFO that they could safely operate the UTV. The DFO also instructed each operator to review the Manual which was in the UTV’s glovebox. Before this accident there had not been any instances of any authorized employees driving the UTV in an unsafe manner.

The cited safety standard by OSHA is a general safety standard and therefore the ALJ utilized a reasonable person standard – would a “reasonably prudent employer” under the same circumstances have done more to instruct its authorized operators on driving the UTV on paved surfaces with tires that were designed for off-road use. Here, although Sentinel appeared to have initially offered conflicting accounts to OSHA’s Compliance Officer during the investigation following the accident, the evidence that was submitted showed that in fact Sentinel had taken adequate steps and instructions that were specific enough to advise employees of the hazards associated with use of this particular equipment and the Citation was vacated.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Construction Companies Must Enforce Their Safety Rules

Construction companies must not only ensure that they have a proper safety program in place, but that it is also adequately communicated and enforced by documented audits and consistent employee discipline, as shown in the matter, Secretary of Labor v. J.D. Abrams, LP. In this matter, the Administrative Law Judge (“ALJ”) affirmed the citations arising from an employee working in a trench excavation, over five feet deep (without proper cave-in protection) and the use of ladder in that trench that did not extend the minimum requirement of three feet above the landing surface.

J.D. Abrams, LP (“Abrams”) performs highway construction projects with about 500 employees. On December 3, 2019, Abrams, was engaged in a large waterline installation project in Austin, Texas. The installation supervisor (foreman) had worked for Abrams approximately two years and he had worked in excavation for over thirty years. He was supervising a three-person crew on this project: one person operated the excavator; the second worked in the trench; and the third worked outside the trench. This particular crew had worked on a section of trench that had been flooded on the previous day when a trench box crushed a section of pipe. No one was working inside the trench at that time and that portion had been repaired. On December 3, the foreman advised his crew that they would not use a trench box that day due to the prior day’s issue. They began excavating the trench, which ran parallel to the road on one side and to the sidewalk on the other. About 18 inches of rock was excavated from the lower layer while the middle layer was determined to be Type B soil. The top layer consisted of about a foot of asphalt on the wall closer to the roadway and six inches concrete and wire mesh material, closer to the sidewalk. One employee would use a ladder to go down into the trench, and prepare the base for a section of pipe, the excavator would then place that portion of pipe. The process would be repeated, and the ladder would be moved further down.

Two OSHA officers arrived at the site to observe the conditions, take photographs, measurements, and employee statements. The trench was six feet wide and between 60 to 86 feet long. The trench depth was measured in three separate locations, and each was over five feet: five feet, eight inches; six feet; and six feet, seven inches. The top of the ladder used to access and exit the bottom of the trench was two feet, eight inches above the landing surface. The foreman at the site admitted that he knew that a trench over five feet in depth had either to be sloped back or protected with a trench box, but he had avoided its use to avoid the incident that occurred on the previous day. He also knew that the top of the ladder should extend three feet above the landing surface, and he had verified it at the beginning of work that day, but he did not continue checking as work progressed.

OSHA cited Abrams for two items: Item 1 pertained to failure to properly protect workers from cave-ins during excavation, which specifically provides that adequate protective systems are required unless excavations are made entirely in stable rock or the excavation is less than five feet in depth and an examination of the ground by a competent person provides that there is no indication for a potential cave-in. Here, employees were noted to have been working in a trench approximately six foot seven inches in depth, without shoring, a trench box or other adequate protective system. Abrams unsuccessfully attempted to argue that the depth of the trench was less than five feet by not including the bottom layer of solid rock and the top concrete/asphalt layer. The ALJ dismissed this argument given that the case law is clear that depth of a trench is measured from the base to the top regardless of the various types of soil or other materials that it consists of. Moreover, the stability of the excavation is evaluated by the weakest material in the structure. Therefore, no exceptions applied, and an adequate protective system was needed, and not provided.

Item 2, cited Abrams for failure to require a portable ladder extend at least three feet above the upper landing surface, exposing the employee to a fall hazard. Here, the top of the ladder extended by two feet, eight inches, and clearly did not comply with the requirements of the cited standard. Given that it was also clearly known by the foreman, the Secretary proved its case for this violation.

Abrams asserted an unpreventable employee misconduct defense as to both citation items and referred the ALJ to its extensive Safety Program. To prevail, on this defense, an employer must show that it “1) established work rules designed to prevent the violative conditions from occurring; (2) adequately communicated those rules to its employees; (3) took steps to discover violations of those rules; and, (4) effectively enforced the rules when violations were discovered.” The ALJ found that Abrams met the first two criteria. Abrams had established adequate work rules that in effect mirrored OSHA’s standards that were cited here, and they were effectively communicated to its employees.

Abram’s Safety Program included a 72-page employee safety manual (the “Manual”) available in English and Spanish, training, and Abrams employed area safety coordinators. Each employee was provided a copy of the Manual during company orientation and received training. The Manual is organized into twenty-five safety topics including excavations, fall protection, stairways, and ladders, etc. The Manual specifically set forth that that no one should enter into an unprotected trench with a depth greater than five feet, unless protected by a trench box, or the sides of the trench are sloped back. Ladders must be set-up with side rails extending a minimum of 36 inches above the landing. Abrams also employs four safety coordinators dedicated to safety, training, auditing of worksites for safety compliance and investigating incidents. The foreman had received excavation training about four of five times during his tenure, as well as interactive training. Abrams conducts every Monday, a 30-minute safety meeting for its staff at every active project where attendance is documented by the signing the Supervisor’s Safety Training Report attendance sheet. Moreover, each day a foreman has a five-to-ten-minute meeting with the crew to go over the work plan and necessary safety measures.

However, Abrams failed to prove that it took steps to detect violations to its safety rules and it did not ensure enforcement and consistent discipline. According to their policies, Abrams’ safety coordinator was required to audit each project at least once per month. If any safety violations are found, the project’s superintendent would be notified so that violations are corrected immediately. Each month, the safety coordinators should report the results of their audits to their management team that would include safety issues and their remediation. However, no documentation of the audits or reports were submitted. The fact that no safety coordinator came to the project on the prior day as result of the crushed pipe flooding the trench suggested that the safety coordinators did not consistently respond to near misses.

According to Abrams, employees who failed to follow their work rules were disciplined either by verbal warning, suspension or termination depending on the nature and severity of the violations. Here, the only offered examples of such discipline were that Abrams’ foreman and worker (in the trench) were suspended for a week without pay following the OSHA inspection. Such post-inspection discipline alone is not sufficient, and no further evidence was submitted of any discipline or enforcement action as a result of its discovery of violations at a worksite.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

One Size Doesn’t Fit All When It Comes To Operating Powered Industrial Trucks

Secretary of Labor v. Huen Electric, Inc. demonstrates the need for construction workers to be properly trained and competent when operating a powered industrial truck (“PIT”) such as forklifts, lift trucks, stacker trucks/pallet stackers, etc. Some of these PITS have a cabin for the operator, while in others the operator walks and controls from behind. On September 30, 2019, Huen Electric, Inc. (“Huen”) an electrical contractor was removing an electrical splice box from a vault approximately three feet below the floor of the Chicago Museum of Science and Industry. Huen’s foreman used a stacker truck he had borrowed from the museum to lift the splice box. During the process the splice box and stacker truck fell in the vault pinning one of the other workers and leading to serious injury.

As a result of the incident, OSHA cited Huen for two violations1, although we shall limit our discussion to the violation pertaining to the lack of adequate training. According to the Citation, Huen had not ensured that the PIT operator was competent to operate the PIT, here a Toyota 6BWC15 Electric Counter Balanced Stacker Truck, by the successful completion of training and evaluation as specified in the regulation including but not limited to formal instruction, practical training and evaluation of the operator’s performance thereby exposing employees to struck by and crushing hazards.

Huen had been hired to upgrade the electrical system to the museum which required the removal of splice boxes located below the floor of the museum. Huen’s crew had previously removed four splice boxes by removing two-foot by three-foot concrete floor panels initially by hand and then by using a rented pallet stacker/forklift operated by the foreman to remove the covers from the vault. Once the covers were removed, the crew wrapped straps around splice boxes and removed them from the vaults using the rented forklift. The underlying incident occurred when Huen’s crew attempted to remove the largest splice box. Although the foreman and the crew were to use the same process as they had to remove the four prior splice boxes, there were some substantial differences with the operation starting with the fact that they did not have their rental stacker available and asked to and obtained permission from the museum to use its Toyota stacker truck (“stacker truck”), which is a hand-operated truck with an electric motor. Moreover, given that there was very limited space for maneuvering and the large size of the splice box, the foreman and crew engaged in significant planning for this removal, and he also reviewed the stacker truck’s manual for about an hour. They would also use straps wrapped around the splice box and then loop around the forks to raise it up from the vault. As the foreman attempted to raise the box from above the threshold, he briefly paused before releasing the parking brake by pressing down on the handle. At that point, the stacker truck did not appear unstable. The foreman then rotated the throttle to move the stacker truck away from the vault when he felt it move forward, towards the vault pit, tumbling into the vault and causing serious injuries to a crew member.

The foreman had approximately 30 years’ experience operating PITs and had no prior accidents until the subject incident. In each of his many jobs he had received some form of formal training mostly on forklifts where the operator sits in a cab. He had also received training on “walk-behind” stacker trucks in a previous job. The foreman’s prior work history and training were recapped but it also became evident during testimony that he had not received recent training on stacker trucks/pallet stackers in the past seven years from his last employer, nor current employer, Huen. Although Huen, through counsel attempted to emphasize the similarities between forklifts and pallet stackers, during the foreman’s testimony, he admitted that the “biggest difference” was the steering, braking and throttle. The foreman spent about an hour reviewing the operator’s manual on the Friday prior to the lift but had never previously operated the Toyota pallet stacker, although he had maneuvered it from the second floor of the museum down to the location of the splice box.

To prove a violation, the Secretary of Labor (SOL) must show by a preponderance of the evidence that (1) the cited standard applies, (2) there was failure to comply with the cite standard, (3) employees had access to the violative condition, and (4) the cited employer either knew or should have known of the condition with the exercise of reasonable diligence.

Here, the PIT standard which “contains safety requirements relating to fire protection, design, maintenance and use of fork truck, tractors, platform lift trucks, motorized hand trucks, and other specialized industrial trucks powered by electric motors or internal combustion engines” clearly applied to the pallet stacker at issue. As to the second element, the Secretary of Labor claimed that Huen had failed to provide the foreman with training specific to this walk-behind stacker truck and had thus failed to ensure that he was a competent operator. Huen, countered with the foreman’s extensive history to show that the standard was not violated. However, the ALJ agreed with the Secretary since it found that Huen failed to provide training compliant with the standard or otherwise evaluate that its foreman was competent to operate this stacker truck. Irrespective of “whether the training is an employee’s initial training on a PIT or refresher training on a related yet different, PIT, such training must meet certain minimum requirements, including a combination of: (1) formal instruction such as lecture, discussion…written material; (2) practical training… and (3) an evaluation of the trainee’s performance in the workplace.” The standards provide who may provide the training, when additional training is necessary and requires the employer to certify that the operator is trained and evaluated. Here, the foreman’s own testimony indicated he did not have formal or practical training on stacker trucks and Huen had an obligation to ensure that he was in fact competent to operate the pallet stacker safely.

Although Huen provided Class IV Forklift training it had an obligation to provide training where forklifts and pallet stackers differed such as those that related to throttle, steering and braking and there was no evidence that Huen provided same ether as an initial or refresher training. The ALJ also clarified that an employer need not duplicate training already received by the operator in a prior training program but rather offer additional training based on the differences between the two PITs.

The ALJ found Huen’s employees were exposed to a hazard because they were working in proximity to the foreman who had not been properly trained and in fact one employee was seriously injured. Given that Huen had rented a different model stacker truck for the four previous lifts over the past six months, the ALJ found it reasonable to infer that Heuen was aware that the foreman was using stacker trucks on multiple occasions and therefore was aware of its obligations to train and evaluate him. A penalty of $11,934 was assessed for this violation.

1 Violation # 2 pertained to modifications or additions to the stacker truck by use of the lifting straps, which were dismissed.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

An Exemplary Safety Program on Paper is Not Enough

Secretary of Labor v. TNT Crane and Rigging, Inc. demonstrates how companies must maintain work safety rules that not only specifically address the requirements of applicable OSHA safety rules and standards but that they also take measures to ensure adequate compliance. TNT Crane and Rigging, Inc. (“TNT”) is a crane service provider from Houston, Texas with more than 250 employees and numerous offices. On May 15, 2016, in Georgetown, Texas, a TNT employee was seriously injured during the disassembling of a crane when it contacted a power line. As a result of the incident, OSHA cited TNT for two violations of OSHA’s Cranes and Derricks in Construction Standards. The OSHA Review Commission ultimately affirmed both violations as against TNT.

On the incident day, four TNT employees (the crane operator, a spotter/rigger (SR1), a second spotter/rigger (SR2), and a driver) were completing the disassembly of a 275-ton mobile crane which had been used to install new antennas on a communication tower. All four employees met to discuss a plan for disassembly. The crane operator (and supervisor) created a job safety analysis (JSA) before the breakdown and discussed it with the three other crew members. The plan was for the crane operator to reposition the crane to lower the boom onto the semi-truck while SR2 would spot and hold the hoist line to keep it taunt, the driver would drive the semi-truck once the boom was on the flatbed and SR1 would spot and guide the truck. SR2 and the driver expressed concerns over the exact location due to nearby powerlines, but the crane operator reassured them it would be disassembled in the same location in which the crane was assembled and that there would be a 20 feet buffer zone from the power line. Therefore, the powerlines would be avoided. Nevertheless, as the crane operator was lowering the boom of the crane and retracting the hoist line, the load line came into contact with a powerline. SR2 who was holding the load line was electrocuted and sustained severe burns and other injuries.

After the incident, an OSHA Compliance Safety and Health Officer investigated. Although the officer was unable to inspect the original jobsite, the officer conducted interviews offsite with witnesses and took photos to recreate the scene. OSHA issued two citations: Violation # 1 – Exposure of employees to the hazard of electrical shock by failing to use at least one of the measures required to prevent encroachment or contact with power lines while disassembling a crane; Violation # 2 – Placing part of a crane and load, whether partially or fully assembled, closer than the minimum approach distance (MAD) to a power line.

To prove a violation, the Secretary of Labor (SOL) must show by a preponderance of the evidence that (1) the cited standard applies, (2) there was failure to comply with the cite standard, (3) employees had access to the violative condition, and (4) the cited employer either knew or should have known of the condition with the exercise of reasonable diligence. The cited safety standards clearly applied to the work that was being conducted at the time of the incident and that there was noncompliance and exposure to the hazardous condition. The issue that the Commission addressed in its most recent decision was whether TNT had knowledge of the violative condition, which it determined that it did.

Both violations rested upon the Commission’s reasoning that the violative conduct was collaborative here. It was not just the crane operator’s activities but the activities of the entire crew, collectively. As for Violation # 1, there was no dispute that TNT crew disassembled the crane without a required protective measure in place to prevent encroachment before disassembly began. Similarly, Violation # 2 involved the crew’s collective failure to maintain the required clearance during disassembly. Prior to disassembly, the crew conducted a JSA together and then met as group to discuss the work prior to commencement. Although two of the crew members expressed concerns, they were reassured by the other two crew members and all agreed to proceed. Therefore, the crane operator/supervisor’s knowledge of the other crew members’ violative conduct could be imputed to TNT, as is consistent with the relevant precedent.

TNT’s defense before the Commission was that the crane operator engaged in unpreventable employee misconduct (“UEM”). To succeed on that defense, TNT must show that it had established work rules to prevent violative conditions from occurring, adequately communicated those rules to its employees, took steps to discover violations of those rules, and effectively enforced the rules when violations were discovered. The Commission found that TNT failed to establish work rules that were specific enough to ensure the violative conditions from occurring.

As to Violation # 1, although TNT’s work rule shared some similarities with the OSHA standard, it did not provide the specific requirements mandating that an employer implement an encroachment prevention measure prior to crane disassembly to ensure that a 20-foot distance from power line is maintained when any part of the crane could breach that distance. TNT’s safety policy only mentioned one of the applicable provision’s numerous encroachment prevention measures.

As to Violation # 2, the Commission found that TNT did have work rules in place that addressed the requirement of the applicable standard and it properly communicated those rules to its employees through various trainings, safety programs/manuals, orientations, etc. However, TNT failed to sufficiently monitor compliance of those rules and effectively enforce them when violations were discovered and therefore could not establish a UEM defense. TNT claimed it monitored compliance through inspections and surprise audits by submitting inspection documentation that included safety checklists. Yet, this particular site was never inspected nor audited. TNT’s practices and the submitted documentation were insufficient as no one from TNT could provide details on how often worksites were generally inspected/audited, what kinds of sites were inspected, etc. TNT’s submitted documentation showed no evidence as to the effectiveness of their monitoring/auditing plan, except that one existed on paper. Lastly, TNT failed to establish they effectively enforced the rules when violations were discovered. Although the crane operator in this instance was discharged, TNT could not offer any other evidence of prior disciplinary action of an employee for violating powerline safety rules, which beggars belief given the size of the company. The fact that the crane operator and the rest of the crew collectively were involved in violative conduct actually was evidence of TNT’s lax enforcement of these rules.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Companies Should Exercise Caution When Outsourcing Inspections to Third Parties for Equipment Maintenance

The matter of Secretary of Labor v. Henkels & McCoy, Inc. demonstrates how companies must heed their equipment’s manuals and be aware of the scope and extent of services provided to them from third parties to ensure proper equipment maintenance. This matter arose from a fatal workplace accident involving a crew leader who was operating an improperly maintained digger derrick. The crew leader was an employee of Henkels & McCoy, Inc. (H&M) which performs general utility maintenance. The underlying incident occurred on May 2, 2018, in Jacksonville, Florida where the crew leader and an apprentice were assigned to remove a utility pole when he was fatally injured.

H&M utilizes digger derricks for utility pole installation and removal. The digger derrick has a flatbed equipped with a boom and operator’s chair that sits atop a pedestal, which is attached to the truck’s frame and chassis. The digger derrick has eighteen rotation bearing mounting bolts that connect the gear ring, on which the operator’s chair and boom sit, to the flange atop the pedestal. The digger derrick’s manufacturer in their manual instructs owners to conduct annual torque testing with a calibrated torque wrench. A warning decal is also prominently placed on the pedestal repeating this instruction and warning that failure to inspect and properly torque the rotation bearing mounting bolts can cause structural failure and lead to death or serious injury.

H&M mechanics used to perform inspections of the company’s digger derricks that also included torque testing. However, in 2007, H&M entered into an agreement with third-party contractor, Diversified Inspections/ITL Inc. (“Diversified”) to provide semi-annual inspection services on the digger derricks. From 2011 to 2016, the companies further engaged in agreements setting forth the scope of Diversified’s inspections. Upon inspection, Diversified would complete a report noting any issues with the equipment and forward to H&M. In February 2018, Diversified’s inspection reports began including a disclaimer that it was not performing torque testing.

On the incident day, the crew leader was operating one of H&M’s digger derricks from the operator’s chair, while the apprentice was working on the ground when they both heard a “creak”. The crew leader stopped operating the digger derrick. Upon investigation, the apprentice found that one of the bolts had “sheared off” and was on the bed of the truck. The apprentice proceeded to check the other bolts and then informed the crew leader that they were tight. Upon resumption of work, the apprentice heard sounds and jumped off the truck and thereafter saw the boom falling and the crew leader being ejected from the operator’s chair to the pavement below. He would tragically succumb to his injuries.

OSHA investigated the incident and issued a citation alleging a serious violation of the Occupational Safety and Health Act’s general duty clause for exposing employee to struck-by and crushing hazards by failing to properly maintain the digger derrick’s bolts. Although, an Administrative Law Judge vacated the citation, the Administrative Law Commission reversed the decision, affirmed the citation and assessed a penalty of $12,934.

To prove a violation of the general duty clause, the Secretary (of Labor) must establish the following four elements: (1) a condition or activity in the workplace presented a hazard; (2) the employer or its industry recognized the hazard; (3) the hazard was causing or likely to cause death or serious physical harm; and (4) a feasible and effective means existed to eliminate or materially reduce the hazard.

As a preliminary matter, the Commission found that the manufacturer’s recall notice as to the digger derrick’s bolts had no bearing on the Secretary’s allegation in the citation as to H&M’s lack of maintenance of the digger derrick’s bolts to ensure that they are properly torqued. Therefore, it proceeded to analyze each element of the alleged violation with respect to the conditions as set forth in the citation, not in terms of the incident or design defect.

The Commission found that a hazard existed as indicated by the existence of the manufacturer’s decal and as per the testimony of the Secretary’s expert who opined that failing to torque test the bolts could result in fatigue failure, which could cause the bolts to “back out and fall out” from the connection and eventually cause the digger derrick to collapse. The existence of the manufacturer’s decal prominently displayed on the equipment and its inclusion in the manual was sufficient to establish industry recognition of the hazard. The Secretary further alleged that there existed a feasible method for abatement of the hazard by torque testing the bolts which as per their expert would uncover “worn out or deformed bolts” for replacement in a safe and controlled environment given that the manual called for replacement of all bolts if one breaks during testing.

The Commission also found that H&M had constructive knowledge of the hazard since H&M could have known about the condition through reasonable diligence. The Secretary argued that H&M failed to exercise reasonable diligence as they never required Diversified to torque test the bolts during inspection nor did they negotiate a price for that service. Further, the 2016 agreement between the companies did not include the service and in the months leading to this incident, Diversified’s reports specifically stated they were not performing such testing. Although, H&M argued that the torque testing disclaimer was self-contradictory because these reports stated that the inspections were performed in accordance with ANSI and OSHA standards, which would have included torque testing, the Commission found that although “the evidence relating to Diversified’s relationship with H&M and torque testing is not a model of clarity” it could have known that Diversified was not performing torque testing with the exercise of reasonable diligence. H&M had an obligation to determine how the torque testing was to be done for the safety of its employees and in fact had expertise in this area since it torque tested the digger derrick bolts prior to retaining Diversified while H&M’s mechanic continued to exercise day-to-day control over the machines.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445