Skip to main content

Reducing the Dangers to Workers from Asphalt and Its Fumes

Asphalt is used extensively in roofing, waterproofing, and, above all, of course, in roadway construction.  It comes in many varieties.  Typically, it contains less than 10% bitumen, a petroleum distillate, mixed with aggregates and solvents. 

The aggregates used may be natural (limestone, granite), artificial (slag aggregates) or recycled (demolition waste, glass, and road planings).  Asphalt may also be synthetic, or modified by the use of polymers, and may contain a wide variety of other components, including binders, hardening agents, bonding agents, crushed rock, and sand.  As it is a petroleum-based product, asphalt should not be confused with coal tar or pitch, a wholly different product, having its own qualities and hazards.  Additives used in recent years in paving asphalt, such as resins and recycled rubber, may present additional, less well-known hazards.

The two primary safety issues associated with asphalt products are the danger of burns, and dangers from respiratory or skin exposure to the product and its fumes.

Of these, the danger of burns from working with hot asphalt is the more obvious one, as paving asphalt is heated to temperatures of between 250 and 325 degrees Fahrenheit, and roofing asphalt may be used at temperatures in excess of 450 degrees.  Many asphalt “recipes” are highly flammable, and some are potentially explosive.

In addition, when heated, asphalt’s fumes not only smell bad, but dangerous in in greater or lesser degree (according to what is in the mix).  The solvents (e.g., naphtha, toluene, and xylene), binders, and other chemicals used in different asphalt products may be extremely hazardous.  Asphalt, especially when stored in unventilated containers, may give off hydrogen sulfide gas which, if inhaled, can cause dizziness, convulsions, coma or death.  Asbestos and silica in the rock and sand found in asphalt are associated with lung disease.  Styrene can cause nervous system damage.  Bronchitis, skin rashes, and eye irritation are further hazards.

Where hardened asphalt is to be cut, drilled, milled or planed, avoiding the inhalation of respirable dust becomes a concern. Aggregates in many asphalt mixes include crystalline silica (quartz) which, if inhaled over a period of time, can cause lung damage, silicosis, and other serious ailments.

Curiously, although a 5 mg/m3 limit was proposed as long ago as 1992 (and, as an average over an 8-hour shift, has the force of law under Cal OSHA, California’s state-administered program) until now federal OSHA has not seen fit to adopt a Permissible Exposure Level for asphalt fumes.  The American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists recommends a threshold limit value of 0.5 mg/m3 (as an 8-hour, time-weighted average) and NIOSH recommends the same level as a maximum per 15-minute, short-term exposure.  One risk assessment study estimated a significant risk of lung cancer, at levels as low as 0.2 mg/m3..

So, while (apart, perhaps, from the requirement to use PPE while working with asphalt) OSHA does not have construction standards that regulate working with asphalt per se, there are things you can do, as a health-and-safety-conscious highway or roofing contractor, to reduce asphalt-related hazards to your employees.

A first thing you can do is to get expert advice regarding which asphalt mixes, available in your area, are the least toxic, while suitable to the work you perform.  Of course, your contracts may prescribe that particular mixes be used, but you may be able to negotiate a substitution, if you can identify an equivalent product that is less toxic and therefore safer.

Since asphalt products differ from one another in their composition and their uses, it’s a good idea, also, to study and to circulate the manufacturers’ Material Safety Data Sheets for the products that you use.

A critical element of the safe use of paving asphalt, with both highway-class and non-highway-class pavers, is the proper cleaning, maintenance and periodic testing of the equipment.  NIOSH, as well as the equipment manufacturers, publishes detailed guidelines on how the equipment can be maintained, to minimize worker exposures.

As always, training your employees, and emphasizing safe practices, and the enforcement of safety rules and procedures, are critical.

Rule #1 for employees is probably to avoid breathing asphalt fumes whenever possible.  Workers should never stick their heads into an asphalt tank or mixing container, or lean over a kettle.  While asphalt fumes are generally not believed to be acutely hazardous while asphalt is being laid in open-air situations, the continuous inhalation of high-vapor concentrations — as may arise in poorly-ventilated, confined, or semi-confined spaces — is to be avoided.  Additional ventilation, and/or the use of respirators, may be required.

PPE (Personal Protective Equipment) should be used when working with asphalt.  Overalls and/or long-sleeved jackets and full-length trousers (without cuffs) should be worn to protect skin from burns.  Heat-resistant, impermeable gloves, and safety boots should be worn to protect hands and feet.  If there is any danger of product (including dust) getting in employees’ eyes, goggles should be worn.

Workers should never eat, drink, or smoke while working with asphalt, and, indeed, hands should be washed thoroughly, before handling or eating food or drink.  Asphalt should be kept away from ignition sources.  Asphalt can cause lung damage, or even death, if swallowed.

Workers should be instructed, and regularly reminded during toolbox talks or at other opportunities, that they should stop working, and consult a foreman, if they experience dizziness, or other symptoms associated with exposure to asphalt or its fumes.

In case of inhalation, the employee should be removed to fresh air immediately.  If the employee has trouble in breathing, seek medical attention at once.  If the employee has stopped breathing, administer resuscitation, and seek emergency medical assistance.

Burns should be flushed immediately with large amounts of cold water.  Except if necessary to allow breathing, do not attempt to remove anything from the burn area.  Bitumen should be removed under medical supervision.  Seek medical attention at once.

Apart from ingestion of the material (or the inhalation of dust where it is being cut, milled, etc., the primary dangers of asphalt (burns, fumes) have to do with the heating of the product.  In case of ingestion, if the person is conscious, he should rinse out his mouth, and be given water to drink. 

In case of fire, dry powder or foam (and not water or carbon dioxide) should be used to extinguish the fire.  Hydrocarbon fumes, as well as smoke, may be released during a fire involving asphalt products.  If first responders are summoned, advise them as promptly as possible that the fire may involve asphalt products, so that appropriate measures may be taken to protect the firefighters and other first responders.

There are many reasons for the perennial popularity of asphalt, especially for road surfaces and parking lots.  It’s durable, and can be milled for recycling and resurfaced.  It offers speed and cost savings in construction, as well as reductions in noise pollution.  Treated with the necessary respect, it’s an extremely useful material.  However, precautions must be taken not only against burns, but against the fumes and gases that the product gives off.

NYC Local Law 81 Expands Requirements and Duties for Construction Superintendents

Job-related fatalities in New York City are not constant from year to year (there were 191 such deaths in 1993, and just 56 in 2013) but, year after year, construction-related injuries and deaths run ahead of transportation deaths as the #1 and #2 causes of workplace mayhem.

Since the inception of OSHA (enacted in 1970) workplace fatalities have been reduced by about 60%, while the American workforce has more than doubled.  Those of you who imagine that an OSHA inspector lurks behind every lamp-post may be shocked to learn, however, that New York, the nation’s fourth most-populous state with more than 19 million inhabitants, was covered by just 66 federal OSHA inspectors statewide in 2015.

Construction-related fatalities in New York City rose from 17 in 2011, to 25 in 2015, and injuries on construction sites rose from 128 in 2011, to 435 in 2015 statewide.  The numbers of OSHA inspections in New York dropped every year from 2011 through 2015, with an overall reduction of 27%. 

While most construction employers take their safety responsibilities seriously, some, regrettably, do not.

One incident from 2015 involved a 28-year-old foreman on a high-rise construction jobsite in Manhattan.  This worker sustained severe injuries when rebar fell on his leg.  His employer sent a supervisor with the injured employee to the hospital, to report to the doctors, falsely, that the injury resulted from an off-site slip, trip, and fall.  The injured worker, a new father, was discharged just days following the incident.

Since anticipated budget cuts appear likely to bring about additional reductions in federal OSHA enforcement, state and local governments, and construction industry employers, are going to have to take up the slack.

Over the past several years, local authorities in New York City, notably the City Council, have taken a number of steps to try to stem the increases in the numbers of deaths and injuries accompanying the post-recession building boom in the City.

One such measure, which took effect in November 2017, is Local Law 81, which expands the role of the construction superintendent, while increasing the range of projects on which a superintendent is legally required.

Prior to the effective date of Local Law 81, a site safety manager was required only during the construction or demolition of “major buildings,” defined as those over ten stories high.  With the advent of Local Law 81, a construction superintendent is now required on buildings having less than ten stories (except one to three-family homes) that meet any of the following criteria:

  • new buildings;
  • demolition of an entire building, or more than 50% of the floor area over a 12-month period;
  • vertical or horizontal enlargement;
  • work requiring special inspections for underpinning;
  • work requiring special inspections for the protection of sides of excavations;
  • other jobs posing risks to the public or to property, as determined by the building commissioner.

Public Law 81 also assigns expanded responsibilities, many of them safety-related, to building superintendents.  Generally, the superintendent is now responsible for the following:

  1. Acting in a reasonable and responsible manner to maintain a safe job site and assure compliance with [the Building Code] and any rules promulgated thereunder at each job site for which the construction superintendent is responsible;
  2. To the extent that a registered design professional or special inspection agency is not responsible, the construction superintendent must assure compliance with the approved documents at each job site, for which the construction superintendent is responsible;
  3. Fulfilling the duties of a superintendent of construction assigned by Chapter 1 of Title 28 of the Administrative Code at each job site for which the construction superintendent is responsible; and
  4. Visiting each job site for which the construction superin­tendent is responsible each day when active work (with limited exceptions) is occurring.

During the construction superintendent’s daily visit, he or she must inspect all areas and floors where construction or demolition work, and ancillary activity, is occurring, and do all of the following:

  1. Verify that work is being conducted in accordance with sound construction/demolition practices;
  2. Verify compliance with the approved documents; and
  3. Verify compliance with Building Code § 3301, and any rules promulgated thereunder.

In addition, the construction superintendent has the following responsibilities under Local Law 81:

  1. Correcting unsafe conditions, giving notice to the person(s) responsible for creating the condition, and taking all appropriate action to ensure the condition is corrected.  The construction superintendent is also responsible to give notice to any design professional or special inspection agency with responsibility for the condition.
  2. The giving of notice to the Department of any conditions listed in Building Code § 3310.8.2.1.
  3. Immediately giving notice of any accidents or damage to adjoining property caused by construction or demolition activities at the job site.
  4. Designating a “competent person” to be present at the job site at all times active work is going on, to carry out the superintendent’s orders; identify unsanitary, hazardous or dangerous conditions; take prompt corrective measures to eliminate such conditions; immediately report to the superintendent accidents and damage to adjoining property; and effectively communicate workplace instructions and safety directions to all workers at the site.
  5. Keeping a log at each job site, each log to contain (at minimum) the date and time of the superintendent’s arrival at and departure from the site for the required visits; the general progress of work (and daily summary of work performed); the construction superin­tendent’s activities at the site, including areas and floors inspected; any unsafe conditions observed, and the date, time, and location the same were observed; orders given in respect of accidents, unsafe conditions, etc., with dates, times, responses, and follow-up actions, if any; violations, stop work orders, or summonses given by the Department; accidents; and the name and signature of any person acting as the “competent person” or successor competent person.

In part because of the complexity of OSHA construction standards, and the limited effectiveness of safety training of the rank-and-file, we have long advocated providing extensive safety training and substantial responsibility for OSHA compliance to superintendents and other field supervisors.  That approach is furthered by the increased responsibility for construction safety assigned to construction superintendents by Local Law 81.

The Expanding Use of “Virtual Reality” Technology in Construction Safety Training

As the cost of the applied technology drops, bringing it within reach of more potential users, “Virtual Reality” (VR) — a shockingly useful outgrowth of the video gaming industry — is finding an increasing range of uses in the construction industry.

VR employs hardware and software to create an artificial, computer-generated simulation (or re-creation) of a real environment.  Images and sound are used to make the user feel as if he were experiencing the simulated environment firsthand.  Ubiquitous in video games, VR has many other uses, one of them being in flight simulators, which exist both as recreational applications, and in advanced versions, used in training pilots.

A related technology is “Augmented Reality,” which adds a computer-generated overlay to something real.  One example is “historic street views,” where computer-generated simulations of how central London or Paris looked, or are thought to have looked, in times past have been created, based on available photographs, historical works and paintings.  These images are available for your smartphone as an “app,” and can be accessed via your phone’s camera, as you walk around the actual area, to see what it looked like long ago.

These technologies are not new, but are increasingly becoming affordable for a wide variety of purposes.  Novel items are coming to market all the time, including headsets with a dock for your smartphone, that can deliver VR or AR to any user within reach of a cellphone signal.

“Reality Technology” is already in widespread use in the construction industry.  As prices fall, it has the potential for enormous benefits in a wide, and expanding, range of construction-related applications.

VR technology is already at work in helping owners, design professionals, builders and other industry players address the perennial (and, often, costly) problems as arise on many projects when —as the work progresses, errors in design and execution become apparent — the technology enables clients, architects, and builders to don a head-mounted display to take a virtual tour of the structure, as first designed.  Then, as changes to the design are proposed, whether as matters of necessity, to address design deficiencies, imperfectly-coordinated drawings, etc., or as matters of choice, to accommodate client preferences, users can see what the structure, as modified, will look like, before any physical work to carry out the changes is performed.

This technology also permits project participants at diverse locations, anywhere in the world with landline or WIFI coverage, to view and discuss the evolving plans, as the same unfold.

Other uses for the technology involve the management of the jobsite, workforce, equipment, and receipt and storage of materials.  Similarly, it is simple to create an apparently life-size, visual depiction of the site (or set of depictions, as the software can be programmed to show what the site, or any part of it, looks like, or will look like, from any desired viewpoint.

As costs drop, and interfaces become easier to use, Augmented Reality technology (which allows the user to maintain full awareness of the “real world,” with additional information superimposed) may, within a few short years, transform drastically the way that construction workers perform their tasks.

While still in its initial stages, the use of this technology allows workers, wearing “smart helmets,” to receive, wherever they may be, safety and other information, as appropriate, in light of the specific tasks they are performing.  The technology can also be used to transmit visuals of project drawings for remote viewing.

The technology also allows for the immediate, and detailed, transmittal of information regarding the locations of other workers, vehicles or heavy equipment, emergent dangers, and the like.

One area of special promise for Reality Technology is in safety training for the construction workforce.

As we have said in this space before, while OSHA, and an increasing number of governmental authorities, prescribe employee training in safety and OSHA compliance, a range of factors limit worker comprehension of safety training, and the practical effectiveness of even well-designed safety programs to bring about habitual employee compliance with the full range of OSHA mandates.

Both studies and experience have shown that conventional safety training — even when done by OSHA, or by well-paid professional consultants — is of limited effectiveness in making the precepts understood, and even less effective in fostering conformity with OSHA’s rules.

Part of the problem is linguistic.  Most training materials are in English (or Spanish) but dozens of other languages are spoken by construction workers in the greater New York City area.

Another difficulty is that safety trainers are exceedingly enamored of acronyms, buzzwords, and technical terminology, that too often goes right over the heads of the intended audience.  We read of one study, in which the OSHA 10-hour course was but faintly understood by graduate students in engineering at Tulane University.  If graduate students don’t assimilate most of what’s in the 10-hour course, chances are your construction workforce won’t, either.

It’s not just a question of construction workers, or many of them, being not the most highly-educated demographic. It’s also that adult learning happens in several different ways.  Some people learn just fine by listening. Others do better by reading, by watching, or by doing.  While professionally-produced, site-specific “full bells and whistles” VT safety tutorials may still be too costly for many smaller companies, we expect that, within a few years, most mid-size and even smaller companies will be doing part of the production work for VT tutorials in-house, with safety consultants adding some higher-end enhancements at moderate cost.

Not long from now, the VR job walk/safety tutorial is likely to become a standard feature of most larger projects.  Such an “immersive” experience, as a complement or alternative to more traditional training modalities, will enhance the effectiveness of companies’ safety programs, providing safety instruction, more extensive and accessible site views (including views of how the site will appear as the work progresses) and allowing virtual access, and teleconferencing concerning site conditions, from multiple sites all over the world.

A further advantage is that the workers’ “smart helmets” can display images that walk employees through safe and OSHA-compliant ways to perform key construction tasks, as the same are being performed.  Unlike comprehensive safety manuals, VR “apps” for the “smart helmet” or smartphone can readily and inexpensively be updated, as regulations change, and new ones are enacted.

The cost of deploying VR technology for safety training, design changes, logistical and other uses will be offset, at least in part, by reduced travel, executive and employee down-time, and administrative costs and other savings.

And, as the expanded use of “Reality Technology” for safety-related purposes begins to have a positive impact on the number of significant jobsite injuries, reductions in lost profits associated with construction accidents will be a further offset.  These include not only obvious, direct costs (medical, hospital/rehab expenses, higher insurance and workers’ comp premiums) but the hidden costs, including such items as lost productivity in responding to and investigating accidents, the cost to train replacement workers, legal expenses, etc.

The use of Virtual Reality in construction may look like an expensive gimmick for the moment, but soon it will be indispensable.  It’s a tool to look at for purposes including your safety program.

Perils of the “Unpreventable Employee Misconduct” Defense

It’s best to resist the urge to take an OSHA citation personally.  Face it:  construction, especially medium- and large-scale commercial projects, is a complicated, and inherently-dangerous, affair.  It’s one of the most hazardous industries in America, and thus one rightly targeted by OSHA for energetic enforcement.  Most sites have six, or ten, or more trades working at any given time, and the cast of characters is usually fluid as the project moves along.  Some subcontractors, particularly smaller ones, and non-union outfits, may not have dedicated safety staff.  If you’re the general contractor, you’re responsible for the OSHA sins of all.  And, while many OSHA construction standards are fairly obvious matters of common sense, others are somewhat technical, and can be difficult to teach to employees.

In short, if construction is your business, unless you’re one of those fly-by-night outfits that works in the dead of night to avoid OSHA inspectors (and the immigration authorities) you’re likely to get inspected once in a while.  And, even if, overall, you strive to work by OSHA’s rules, a sharp-eyed Compliance Officer can usually find something to cite you for.

We have encountered some construction business owners, however, who see a citation alleging one or more OSHA violations as a stain on their personal integrity.  Their first impulse is to file a Notice of Contest, and fight every citation item to the very death.  Which, more often than not, is a mistake (we have addressed matters to consider in deciding whether to contest an OSHA in a prior article).

Another knee-jerk reaction we have encountered is that the business owner who sees himself as safety-conscious, and whose company has even a lukewarm safety program, assumes that the fault must lie with one or more errant employees, rather than with ownership.  Such an owner, if he has heard the term, “unpreventable employee misconduct defense,” may seize upon this, as a promising means to contest the citation.

Given the cost of preparing and trying the trial of a contest proceeding, we counsel caution before going down this path.

To be sure, OSHA does recognize a defense based on unpreventable employee misconduct.  If you have a pending citation, and after reading this article you think you may have a basis to assert this defense, by all means discuss it with your attorney.

Be aware, however, that since unpreventable employee misconduct is an “affirmative defense,” you will have the burden to plead and prove every one of its four elements, by a preponderance of the evidence.

Also, contrary to a misconception held by many, you will not sustain “unpreventable employee misconduct” just by showing that you have a safety program, provided training, and one or more employees broke company rules, resulting in the OSHA violation.

Alas, the requirements to establish “unpreventable employee misconduct” are stringent, and if this is “all you’ve got” by way of grounds to have your citation vacated, you are likely to be better off trying to negotiate on the monetary penalties (and, perhaps, the severity level of the citation item[s]), showing contrition for the violation, providing some extra training on the issues relevant to the citation, and moving on.

The exigencies of the defense are illustrated by Secretary v. Empire Roofing Company of Georgia, Inc.  In that case, the employer was charged with violations related to the fall-protection standards, detected when OSHA Compliance Officers, driving past a jobsite in Georgia, espied two foremen and two laborers working about 40 feet above grade on the roof of a hotel under construction. without any visible means of fall protection.

To make a bad situation worse, the workers, when ordered by the OSHA inspectors to come down off the roof, chose not to tie off while descending from the roof in an aerial lift, resulting in an additional citation item.

To digress, we can’t tell you how many OSHA cases we have seen in which employers were cited for fall-protection violations seen by OSHA inspectors from the street.  Not only are falls the #1 cause of construction fatalities (and OSHA citations) but they are singularly-obvious violations as well.  While of course there do exist some complex construction standards, nearly anyone can foresee the probable result of falling from a 40’ rooftop.  The fall-protection standard is one you should never tolerate being violated on your jobsites.

In Empire Roofing’s contest of the citation, the ALJ, based on OSH Review Commission precedent, rejected the employer’s argument that traveling in the lift, to and from the work location, did not constitute “working from an aerial lift” within the meaning of the regulation.  The ALJ rejected, also, the employer’s contention that the laborers (who testified that they had removed their harnesses on the roof only as their shift was about to end, about 15 minutes before the OSHA inspectors’ arrival) had been induced by the inspectors to descend, without tarrying to put their harnesses back on, and tie off to the lift.

The employer in Empire Roofing asserted, but failed to sustain, the “unpreventable employee misconduct” defense, which is recognized when “the actions of the employee were a departure from a uniformly and effectively communicated and enforced work rule.”

In order to successfully establish this defense, the respondent employer must show that it has (1) established work rules designed to prevent the violation; (2) adequately communicated those rules to its employees; (3) taken steps to discover violations; and (4) effectively enforced the rules, when violations have been discovered.  More rigorous proof is needed where, as in Empire Roofing, one or more supervisors were involved in the conduct constituting the violation(s).

The ALJ in Empire Roofing found that the employer had succeeded in showing three of the four elements of the defense.  First, it showed that it had rules addressing the need for fall protection while working at elevations above 6 feet, or in an aerial lift.  It established, too, that by various means (new hire training, a full-time safety manager, training in Spanish as well as English, toolbox talks, etc.) it strove to ensure that safety rules were communicated to its employees.

The third element — steps to detect violations of the employer’s safety rules — was also found to have been established.  The employer’s service manager visited the worksite at least three times a week, and an outside consultant made 10 random, unannounced inspections per month.

Despite all of the foregoing, the “unpreventable employee misconduct” defense failed, and the citations were upheld. The ALJ found that the defense was effectively negated by the participation in the misconduct of two foremen. In so doing, the ALJ cited Commission precedent for the proposition that “a supervisor’s breach of a company safety policy is strong evidence that implementation of the policy is lax.”

Although the employer’s “broad description of [its] enforcement efforts suggest[ed] a robust program,” the ALJ found, the heightened scrutiny required, due to the supervisors’ participation in the misconduct, uncovered failures and inconsistencies that the ALJ found negated the defense.  For example, the “job inspection check list” for the day of the inspection found that the foreman had checked “yes” for the use of a safety monitor, although the testimony was consistent that a personal fall arrest system was the form of fall protection used.

Another example was that one of the laborers was found to have signed a document indicating that he understood the hazards of chemicals being used on the Project.  This document, however, was in English, and the laborer who signed it did not know how to read English.  On the whole, the ALJ found the employer’s evidence of effective enforcement “unconvincing.”

Thus, if “unpreventable employee misconduct” is the linchpin of your defense to an OSHA citation, you and your attorney should scrutinize it closely, before going forward with a contest proceeding, because the ALJ certainly will, and good intentions and desultory efforts will not sustain it.

ALJ Upholds Citation Based on Bridge Collapse Under 45-Ton CAT Excavator

Let’s cut right to the moral of the following story:  if you’re doing a partial demolition of a 100-year-old bridge, and the work involves cutting work beneath the bridge deck, it’s important to have a qualified engineer perform an analysis, before parking a 45-ton-excavator on the deck (above where the supports have been weakened).  Should you fail to do this, you may find that the structure retains too little strength to bear the weight of the equipment.

In Secretary v. Francis J. Palo, Inc., the employer, Palo, was the general contractor on a Pennsylvania DOT contract for a demolition and construction project on a state road n Elk County, Pennsylvania.  A segment of the project, a bridge over a creek, partially collapsed beneath the weight of a 45-ton CAT excavator that the contractor had parked on the bridge’s closed, northbound lane that was being demolished.

The span in question had been built in 1912, and PennDOT had cautioned bidders on the project that no design drawings for it were available.  The bridge had one traffic lane, plus a sidewalk, running in each direction.  Beams spanning the bridge in the north-south direction were fixed into abutments at each end.  Just above the abutments at each end, the beams were interconnected through a diaphragm.

The beams were cast-in-place concrete, in the shape of an arch, with the center of each beam about two to three feet shallower than the ends.  The bridge was identifiable on sight as a “cast-in-place, rigid, fixed beam, arch bridge.”  The bridge’s greatest strength was at the ends of the beams, not at the center of the span.

The employer’s demolition plan, accepted by PennDOT, called for the bridge to be demolished and rebuilt in phases.  Demolition was to be carried out by cutting the concrete away from the supporting abutments on both sides.  A longitudinal cut was made down the center of the bridge roadway deck, separating the north side from the south side.  This allowed the southbound traffic lane to remain open, during the partial demolition and reconstruction of the bridge’s north side.

Following the initial cut, workers focused on demolishing the north side of the bridge, by cutting the supporting abutments at each end.

This cutting work was done by a subcontractor, and Penn
DOT had an employee onsite, and engaged an engineering firm to inspect the worksite.  However, as the general contractor, the employer was responsible for worksite safety.

It could be argued that PennDOT was somewhat at fault, as it did not assign the bridge a specific weight limit before the project began, and nothing in its documentation specified whether the bridge could withstand having a piece of mechanical equipment, weighing some 45 tons, being used or parked on it, particularly after the cutting work began.

However, PennDOT did specifically caution bidders to verify the information it provided, and the OSHA standard under which the employer was cited effectively assumes a hazard, as it prohibits the use of mechanical equipment, without first ensuring that the working surface has sufficient strength to support the imposed load.

While the cutting work beneath the bridge deck was ongoing, the CAT was brought onto the bridge, and was used on that day, and the next following day, to remove rubble created by the demolition process.  On the third day, the CAT was parked on the closed northbound traffic lane.  The cutting subcontractor had already made several cuts to the supporting abutments located beneath the bridge deck.  One of the abutments had been vertically cut, and the subcontractor was making vertical cuts to the second abutment in the north lane.

Suddenly, the employer’s super noticed that the deck on the north side of the bridge was lower than it had been, and tried to order everyone off the bridge.  Unfortunately, this condition was detected too late, and the north side of the bridge collapsed into the creek, injuring four workers.

The employer contested the citation, conceding, however, the elements of applicability of the standard, violation of its terms, and employee exposure).  The sole basis for the contest was that the employer denied actual or constructive knowledge of the hazard.

OSHA’s expert engineer testified at the trial that, as an experienced demolition contractor, Palo should have recognized from the start the character of the bridge as a cast-in-place, arched, rigid frame beam bridge.  Because of its design – the beam ends being deeper, and supported by the diaphragm and abutment – when a load was imposed on the bridge, its path went to the end of the beam, where the strength was.

As OSHA’s expert testified, the horizontal and vertical cutting work at the bridge’s supporting ends — affecting the abutments, diaphragm, and beams — had the effect of changing the bridge’s structure to that of a simple span bridge.  This change compromised the bridge’s load-carrying capacity.  Unlike a fixed rigid frame bridge, a simple span has a hinged connection at each end, for a fixed connection.  As such, a bridge functioning as a single span bridge does not continue to distribute loads onto the abutments.  Thus, its ability to support its own weight and that of a superimposed load having been undermined by the contractor’s having severed the bridge’s support mechanisms (abutment, diaphragm, and beam) from one another, the bridge collapsed beneath the weight of the excavator.

As underscored in the Administrative Law Judge’s decision affirming the OSHA citation and penalty, the employer called no expert witnesses to rebut OSHA’s engineer.  It had to admit it had taken no specific actions to ascertain whether the bridge would be able to continue to support the excavator’s weight after it was cut multiple times, including through both supporting abutments.

Palo made what the ALJ found to be an insufficient attempt to establish due diligence, by arguing that it had reviewed information PennDOT provided as part of the bidding process, “inspected” the bridge, worked according to a demolition plan, and was an experienced contractor.

The employer’s review of information from PennDOT was insufficient, as there was nothing in that information that specified that the bridge could withstand having a 45-ton piece of equipment being used or parked on it.  Palo’s “inspection,” the ALJ found, did not include an engineering analysis prepared by an engineer, nor did any other documentation provide any analysis supporting the conclusion that the bridge would withstand the CAT’s eight, once the abutments had been cut.

The mere fact of proceeding according to a demolition plan, the ALJ found, did not suffice to establish due diligence.  Palo’s demolition plan did not discuss using the CAT on the bridge deck at any time, much less after multiple cuts had been made to both abutments.  Palo did not request any inspection reports, or other information from PennDOT, to ascertain the bridge’s structure and strength, or obtain an engineering survey on its own.

All in all, the ALJ found, the record lacked evidence from which it might be concluded that anyone else involved with the project agreed with Palo’s assertion that it performed reasonable diligence, or agreed it was reasonable to move and leave the CAT on the bridge, after the cutting began.

The notion that Palo’s “experience” established due diligence was rejected by the ALJ, as most of that experience was with bridges with a different design than the one that collapsed, and the employer’s decision-makers, none of whom were professional engineers, took no specific action to verify that the bridge would be able to support the CAT’s weight after both supporting abutments had been cut.

If you are in the business of demolishing and reconstructing bridges, it should be obvious that a formal engineering evaluation of your demolition plan should be done by a qualified professional engineer, before any demolition gets underway.  As even many “civilians” are aware, thousands of bridges in the USA remain in use, decades beyond their life expectancy.  The need for engineering advice is even more pronounced when the project calls for work on a bridge of an older, uncommon, or unfamiliar design, or where it will involve equipment much larger than any in use when the bridge was first constructed.

Communication and Coordination to Ensure Safety on Multi-Employer Jobsites

The construction industry is unique, in that — leaving aside very small projects, and some limited to upgrading one or two building systems — on most jobs, there are at least a dozen, and at times literally scores of trades, often with large regional firms working shoulder-to-shoulder with tiny “mom and pop” subcontractors, the trades frequently having wildly disparate modes of organization and management styles.

The responsibility to ensure employee safety and health is shared among the owner, the general contractor, and every employer whose employees may be exposed to unsafe conditions at the site, or who has the responsibility and authority to prevent, detect, or correct hazardous conditions.

Not only do employers on a construction site often have varying management styles, but their employees may speak an array of languages, and trades may vary greatly in the diligence and resources devoted to their health and safety programs.

Since, typically, the general contractor is formally in charge of the jobsite, if you are a general contractor, you may be in the unenviable position of having to keep a large number of employees, employed by a large number of trades, on the “straight and narrow,” in terms of safe work practices and OSHA (and state law) compliance.

Conversely, subs cannot abdicate responsibility for the safety of their employees to the general contractor, and they remain responsible for violative conditions (1) created by their own employees, and (2) to which their employees are exposed.  This remains so even where a subcontractor has but a handful of employees, and little “clout” in determining how the project is managed.  If the general contractor is lukewarm in its approach to employee safety, at times the small subcontractor, as a practical matter, will be hard-pressed to do more than to surveil the safety and OSHA compliance of its own workforce.

Another factor complicating the maintenance of high standards is the proliferation of staffing agencies supplying workers to the construction industry.  These firms vary in how much safety training they provide, and even the better-trained workers seldom have the close relationships with company safety managers and other supervisors that foster the faithful observance of safety rules.

Communication and coordination are the key elements in ensuring effective safety practices on the multi-employer jobsite.  Communication, among other things, entails study and identification — before the physical work of the project begins — of the principal hazards likely to be encountered over the life of the project, and the planning of measures to avoid or control them.  It is important, also, as subcontractors (and, if applicable, staffing agencies) are added to the project, to identify and to have e-mail addresses and cell phone numbers for safety managers or key supervisory personnel from each employer.  This is important, not only for the general exchange of safety-related information, but for reporting hazardous conditions, reporting incidents, and consulting when decisions affecting safety issues must be made quickly.

It is also indispensable to know the location and alternate routes to the nearest emergency room or acute care clinic, and the means to summon first responders.  Since non-supervisory employees are commonly prohibited from carrying cell phones while working, make sure that procedures are in place to summon emergency personnel, without delay, in case of need.  The means should also be at hand to contact the general contractor, owner, and OSHA to get information, report an injury, illness, or incident, or if a safety concern arises.

Usually, the general contractor has the leading role in devising, implementing, and maintaining the project’s health and safety program.  These responsibilities may be spelled out in contract documents, and are usually addressed in pre-construction meetings.  The general contractor typically sets up procedures, whereby it gathers and communicates information needed by each employer to assess and address hazards, while the subcontractors furnish information concerning injuries, illnesses, hazards or concerns reported by their respective employees (or discovered during inspections, inquiries or analyses performed by them).

Where unanticipated operations must be carried out, due to such things as defects discovered in installations, weather events, or natural disasters, it is usually the general contractor (often in collaboration with the project architects or engineers) who collects the relevant information, conducts any necessary analysis, and communicates to all interested parties what must be done to respond to the situation.

Since the complement of trades working on the project usually changes as the work progresses, membership in the “safety committee” will change correspondingly, and it will become necessary to assess from time to time (particularly as major milestones are reached) what work has been completed, what hazards are currently extant at the site, and what counter-measures are indicated, to avoid or neutralize them.

Communication includes, among other things, evaluating and resolving any potential conflicts before work starts.  It is desirable that all subcontracts include express provisions requiring compliance with OSHA and all other safety laws and regulations, and cooperation with the general contractor and other subcontractors in matters affecting employee health and safety.  Pre-construction meetings are additional propitious occasions to clarify key safety issues, measures indicated to combat hazards already identified, and lines of authority and communication regarding safety matters.

Another key element of “coordination” is that careful planning will often enable you to sequence or locate tasks, e.g., to reduce the numbers of employees, not needed to carry out the task in question, who will need to be working in proximity to a given hazard.  You may also be able to isolate work that produces hazardous chemicals or vapors, respirable silicate, or other harmful substances, thereby limiting employee exposure.

Another thing the general contractor can do before the work is underway is to coordinate with the subcontractors, to ensure that all needed safety equipment will be onsite as needed, and that appropriate employee training (which, increasingly, is required by law) has been completed.  Responsibility for “toolbox talks” and other training, as the project goes forward, should also be planned.

One of the most important aspects of coordination is discussion, especially among the primary trades, and firm leadership, to ensure that safety practices, especially regarding hazards that are perennially leading causes of fatalities and serious injuries (and those most frequently cited by OSHA) are uniform, and at the highest and best levels.  Nothing undermines employees’ belief in the sincerity of management’s commitment to safety than seeing such things as supervisors looking the other way while employees work on elevated surfaces without fall protection, or do down into unshored trenches.

Finally, while strictly speaking it’s not part of health and safety practices per se, it’s an excellent idea for the general contractor to do whatever is necessary to ensure first, that its subcontracts all require the subcontractors to name the general contractor as an additional insured on its contracts of liability insurance, and, second, to verify that its own mutual insurance obligations, vis-à-vis the owner and any subcontractors, have all been complied with.  The better practice is to obtain not just insurance certificates, but copies of the actual policies.

Since worker safety involves all participants in a construction project, getting it done right generally requires a difficult-to-achieve mix of patience, firmness and tact.  Coordinating safety efforts among so many parties can be challenging, but most construction companies are increasingly aware of the need for it, since, after all, it’s a life-or-death task not only for your employees, but for your business as well.

Don’t Overlook Hand Safety in Construction

Avoiding hand injuries is a too-often-overlooked aspect of construction safety.  On most jobsites, it’s common to see construction workers working barehanded, at least for a part of their workday.  (Our research yielded up one estimate that 80% do so.)  Lacerations and puncture wounds, more than half of which are believed to be avoidable just by wearing gloves, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics cost the industry upwards of $400 million per year.  (That figure includes medical costs, 4-5 days lost time per incident, downtime, cleanup, and legal costs).

Other types of hand injuries sustained in construction include cutting or crushing injuries resulting in amputations, abrasions, the breaking of fingers or other bones in the hand, chemical burns or dermatitis resulting from contact with certain chemicals, thermal burns, electrical burns, and the absorption through the skin of hazardous substances.  And don’t forget frostbite and bites (insects, spiders, snakes, and animals) as additional dangers.

According to the CDC, work-related hand injuries result in more than 1 million emergency room visits annually (which figure includes “general industry” employees, not just construction workers).  The number of “days away from work” incidents associated with hand injuries is second only to back strains and sprains.

The first line of defense against hand injuries is wearing high-quality, undamaged, properly-chosen work gloves.  To effect a reduction of up to 60% in hand injuries, the gloves must fit properly, and they must actually be worn. Gloves must be inspected regularly, discarded if damaged, and replaced periodically.  (Electrical and chemical protective gloves, in particular, have limited life spans).

In 1994, OSHA amended its PPE standards, by adding 29 C.F.R. § 1910.136.  The impetus for the amendment was a finding that 70% of construction workers suffering hand injuries were not wearing gloves at all, and that nearly all of the remaining 30% were wearing gloves that were inadequate, damaged, or unsuited to the relevant hazard(s).

OSHA’s hand-protection standard requires employers to “select and require employees to use appropriate hand protection when employees’ hands are exposed” to a variety of hazards, and places the burden on employers to “base the selection of the appropriate hand protection on an evaluation of the performance characteristics of the hand protection relative to the task(s) to be performed, conditions present, duration of use, and the hazards and potential hazards identified.”

The challenge, obviously, is identifying hand protection that affords adequate protection against hazards likely to be encountered in your trade, without unnecessarily impeding the employees wearing them in carrying out their tasks.  While OSHA assigns to the employer primary responsibility to make the risk assessment, and the selection of appropriate PPE, employees should be asked to help compile a list of tasks they perform, and the kinds of hand injuries (cuts, puncture wounds, crushing injuries, chemical burns, thermal burns, etc.) that could result.

Among the many types of safety gloves available are the following:

  • Leather gloves (protect against rough surfaces);
  • Insulated gloves (protection from hot objects or surfaces);
  • Cut-resistant gloves;
  • Anti-vibration gloves (protect against excessive vibration of hand-tools and machinery);
  • Disposable gloves (typically, latex, or nitrile for the 10% of the population that is sensitive to latex) (blood and other biocontaminants);
  • Kevlar gloves and stainless-steel mesh gloves (protect against cuts, slashes, and abrasions);
  • Certified linesman’s gloves (it’s critical to inspect these before use, as they must be electrically tested every 6 months, and even a pinhole leak can cause death);
  • Chemical-resistant gloves (these come in diverse types, and must be matched to the specific chemicals or classes of chemicals [corrosives, solvents, pesticides, etc.] to which the wearer is likely to be exposed).

“Chemical-resistant” gloves are not totally and permanently chemical-proof.  Different glove materials offer protection against particular types of chemicals, and, over time, the material will deteriorate, allowing chemicals to penetrate the glove.  Employees need to ascertain what chemicals they can expect to be handling, and that the gloves being used are made from materials that will protect them.

Fortunately, the industry has made significant advances in recent years in improving both materials and design utilized in protective gloves.  Today’s work gloves are superior (in terms of dexterity and touch sensitivity, as well as strength of materials) to the clumsy work gloves of yore.  Thanks, also, to the internet, and the increased attention given to hand injuries since the 1990s, there now exist more knowledgeable, specialized vendors, and it has become easier to find help and advice in fulfilling the employer’s responsibility to assess the risks, and select suitable PPE.

Of course, while gloves are the chief component of a successful hand safety program, lacerations, broken bones, and amputations are not fully guarded against, even by the improved PPE now available.

Other safety measures that should be included in a hand safety program include, but are not limited to, training employees in the safe operation of machinery, hand tools, and power tools.  It’s especially important to train employees, and to have (and enforce) work rules, on the subject of machine guards —i.e., that they must never be disabled, bypassed, or removed.  Nail guns are another notorious culprit in hand injuries, and training in their safe use is also recommended.

Another thing you can do to reduce the incidence of hand injuries is to require your field employees to wear glove clips.  Especially since a great majority of construction workers who wear gloves remove them to perform certain tasks, the gloves are at risk of being forgotten, or left aside, once removed.  A glove clip attaches to a belt loop, harness, or belt, and workers, upon removing their gloves, should be required to put them on the glove clip.  In that way, the gloves are kept close at hand (pun intended) and can be put back on, once a task requiring a high degree of dexterity, or the removal of gloves for any other reason, has been completed.  One study showed that this simple and inexpensive measure can reduce hand injuries by as much as 85%.   We did a quick online search, which showed glove clips available at prices between about $5 and $13 each, or as low as $2.80 apiece if purchased in bulk.  They’re a good investment, and if you’re not already requiring your workers to wear them, you should give serious consideration to doing so.

Yet another thing you can do to reduce the risk of hand injuries is to train your employees to report perceived dangers to hands, especially defective, damaged, or otherwise unsafe equipment and tools.  Work station housekeeping is another important item in any hand safety program.  Sharp items must be disposed or stored, and chemical spills cleaned up thoroughly and promptly.

As with other varieties of injuries, the prevention of hand injuries is largely a matter of leadership and common sense.  If you are fortunate enough to head up a construction company, you owe it to your employees — and to your bottom line — to provide the right PPE and training, and to promulgate and enforce appropriate work rules.  Everyone in your company must be accountable, since the machinery, chemicals, electrical current, etc. on the jobsite are indifferent to worker safety, and will inflict injuries if you fail.

Responsibility for OSHA Violations on a Multi-Employer Jobsite

The work done on nearly every construction jobsite is done by the employees of multiple employers.  At any given time, depending on the complexity and the size of the project, there may be dozens of different trades at work on the jobsite.  When an OSHA inspection occurs, and violations are found, which employer (or employers) will receive citations?

Under OSHA policy, the general contractor, as well as each subcontractor or other employer of workers present on the jobsite, may play one or more of several roles, any one of which may subject it to being cited for OSHA violations.  These roles are referred to as the “creating,” “exposing,” “correcting,” and “controlling” employer.

As the name implies, a “creating” employer is one who causes a condition that violates an applicable OSHA standard.  Since, unsurprisingly, it is forbidden to create hazards that violate OSHA standards, any employer that does so will be cited, even if none of its own employees are exposed to the violative condition, and even if the extent of the employer’s overall control of the project is slight.  (Naturally, it remains a requirement that someone’s employees be exposed to the hazard, although it need not be the “creating employer’s” employees).

Also subject to being cited for any OSHA violation is an “exposing employer,” which is to say every employer whose employees were exposed to the condition that violated an OSHA standard.  An “exposing employer” is liable as such, even if its employees created the hazard, but if the exposing employer was not also the creating employer, it must be shown that it had actual or constructive knowledge of the hazard, and failed to take steps to protect its employees.

Actual or constructive knowledge on the part of the cited employer is an indispensable element of every OSHA violation.  “Constructive” knowledge means that the employer ought to have known of the violation, in the exercise of reasonable diligence.

An “exposing” employer, if lacking authority to correct a given hazard, has a duty to ask the “creating” or “controlling” employer to do so.  It must also inform its employees of the hazard, take reasonable alternative protective measures, and remove its employees, if the hazard presents an imminent danger.

The “controlling” employer — most often, the general contractor or construction manager — is the employer having general supervisory authority over the jobsite, and the power (whether by contract, or in practice) to correct safety hazards, or require others to do so.  Note that project architects and engineers are sometimes deemed to be “controlling employers.”  A “controlling employer” must take reasonable care in preventing and detecting OSHA violations.

Although the Evergreen Construction case, discussed below, calls into question the extent of the controlling employer’s responsibilities in inspecting the jobsite to discover hazards created by others, traditionally the level of care required of a general contractor, in safeguarding the trades’ employees, is lower than is mandated in looking out for its own employees.

However, among the factors in determining how frequently a “controlling employer” must inspect the site, to detect hazards created by others, is what the controlling employer knows about the safety and health efforts of the subcontractors.  “Reasonable diligence” on the part of the controlling employer requires fewer inspections, where the subs are known to be conscientious with respect to safety, and more frequent ones, where there are subcontractors known to have been non-compliant, or about which little is known.

Finally, a “correcting employer” may be cited for an OSHA violation.  Such an employer must be engaged in a common  undertaking, at the same worksite as the exposing employer, and responsible for correcting a hazard.  It must exercise reasonable care in preventing and discovering violations, and diligence in meeting its obligation to correct hazards.

Naturally, a particular employer may simultaneously exercise more than one of the roles of creating, exposing, controlling, and correcting employer.

The recent decision by the OSH Review Commission in Secretary v. Evergreen Construction Company calls into question just how much diligence is required of a general contractor, or other “controlling employer,” in discovering and remedying violations by project subcontractors.

The facts in Evergeen Construction were straightforward.  Evergreen was general contractor on a hotel construction project in Atlanta.  This project was for the construction of a six-story building on 3 acres of land, with up to 20 subcontractors working onsite at any given time.

The masonry subcontractor, Nuñez, was cited for a fall-protection violation, with the OSHA compliance officer arriving onsite for his inspection one morning at about 10:00 A.M.  Nuñez’s employees were building walls close to the unprotected edge of the building’s fourth floor, without exterior walls, guardrails, or safety nets to protect against falls.  The employees were not wearing harnesses or lanyards, and, at the time of the inspection, no anchorage points to affix lanyards had been installed.

In addition to citing Nuñez as the “creating” and “exposing” employer, OSHA cited Evergreen as the “controlling” employer.

The facts established at trial showed, on the one hand, that overall Evergreen appeared to be highly conscientious, its supervisor and safety manager walking the site up to four times daily to check on the progress of the work, look for safety issues, and point out to subcontractors any safety violations he observed.

However, Evergreen’s supervisor had repeatedly observed Nuñez employees working without fall protection.  Indeed, on the day prior to the inspection, the supervisor had inspected the jobsite twice, and saw Nuñez’s employees working without fall protection both times.  On both occasions, he had admonished them to use fall protection.  From 7:00 A.M. the following morning until the compliance officer’s arrival at about 10:00 A.M., the supervisor had been in meetings in the jobsite trailer, and did not inspect the worksite before OSHA arrived, and found Nuñez’s employees once again working without fall protection.

The ALJ affirmed the violation as against the general contractor on two grounds, finding (1) that reasonable diligence required Evergreen to inspect Nuñez’s work during the period of 1-3 hours on the morning of the OSHA inspection (wherefore, it would be deemed to have had constructive knowledge of the violation); and (2) that Evergreen’s program was deemed inadequate, with regard to enforcing Nuñez’s compliance with OSHA requirements.

On review by the Commission, Commissioner MacDougall expressly, and Commissioner Attwood tacitly, disapproved the ALJ’s view that Evergreen’s enforcement program was insufficient.  Commissioner MacDougall, moreover, stressing Commission precedent that the controlling employer does not need to inspect as frequently as an exposing employer, found that requiring Evergreen to inspect the jobsite before work even began on the morning of the inspection would raise the standard for “reasonable diligence” to an unreasonable level.  As one subject of Evergreen’s meeting on the morning of the inspection was again to remind Nuñez of its OSHA obligations, Commissioner MacDougall found that Evergreen had informed Nuñez of those obligations three times in the 24-hour period preceding the inspection, and that requiring more would be to effectively punish Evergreen for its laudably attentive past efforts, while disregarding the obligations and constraints placed on a controlling employer’s onsite supervisor on a large, active jobsite.

Disagreeing, Commissioner Attwood opined that Evergreen’s superintendent’s knowledge that Nuñez had violated the fall protection standard twice on the day before the inspection required it to exercise reasonable diligence to prevent the same violation from occurring prior to OSHA’s inspection of the worksite on the following day.

In light of the impasse between the two participating commissioners, they determined to vacate the Commission’s direction for review, allowing the employer the choice to appeal the ALJ’s decision to an appropriate U.S. Court of Appeals.

Carbon Monoxide Poisoning as a Construction Hazard

Most people are aware that carbon monoxide (CO) gas is a colorless gas with no taste or smell, and, when inhaled, inhibits the blood in bringing oxygen to cells, tissues and organs.  We have all heard accounts of people being overcome and dying from carbon monoxide poisoning, and many of us have carbon monoxide detectors or alarm systems in our homes.

Carbon monoxide is a common hazard, resulting from the incomplete combustion of natural gas and any other material containing carbon, such as gasoline, kerosene, oil, propane, coal, or wood.  CO exposure at high levels can result in death, or permanent organic injury, in a matter of minutes.  Since construction operations often involve gasoline-powered or other fuel-burning equipment, and work indoors (or in poorly-ventilated outdoor spaces) it’s a construction hazard, with welders and forklift operators at particularly high risk.

Situations in which carbon monoxide can pose a serious hazard in construction include the use of equipment powered by gasoline or by liquefied petroleum gas (propane and/or butane), such as generators or cut-off saws, in enclosed spaces — indoors, certainly, but also in trenches, or outdoor spaces where plastic sheeting is in place to protect against dust, rain, etc.  CO tends to build up in pockets in poorly-ventilated areas.

CO gas may be a hazard, also, where building renovations disturb gas flues or ventilation systems, or where gas-powered stoves, fireplaces or other appliances are incorrectly installed.

All fuel-burning equipment emits some quantity of carbon monoxide.  This includes car, truck and forklift engines, gasoline-powered power washers, construction equipment powered by gasoline or propane, and non-electric heaters.  Any fuel-burning equipment to be used indoors, or in semi-enclosed outdoor spaces, must be maintained and tuned regularly, as a poorly-tuned gasoline engine can produce up to 12 times as much CO as a well-tuned one.  (Water heaters, space heaters, and cooking ranges that produce CO should also be maintained in good working order, to reduce CO formation.)

Indications that incomplete combustion is occurring, and that CO may be produced, include yellow or orange rather than blue flames, soot or yellow/brown staining around or on appliances, pilot lights that frequently blow out, and increased condensation inside windows.

Keeping gasoline-powered equipment well-tuned, however, is not sufficient, where such equipment is to be used indoors, or in confined or semi-enclosed spaces (such as a garage, crawl space, or basement).  Generators should never be operated indoors — and, when operated outdoors, they should be kept away from doors, windows or vents, which could allow CO to enter the structure, and build up in occupied spaces.  The generator should also be placed with at least 3 to 4 feet on all sides and above it, to ensure adequate ventilation.

Optimally, fuel-burning equipment producing more CO than, say, a gas range should not be used at all in indoor or partially-enclosed spaces.  Where it is necessary to operate such equipment in such spaces, however, all areas where fuel-burning equipment is to be used must be ventilated by mechanical means to the outside air.

 Air-monitoring devices with audible alarms should be deployed wherever practicable.  OSHA’s PEL (averaged over 8 hours) for CO is 50 ppm; a maritime standard (not applicable to the construction industry) requires that employees be removed from the premises, if CO levels reach 100 ppm.  Other agencies recommend that long-term exposure not exceed 35 parts per million, and that the alarms should be set at a lower value.  (The maximum short-term exposure value for CO is 400 ppm; 1500 ppm is “immediately dangerous to life and health”).  OSHA prescribes that tests for CO concentrations are to be made by designated persons, using gas detector tube units (e.g., Drager, Gastec) certified by NIOSH under 30 CFR Part 11, or other instruments, whose accuracy is as great or greater.

Respirators with appropriate canisters may be used for short periods under certain circumstances, where CO levels are not exceedingly high.  More heavy-duty equipment, such as a full-facepiece, pressure-demand self-contained breathing apparatus, certified by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, is indicated, where work must be performed (or rescue operations carried out) where CO concentrations in the “immediately dangerous to life and health” range are suspected.

During the planning stage, in advance of building renovations, the impact of the work on existing gas-fired systems should be carefully evaluated.  Also, future maintenance access to flue systems concealed within voids should be provided for, and properly documented.

It’s a good idea, also, to use electrical appliances in lieu of gasoline or propane-powered ones, or to locate generators, etc. outside, and in well-ventilated spaces.

As always, equipment maintenance and employee training are essential.  In addition to knowing how to implement the controls properly, employees should be taught that drowsiness, faintness, headache, breathlessness, nausea and an irregular heartbeat are early signs of CO poisoning, and that these symptoms may be confused with food poisoning, the flu or other viral infections, or fatigue.

If not properly trained concerning the dangers of carbon monoxide, workers experiencing these early signs may not know that they need to move away from the source of the CO gas, alert others, and seek immediate medical attention.  It is critical that employees be trained that they must never ignore symptoms that may be the result of carbon monoxide poisoning.  Workers should be trained, also, to alert supervisory personnel to any situation that might cause CO to accumulate.

 Workers responding to an emergency situation where CO may be present may themselves be exposed to potentially-fatal levels of CO gas, and all employees should be warned accordingly as part of their training.  Obviously, it is best if rescuers are skilled in in carrying out such operations, and in the use of recovery equipment.  They should use supplied-air or self-contained respirators in entering any area where concentrations of CO may be present.

The victim should be moved at once to an open area, and “911” or other emergency responders summoned.  If the victim is breathing, 100% oxygen should be administered, using a tight-fitting facial mask.  If the victim has stopped breathing, CPR should be administered by a trained individual.  Appropriate respirators, supplies of oxygen, etc. must be kept on hand, if your employees work in proximity to fuel-burning engines or equipment, whether the same is in use by your employees, or by other trades.

Finally, the design, installation, maintenance, alteration and inspection of fuel gas piping and equipment is governed by a variety of state and local codes.  To ensure safety, it is critical that all such work be performed in strict conformity with all applicable codes, and by persons holding appropriate licenses or permits, as may be required by state or local law.

Carbon monoxide is a formidable danger.  Because it is detectable only with special equipment, can cause serious injury or death within minutes, and can accumulate from something as easily done as the improper placement of a generator too close to windows and vents, it must be guarded against assiduously.

Don’t Neglect “Lockout/Tagout” Safety Precautions

“Lockout/Tagout” refers to procedures to protect employees from injury or death resulting from the unexpected startup of equipment or machinery, or an uncontrolled release of energy, during the performance of installation, maintenance, service or repair tasks.

“Lockout/tagout” requires, among other things, that a designated individual turn off and disconnect the machinery or equipment from its energy source(s) before performing service or maintenance, and that he either lock or tag the energy-isolating device(s), and verify that the energy has been effectively isolated.

In addition, if the potential exists for the release of hazardous stored energy (or the re-accumulation of stored energy to a hazardous level) appropriate protective measures must be taken.

Lockout devices hold energy-isolation devices in the “off” position.  They employ physical restraints, that cannot be removed without a key or other unlocking mechanism (or a bolt cutter) to prevent the machine or equipment to which they are affixed from becoming energized. Tagout devices, which provide less protection, and are therefore approved only where locking out is not an option, are prominent warning devices, cautioning employees not to re-energize the machine during service or maintenance operations.

While OSHA’s primary lockout/tagout standard, CFR 1910.147, is a general industry standard, not applicable to the construction industry, if your employees service or maintain machines or equipment, and the unexpected startup, energization of the machinery, or the release of stored energy might cause injury, lockout/tagout probably applies to you during set-up activities and the servicing and maintenance of equipment, whenever the unexpected startup of the equipment, or the release of stored energy, could occur.

Lockout/tagout most often comes into play in construction with respect to electrical circuits, and concrete and masonry construction.  Electrical controls to be deactivated during work on energized or deenergized equipment or circuits must be tagged.  For concrete and masonry, maintenance or repair activities must be prohibited, where the inadvertent startup of the equipment could occur and cause injury, unless and until all energy sources have been locked out and tagged.

Generally, lockout/tagout does not apply to portable hand tools, and other cord-and-plug connected machinery and equipment, where electricity is the only form of hazardous energy to which employees might be exposed, and the user can control exposure by simply disconnecting the device from the outlet.

The failure to implement and to observe lockout/tagout protocols is one of the most-cited OSHA violations in general industry, and a significant cause of injury and death in construction.  One study based on OSHA accident investigation reports from 1984-97 found that lockout procedures were not even attempted in more than half of the cases investigated.

You need to have (and train your employees concerning) a written energy control and lockout/tagout protocol.  It must include steps to shut down, isolate, block, and secure machines; designate the safe placement, removal, and transfer of lockout/tagout devices, and provide for testing, to verify the effectiveness of lockout/tagout devices, and other energy-control measures.  You should use lockout devices for equipment that can be locked out, and ensure that new or overhauled equipment is capable of being locked out.

You should employ tagout devices and procedures only where the equipment in question cannot be locked out.  Lockout/tagout devices used must be durable, standardized, and substantial.  The devices used should identify the individual users, and, generally, only the employee applying a lockout/tagout device should be permitted to remove it.

OSHA has additional energy control provisions, to be observed when machines or equipment must be tested or repositioned, when outside contractors are at work onsite, in group lockout situations, and during shift or personnel changes.

Among the measures recommended to employers by NIOSH are the following:

  • Make sure there is a written protocol in place, employee training, and inspections, before any maintenance or service work is performed.
  • Make sure all employees know when the lockout/tagout procedures apply, and are trained in how to carry them out.
  • Procedures developed should be specific to each machine.
  • Workers must have available an adequate number of lockouts and tagouts, and other hardware, as may be required.
  • Isolation devices (breaker panels, control valves, etc.) must be clearly labeled.
  • After lockout/tagout devices are removed, but before circuits are re-energized, or equipment re-started, make sure that all employees who work with them (or nearby) know that the devices have been taken off, and that that power has been restored.
  • Strictly forbid anyone under age 18 from working on machinery deemed hazardous in the Child Labor rules (29 C.F.R. 570.120).

Workers must be conscientiously trained to do all of the following:

  • Before beginning machine adjustment, maintenance or servicing, de-energize all sources of hazardous energy, by disconnecting or shutting down engines or motors, de-energizing electrical circuits, cutting off liquid or gas flow in hydraulic or pneumatic systems, and blocking machine parts against motion.
  • Lockout and tagout all forms of hazardous energy, including electrical breaker panels and control valves.
  • Block or dissipate stored energy, by discharging capacitors, releasing or blocking springs under compression or tension, and venting fluids from pressure vessels, tanks, or accumulators.  Exception:  toxic, flammable, or explosive substances must never the vented directly into the atmosphere.
  • Verify that all energy sources have been de-energized.
  • Make sure that only one key exists for each individual’s assigned locks, and that only the worker in question holds the key (master keys must be kept under supervisory control and used rarely, as when the worker assigned to the locks is absent, or unavailable).
  • Inspect repair work, before removing locks and activating the equipment.
  • Make sure that all workers are clear of danger points, before re-energizing the system.

Naturally, employee training is an indispensable part of lockout/tagout compliance, and the employer must:

  • Establish procedures to interrupt the supply of energy to machines, and to put appropriate lockout or tagout devices on the energy-isolating devices, to prevent unexpected re-energization.
  • Where applicable, address stored or potentially re-accumulated energy.
  • Train employees in the correct application, use, and removal of energy controls; and
  • Review procedures at least annually, to ensure that employees are following them, and that the procedures remain effective.