Question.
Prior to closing on their home, the Purchasers hired an Engineer who
performed an inspection of the house. The inspection revealed the
presence of termites in the crawl space in front of the house. In his
inspection report, the Engineer noted, in addition to the termite
condition, among other things, the boiler was in “good shape, showing no
sign of leaking activity.”
In accordance with certain provisions in the
Rider attached to the Contract of Sale, upon being advised of the
results of the inspection, the Seller hired a Pest Control Company to
treat the termite condition, which it did by spraying in the crawl space
and placing termite baits around the perimeter of the house. After
taking possession of the premises, the Purchasers discovered extensive
termite damage throughout the house and a leak in the oil line feeding
the boiler tank, resulting in contamination of the soil under the house,
(which ultimately had to be removed by a specialty company, monitored
by the Department of Environmental Conservation). The Purchasers would
like to sue the Pest Control Company, the Seller, and the Engineer for
breach of contract with regard to all, negligence with regard to the
Engineer and the Pest Control Company, and fraud in the inducement with
regard to the Seller. May they do so?
Answer. NO as to the Seller. MAYBE as to the Engineer. NOT LIKELY as to the Pest Control Company.
The Seller made the premises fully available
for inspection by the Purchasers and their agents without restriction as
to length or scope of inspection. Under these circumstances, the facts
represented were not matters peculiarly within the Seller’s knowledge
and the Purchasers had the means available to them of knowing, by the
exercise of ordinary intelligence, the truth or the real quality of the
subject of the representation. It was their responsibility to make use
of those means, (which they did through the Engineer) and cannot now
complain that they were induced to enter into the transaction by
misrepresentations Since, the Seller or his agents did not thwart the
Purchasers efforts to fulfill their responsibilities fixed by the
doctrine of caveat emptor (buyer beware) they have no claim against the
Seller.
In addition, pursuant to the Contract of Sale
the Purchasers specifically disclaimed reliance on any representations,
written or oral, of the Seller and/or his representative. and declared
that the buyers had inspected the premises and agreed to accept it “as
is”, and understood that no representations were made as to its
condition. Any claim of fraud against the Sellers was therefore
extinguished upon closing.
As to the Pest Control Company, there can be no
breach of contract claim against them by Purchasers since they were
hired by Seller. There is also no indication that there were any
representations made to the Purchasers by the Pest Control Company or
that there continues to be a termite infestation problem so it would
seem that a negligence (or third party beneficiary) claim would not
survive either.
As to the Engineer however there remains a
question fact as to whether he properly executed his duties to the
Purchasers. In other words, a claim may be stated against the Engineer
but it remains to be seen whether he actually did anything wrong. Nor
can the Engineer avoid the claim by relying on his invoice which is
entitled an “inspection agreement”. Neither the invoice nor the
inspection report, which also contained a provision limiting liability,
was signed by either of the Purchasers. Absent documentary proof of the
Purchasers’ agreement to these provisions limiting liability the claim
would be allowed.