Skip to main content

On December 28, 2009, New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg signed comprehensive legislation dubbed the “Greener, Greater Buildings Plan.”

On December 28, 2009, New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg signed comprehensive legislation dubbed the "Greener, Greater Buildings Plan." The purpose of this legislation is to reduce New York City's carbon footprint by five percent. In the first of this three part series, we will discuss several important provisions of the new New York City Energy Conservation Code (the NYCECC), and what it means to property owners and builders.  

The enactment of the NYCECC is intended to close what was perceived to be a loophole in the Energy Conservation Construction Code of New York State (the State Code), adopted in 2007. The State Code applies only to new construction and renovation work where more than half of a building's system of subsystems were replaced. Thus, everything from simple remodeling work to extensive renovations and additions (provided that the new work used more than half of the building's existing systems) were exempted from compliance with the State Code. As a result of the enactment of the NYCECC, now any construction which requires a building permit including residential construction must be analyzed for energy efficiency to the standards set forth under the State Code.  

In order to comply with the NYCECC, an applicant for a building permit must have the lead design professional submit three items along with the permit application: 1) a statement that to the best of [the design professional's] knowledge, belief and professional judgment; [the plans and specifications submitted] are in compliance with the NYCECC, or that the project is exempt from its requirements; 2) the results of an energy analysis (which must include the building's envelope, its service water heating, lighting and power systems, and its mechanical systems) comparing the proposed project to the requirements of the NYCECC and setting forth how the project meets the NYCECC requirments; and 3) construction drawings which demonstrate conformance with the NYCECC. It is important to note that this submission is an ongoing process. The analysis and construction documents must be updated to account for any substitutions and changes made during the course of construction.  

This Legal Alert is supplied for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. You should consult competent legal counsel depending on the specific issues of your matter.  

1 Consult Real Property Tax Law § 1802(1) (Class One) for a full definition of exempt property.  

2 “Energy” is defined as electricity, natural gas, fuel oil, and steam.  

3 With some exceptions, a “city building” is a building that is more than 10,000 square feet that is owned by the city or for which the city regularly pays all or part of the annual energy bills.   

4 Ratings generated by the benchmarking tool for a covered building that contains a data center, television studio, and/or trading floor that together exceed ten percent of the gross square footage of any such building shall not be disclosed until the office of long-term planning and sustainability determines that the benchmarking tool can make adequate adjustments for such facilities.  

5 Not applicable to separately-metered dwelling units.   

Amendments to The New York City School Construction Authority Act Allow Subcontractors to Elect a Remedy for Nonpayment

I. Background  

Section 101 of the General Municipal Law, also known as the Wicks Law, sets forth requirements for public construction contracts.  The Wicks Law requires public works owners to prepare separate specifications and award separate contracts for general construction, plumbing, HVAC, and electrical work when the total value of the contract exceeds three million dollars for public construction within New York City.  

The Wicks Law provision was preempted by Section 1735 of the New York City School Construction Authority Act (“Act”) for contracts awarded by the New York City School Construction Authority (“Authority”) between July 1, 1989 and June 13, 2014.  Unlike Wicks Law contracts, the Authority can award one contract.  Contractors submitting bids with the Authority during this time period must identify the names of the subcontractors they intend to use for the performance of the plumbing, HVAC, and electrical work.    

Contracts that come within the Act are also subject to its payment protection clause.  Under Subsection Six of the Act, contractors are required to pay subcontractors within seven (7) days of receiving payment from the Authority.  The contractors must pay their subcontractors the portion of the proceeds of the payment they receive representing the value of the work performed by their subcontractors which has been approved and paid for by the Authority.  Contractors may hold back an amount necessary to satisfy any claims, liens or judgments against the subcontractor which have not been suitably discharged and they may hold retainage.  Retainage is set at either five or ten percent depending on whether the subcontractor has posted a performance and/or a labor and material payment bond.   

If a subcontractor notifies the contractor and the Authority that the contractor failed to make a required payment, the contractor must provide the Authority with either proof of the payment to the subcontractor or a notice that the amount claimed by the subcontractor is in dispute.  The contractor must do so within five (5) calendar days of receiving the notice of nonpayment from the subcontractor.  If the contractor fails to respond to the subcontractor’s notice or notifies the Authority that the payment to the subcontractor is in dispute, the Authority withholds money from the contractor’s payment.  If the contractor disputes the payment owed to the subcontractor, the Authority deposits the amount withheld into an interest bearing account.  Any amounts owed together with interest will be paid to the party ultimately determined to be entitled to payment.  The Act also contains provisions for determining priority and distribution of amounts withheld in the event of multiple withholdings.  

Amendments to the Act became effective on September 17, 2010 (“Amendments”).  The purpose of the Amendments the Amendments will significantly impact the amounts withheld from contractors by the Authority, contractors’ ability to bond the payment amounts disputed by subcontractors, and subcontractors’ remedies for payment protection.   

Pursuant to the Amendments, the Authority will now withhold one hundred fifty percent (150%) of the portion of the Authority’s prior payment to the contractor which the subcontractor claims to be due from the contractor.  Notably, the amendment does not alter that portion of the statute that provides that if the contractor fails to dispute the withholding the Authority will remit the amount withheld (i.e. the 150%) to the subcontractor and deduct such payment from the amounts then otherwise due and payable to the contractor.  Such payments by the Authority are deemed a payment by the Authority to the contractor. Prior to the Amendments, the Authority held an amount equal to the prior payment to the contractor which the subcontractor claimed to be due from the contractor.  

To avoid the Authority’s one hundred fifty percent (150%) withholding, the contractor can file a bond or undertaking in the amount(s) withheld by the Authority.  This remedy was added by the Amendments and is new to the Act.  

The Act was also modified so that subcontractors must now choose between filing a lien or seeking payment protection from the Authority under the one hundred fifty percent withholding clause of Section 1735.  Going forward, a subcontractor can file a lien for the amount disputed in the event the Authority does not withhold the required amounts within sixty (60) days after the Authority’s receipt of written notification from the subcontractor of the contrator’s failure to make a payment.  Significantly, such a lien will be the subcontractor’s sole remedy in lieu of the remedies provided by the Act.  This election of remedies clause was added to avoid the financial burden placed on a contractor when the Authority withheld a percentage of the amounts owed to a subcontractor in addition to one hundred fifty percent of its lien amount.  The Authority will stop this double withholding by limiting the amounts withheld to either one hundred fifty percent of a subcontractor’s lien or one hundred fifty percent of a subcontractor’s claim under the special payment protections of section 1735.  

These provisions do not apply to subcontractors acting as primes (i.e. subcontractors whose contract is limited to the performance of a single scope of the plumbing, electrical or mechanical work for the project). These Amendments are already effective and certain contractors and subcontractors currently performing work for the Authority are already subject to these provisions if their contracts come within the Act rather than the Wicks Law. 

If you would like more information on this issue or any other construction issue, please contact Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP. 

This Legal Alert is supplied for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. You should consult competent legal counsel depending on the specific issues of your matter. 

The E-Verify Electronic Employment Verification System is Up and Running.

Soon, contractors entering into federal works contracts will be required to agree to use the electronic employment verification system (“E-Verify” ), administered by the Department of Homeland Security (“DHS”), to confirm the employment eligibility of their workforce. E-Verify is an internet-based system that will take in information that an employer obtains from each newly hired employee on Form I-9, and it will check that information against records contained in DHS and Social Security Administration databases.
 

Employers take notice. Governor Paterson has signed legislation affecting the obligations of employers vis-a-vis their employees. Here is what this means to you, as an employer.

Past Due Wages: As of November 24, 2009, the Commissioner of Labor will be empowered to prosecute claims to collect underpaid or unpaid wages before administrative judges within the Department of Labor. This process is similar to that which is used to determine contested unemployment eligibility claims. The legislation also permits the judge to impose an additional assessment against the employer (“liquidated damages”), unless the employer can demonstrate that it had a good faith basis to believe that its underpayment of wages was legal. Previously, the Commissioner of Labor was required to prosecute such claims by starting a civil lawsuit, and the burden required to recoup liquidated damages was the employee’s (by demonstrating that the employer’s underpayment was willful).  

Employer Retaliation: In connection with the past due wage legislation, there has been an increase in the penalties which can be imposed upon an employer who is determined to have retaliated against an employee for complaining of a wage or other Labor Law violation (by, for example, firing the employee or reducing the employee’s work hours or benefits, or by reassigning the employee to a less favorable task or position). These penalties, which previously had a range of $200 to $1,000, now range from $2,000 to $10,000. The penalty provision has also been expanded to include officers and agents of limited liability companies and partnerships.  

New Hire Notice: Commencing October 26, 2009, employers will be required to notify all newly hired employees, in writing, of: 1) their base rate of pay; 2) their overtime rate of pay; and 3) the employer’s regular paydays. The employer must also obtain from the new employee a written acknowledgment of the receipt of this notice.  

If you have any questions about the information set forth in this Legal Alert, call us at 
914-428-2100.  Please understand that this alert provides general information only.  It is not intended to provide legal advice. We encourage you to contact an attorney should you desire to discuss specific situations for which you may need legal advice.   

NYC Building Owner Can Recover All Rent Stabilized Apartments for Personal Use

In a decision that will surely make NYC rent stabilized tenants unhappy, the New York Court of Appeals has ruled that the husband and wife owners of a five story, 15-unit apartment building in Manhattan, have the right to recover possession of all six of the rent stabilized apartments in the building (located on different floors) for the husband’s personal use as his primary residence.

New Law Protects Subcontractor’s and Supplier’s Right to Payment

Governor Patterson recently signed legislation which limits subcontractors and suppliers exposure of a general contractor passing along the risk of non-payment by an owner on a construction project. The new law, contained in the New York State General Obligations Law, voids as against public policy any contract clause which attempts to condition a subcontractor’s or supplier’s right to file and pursue a claim against a labor and material payment bond until after the exhaustion of mechanic’s lien remedies. 
 
Prior to the 1995 New York State Court of Appeals case, West-Fair Electric Contractors, Inc., et al v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Company of America, et al (argued successfully by Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP), construction contracts routinely contained clauses which conditioned a subcontractor’s or supplier’s right to payment on the general contractor’s receipt of payment from an owner. In West-Fair, the New York State Court of Appeals ruled that any clause which attempted to pass along the risk of non-payment by an owner to a subcontractor or supplier was void. 
 
Subsequent to West-Fair, clauses have appeared in construction contracts attempting to circumvent the Court’s decision by requiring subcontractors and suppliers to exhaust their mechanic’s lien rights before they are able to pursue collection against a labor and material payment bond, which traditionally offered an independent remedy. As many in the construction industry know, mechanic’s lien enforcement proceedings are both lengthy and costly. In many cases, by the time the mechanic’s lien proceedings concluded, there was no money available for payment to the subcontractor and supplier and the statute of limitations to pursue claims against the labor and material payment bond expired, thereby eliminating the subcontractor’s or suppliers ability to collect payment. 

Although this new law makes it easier to pursue claims against labor and material payment bonds, you must be sure that you comply with all statutory and bond provisions with respect to timely and adequately providing notice and commencing a lawsuit to preserve your rights for payment under the bond. In essence the new law underscores the independent and alternative remedy the payment bond offers to subcontractors and suppliers. For peace of mind, it is also wise to contact a construction attorney should you need any assistance.  

If you have any questions about the information set forth in this Legal Alert, please call Anthony P. Carlucci, Jr. at 914-428-2100. Please understand that this alert provides general information only. It is not intended to provide legal advice. We encourage you to contact an attorney should you desire to discuss specific situations for which you may need legal advice. Under the ethical rules that govern the practice of law, this communication may be considered as attorney advertising. 

 

Home Improvement Contractor License – New Home.

Do you need a home improvement contractor license when you perform work associated with the construction of a new home? The appellate Division, Second Department says yes, if the work you are performing, in this case landscaping, is not part of the construction of the new home’s envelope. 

Arbitrator’s Authority to Decide Jurisdictional Questions

A court’s jurisdiction is established by statute. It sets forth the limitiations and powers of 
the court to decide cases that come before it. For example, small claims courts and district courts 
have a dollar amount limits on judgments they can award. Similarly, the state Court of Claims 
can only decide cases brought against the state. Determining whether a case fits within a court’s 
particular jurisdiction, is decided by that court. 
 
Arbitration is different. In arbitration, the arbitrator’s jurisdiction is established by the 
parties’ arbitration agreement, not by statute. Determination of whether a particular dispute is 
arbitrable – that is, within the arbitrator’s jurisdiction – was a question for the courts to decide. 
 
 Recently, New York’s highest court, the Court of Appeals, ruled that where empowered 
by the parties, an arbitrator can decide questions of his or her own jurisdiction. The case is Life 
Receivable Trust v. Goshawk Syndicate 102 at Lloyd’s.1
 
 Life Trust owned a portfolio of life insurance policies. It purchased contingency cost 
insurance from Goshawk as a hedge on payments that would have to be made on those policies. 
Life Trust paid premiums for the contingency cost insurance to Goshawk, however, Goshawk did 
not pay any claims. The contingency cost insurance agreements contained an arbitration 
agreement. Goshawk commenced arbitration before the American Arbitration Association’s 
International Center for Dispute Resolution. Life Trust, not wanting to arbitrate the dispute, 
made a motion in court to stay the arbitration based upon arbitrability grounds.2
 
 
The lower court denied Life Trust’s motion, noting that the contingency cost insurance 
agreements contained an arbitration provision indicating that “All disputes and differences arising 
under or in connection with this Insurance shall be referred to arbitration under the American 
Arbitration Association Rules.” The lower court further found that the arbitration provision was 
plain and expansive and indicated that the parties agreed to arbitrate their disputes under the AAA 
rules. Those rules, said the court, gave the arbitrator, not the court, the authority to decide the 
“existence, scope, or validity” of the arbitration agreement. 
 
 Life Trust appealed the denial of its motion to stay the arbitration to the Appellate 
Division (First Department). The appellate court upheld the lower court, by a 4 – 1 majority, 
indicating that although questions of arbitrability are generally ruled upon by the court, 
when the parties arbitration agreement specifically incorporates the AAA rules, which 
give the arbitrator the power to rule on his or her own jurisdiction, including challenges 

 

 1
 2008 WL 4461446 (N.Y. Sup.), affirmed, 66 A.D.3d 495, 888 N.Y.S.2d 458 (1st Dept. 2009), 
affirmed, 14 N.Y.3d 850, 901 N.Y.S.2d 133 (2010). 
 
2
 Life Trust argued that the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Hall Street Assoc. LLC v. Mattel, 
Inc., 128 US 1396 (2008), nullified the arbitration agreement with Goshawk because the arbitration 
agreement expanded the scope of the court’s review beyond the grounds of review set forth in the Federal 
Arbitration Act. Life Trust also argued that Goshawk’s obligation to pay claims was absolute and the 
agreement precluded Goshawk from asserting any defense. Goshawk argued that the parties unequivocally 
agreed that the arbitrators, and not the Court, would decide issues of arbitrability. 
 
  
to the existence, scope or validity of the arbitration agreement itself3
 and the agreement 
uses expansive “all disputes” language, the courts will leave the question of arbitrability 
to the arbitrator. 
 
Life Trust appealed to the Court of Appeals, however that court agreed with the 
lower courts. 
 
 What is the ramification of this on the construction community? 
 
 If you are using AIA forms of contracts, or contracts containing broad arbitration 
clauses incorporating the AAA Construction Industry Arbitration Rules, what is or is not 
arbitrable under the contract will be decided by the arbitrator, not by a court. Contractors 
should therefore be mindful of any arbitration agreement in their contracts. They must be 
alert, when it comes time to select an arbitrator. If the dispute involves questions 
pertaining to whether or not a particular issue is subject to arbitration, additional 
consideration should be given to select an arbitrator who has experience with arbitrability 
questions. Merely selecting an arbitrator based upon his or her construction or design 
background may put significant questions of whether an issue is arbitrabile in the hands 
of someone without experience or knowledge of such jurisdictional matters. In such 
situations the parties may want to have an attorney with construction law background as 
their arbitrator. 
 
This alert provides general information only. It is not intended to provide legal advice. 
We encourage you to contact an attorney should you desire to discuss specific situations 
for which you may need legal advice. 

 

Worker Notification – Wage Rates

If you do public works contracting in New York, be aware of the new wage rate notification requirement under section 220 of the Labor Law, which became effective on February 24, 2008, even though it was not approved until April 23, 2008.