Skip to main content

Contract Document Ambiguities Heap More Risk On Contractors

When will an ambiguity in a public owner’s contract documents not support a contractor’s claim for extra work? Answer, (according to the New York Court of Appeals) is when the ambiguity is obvious (patent) on the face of the document, and the contractor did not follow the contract and seek clarification prior to bidding. 
 
Here is what happened. The Contractor was awarded a contract with New York City to remove lead-based paint from the Queensboro Bridge. The Contractor was required to install scaffolding platforms above the inner vehicle roadways and outer pedestrian roadway. Drawing No. 26R contained Note 5 stating that, “minimum vertical clearance of 14 feet shall be maintained above all roadways.” The drawing also contained arrows pointing Note 5 to the area of the inner vehicle roadways. Note 7 on the same drawing stated that protective shielding, platforms and containments shall be installed in accordance with approved shop drawings, to the satisfaction of the contractor’s engineer. The arrows associated with Note 7 pointed to the outer pedestrian roadways. The contractor interpreted Note 7 as being applicable to the outer pedestrian roadway. There was no problem with providing 14 feet of clearance over the inner roadways, as the inner 
roadways were several feet lower than the outer roadway. However, existing power cables located over the outer roadways limited clearance of the platforms over the outer roadways to between 8 feet 5 inches and 12 feet. In order to install work platforms with a minimum 14 foot clearance over the outer roadways, the contractor was required to remove and relocate the power cables – additional work, for which the contractor wanted to be paid. The City denied the Contractor’s claim for payment whereupon the Contractor, following the dispute provisions in the contract, took the dispute to the Contract Dispute Resolution Board (CDRB). 
 
The City argued to the CDRB that the drawings were ambiguous on their face. This, said the City, triggered a contractual provision that required the Contractor to seek clarification of the ambiguity before it submitted its bid. The Contractor having failed to do so, said the City, its claim was barred. The CDRB agreed stating that the City “produced a confusing and contradictory set of drawings” and that, “the conflict between the drawing and the notes indeed created an ambiguity in the contract.” Accordingly, the CDRB concluded, the Contractor was not entitled to claim for additional work, because it failed to comply with the contract. 
 
The Contractor then sought a review of the CDRB’s determination by the Supreme Court in an Article 78 proceeding. 1 The Court noted that, in undertaking its review, it may not substitute its judgment for that of the CDRB, and that it must uphold the CDRB’s determination if the CDRB had a rational basis for it. As you will have guessed, the Supreme Court concluded that the CDRB had a rational basis for its determination. It held that the drawing and notes were confusing and in conflict, which triggered the “seek clarification before bidding” contract clause. “Where a contract requires a contractor to raise any ambiguities or any questions about the requirements of the job with the City before submission of its bid and the contractor fails to do so… the contractor will be bound by the City’s interpretation of the contract.” 

 
The Contractor then appealed to the Appellate Division. There, by a 3 to 2 majority, the appellate court upheld the lower court’s dismissal of the Contractor’s Article 78 petition.2 The Contractor tried again in the Court of Appeals 3, but it fared no better, and its claim stayed dismissed. 

The result of the Contractor’s travels through the state judicial system may have negative repercussions to the entire construction community. By breathing new life into what was previously a relatively innocuous provision in the instructions to bidders, public owners may take a harder line about paying extra work claims arising as a result of patently ambiguous contract documents, where clarification was not sought prior to bidding. 

 1
 L & L Painting Co., Inc. v. Contract Dispute Resolution Board of the City of New York, 2008 WL 226979 
(N.Y. Sup.) 
2 Id. at 68 A.D. 3d 594, 892 N.Y.S.2d 55 (1st Dept. 2009)  
3
 Id. at 2010 WL 1704644 (Ct. of Appeals, 4/29/10) 

The Appellate Division First Department Finds in Favor of a Subcontractor That Oral Directions to Perform Extra Work May Override Contract Provisions Requiring Written Authorization

Generally, a provision in a private construction contract that extras must be ordered and agreed to in writing, is valid and binding upon all parties and no recovery can be had for alterations or extras done without a written order. However, as evidenced by the following, where there is an oral waiver, modification, or abrogation of such a provision, the First Department of the Appellate Division, will recognize and enforce such oral agreements.

 A mechanic’s lien foreclosure action was initiated by the HVAC subcontractor on the improvement and reconstruction of the Uniqlo USA’s (“Uniqlo”) flagship retail store in the SoHo district of Manhattan (the “Project”). A named defendant and fellow mechanic’s lienor, Absolute Electrical Contractors, Inc. (“Absolute”), the protagonist of our story, answered the complaint and asserted counter-claims1 against Uniqlo, as the owner, and the general contractor, Richter & Ratner Contracting Corp. (“R&R”) for amounts owed for additional labor, including overtime and shift work, performed at the direction of R&R. 

Absolute asserted that significant amounts of overtime work and additional shifts were required to meet the scheduled completion date, understood to be grand opening party for the store on November 10, 2006. R&R orally agreed to pay Absolute for its overtime and additional shift work on the basis of “work tickets” submitted by Absolute and signed by R&R. Based on this agreement, Absolute submitted daily work tickets and requests for additional compensation for overtime, additional shift and other extra work. R&R issued and executed 19 change orders and paid all. However, roughly three weeks before the completion date, R&R directed Absolute to further accelerate its work by working literally around the clock, including weekends, but instructed Absolute to stop submitting daily work tickets. Instead, R&R directed Absolute to submit a bill for the overtime and additional shift work at the completion of the Project, which R&R agreed to pay. At the completion of the Project, Absolute submitted a “Proposal for Equitable Adjustment,” requesting payment of overtime, additional shift work and other costs and damages resulting from R&R’s accelerated work directives. In the end, R&R refused to issue a change order or pay any portion of these sums.

 R&R responded to Absolute’s claims by cross-moving for summary judgment based on provisions of the subcontract, which expressly required that “any additional or extra work must be authorized in writing by a Project Manager, Project Executive or Officer of R&R,” and restricted any remedy for delay to an extension of time. Absolute then cross-moved for summary judgment on their “counter”-claims for amounts owed for extra work against R&R. Judge Lowe of the Supreme Court, New York County, granted Uniqlo and R&R’s motions for summary judgment dismissing the counterclaims asserted by Absolute and denied Absolute's motion for summary judgment as to liability on such counterclaims. Absolute appealed. 
                                                              1 The decision as reported and the documents filed erroneously refer to the cross-claims made by the co-defendants as counter-claims.

The Appellate Division ruled that R&R failed to meet its burden on summary judgment of Absolute’s counterclaims, holding that the oral directions to perform extra work overrode the contract provisions requiring written authorization and that there were issues of fact to be resolved as to whether Absolute was paid in full. Quoting Barsotti’s Inc. v. Consolidated Edision Co. of N.Y., 254 A.D.2d 211 (1998) and citing testimony of R&R representatives, the Court stated that “[u]nder New York law, oral directions to perform extra work, or the general course of conduct between the parties, may modify or eliminate contract provisions requiring written authorizations or notice of claims.” The Court found that, given such testimony admitting to directing Absolute to perform the additional work, agreeing to pay for the work and instructing them not to bother with the “tickets,” the general contractors claim that it did not have to pay for this overtime because there were no written tickets or change orders was meritless. 

The Court also alluded to the fact that the no-waiver provision of the subcontract did not avail R&R, as Absolute was not claiming that the general contractor waived its right to enforce the no-oral-modification clause by making other payments. Rather, Absolute was claiming that R&R waived such right by directing it to perform overtime work and not to bother with the tickets. Further, R&R could not rely on a “no damages for delay” clause as Absolute was not seeking to recover damages caused by delay, but rather to be paid for overtime that R&R directed and for which it had agreed to pay. 

Ultimately, the court found that there were issues of fact as to whether R&R had fully paid Absolute for Absolute’s overtime work during the three week period. Therefore, where there is a provision within a subcontract requiring that all extra work be requested and agreed to in writing, any oral waiver, modification, or other abrogation of such a clause will be recognized and enforced if supported by corroborating testimony.