Heed the instructions to bidders is the lesson from a recent case in the Appellate Division, Second Department. The Contractor didn’t and lost it $772,000 claim, after winning at trial.
In 2003 the New York State Court of Appeals ruled on a public project the time within which material supplier had to give notice of its claim for payment under a statutory payment bond is measured from the date of the last delivery of materials for which the claim is made.
A recent case out of the Appellate Division, Second Department is instructive to
public works contract bidders, who believe that the low bidder gets the contract. The
case is In the Matter of AAA Carting and Rubbish Removal, Inc. v. Town of Southeast.1
In this case the Town awarded a contract for rubbish removal to the second low bidder
(Suburban Carting). and the low bidder (AAA Carting) sought court review of the
Town’s decision by bringing an Article 78 proceeding. The Town favored the second
low bidder on the basis that it could offer superior service as compared to the low bidder.
To the Town, the second low bidder was the lowest responsible bidder even though the
cost would be higher.
The Supreme Court, Putnam County, granted the low bidder’s Article 78 petition, thereby
overturning the Town’s decision to award the contract to the second low bidder. The
second low bidder (not the Town) appealed to the Appellate Division, Second
Department. The appellate court reversed the lower court and dismissed the low bidder’s
Article 78 petition, leaving intact the contract between the Town and the second low
bidder.
In reversing the lower court, the appellate court summarized several principals of law that
potential bid challengers should be aware of:
a. A court reviewing an Article 78 bid challenge may not substitute its
judgment for that of the public body unless the decision is arbitrary and capricious or the
public body’s exercise of discretion lacks a rational basis.
b. It is not the reviewing court’s role to weigh the desirability of any action
or to choose among alternatives.
c. General Municipal Law §103(1) requires any public works contract for
more than $10,000 to be awarded to “the lowest responsible bidder”. This is an elastic
concept that includes “consideration of skill, judgment and integrity”.
d. Public bodies may investigate the experience and background of the
bidder.
e. Public bodies need not give “slavish attention to financial considerations
alone.”
f. Where good reason exists, the low bid may be disapproved or all the bids
rejected.
g. Where a public body exercises its discretion and rejects one or more bids,
its decision “ought not to be disturbed by the courts unless it is irrational, dishonest or
otherwise unlawful.”
Successful bid challenges are difficult to achieve. Now you know why.
\
This alert provides general information only. It is not intended to provide legal advice.
We encourage you to contact an attorney should you desire to discuss specific situations
for which you may need legal advice.
New York’s Labor Law 240(1) covers Employees, not Volunteers. New York’s employee protection scaffold law, Labor Law §240(1), makes all contractors and owners and their agents (except for owners of one and two-family dwellings who contract for but do not direct or control the work) responsible for work-site safety practices. However, in a recent case decided by the New York Court of Appeals, light has now been shed on who is and is not a protected employee.
The New York Court of Appeals has ruled that a Contractor lost its general liability insurance protection because it did not give timely notice of the occurrence, even though it did give timely notice of the same occurrence to the same insurance company under its worker’s compensation policy.
Contractor Forfeits $260,000 Balance owed on Contract. The Appellate Division, First Department, has ruled that a Contractor must forfeit more than $260,000 owed to it by the City under a contract to renovate the Brooklyn Borough Hall, because its president attempted to bribe two City workers who were reviewing a $101,000 change order request submitted by the contractor. The Contractor’s president had left envelopes containing $3,000 and a Christmas card on the employees’ desks. One envelope also contained the pending change order request. After being alerted by its employees, the City’s Department of Investigation obtained the Contractor’s president’s admission that he had left the envelopes. The City cancelled the almost fully-completed contract and told the Contractor that no further payment would be made.
Contractors who perform (or intend to perform) public contracting work for the NYC School Construction Authority, may have reason to rejoice (a little). As of March 19, 2008, a new provision has been added to the SCA’s Construction General Conditions. New Section 7.04, “Allowance Change Orders” should alleviate some of the economic pressure faced by Contractors and Subcontractors when they are directed to perform changed work, but are unable to agree with the SCA as to the value and credits for that work.
The Appellate Division, Second Department recently affirmed a lower court decision that held that a Letter of Intent (“LOI”) together with expressly incorporated documents constituted a valid and enforceable construction contract. Although the decision is sparse as to factual details, the court reiterated the rule that an LOI that manifests the parties’ intent to be bound by its terms, and that contains the price, scope of work and time for performance – but does not contain an express reservation by either party of their right not be bound until a more formal agreement is signed – is a binding contract.
Soon, contractors entering into federal works contracts will be required to agree to use the electronic employment verification system (“E-Verify” ), administered by the Department of Homeland Security (“DHS”), to confirm the employment eligibility of their workforce. E-Verify is an internet-based system that will take in information that an employer obtains from each newly hired employee on Form I-9, and it will check that information against records contained in DHS and Social Security Administration databases.