Skip to main content

Author: WB&G

Liquidated Damages 101

Many construction contracts—and the parties that enter into those contracts—include specific contract provisions which seek to mitigate or shift risk. One such provision to a construction contract is the liquidated damages provisions, which may seem odious at first glance but may provide benefits to the parties who include them.

What are Liquidated Damages?

The first thing to understand about liquidated damages provisions is what exactly they are. Liquidated damages provisions are contract clauses that seek to avoid the difficult task of proving loss due to a failure by a contracting party to adhere to specific performance conditions. In the context of a construction contract, liquidated damages clauses typically specify a daily sum that a contractor will be charged for each day the project is delayed past the project completion date and any extension. In some—rare—cases, these provisions can be reciprocal. 1

New York Law on Liquidated Damages

There are some limitations on the use and validity of liquidated damages clauses, specifically, in New York, liquidated damages clauses are enforceable so long as they are not attempts to penalize a party. To ensure that the liquidated damages clause is enforceable, the liquidated damages amount must bear a reasonable relationship to the amount of damages that may be sustained. If there is no reasonable relationship between the actual damages sustained and the liquidated damages amount, the liquidated damage amount is considered a penalty and is unenforceable. Additionally, to ensure that a liquidated damage clause is sustainable, the actual damages must be difficult to determine, and the assessed liquidated damages amount must not be disproportionate to the possible loss.

How Can Liquidated Damages Hurt a Contractor?

From the simple definition above, liquidated damages provisions can be daunting, as most contractors are aware that delays are commonplace on most construction projects. In many cases, liquidated damages provisions can be harmful where a contractor faces significant delays. Typically, liquidated damages are assessed against the contractor where they are delayed from achieving substantial or final completion by a specified date. However, in many instances, delays suffered by a contractor on a project can be the result of delays that may be outside of a contractor’s control, such as delays faced by downstream material suppliers. Even if that is the case, a contractor may still be required to pay liquidated damages to the upstream owner.

How Can Liquidated Damages Help a Contractor?

Based on the above, liquidated damages seem detrimental to the parties that include them as provisions in their contract. This may be true on the surface but, liquidated damages clauses can provide significant benefits to contractors.

Aside from the obvious—but rare—examples where liquidated damages clauses are reciprocal, there is another latent benefit of liquidated damages clauses that benefit contractors. Namely, liquidated damages clauses will not be enforced where its enforcement would be unjust or unconscionable. Normally, where the owner is responsible for a portion of the delay the proper remedy is an extension of the project completion time. These time extensions serve to delay the project completion deadline and stall the accrual of liquidated damages.

In addition, a liquidated damages clause provides an easily identifiable number for both parties to understand the risk of failing to complete the project within the required timeline. Viewed from another angle, a contractor who has an upstream liquidated damages clause can foresee the costs of project delays and can mitigate that risk throughout the course of the project. Additionally, the parties who include a liquidated damages provision in their contract can avoid the time and costs associated with calculating actual damages after the project is completed.

Conclusion

Liquidated damages clauses can be both a benefit and a detriment to contractors who have those provisions included in their contracts. Consult with a construction law attorney before taking action, which may be detrimental.

1 Where the contractor pays the owner liquidated damages for each day that a project is delayed and the owner pays
the contractor a bonus for each day that the project is completed prior to the specified completion date.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Giovanni Care at gcare@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6437

ALJ Vacates Citation for Failure of Proof Despite the Employer’s Failure to Protect Its Workers

When a client is cited for alleged OSHA violations, it’s a perennial — and often difficult — question as to whether, or in what circumstances, all or some of the  items should be contested.

While it’s rumored that penalties for OSHA violations may be increased (as much as tenfold) in the near future, historically the penalties have been sufficiently small, that the disproportion between the legal fees and expenses involved in litigating a contest proceeding before the OSH Review Commission, and the penalties at stake, has usually counseled in favor of striking a quick compromise, if one is to be had, and moving forward.

In addition to the Secretary’s advantage of having at his disposal a corps of specialized lawyers paid by the taxpayers. (and the dearth of private attorneys experienced in handling such matters) there are technical and procedural advantages favoring the government in citation contest proceedings. 

Of course, OSHA infractions are a blemish on an employer’s safety record, and “Willful” and “Repeat” violations (in addition to carrying penalties that can run into six figures per item) can impair an employer’s ability to win contracts. (So, too, can an accumulation of “Serious” infractions). Every employer likes to be seen as safety-conscious.  Many business owners take citations very personally, and it’s irksome to be slapped with a substantial monetary penalty, due possibly to a lapse on the part of a careless employee.

But while the OSH Review Commission is no “kangaroo court,” and its Administrative Law Judges, in my opinion (based on having read hundreds of published opinions over the years) .are knowledgeable and conscientious, I have perceived some reluctance to discount the testimony of OSHA inspectors. My belief is that a defense based on legal grounds offers the respondent better chances than one that would require the ALJ to discredit the testimony of an OSHA Compliance Officer.

I believe the most fertile grounds for success in an OSHA contest proceeding are a thorough understanding of the elements of the Secretary’s case, and (if the case goes to trial) close attention to the proofs. If the attorney representing the employer is both attentive and well-prepared, an argument to the ALJ that the Secretary has failed to prove any element of his case by a preponderance of the competent and admissible evidence, will often win the day.

It sometimes comes as a surprise to an employer that the ALJ, where warranted, will vacate a citation, even where there was an injury (actually, an injury, even a fatality, is legally irrelevant) and despite the employer’s conduct having been less than exemplary. However, the Secretary’s failure to prove even a necessary element of his case is probably the most common basis for citation items being vacated.

A striking example of this is the case of Secretary v. George Weis Co. The employer in that case was a family-owned drywall, ceiling, and plaster contractor, working as a subcontractor on a hotel construction project in Missouri.

The employer had a two-man crew installing soffits underneath a sun deck about 26 feet above grade.  The foreman installed the soffits from the bucket of an aerial lift located just below the sun deck, while the second worker knelt on the edge of the sun deck, just inside the wire rope guardrails, and handed materials to the foreman.

The worker on the roof, intending to rise to his feet, grabbed the mid-rail and pushed down, in order to support himself. The mid-rail gave way, and as it did so, the worker fell headfirst through both the mid-rail and top-rail onto the aerial lift.  Although the worker, fortunately, did not plunge to the ground, he was badly injured when he tumbled into the bucket.

Subsequent inspection by OSHA showed that the c-clamps, which allowed the wire ropes to loop around the stanchions and clamp back onto themselves, had not been adequately tightened. The OSHA inspector determined that a contractor had removed the guardrails from the sun deck to deliver materials, and failed to re-set them properly. Although the employer proffered testimony that it had inspected the guardrail, such inspection, if it occurred at all, was merely visual, and neither the employer nor the general contractor, following the removal of the guardrail to allow the materials delivery, had physically tested it to ensure that it met the standard requiring that it be capable of withstanding a force of at least 200 lbs., applied within 2 inches of the top edge, in any outward or downward direction.

The employer was cited under 29 CRF 1926.502(b)(3) and timely contested the citation. The Secretary had the obligation to prove at trial (1) the applicability of the standard; (2) that the standard was violated; (3) employee access to the cited condition; and (4) the employer’s actual or constructive knowledge.

Following trial, the administrative law judge, in his decision, had no difficulty in finding that the standard applied, and that the employer had a duty to provide fall protection to the injured employee. Since the guardrail was the sole means of fall protection deployed, the ALJ found that both the top-rail and the mid-rail needed to satisfy the 200 lbs. of force requirement.

Employee exposure was obvious, the ALJ ruled, as the injured employee had been working next to the guardrail for about two hours when the mishap took place. Plainly, given that the fall occurred upon the employee having grabbed the guardrail to support himself as he stood up, he was exposed to the allegedly defective condition.

The complainant had established constructive knowledge, the Court also found, as (notwithstanding some inconsistent testimony on this issue) the respondent had failed to discharge its obligation to perform a “careful and critical examination” necessitated by the location of the work, the potential gravity of injury, and lack of any additional means of fall protection. The foreman’s claim of having tugged and pulled on the rope, the ALJ found, was unconvincing and. in all events, insufficient.

Despite the foregoing, and while emphasizing that he was not finding that the employer had acted properly, the ALJ vacated the citation for lack of testimony or documentary evidence that a man of the injured worker’s height and weight, performing the activities engaged in at the time of the accident, would not have imposed more than 200 lbs. of force on one or more of the wire guardrails. The ALJ distinguished several cases cited by the Secretary, finding that in the case before him, unlike the cases cited, there was lacking “objective and  patently obvious reasons” why the guardrail could not support the required force.

“This case,” the ALJ concluded, “highlights the importance of the Complaint’s burden of proof, and the distinction between failing to prove a violation and whether a violation, in fact, existed.”  The employer in Weis “failed to take appropriate steps to ensure its employees were not exposed to hazardous conditions,” but while it was likely, even probable, that the guardrail could not have met the specific terms of the standard, the Secretary failed to prove it, wherefore the citation had to be vacated.

Geoffrey S. Pope, an attorney, is Of Counsel to the construction law firm of Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP, with its main office in White Plains.  The articles in this series do not constitute legal advice, and are intended for general guidance only.

Reducing Hazards Associated with Manual Handling of Materials in the Construction Workplace

This month’s column is inspired by materials I found online, published by the European Agency for Safety and Health at Work.  OSHA’s construction standards do not have a subpart dedicated specifically to ergonomic approaches to prevent or ameliorate lower back pain (which, in Europe, is said to be the #1 item among reported work-related disorders).

Although apparently this isn’t an OSHA compliance issue, your company would do well to carry out assessments of how tasks are performed, provide training to your employees, and act to protect employees from cumulative harm to the musculoskeletal system over months and years of repetitive lifting and handling activities on the jobsite.

Generally described, your company should be doing the following:

  • Designing and organizing tasks to avoid, or limit, the handling of materials manually;
  • Employing automation and lifting devices;
  • Where repeated lifting and manual handling cannot be avoided, organizing the work in a safe way, by dividing larger loads into smaller ones, providing rest periods, etc.;
  • Training employees in the correct handling of materials, including the opportune use of equipment, and how frequently-.required tasks should be performed.

“Manual handling” can be defined as supporting or transporting a load by lifting, holding, putting down, pushing, pulling, carrying, or moving it.  In the EU at least, just under two-thirds of  all workers spend at least a quarter of their working hours performing such tasks, and (in addition to fatigue) two varieties of injuries may result.  One includes sudden events, such as cuts, bruises, fractures, and the like, and the other variety involves damage to muscles, tendons, ligaments, bones, joints, bursa (the small, fluid-filled sacs that reduce friction between moving parts in the body’s joints), blood vessels and nerves.

What are referred to as musculoskeletal disorders are divisible into three groups: neck and upper limb disorders; lower limb disorders, and  back injuries and back pain.  Most people experience lower back pain to some extent by age thirty, and between one-quarter and one-half of construction workers complain of it.

The factors that make manual handling more or less hazardous fall into four groups:  the load, the task, the environment, and the individual.  The risk of back injury increases if the load is too heavy (20-25 lbs. is heavy for most people, especially if the load must be handled repeatedly), too large, difficult to reach or to grasp, unbalanced, or contains items within that move around.  A basic rule is that items should be lifted and carried as close to the body as possible.

Pushing and pulling generally impose fewer stresses on the body than lifting and carrying. Unbalanced loads are difficult to support, and sudden movement can throw the bearer off-balance.  Gloves, handles, or other aids for gripping can make it easier to maintain one’s grasp.  Loads that can only be reached with outstretched arms, or by bending or twisting the torso, may harm the spine, and carrying loads with sharp edges or dangerous materials is also to be avoided.

As for “the task,” the same can be very rigorous, if carried out over and ever for too long a period, or at a tempo that cannot be varied by the worker, or without sufficient rest periods.

The “environment“ means factors such as the space available to carry out the handling, the condition of the floor or working level, climate, and illumination.  If a large load must be hefted in a tight space, awkward body postures may be required, which can require joints to be held close to their maximum range of movement, or result a heavier load on the joints and spine and increased fatigue.

If the flooring is wet, uneven, or subject to moving (e.g., the deck of a fishing boat) handling materials becomes more difficult, and accidents more likely. Temperature, humidity, and ventilation affect a worker’s ability to carry out handling operations, especially if the same are to be repeated over the course of the workday. Poor lighting may increase the risk of an accident, or require the employee to work in awkward positions.

Naturally, individual factors also affect the likelihood of back injuries or other bad outcomes from handling operations.  An employee’s size, fitness, strength, lifestyle, age, medical history, experience, training, familiarity with the job and the tasks to be performed, and willingness to use personal protective equipment all affect his or her ability to perform handling operations, and prospects of avoiding injury while doing so.

Your company should carry out a risk assessment, or examination of potential hazards from manual handling operations,  Consider carefully tasks, and locations where they are performed, that could produce accidents, injuries, or poor health. Evaluate whether procedures and precautions in place are sufficient to minimize risks of harm, and what additional measures might be taken.

Among other things, you should consider the practicability of eliminating the “manual” element of at least some manual handling, and reduce or avoid altogether employees having to lift, carry and move things, by instead using devices such as conveyor belts, lift trucks, electric hoists, or a gravity-powered roller track.  Due consideration should be given to the potential downside, however (e.g., possible noise or hand-arm vibration hazards) from any alternatives being considered.

If the elimination of manual handling is not possible, or technical measures are ineffective in reducing the risks, you should next consider organizational or administrative measures.  For example,   heavier items could be lifted or carried by two people instead of one, or amounts to be handled could be reduced, or loads split into two or more smaller ones.

The pace of manual handling should not be set by a machine, supervisor, or co-workers.  The time for performing manual handling tasks should be extended by providing for breaks, or by alternating such tasks with other tasks, to allow muscles time to recover.

Pretty much all construction employees, even those who infrequently have to perform manual handling, should be trained in the correct techniques for lifting and carrying, and for pushing and pulling devices such as barrows and trolleys.

If your company has employees who must frequently perform manual handling, I commend to you NIOSH Publication No. 2007-131, “Ergonomic Guidelines for Manual Material Handling,” which you can download online.  It contains a wealth of information that will make their lives easier, more productive, and less painful.

I conclude this month’s installment .on .a personal note.  After 15 years of working on these articles, next month’s column will be my last for Construction News.  My deep thanks to my readers, and to George Drapeau and John Jordan, my editors.  Stay safe, everyone!

Geoffrey S. Pope, an attorney, is counsel to the construction law firm of Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP, with its main office in White Plains.  The articles in this series do not constitute legal advice, and are intended for general guidance only.

Court Reinforces that Arbitration Must be Consensual

Arbitration is often the most prompt and just means for dispute resolution. However, this leads to the questions: when can you arbitrate? and: what arbitration remedies might a contractor choose to exercise?

In BML Properties Ltd. v. China Construction America, Inc., et al., an appellate court reminded us that arbitration is a consensual process. BML involved a series of agreements in connection with the development of the multi-billion Baha Mar resort complex in the Bahamas. BML was the direct parent of Baha Mar Ltd.  In 2009, Baha Mar Ltd. and one of the China Construction defendants memorialized their agreement in a Main Construction Contract, which provided that any suit, action, or proceedings shall be brought in the courts of the State of New York, or the United States District Court, located in the Borough of Manhattan in the City of New York. A subsequent Bahamian receivership proceeding (think: bankruptcy) resulted in the sale of the assets of Baha Mar Ltd. to Perfect Luck Assets Ltd, (“Perfect Luck”). Consequently, BML lost its entire investment in in Baha Mar Ltd., or approximately $845 million, as well as its expected profits from the resort.

In 2016, Perfect Luck and one of the China Construction defendants amended the Main Construction Contract, deleting the New York forum selection clause and inserting a new provision requiring that any disputes be referred to and finally resolved by arbitration under the Rules of the International Chamber of Commerce. On December 26, 2017, BML filed a lawsuit in New York State Supreme Court in Manhattan alleging a multi-year scheme to fraudulently delay the Baha Mar resort project and increase construction costs. China Construction moved pursuant to NY CPLR 7503 and to the Federal Arbitration Act to compel arbitration.  BML countered, arguing that BML had not consented to arbitration and, accordingly, could not be compelled to participate. Correctly, the Court determined that its threshold question was whether the parties made a valid agreement to arbitrate, noting that the proponent of arbitration has the burden of demonstrating that the parties agreed to arbitrate. The appellate court affirmed, noting that while the Federal Arbitration Act favors arbitration, it is limited by the principle that arbitration is always a matter of consent, not coercion.  Defendants, while moving to compel arbitration, argued that the Main Construction Contract, as amended by Amendment No. 9, required BML to arbitrate the dispute.  However, BML was a non-signatory to Amendment No. 9, which post-dates the disputes at issue.

While in certain limited circumstances New York courts can impute the intent to arbitrate to a non-signatory, such as where the non-signatory may evince an intent to be bound or where the non-signatory received a direct benefit from a contract containing an arbitration clause, such as payment under the contract, or enforcement of the contract against others.  However, neither the lower nor the appellate courts found those triggering circumstances here. Accordingly, it found the arbitration clause inapplicable and, therefore, denied the motion to compel.

To understand the lower court’s ruling, it is important to remember the basic premise of arbitration: that arbitration is a consensual method of dispute resolution.  Parties contemplating arbitration can enter into an arbitration agreement either before or after a dispute arises; but enter into an agreement they must. The situation in BML fatally departed from this basic requirement and, accordingly, the case was relegated to ordinary litigation.

CONCLUSION:

It is clear that Courts are more inclined to sustain the right to arbitrate when supported by signed documentation, rather than surrounding factual circumstances. Should you believe you have a right to arbitrate, it is best to have the documents or circumstances on which you rely reviewed by your attorneys.

Using Near-Miss Reporting to Prevent Future Accidents

It’s important to fully exploit every accident-prevention strategy at your company’s disposal. Unfortunately, some construction employers have no near-miss reporting system in place, or neglect to put the necessary energy into convincing employees to faithfully report near-miss occurrences (or to follow-up with training, when near-misses are reported).

A near-miss, narrowly defined, is an occurrence that could have produced an injury (or property damage or other loss) but did not. If reported to management and investigated, often a near-miss will lead to changes in procedures, greater training emphasis, or stricter enforcement of company safety rules, and prevent a recurrence that could result in serious injury or other harm. In investigations if fatalities or other cases involving serious bodily harm, it is frequently found that the occurrence was preceded by prior incidents in which safety rules were ignored, and a near-miss occurred, but through dumb luck, usually, with no injuries.

Since effective harm prevention, although involving the rank and file, requires leadership usually from the top down, if you are an owner, officer, safety manager of field supervisor in a construction enterprise, you want every near-miss to be reported. The point must not be to identify and punish offenders — persons reporting near-misses should be allowed to do so anonymously. Instead, the point is to identify the weak spots in your procedures, or equipment, or training, or supervision, so that today’s near-miss doesn’t become tomorrow’s fatality, mass casualty event, or life-changing injury.

Of course, every report of a near-miss should bring about an appropriate level of investigation, and an analysis of what you can do to improve safety systems, better control hazards, reduce risks and reduce risk-taking among employees.

Company-wide, in addition to a top-down commitment from ownership and management, effective safety policy requires the company to hire, train and retain sober, safety-conscious workers, but especially field supervisors who know all of the applicable rules, don’t cut corners, and won’t overlook violations when seen to occur. Frankly, it is challenging indeed to train every construction worker in the full range of standards that apply to their jobs. Conscientious, thoroughly trained field supervisors are probably your best bet to minimize both OSHA citations and injuries to employees.

In addition, of course, time and money must be devoted to training and the provision of adequate and well-maintained equipment.

At the individual level, once a construction worker has developed the necessary adult attitude about risk-taking, safety is in large measure a matter of paying attention. Once the individual moves beyond seeing safety (beyond the necessity of avoiding the most obvious and serious risks to life and limb) as primarily a matter of avoiding getting called out by management, he or she can develop the habit of casting vigilant eyes on the workplace environment (and their own and co-workers’ conduct).

If your company implements a well-designed program of reporting not only obvious near-misses (e.g., an unsecured object falling from a scaffold, but by good fortune not striking anyone) but hazards or conduct that are nonetheless accidents waiting to happen if continued or repeated, that will be a great benefit. It’s been shown that most serious or calamitous events at jobsites are usually preceded by near-misses or situations that, if noted, could have served as warning. Generally, without encouragement, whether workers will report things that haven’t produced a frightening, although harmless incident, is largely a function of whether the situation was observed by others, such that failing to report it would be conspicuous.

Workers, lacking encouragement, are not avid to report as “near misses” things they may deem to be less than potentially life-threatening hazards, in part because it can be time-consuming, but also because the perception is often that reporting will get the reporter, or one or more other employees, in trouble.

It’s important, therefore, to give assurances that prevention, and not punishment, is the objective in urging the reporting of all “near misses” (broadly defined) and not just those that came really close to producing real harm. You might stress, also, that not only are employees answerable to the company, but the company is responsible to employees (as well as to OSHA) and employees are answerable to one another, too.

Workers, studies have found, are more inclined to speak with management about near misses than about incidents actually resulting in injuries. Employers should provide incentives to report near misses (although quotas are usually counter-productive) and allow occurrences to be reported anonymously. Discretion is called for in determining the level of investigation and documentation required. Reporting is something employees don’t want to spend a lot of time doing, and reporting could be deterred by an inquisition not commensurate with the situation. Selected near miss reports should become the subjects of periodic near-miss training sessions.

Examples of what should be seen as near-miss situations are where equipment remains in use despite damage or excessive wear, or there exist hazards such as holes in the floor, crumbling stairs, or nonconforming scaffolds, or whenever employees take risks, such as disconnecting one’s harness to retrieve a dropped tool on a roof, entering an unshored trench “for just a few minutes.” or operating equipment while impaired. Especially given that jobsites often involve vehicles, multiple employers, heavy equipment, temporary structures, a dizzying variety of activities (many of them inherently dangerous), and abrupt changes in the environment as the job progresses, it’s unrealistic to think that detecting and correcting hazards can be effective, without the participation of everyone onsite.

At training sessions, employees should be invited to bring up additional near misses they know of or have seen, and if a hazard in a particular work area or operation has been mentioned, to imagine what else might go wrong in that environment.

If you gain employees’ cooperation, the benefits of individual workers having paid attention can be spread company-wide, reducing significantly the possibility that the recurrence or continuation of hazards seen, but not reported, will result in serious physical harm. Near miss reporting, and the use of information obtained for training, is a proven method of reducing both near misses and actual incidents.

Geoffrey S. Pope is Of Counsel to the construction law firm of Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP, with its main office in White Plains. The articles in this series do not constitute legal advice, and are intended for general guidance only.

Public Authorities Law Bars Contractor’s Claim

Statutes of limitation set time periods by which a lawsuit must be commenced. Generally, under New York’s statute of limitations, a breach of contract claim must be brought within six years from the date upon which the cause of action accrued. Contractors should be aware that their contract may substantially reduce the period within which to bring an action. Likewise, local and state laws may similarly reduce the period to bring an action where the defendant is a municipality or a public benefit corporation.     

In Arnell Construction Corporation v. New York City School Construction Authority, an appellate court recently  addressed this issue. In Arnell, the Plaintiff was awarded a contract with the New York City School Construction Authority (“SCA”)  to renovate an existing building and construct a three-story addition. While work was ongoing, Arnell submitted a requisition to the SCA. Shortly thereafter, on or about August 5, 2015, Arnell filed a Notice of Claim with the SCA, setting forth a claim in the amount of $451,000.00 for damages, costs and expense for additional work. Thereafter, on or about September 14, 2015, Arnell filed a Second Notice of Claim for damages in the amount of $809,394.23 in connection with unforeseeable delays. Although the Notices of Claim were not resolved, Arnell continued work on the project until a Certificate of Substantial Completion was issued in October of 2016. During this time, Arnell appears to have taken no further steps to commence any legal action. On January 17, 2018, Arnell filed a Summons and Complaint seeking $1,260,394.23.

The SCA quickly moved to dismiss the claim based on a one-year statute of limitations. Public Authorities Law § 1744, perhaps unbeknownst to Arnell, states that any action “other than the one for personal injury, death, property damage or tort…shall have been commenced within one year after the happening of the event upon which the claim is based”. The lower court initially denied the SCA’s motion, finding that it failed to meet its burden to show that the Arnell’s claims for monetary damages were time barred. The appellate court disagreed and held that Arnell’s claims were barred by the applicable statute of limitations, and that Arnell had provided no evidence that the statute of limitations was tolled or that an exception applied. Thus, Arnell’s claims were dismissed.

Courts do not have discretion to extend the statute of limitations periods. Contractors, subcontractors, suppliers and materialmen far too often lose out on their right to bring a lawsuit by waiting too long to commence the lawsuit. Acting quickly when disputes arise can make the difference between full recovery and a complete loss (not to mention avoiding responsibility for attorney’s fees and litigation costs).

Because there are a number of different deadlines to file notices of claim and/or commence the lawsuit, you should contact an attorney to review the highly technical and rigidly enforced accrual dates (when the time to bring an action starts) and notice of claim requirements (how to notify a municipality). Contractors have to be mindful of two periods of limitations: the Notice of Claim deadlines and the Statutes of Limitations. It is necessary to comply with both, otherwise your claim will be lost.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Robert W. Bannon II at rbannon@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6455

Breach of Contract Claims Must be Supported by A Contractual Relationship

Generally, a direct contractual relationship – privity – is required between a plaintiff and a defendant in order to maintain a lawsuit for breach of contract. However, is a relationship in which one party deals directly with another and exercises control over the other sufficient to allege the functional equivalent of privity such that a breach of contract lawsuit could be maintained? A recent New York appellate court decision provided a resounding answer – No.

In the case of Tutor Perini Building Corp. v. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, 191 A.D.3d 569, 143 N.Y.S.3d 12 (1st Dept. 2021), Tutor Perini (hereinafter “GC”) contracted with George Washington Bridge Bus Station Development Venture LLC (the “Developer”), the lessee of the George Washington Bridge Bus Station in Manhattan, to perform construction and renovation work. The Developer had previously contracted with The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, as the Owner of the property (“Owner”). After not being paid for its work, the GC commenced a lawsuit directly against the Owner, alleging breach of contract and unjust enrichment. The GC based its breach of contract claim on the theory that the relationship between the GC and the Owner was the “functional equivalent” of privity based on the repeated interactions between the parties and the Owner’s “almost total control” over the project. The functional equivalent of privity doctrine is generally utilized to enable third-party beneficiaries to assert breach of contract claims directly against parties to a contract to which they are not signatories.

In the present case, the court rejected the attempt to apply the functional equivalent of privity doctrine because it found that the GC’s allegations of direct dealing and the exercise of some control were insufficient as the functional equivalent of privity doctrine (in the context of a breach of contract action) requires the plaintiff to be a third party beneficiary to the contract. The court further held that the application of the functional equivalent of privity doctrine, as applied by the GC, would essentially eliminate the need for privity to bring a breach of contract action. Additionally, it would lead to a significant increase in potential litigation and would unnecessarily complicate future commercial relationships.

In addition to the functional equivalent of privity doctrine argument, the GC also claimed that the Owner and the Developer were essentially a joint venture. However, the court quickly dismissed this argument stating that the GC failed to allege the requisite acts which manifest the intent by the Owner and the Developer to be associated as joint venturers. Further, the lease agreement between the Owner and the Developer explicitly stated that no such joint venture relationship was created. For these reasons, the court also dismissed the GC’s breach of contract claim.

While the court ultimately dismissed the breach of contract claim, it did maintain the GC’s unjust enrichment claim, which was plead in the alternative to the breach of contract claim. This claim stated that the Owner was enriched by the GC’s work at the project and thus the GC should be compensated for the value of work performed. As this claim does not require privity and is based on the court’s ability to provide equitable relief , it was allowed to proceed. The takeaway here should be that when commencing a lawsuit, one should include all potential theories of recovery – particularly where, as here, the right to assert a particular claim against another party is not certain.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Giovanni Care at gcare@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6437

HAVS: A Key Construction Peril Lacking Its Own OSHA Standard

You may be surprised to learn, as I was, that a hazard described by one expert as “probably the No. 1 neuromuscular disorder in the world in manufacturing and construction environments, the most costly, and underappreciated,” is not the subject of its own OSHA construction standard.

I am referring to “Hand Arm Vibration syndrome,” also known as HAVS (and formerly known as “vibration white finger,” as a prime symptom of its circulatory and neural effects includes the blanching — pale and ashen appearance — of the fingers).

This malady, although identified by industrial physicians more than 100 years ago, is severely under-reported by workers and health professionals.  Perhaps two million workers in the U.S.  are at risk, of which as many as half will develop HAVS.

The syndrome is defined as a type of industrial disease that produces symptoms in the arms and hands, and damage to blood vessels, nerves, and other musculoskeletal structures, usually from the prolonged use of vibrating power tools in the workplace. Working in a cold climate, and smoking (which impairs circulation to the extremities) are additional risk factors.

Devices linked to HAVS include grinders, riveters, drills, jackhammers, chipping hammers, jigsaws, sanders, vibrating pokers and compactors, scabblers,  and chainsaws.  Of course, any kind of hand-held vibrating tool can contribute to HAVS, and regardless of whether the tool is powered by electricity, gasoline, or air.  However, while the frequent use of vibrating hand tools having a frequency range between 8 Hz and 1500 Hz is problematic, the most hazardous frequency range is 100-150 Hz.  In addition to construction and maintenance, workers in the mining and forestry industries are also very much at risk.

Initially, nerves are irritated by the vibration, resulting in tingling and numbness in the hand and fingers.  At first, symptoms are most likely to be noticed while working in cold conditions.  Blood vessels may become irritated and spastic,  causing the fingers (and especially the fingertips) to feel cold and painful.  Over time (the syndrome typically takes between 6 months and 6 years of frequent exposure to develop) the attacks of pain, blanching and numbness usually become more frequent, although often they subside during warmer weather. 

Symptoms of HAVS may also include loss of feeling in the hand and fingers, a progressive decrease in hand strength, reduced dexterity, and arm muscles that tire easily.

In the most severe cases, individuals may experience atrophy of the muscles in the hand, and even gangrene.

Treatment usually consists primarily of reducing work exposure to vibration.  Perhaps half of affected individuals experience a return to near baseline within 5 years after the elimination or sharp reduction of exposure.  As the syndrome advances, however, often from the time that blanching of the fingers appear, the nerve damage may become irreversible.

Thus, prompt detection, and reducing or eliminating the exposure, is critical.

While, surprisingly, HAVS is not addressed by a specific OSHA standard, it may be addressed under OSHA’s General Duty Clause, which requires each employer to provide a safe and healthful workplace.

Compliance with acceleration levels and exposure duration guidelines established by the American Conference of Government and Industrial Hygienists is suggested, both as a means to limit your employee’s exposure, as well as a means of demonstrating compliance with the General Duty Clause, should you be cited based on one or more employee’s exposure to vibration.

You need to know the vibration rating of all equipment used by your employees, and to calculate the safe time exposure for each item.  Make sure that you know for how long employees can use particular tools, and if you don’t know, you need to inquire of the manufacturer, or get the various tools assessed.

Naturally, you should be discriminating in selecting equipment.  Look for low-vibration items, or tools incorporating built-in features that absorb a significant amount of the tool’s vibration.  Make sure employees use the correct tool for the job, and consider possible alternative means to accomplish tasks that will reduce employee exposure.  It may be possible, also, to alter the job to reduce the grip or pressure necessary.

Frequent breaks should be scheduled to avoid long periods of vibrating tool use, and you should try to minimize the use of vibrating tools in cold weather conditions.

Other practices users of vibrating equipment should be trained to observe include the following:

  • Abstain from smoking;
  • Keep one’s hands dry and warm;
  • Grip tools as lightly as possible (while keeping control of the tool);
  • Keep tools in good working order;
  • Keep one’s hands away from cold exhaust air from pneumatic tools;
  • Rest for at least 10 minutes each hour;
  • Alternate, whenever practicable, between vibrating and non-vibrating tools;
  •  Wear gloves that cover the fingers, and are certified by ISO 10819;
  • Seek medical attention, if HAVS symptoms appear.

As PPE is usually the least-preferred control measure, anti-vibration gloves are at best moderately effective.  They  protect the palm more than the fingers, and are of little use at frequencies lower than 25 Hz.  Gloves may actually amplify vibration from low-frequency tools.  Damping techniques (e.g., wrapping tool handles in viscoelastic material tape), or using vibration isolators on equipment provide more effective protection.  While some prefer the greater tactile “feedback” into the fingertips that fingerless gloves provide (and may cut the fingers of the gloves off, leaving only the palm area covered) that should be forbidden, if the user works with vibrating tools.

HAVS is a debilitating, life-changing affliction, and by the time symptoms become pronounced, they will likely be irreversible.  Workers must be trained about vibration hazards, early signs and symptoms of HAVS, and best practices to limit exposure.  Indeed, they should be cautioned that it is better to change jobs, rather than permitting HAVS to progress beyond its earliest stages.

PPE, the Hierarchy of Controls, and Covid Recovery Safety Planning

As the sun seems to be peeking out from behind the clouds of the Covid-19 pandemic, a semblance of normalcy has returned to some construction activities at least.  Still, we are by no means “out of the woods,” infections and deaths continue to occur and to spike around the country, and various experts are cautioning that variants of the original virus, or the need to vaccinate and keep vaccinating everyone, leaves us open to successive waves of infections and deaths.  So, I’m sure that nearly all construction employers are continuing to take special precautions, and striving to calculate how the unknowable course of Covid over the next year or two might impact the industry, generally, and day-to-day construction tasks in general.

PPE, as most readers know, is “personal protective equipment” worn on construction sites to reduce exposure to hazards that cause serious injuries and illnesses. Generally, it must be provided at employer expense.  It must be designed and constructed per ANSI or other industry standards, be regularly inspected, cleaned, and maintained, taken out of use when damaged or worn out, and fitted properly.  Users must be trained to know when and what kind of PPE is necessary; how to put it on, adjust, wear and remove it; its limitations, proper care, maintenance, useful life, and disposal of each item.

Some items (the hard hat, safety glasses, study work shoes or boots, high-visibility shirts with sleeves, long work pants) must be worn by all while onsite.  Other items, such as high visibility safety vests with reflective striping, must be worn in proximity to vehicular traffic.  Protective gloves are usual, but the material will vary, according to what is being handled by the wearer.  Full-face shields are necessary when cutting, grinding or chipping; splash goggles are needed to protect against harmful chemicals.  Respiratory protection is needed to work to avoid the inhalation of harmful substances.  Welders must wear welding leathers, and electricians must wear rubber gloves, with leather protectors, shock and slip-resistant boots, flame-resistant clothing and face shields, and insulated sleeves, in addition to the hard hat.  Anyone working on a surface elevated by 6 feet or more must (in the absence of other fall-protection measures) wear fall protection — usually, a harness to be fastened to a safety line.  The foregoing are common examples, not a comprehensive list.

NIOSH prescribes what it calls its “hierarchy of controls,” whereby it ranks the effectiveness of five means of controlling hazards.  The best way of reducing a hazard (if available) is to eliminate the hazard, by physical removal. Next-best is substitution, or replacing the hazard.  Number three is engineering controls, to isolate people, to the extent it be possible to do so, from the hazardous condition.  Number four is administrative controls, or changing the way people work.  Fifth (and last) is sole reliance on PPE.  While face coverings and gloves are high on the list of anti-Covid precautions, you want to steer away from over-reliance on these items.

Of course, in fighting Covid contagion, as in many other contexts, approaches in combination will often prove to be beneficial.  One illustration is that a major risk factor for contracting Covid-19 is close exposure to infected individuals, their exhalations, and their droplets (especially in poorly-ventilated, indoor spaces).  Infected surfaces are also thought to be a risk factor (although a less important one than was thought early in the pandemic).  Naturally, PPE (gloves and face coverings) have a role to play, but the masks in particular are far from sure protection.  So you will want to add administrative controls, such as limiting the sharing of items such as respirator masks and hand tools, and requiring that they be diligently cleaned and sanitized between uses.  “Social distancing,” and planning the scheduling of tasks to be performed in indoor spaces so as to permit distancing and, more generally, reduce the number of people present in indoor work areas simultaneously, are further administrative controls that should be helpful in curbing transmission.

Yet another administrative measure you might consider where, for example, you learn that symptomatic individuals have recently been present in an area, especially a closed, indoor space, where work is needed is to postpone that particular work, and deploy those forces elsewhere.

Of course, while limiting proximity (and crowding) as among employees is part of this equation, so, too, do you want to reduce potential worker exposure to occupants of building areas not under construction, customers, inspectors, visitors, or other outside individuals, as may enter or be present in the work area.  As you probably can’t prevent entirely the entry onto your site, or even into an enclosed area, of all who might possibly be infected (e.g., by testing all comers for the virus) this is a further administrative measure to implement.  Specifics to consider are placing plexiglass or other barriers to ensure that outside individuals cannot come closer than 6 feet to your workers; restricting access, or the numbers of individuals who can be present in proximity to your employees at any given time, or requiring that entrants be masked.

So, while basic PPE is a routine daily requirement, and special-purpose PPE is useful or indispensable for certain tasks, masks and gloves (even coupled with general exhortations to socially distance and wash one’s hands a lot, which may be difficult, or impossible to carry out) are by no means a sufficient ongoing response to Covid.  From today forward, a more attentive, analytical, well-organized and coordinated approach to integrating health and safety concerns is going to be required.  Consulting services from an industrial hygienist are also something you might consider.  Distancing, job hygiene (particularly with respect to PPE and tools that may be shared) and other Covid-specific measures now or hereafter recommended are likely to be leading priorities, but other perennial or job-specific hazards will also benefit from more attention, and better planning, the necessity for which needs to be seen as a fact of life going forward.  Consideration of the “hierarchy of controls” offers construction employers .an important analytical tool.

Whither Construction Safety in an Era of Massive Technological Change?

This series dates back about 14 years, and has always had OSHA compliance as a primary focus.  While the OSH Act, soon to be fifty years old, has never quite reached its stated goal of providing all workers in America with workplaces free from health and safety hazards, it has achieved much in reducing on-the-job mayhem.

If you are a construction company owner, executive, or field superintendent, you probably view OSHA as a welter of rules, some simple, but many of them complicated, and so numerous that few — if any — employers truly fulfill the mandate to train field employees, not only in all the OSHA rules that pertain closely to your company’s trade, but, in addition, hazards they might encounter, due to work being performed on the site by other trades.

While, increasingly, owners (and government bodies) are requiring OSHA cards for construction workers, I recall reading, just a few years ago, of a study at Tulane University, in which graduate students of engineering were given the OSHA 10-hour course and then (with dispiriting results) quizzed on how much of the material they had retained.  OSHA training is rich in jargon, buzzwords and acronyms.  Few of your rank-and-file workers have engineering degrees, and many have a first language other than English.  They may understand English poorly, or scarcely at all.

Supposedly, all are entitled to receive safety training in a language they understand.  Safety manuals are widely available in Spanish, but written materials (or competent construction trainers) can be hard to come by in Albanian, Somali, Gujurati, the dozens of African dialects widely spoken in the Bronx, or most of the 140 or so languages spoken in Queens County.

In short:  OSHA courses don’t hurt, and may be mandatory, but you’re kidding yourself if you think that OHSA 10- or 30-hour courses guarantee more than a rudimentary level of OSHA literacy in your workforce.

We have come to see construction safety as a set of rules, many of them supplied by OSHA, but others coming from New York’s Industrial Code and other sources.  In recent years, however — and this trend is likely to continue its sharp acceleration — sweeping changes in construction technology and practices have changed tremendously how projects, large and small, are carried out.

Here’s a partial list of things that have become widespread in just the last few years:

  • Onsite robots;
  • Drones, including drones integrated with software and hand-held devices to monitor workers, detect problems, and allow instantaneous communications, and on-the-fly changes;
  • 3-D printing technology;
  • Augmented and virtual reality;
  • “Green” technologies and materials (notably, “greener” asphalt);
  • Solar installations in roadways;
  • Modular construction, including very large projects.

While no doubt it’s thrilling, and potentially hugely profitable, if you happen to be on the bleeding edge of bringing these new technologies to construction sites, it should be sobering that, even as many tasks are, increasingly, being performed by smaller crews (and robots) the construction sector continues, alas, to account for approximately one-fifth of all occupational fatalities in the United States.

Tech changes bring both opportunities and challenges in terms of construction safety, but in years to come, the checking-off-boxes approach will likely be insufficient to get the job done, as additional, as-yet-unheard of technologies arrive on the scene and gain acceptance,

OSHA has resource (funding) as well as technical challenges facing it, but isn’t about to close up shop.  You will continue to have a legal duty to train and to enforce safety standards, even if the latter may struggle to keep pace with the sweeping technological changes in the industry.

Consider, as a basis for comparison, how in most localities in the U.S. and elsewhere in the developed world, roadway fatalities fell steadily for half a century, due to enforcement and other efforts to curb drunk driving, the required use of seat belts and child safety seats, better-designed cars, roads, lighting and signage systems, driver’s education programs, etc.

As you’re probably aware from daily alarms in the media, however, distracted drivers texting and talking on cell phones have given back a significant part of the gains realized over decades in reducing roadway fatalities.

Surviving the Interstate is, I believe, relatively easy, compared with going from ground-breaking to final completion on a large construction project.  Such projects typically involve multiple employers, diverse operations being carried out simultaneously, and rapid changes in tasks being performed as the project unfolds.

Construction operations involve tremendous numbers of moving parts, people working in trenches and hundreds of feet above grade, the use of heavy equipment and cranes, and delivery and other vehicles coming and going.  You drive your car in heated and air-conditioned comfort, but construction work may be performed in blistering heat, and sub-freezing temperatures.  Many projects — consider, for example, the construction, or the rehabilitation, of bridges, dams and other infrastructure — present tremendous public safety implications.  Work on highways and bridges is carried out in close proximity to traffic, often during nighttime hours.

  For years after the advent of cell phones, many construction employers forbade their use on the job.  Today, however, hand-held devices are increasingly indispensable for purposes of monitoring, transmitting images, and instantaneous communication, but not without risk of being a distraction.

How to confront the oncoming wave of safety challenges?

There isn’t a simple answer.  I do believe it’s going to require leadership, a collaborative and nimble approach, and — while you probably can’t give your workers a Ph.D. in construction safety, or OSHA compliance — you can give them the beginnings of wisdom, including that construction work is a fast-changing environment, and safety a shared responsibility.  You can demonstrate top-down commitment to avoiding injuries, and — this, I think, is critical — establish lines of communication (with workers, other trades, and vendors of new technologies).  When practical changes become desirable, in light of changes in technology, solutions must be devised and implemented among all stakeholders.

While new technologies often require fresh approaches, when knowing what to do to avoid perennial dangers such as falls is well-known, you’ve just got to do it.  Supervisors shouldn’t look the other way when, for example, if someone isn’t tied off while working on an elevated surface, or is working too close to live wires, or in an unshored trench.

Today, career success is not so much based on credentials, but increasingly a matter of flexibility, self-confidence, resilience, and a collaborative spirit.  Similarly, ensuring the safety of your workers, and the success of your business, will likely depend on attentiveness, persistence in communications, and doing whatever is needed to create a safe working environment.