Skip to main content

Author: WB&G

Frank Gramarossa portrait

Frank Gramarossa

Partner

Partner

Frank Gramarossa is a highly accomplished Partner at Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP with a strong background in construction and real estate law.

With a decade of experience in the business, Mr. Gramarossa has successfully litigated and defended claims across all areas of construction and real estate law. His practice focuses on breach of contract, mechanic’s liens, surety law, delay claims, extra work claims, and construction defect claims. In addition to his litigation experience, Mr. Gramarossa has extensive experience in transactional matters, including negotiating construction contracts, condominium offering plan applications, real estate closings, and corporate mergers and acquisitions.

Prior to joining WB&G, Mr. Gramarossa worked as an in-house counsel for a large general contractor in New York City, where he managed various legal aspects and compliance functions in support of Turner’s operations. He has also worked as an accountant at Turner Construction Company, where he gained valuable insight into the financial aspects of the construction industry.

Mr. Gramarossa’s unique background and experience working in different facets of the construction industry give him a comprehensive understanding of his clients’ needs. His extensive knowledge and focus in construction law and business operations make him a trusted advisor to construction professionals in various areas of the industry. Mr. Gramarossa joined WB&G in June of 2015 and has been an invaluable asset to the firm ever since.

Admissions

New York

New Jersey

United States District Courts for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York

Education

  • St. John’s University School of Law, J.D.

  • University of Scranton, B.S., Business Management

Associations

Columbian Lawyers of Westchester

Recent Articles

Continue reading

Gregory J. Spaun portrait

Gregory J. Spaun

Partner

Partner

Gregory J. Spaun is an accomplished Partner at Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP, concentrates his practice in construction and commercial litigation, as well as real estate and property litigation.

He has an impressive record of representing clients in high-stakes cases, including North Star Construction Corp. v MTA Capital Construction Corp., where he successfully argued on appeal that a negligent misrepresentation claim against an owner/designer should not be dismissed because of credible allegations of a relationship that was the functional equivalent of privity sufficient to get around the lack of an actual contractual relationship.

Mr. Spaun also achieved a significant victory in 110 Central Park South Corp. v 112 Central Park South, LLC, where he demonstrated that the common law implied housing warranty was superseded by Section 777 of New York’s General Business Law, thereby preventing a cooperative building owner from asserting such a claim.

Additionally, in Kamco Supply Corp. v JMT Brothers Realty, LLC, he prevailed on appeal in a case involving an unlicensed home improvement contractor’s material supplier, highlighting the importance of verifying the licensure status of upstream contractors to preserve the ability to assert claims such as mechanic’s lien claims.

Mr. Spaun’s extensive experience has also earned him the role of General Counsel to the Queens and Bronx Building Association, in addition to his work at WB&G.

Admissions

New York

Connecticut

United States District Courts for the Northern, Southern, Eastern and Western Districts of New York and the District of Connecticut

United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit

Education

  • Brooklyn Law School, J.D., cum laude

  • John Jay College of Criminal Justice, M.A., Criminal Justice

  • John Jay College of Criminal Justice, B.A., Criminal Justice, summa cum laude

Associations

  • General Counsel and Director at Large, Queens and Bronx Building Association
  • Member, Grievance Committee, Dutchess County Bar Association
  • Director at Large, Dutchess County Habitat for Humanity
  • Attorney-Client Fee Dispute Arbitrator, New York State Supreme Court, Ninth Judicial District
  • Served as an Appellate Court Attorney with the New York State Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Second Department

Recognitions

  • Martindale-Hubbell’s Preeminent AV Rating
  • Honored by the Exchange Club of Southern Dutchess for his assistance with patient care for a cardiac arrest patient who was successfully resuscitated

Prior to his legal career, Mr. Spaun served as a Crew Chief and Corporate Secretary for the Glen Oaks Volunteer Ambulance Corps and as an Emergency Medical Technician with the LaGrange Fire Department. His commitment to community service was recognized by the Exchange Club of Southern Dutchess for his assistance with patient care for a cardiac arrest patient who was successfully resuscitated.

Recent Articles

Continue reading

Michael E. Greenblatt portrait

Michael E. Greenblatt

Founder & Senior Counsel

Founder & Senior Counsel

Michael E. Greenblatt is a highly skilled Senior Counsel at Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP. He has been practicing law for over two decades, focusing on all aspects of construction law.

Mr. Greenblatt’s practice focuses on the management of complex litigation matters through arbitration and trial, where he has consistently achieved favorable results for his clients.

Mr. Greenblatt’s impressive track record includes successfully representing clients in high-stakes disputes involving breach of contract, mechanic’s liens, delay claims, construction defect claims, and surety law. He has also handled transactional matters, negotiating and drafting construction contracts, as well as conducting closings for real estate transactions.

Mr. Greenblatt is a respected authority in the field and has authored several articles on construction law. He is also a frequent speaker at industry conferences and continuing education courses for attorneys and construction professionals. His notable cases include West-Fair Electric Contractors, et al. v. Aetna Casualty & Surety Co., et al., and Atlas Building Systems, Inc. v. Rende, both of which have been reported in legal journals.

Admissions

New York

New Jersey

Connecticut

Pennsylvania

Commonwealth of Massachusetts

District of Columbia

United States District Courts for the Northern, Southern, Eastern and Western Districts of New York

United States District Court for the District of New Jersey

United States District Court for the District of Connecticut

United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts

United States Courts of Appeals for the Second and Third Circuits

United States Supreme Court

Ninth District Court of Appeals

Education

  • St. John’s University Law School, J.D.

  • SUNY New Paltz, B.A.

Associations

Counsel for The Hudson Valley Mechanical Contractors Association, Inc.

Recognitions

  • Rated Distinguished by Martindale-Hubbell
  • Thomson Reuters Super Lawyers
  • U.S. News and World Report Best Lawyers
  • Fellow of the Construction Lawyers Association of America
  • Ranked Band 3 by Chambers & Partners
  • Fellow, Construction Lawyers Society of America
  • Member, Trial Law Institute & Diversity Law Institute
  • Barrister, Order of Maximus

Continue reading

Gerard P Brady portrait

Gerard P. Brady

Founder & Senior Counsel

Founder & Senior Counsel

Gerard P. Brady is a Founder and Senior Counsel at Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP. He concentrates his practice in construction law, lien law, and surety law, offering counsel to clients on complex construction-related disputes.

With extensive experience in resolving disputes through mediation, arbitration, litigation, and administrative proceedings, Mr. Brady has prosecuted and defended numerous claims, including extra and additional work claims, delay and impact claims, defective work claims, professional errors and omissions claims, trust fund diversion claims, and payment and performance bond claims. He has also served as an arbitrator and mediator for construction-related disputes and is a member of the Construction Industry Panel of Arbitrators for the American Arbitration Association.

Mr. Brady has an AV Preeminent Rating, the highest rating possible in both Legal Ability and Ethical Standards, from Martindale-Hubbell. He has also been recognized by Super Lawyers and Top Attorneys in New York. Notable cases he has worked on include North Star Contracting Corp. v. the City of New York, Commercial Electrical Contractors, Inc. v. Pavarini Construction Co., Inc., Board of Managers of the Hudson Street Condominium v. 195 Hudson Street Associates, LLC, et al., and Liberty Electrical Supply Co., Inc. v. National Union Fire Insurance Co. of Pittsburgh, PA.

Mr. Brady is a Registered Professional Engineer in New York State and is a frequent speaker on construction law topics in various continuing education courses for attorneys and construction professionals.

Admissions

New York

New Jersey

United States District Courts for the Eastern, Southern and Northern Districts of New York

United States District Court for the District of New Jersey

Education

  • Pace University Law School, J.D.

  • Manhattan College, B.C.E.

  • New York University, M.S.C.E., (f/k/a Polytech Institute of New York)

Associations

  • Construction Industry Panel of Arbitrators for the American Arbitration Association
  • Formerly President of the Lower Hudson Valley Branch of the American Society of Civil Engineers
  • Moles and serves as the Moles’ General Counsel

Recognitions

  • Martindale-Hubbell’s Preeminent AV Rating (Highest Rating Possible in both Legal Ability and Ethical Standards)
  • Recognized by Super Lawyers and Top Attorneys in New York

Continue reading

Thomas H Welby portrait

Thomas H. Welby

Thomas H. Welby

Founder & Senior Counsel

Thomas H. Welby

Founder & Senior Counsel

Thomas H. Welby is the Founder and Senior Counsel at Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP, where he provides comprehensive counsel on all aspects of construction law.

Mr. Welby’s practice includes contract disputes, public bidding, mechanic’s liens, and construction claims. He has extensive experience representing general contractors, subcontractors, owners, developers, sureties, suppliers, and engineers in transactional matters as well as the prosecution and defense of claims in litigation, arbitration, and mediation.

Mr. Welby’s notable cases include West-Fair Electric Contractors v. Aetna, Waltech Construction v. Town of Thompson, and Beninati Roofing v. Gelco Builders. Prior to his legal career, Mr. Welby worked as a field engineer, estimator, and executive at various engineering and contracting firms, gaining extensive experience in the construction industry. He is a Registered Professional Engineer in the states of New York and New Jersey (now inactive). Additionally, Mr. Welby served as an Adjunct Professor of Civil Engineering at Manhattan College and Adjunct Professor of Law at Pace University School of Law for many years.

Admissions

New York

Connecticut

United States District Courts for the Eastern, Southern and Northern Districts of New York

United States District Court for the District of Connecticut

United States Courts of Appeals for the Second and Federal Circuits

United States Supreme Court

Education

  • Pace University School of Law, J.D.

  • Polytechnic Institute of New York, M.S., Civil Engineering

  • Polytechnic Institute of New York, Certificate in Construction Management

  • New York University, M.S., Geotechnical and Structural Engineering

  • New Mexico Highlands University, Master of Business Administration

  • Manhattan College, B.E., Civil Engineering

Associations

  • Fellow Chartered Institute of Arbitrators, ADR Subcommittee of Construction Litigation Committee, ABA Section of Litigation
  • AAA Arbitrator, Large Complex Construction Panel
  • AAA National Construction Master Mediator
  • ABA Forum on Construction Law
  • Construction Management Association of America – Past Chair, Legal Counsel Committee
  • National Construction Dispute Resolution Committee
  • General Counsel to Construction Industry Counsel of Westchester and the Hudson Valley
  • The Moles – Member
  • Dispute Resolution Board Foundation

Recognitions

  • Super Lawyers, Thomson Reuters
  • Best Lawyers, U.S. News and World Report
  • Martindale-Hubbell’s Preeminent AV Rating
  • Chi Epsilon Chapter Honorary Member, Manhattan College
  • Distinguished Service Award, Pace Law School

Recent Articles

Continue reading

Paul G Ryan Portrait

Paul G. Ryan

Partner

Partner

Paul G. Ryan is a Partner at Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP, with extensive experience in construction law, surety law, and general commercial litigation. He also collaborates with a range of architects and engineers on complex matters.

Mr. Ryan has litigated complex commercial and construction disputes in state and federal courts across New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut, and has represented clients in matters venued in California through pro hac vice admission and in coordination with local counsel. He has extensive experience arbitrating and mediating cases before the American Arbitration Association.

Admissions

New York

Connecticut

New Jersey

United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit

United States District Courts for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York

United States District Court for the District of Connecticut

United States District Court for the District of New Jersey

Education

  • Quinnipiac University School of Law, J.D.

  • Syracuse University, B.A.

Associations

  • New York State Bar Association
  • American Bar Association – Forum on Construction Law
  • Connecticut Bar Association
  • Executive Advisory Committee for the Subcontractors Trade Association of New York City
  • Member of the Connecticut Contractors Industry Association
  • Member of the Associated General Contractors
  • Member of the Building Trade Employers Association
  • Member of the Greater New York Construction Users Council
  • Member of the Hudson Valley Mechanical Contractor’s Association
  • Member of Catholics in Construction
  • Member of the New York Building Congress
  • Member of the Surety Association of New Jersey
  • Member of the New York Surety Association

Recognitions

Super Lawyers New York Metro, 2013, 2014, 2024

Continue reading

Anthony Carlucci portrait

Anthony P. Carlucci, Jr.

Partner

Partner

Anthony P. Carlucci, Jr. is a Partner at Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP with extensive experience in construction law.

His practice is dedicated to assisting clients with both private and public construction contracts, architect and engineering insurance defense, and surety law.

Mr. Carlucci has represented a diverse range of clients, including general contractors, subcontractors, suppliers, design professionals, construction managers, and owners. He has extensive experience before the American Arbitration Association and effectively resolves issues that arise during all phases of construction projects.

Mr. Carlucci counsels and advises clients on contract preparation, administration, and termination, as well as prosecution and defense of claims. With his understanding of the construction industry, Mr. Carlucci provides clients with strategic, effective legal solutions that help them achieve their goals.

Admissions

New York

New Jersey

United States District Courts for the Southern, Eastern and Northern Districts of New York

United States District Court for the District of New Jersey

Education

  • Pace University School of Law, J.D.

  • Marist College, B.S., Business Administration

Associations

Board Member for Family Friends Future, Inc., a non-profit organization dedicated to raising awareness, education and resources for Alzheimer’s and other related dementia diseases.

Recognitions

  • Best Lawyers
  • Super Lawyer
  • Martindale-Hubbell’s Preeminent AV rating

Recent Articles

Continue reading

Thomas S Tripodianos portrait

Thomas S. Tripodianos

Partner

Partner

Thomas S. Tripodianos is a Partner at Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP, where he is involved in all aspects of construction, labor, and employment law.

Doing a good job for the range of clients we represent—buyers, sellers, lenders, developers, general contractors, construction managers, owners, architects, engineers, subcontractors, suppliers, sureties and other entities—means going beyond essential legal services to developing relationships and a deep understanding of client goals and needs. 

As a first-generation Greek American, Mr. Tripodianos’ interest in real estate and construction law grew out of his early responsibilities managing properties for his family’s business in Queens. Mr. Tripodianos is a mentor for the next generation of attorneys, providing thoughtful leadership, actively participating in industry organizations and committees, and making connections. Putting two clients together who may not otherwise have joined forces and seeing their ventures succeed is one of his most satisfying aspects of work. Mr. Tripodianos prides himself on going beyond essential legal services to developing relationships and a deep understanding of client goals and needs.

Admissions

New York

Connecticut

Commonwealth of Pennsylvania

Commonwealth of Massachusetts

United States District Courts for the Eastern, Southern and Northern Districts of New York, the District of Massachusetts, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit

Education

  • Hofstra University School of Law, J.D.

  • St. John’s University, B.A., Government, magna cum laude

Associations

  • Director of the New York City Chapter of the Construction Financial Management Association (CFMA)
  • New York Building Congress
  • Construction Law Committee
  • Education, Arts & Culture Committee
  • Energy & Sustainability Committee
  • Government Affairs Committee; Planning, Growth & Sustainability Committee
  • Public Building & Procurement Committee
  • Transportation & Infrastructure Committee
  • President of the Construction Financial Manager Association, New York City Chapter
  • Orange County Bar Association: Construction Law Committee Chair; Judiciary; Committee Continuing Legal Education Committee
  • Past President Hudson Valley Builders and Remodelers Association Board of Directors: Education Committee Chair; Grievance Committee Chair; Membership Committee
  • Associate Director of New York State Builders Association
  • Chairman for Legal Defense Fund
  • Lorman Faculty Member
  • American Hellenic Educational Progressive Association (AHEPA)
  • Free and Accepted Masons

Recognitions

  • Martindale-Hubbell® AV Preeminent® rating
  • Selected for inclusion in New York Super Lawyers
  • Trained in Alternative Dispute Resolution
  • Top Attorneys in New York Metro/Westchester

Mr. Tripodianos is a New York State Licensed Real Estate Broker and a frequent speaker at national and local professional and trade organizations, including Lorman, the International Risk Management Institute, and the Building Realty Institute.

Recent Articles

Continue reading

Supreme Court Rules that Mechanic’s Lien is Void Due to Willful Exaggeration and Homeowners are Entitled to Damages

The lien law affords contractors a safeguard for payment in connection with the improvement of real property in the form of a mechanic’s lien, which can ultimately be foreclosed like a mortgage. This is separate from, and in addition to, any breach of contract or other claims that may be asserted against the non-paying owner or contractor in connection with the project. In the recent case of Gregory Allan Cramer & Co. Inc. v. Robert Edward Rescoe and Erin Stacy Rescoe, the Court also reminds us that the amount stated in the lien must not be willfully exaggerated. If a lien is found to have been willfully exaggerated, courts have authority to, among other things, void the lien and award statutory damages to property owners. Cramer also stands for the principle that a construction contract for a home improvement project can be deemed unenforceable if the contract is not compliant with applicable consumer protection statutes, or is ambiguous with respect to key provisions—such as the project completion date.

In Cramer, the Rescoes hired Cramer & Co. an interior designer and contractor, to renovate and furnish their home in Westchester County. The contract entitled Cramer & Co. to a 25% commission on the total net budget, and required them to provide detailed documentation for all goods and services. The Rescoes ultimately paid Cramer & Co. over $780,000, though the certificate of occupancy (CO) was never procured. A dispute arose over the final balance, which Cramer & Co. claimed to be $152,924.90. This was substantially more than the previously discussed remaining balance of $43,000.

The Rescoes alleged that the mechanic’s lien filed by Cramer & Co. was willfully exaggerated. In doing so, they cited discrepancies such as inflated invoices, missing receipts, and goods that did not constitute permanent improvements. The court noted that some items listed as “gifts” or “free of charge” were later included in the lien claim. The Rescoes also argued Cramer & Co.  failed to perform agreed work including, but not limited to, obtaining the CO. (The Rescoes also claimed that Cramer & Co. took affirmative steps with the village to impede the CO procurement process.)

The court found that Cramer & Co.’s testimony was not credible, and it determined that the lien was willfully exaggerated. The court also found that Cramer & Co. acted in bad faith and breached the contract by failing to complete the work, and by obstructing the CO process. Specifically, the record showed that the lien included items explicitly waived, or never agreed upon by and between the parties.

The court further rejected Cramer & Co.’s breach of contract claims due to its non-compliance with Section 771 of the General Business Law (which provides for certain requirements in home improvement contracts), lack of performance, and absence of agreed pricing or documentation. As a result, the court (i) declared Cramer & Co.’s  mechanic’s lien void due to its willful exaggeration; (ii) awarded the Rescoes  $109,924.77 in statutory damages (the difference between the lien amount and the previously agreed-upon balance), plus costs and prejudgment interest at 9%; and (iii) ordered Cramer & Co. to pay the Rescoes’ attorneys’ fees as the non-prevailing party under the contract.

This case underscores the importance of correctly identifying the amounts to be included in a mechanic’s lien filing, and the grave consequences of failing to do so. Additionally, the case reminds us that it is critical for home improvement contractors and owners to only enter into contracts that are compliant with Section 771 of the General Business Law, as well any local requirements.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Andrew E. Zeyer at azeyer@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6485

Understanding Suspension-of-Work Clauses: Insights from a Recent Agency Decision

Construction contracts, much like other contracts, are designed to delineate the rights and obligations of the parties involved. These contracts often contain detailed provisions that dictate these rights and obligations, frequently incorporating terms from other documents or agreements, especially in public project contracts. These contracts are typically intricate, accounting for numerous potential scenarios that could arise during construction, including ordinary events and extraordinary situations.

A recent decision by the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals in Granite Construction Company highlights the complexities and potential issues that can arise with such detailed contracts involving government projects (Granite Construction Company, ASBCA No. 62281, November 1, 2023).

Background

In the Granite case, the contractor entered into a contract with the United States Army Corps of Engineers to construct new outlet structures and cutoff walls at two dams in Houston as part of a federal flood control project. The contract included a suspension-of-work clause incorporated by reference and a provision detailing how time extensions and compensation for delay costs would be handled in the event of unusually severe weather.

In August 2017, after work had commenced, Hurricane Harvey caused substantial rain and flooding at the project site, leading to the release of water from the dams by the government. Consequently, the government issued a suspension of work, instructing the contractor to stop work on the project. This suspension lasted for approximately 49 days.

The contractor subsequently filed a request for equitable adjustment related to the costs incurred due to the suspension. Although the parties executed a modification for 30 days of the suspension, they did not resolve the issue of compensation for the remaining 19 days. The government contended that the 19 days were anticipated adverse weather days, as identified in the contract, leading to a dispute.

Decision

The Board granted the contractor partial summary judgment, holding that adverse weather delays specified in contract section 1.4 could not be subtracted from a suspension period issued under the suspension-of-work clause. The Board clarified that section 1.4 only defines “unusually severe weather” for determining if a default is excused under the default clause, with no connection to the suspension-of-work clause.

The Board stated that the remaining issue was whether the 49-day suspension period was “reasonable” under the suspension-of-work clause. According to the clause, a contractor is entitled to an equitable adjustment only if the government suspends work for an unreasonable period, thereby delaying the project.

To prove entitlement, the contractor had to establish:

  1. There was an unreasonable delay extending the contract completion time.
  2. The unreasonable delay was caused by the government’s actions or inactions.
  3. The delay resulted in injury to the contractor.
  4. There was no concurrent delay attributable to the contractor.

However, the Board concluded that the contractor was not entitled to compensation for the full 49-day suspension. The contractor did not prove that the government suspended the contract for an unreasonable amount of time, noting that the contractor could perform other work during the suspension period. The contractor’s reports indicated that critical activities could not be performed during the 49-day period, and the delay was proximately caused by the flood, not the government.

Commentary

The Granite decision underscores two critical points:

  1. Thorough Contract Review: Contracts should be meticulously reviewed and understood before signing.
  2. Meticulous Clause Interpretation: When a contract clause is triggered, it must be carefully reviewed to properly interpret and apply the clause to avoid further issues.

Failure to adhere to these practices can lead to significant financial consequences, as demonstrated in the Granite case.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Andrew E. Zeyer at azeyer@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6485