Skip to main content

Lien Rights At Risk When Doing Business With Unlicensed Contractor

The Lien Law provides a remedy to unpaid subcontractors and suppliers by allowing them to file a mechanic’s lien directly against an owner’s property. However, this remedy is not unlimited and is balanced against the countervailing consideration of preventing the owner from having to pay twice for the same work or materials. Thus, while an unpaid subcontractor or supplier may file a mechanic’s lien, the lien is derivative of the general contractor’s right to recover from the owner. If the owner has paid the general contractor in full, there is no lien fund from which a subcontractor or supplier lienor may recover. 

In Kamco Supply Corp. v JMT Bros. Realty, LLC, which was successfully argued on appeal by this author’s associate, the appellate court dealt with the issue of whether a supplier (and, by extension, a subcontractor) can recover when the reason for the lack of a lien fund is attributable to the general contractor’s inability to recover, as opposed to the owner’s full payment to the general contractor.

Background 

J.M.T. Brothers Realty, Inc., a homeowner, retained a general contractor who turned out not to have the home improvement license required by the New York City Administrative Code. There are similar provisions applicable to home improvement contractors doing business in Westchester, Rockland, Putnam, Nassau and Suffolk Counties. Kamco Supply Corp., a supplier, entered into a contract with the unlicensed general contractor to furnish windows to the project. The supplier did not have a contractual relationship with the homeowner. The homeowner eventually terminated the general contractor and claimed various backcharges against the contractor. After the contractor was terminated, the supplier filed a mechanic’s lien against the homeowner’s property and started a lawsuit to foreclose that lien. 

Early in the lawsuit, the homeowner moved to dismiss the lien foreclosure action arguing that because the supplier’s lien rights were derivative of the general contractor’s rights, the general contractor could not recover from the homeowner because the contractor was not licensed as a home improvement contractor. Therefore, the homeowner argued, there was no lien fund from which the supplier could recover from the homeowner. The trial court agreed and dismissed the supplier’s lawsuit. The supplier appealed the decision.

Decision

The appellate court affirmed. The court held that the contractor’s unlicensed status made its contract with the homeowner unenforceable. Therefore, there could be no funds due or owing from the homeowner to the unlicensed contractor which would support the supplier’s mechanic’s lien. In the absence of a direct contractual relationship between the homeowners and the supplier, the supplier could not recover on its lien foreclosure action against the homeowner. 

Comment

A subcontractor’s or supplier’s lien can only be satisfied out of monies due and owing from the owner to the contractor at the time the lien is filed. In this case, there were no monies due to the contractor because of its unlicensed status. A subcontractor or supplier would be well advised to research the licensing status of a home improvement contractor before they contract because their lien rights may be adversely impacted if the contractor is unlicensed.

New York City Issues New BIM Standards

The New York City Department of Design and Construction (DDC) has become the most recent agency to issue building-information-modeling (BIM) technology standards. The standards issued relate to the design and construction of new public buildings and seek to establish a framework for the implementation of 3-D design technologies and BIM processes on DDC-managed projects. Specifically, the new standards require the use of BIM on projects valued between $15 million and $50 million. According to DDC Commissioner David J. Burney, “BIM strengthens collaboration by allowing all members of the design team to accurately add, to a shared database, information about how a building looks and functions.”

Similar to the DDC, this past April the New York City Department of Buildings (DOB) established a program by which 3-D site safety plans are accepted in an attempt to expedite the permit approval process. The program presents DOB inspectors with the unique opportunity to take an interactive virtual tour illustrating how the City’s largest projects will be built. This allows the DOB to successfully evaluate a project’s safety measures and potential complexities prior to construction. With the launching of this program, New York City has become one of the first cities worldwide to accept 3-D plans for construction approvals.

If you would like more information on this issue or any other construction related issue, please contact Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP at (914) 428-2100.

Safety Policy: Basics of Concrete and Masonry Construction Safety

Now and then it’s a good idea to review the foremost safety and OSHA compliance concerns peculiar to your trade. While many of the concepts will be familiar, it’s dismaying how often employers are cited for violating everyday, easily-complied-with stand-ards.

Safety “Rule One” for concrete and masonry work is that a load must not be placed on any portion of a structure, until a qualified structural designer has determined that the structure is capable of supporting it.

Concrete pour operations should be directly overseen by a competent supervisor. This should include a safety briefing to all employees, the inspection of forms and reinforcing materials, bracing, troughs, and Personal Protective Equipment, and conformity with relevant drawings and structural details. Protective head and face equipment should be worn, whenever concrete is to be applied using a pneumatic hose

Reinforcing steel for walls, piers, columns and other vertical structures must be adequately supported, and employers must take measures to prevent unrolled wire mesh from recoiling.

Laxity in protecting employees from impalement is a frequently-cited OSHA violation. All protruding rein-for¬c¬ing steel, onto or into which someone might fall, must be guarded. Use only hard plastic mushroom-type caps, or other approved devices (not paper cups, orange traffic cones, or tape). Guardrails, or other fall protection measures, should be implemented, to safeguard employees in areas from which they could fall onto rebar.

A restricted-access zone is required, where a masonry wall is being built. The zone should be as long as the wall under construction, and extend out from the base for a distance four feet greater than the height of the wall. The zone should be clearly marked off, and only employees actually working on the construction of the wall should be permitted in the area. The failure to create and enforce such a zone is another frequently-cited OSHA violation.

Similarly, post tensioning operations should be performed within a limited-access area, with access permitted only to employees essential to the tensioning operations.

To the extent practicable, elevated concrete buckets should be routed to eliminate, or minimize, risks to employees from falling concrete buckets. No one should be permitted to ride in a concrete bucket, or to work beneath one as it is being raised or lowered.

Formwork must be designed, fabricated, erected, supported, braced and maintained, so that it will not fail in supporting all vertical and lateral loads applied to it. Drawings and plans, including all revisions, for the jack layout, formwork (including shoring equipment), working decks, and scaffolds, must be available at the jobsite. Failure to comply with this requirement is frequently cited by OSHA inspectors.

Shoring (and reshoring) equipment must be inspected prior to erection, to avoid the use of damaged equipment, and to determine conformity with the formwork drawings. Erected shoring equipment must be inspected immediately prior to, during, and immediately after concrete placement. Damaged or weakened equipment must be reinforced at once.

Sills used for shoring must be sound, rigid, and capable of carrying their maximum intended load. All base plates, shore heads, extension devices, and adjustment screws must be in firm contact and secured, when necessary, with the foundation and the form. “Eccentric” loads on shore heads (anywhere other than where the shore head has been designed to accept them) must be avoided.

If single-post shores are “tiered,” or placed one on top of another, additional requirements must be met. The shores must be designed by a qualified designer; vertically aligned; spliced to prevent misalignment; adequately braced in two mutually-perpendicular directions at the splice level (each tier to be diagonally braced in the same two directions); and inspected, after erection, by a qualified engineer.

The adjustment of single-post shores to raise formwork must not be made after the placement of concrete. Reshoring must be erected, as the original forms and shores are removed, whenever the concrete is required to support loads exceeding its capacity.

The steel rods or pipes on which vertical slip forms (i.e., forms jacked vertically during the placement of concrete) must be specifically designed for that purpose, and adequately braced where not encased in concrete. Forms must be designed to prevent excessive distortion of the structure during jacking. Jacks and vertical supports must be positioned in such a manner that the loads do not exceed the jacks’ rated capacity.

Jacks or other lifting devices must be provided with mechanical dogs, or other automatic holding devices, to support the slip forms, should there occur a failure of the power supply or the lifting mechanism itself.

During jacking, the predetermined safe rate of lift must not be exceeded, and the form structure must be maintained within design tolerances for plumbness. All vertical slip forms must be provided with scaffolds, or work platforms, where employees are required to work or pass.

Forms and shores must not be removed until the concrete has gained sufficient strength, based on compliance with conditions stipulated in the plans and specifications, or testing by an ASTM standard method, verifying sufficient compressive strength.

Precast concrete wall units, structural framing, and tilt-up wall panels must be adequately supported until permanent connections are completed. Lifting inserts for tilt-up wall panels must be capable of supporting at least twice the maximum intended load; inserts for other precise members must be capable of supporting four times the load. Lifting hardware must be able to support at least five times the maximum load to be applied or transmitted to it.

“Lift-slab” operations are subject to many requirements applicable to vertical slip form jacking operations. Jacking equipment (and all load-bearing components) must be capable of supporting at least 2-1/2 times the load being lifted, and must not be overloaded. Units must be designed to support the load, at any position, in the event of malfunction or power failure, and to stop lifting if overloaded.

All lift-slab operations must be pre-planned by an experienced professional engineer, with plans to include detailed instructions and sketches. The plans and designs must also provide for maintaining the lateral stability of the building or structure during construction.

No non-essential employee shall be permitted in the building or structure while any jacking operation is taking place, unless a licensed professional engineer, independent of the engineer who designed and planned the lifting operation, has determined from the plans that the building/structure has been reinforced sufficiently to ensure that, in the event of a loss of support at any jack location, such loss will be confined to that location. No non-essential employee shall be permitted beneath a slab, while it is being lifted.

Any masonry wall over 8′, if not supported by itself or by another structure, must be braced to prevent tipping over or collapsing. The bracing should be prescribed by a competent person or the project engineer, taking wind loads into account. The bracing must remain in place until the engineer of record has given written consent, and the wall is permanently supported by the rest of the structure. Failure to comply with these requirements is a frequent ground for OSHA citations.

Statute of Limitations for Lawsuit Between HOA and Developer

Question. Can a Home Owners Association (HOA) sue a developer of residential units completed and sold fifteen years ago for indemnification when a resident slips and falls in the street even though the statute of limitations (the time within which a law suit can be commenced) for negligence is three years and for breach of contract six years?

Answer. YES. The answer to whether someone can sue you is almost always yes. However, before thoughts of never-ending liability come into mind realize this does not mean all lawsuits are successful. Unfortunately, even unsuccessful suits must be defended.

The lawsuit we are talking about here arises when the plaintiff slipped on black ice. The plaintiff sued the HOA and the snow removal company. The HOA in turn sued the developer for breach of contract, negligence and common law indemnification. The breach of contract and negligence claims are clearly outside the statute of limitations and will fail. The common law indemnification is viable.

The statute of limitations applicable to a claim of common law indemnification is six years. The concept of common law indemnification (also referred to as “implied indemnification”) is rooted in the principal of equity and recognizes that a person who, in whole or in part, has discharged a duty which is owed by him but which as between himself and another should have been discharged by the other, is entitled to indemnity. In other words, if and when the HOA is made to pay for plaintiff’s injuries the HOA argues, such payment should have been made by the Developer. Therefore, because of the quasi contractual nature of the indemnification action, the six year limitations period applicable to a breach of contract claim is applied.

However, a cause of action for indemnification is not complete until loss is suffered. This occurs upon payment by the party seeking indemnity. An indemnity claim is a substantive cause of action that is independent of the underlying wrong for which the claim arises out of (i.e. the slip and fall). So the clock on the six year statute of limitations for indemnification does not begin to tick until the HOA is compelled to pay the plaintiff. Nonetheless, asserting such a claim before a loss has been suffered is permissib le.

So we’ve now established that the HOA can sue. But will they win? In order for a party to establish a claim for common law indemnification, it must be proven (1) that the party seeking indemnification [the HOA] was not negligent, (2) that the person indemnification is being sought from (the indemnitor) [the Developer] was responsible for the negligence that contributed to the injury claimed, and (3) in the absence of negligence, that the indemnitor [the Developer] had the authority to direct, supervise and control the work giving rise to the injury, and that the indemnitor [the Developer] actually exercised such supervision and control.

Common-law indemnification is predicated on “vicarious liability without actual fault,” which necessitates that a party who has itself actually participated to some degree in the wrongdoing cannot receive the benefits of the doctrine. So if for example, the HOA failed to properly maintain the sidewalk and street (as is required by many offering plans and municipal codes) and that failure contributed in even the most minute way to plaintiff’s injuries, the HOA’s cause of action for common law indemnification will also fail. If the HOA is found liable in the main action, it will likely be because it failed in these duties and consequently shares part of the blame. Therefore, it will likely be barred from obtaining indemnification.

Possible Amendments to Statutes Regarding Negligence Indemnification Clauses and the Pro Rata Approach for Distributing Trust Funds

There are two important bills that will soon be proposed to the New York State Senate and Assembly. These bills, if passed, will directly affect contractors across the state.

Currently, New York General Obligations Law Section 5-322.1 provides that contractual clauses purporting to indemnify higher tier contractors on a project (and owners) for their own negligence are void and unenforceable. Owners and contractors have circumvented the purpose of this law by simply requiring that the lower tier contractors of whom indemnity cannot be sought, name owners and contractors as additional insureds. The proposed bill would invalidate any contract provision requiring such insurance for the scope of what is otherwise prohibited by section 5-322.1.

The second bill potentially affects the operations of New York Lien Law’s trust fund statutes. Generally, the trust fund statues provide that all monies received by a party on a construction project are to be used to pay those furnishing labor, materials and equipment to the project. When funds are diverted to another project, claims ensue. If there isn’t enough money to pay all of the claimants, New York Lien Law currently distributes the available funds on a pro rata basis, based upon the amount of the claim; i.e., the amount left unpaid. The bill seeks to alter this formula by distributing the funds on a pro rata basis, based upon the total value of each claim; i.e. the amounts unpaid and the amounts already received. The current formula allows the earlier completing contractors (or the more vigilant ones) to fare better overall on the project by getting a larger piece of the proverbial pie. The amendment puts all claimants in the same position, as if no one had been paid anything.

Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP will monitor the progress of these two bills and will advise as to their progress.

If you have any questions about the information set forth in this Legal Alert, call us at 914-428-2100.

Notice of pendency cannot be extended after it expires.

On June 13, 2012, the Second Department of the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York issued a decision holding that a lapsed notice of pendency cannot be extended.

In Ampul Electric, Inc. v. Village of Port Chester, 96 A.D.3d 790 [2d Dept. 2012], the mechanic’s lien foreclosure action was commenced in October 2006 and a notice of pendency was filed at that time. A notice of pendency is required to extend a lien and to maintain a public lien foreclosure action, but it expires after 3 years unless an application is filed to extend the notice of pendency for another 3 years for good cause.

The Supreme Court judge stayed the lien foreclosure action in March of 2009 because one of the parties filed for bankruptcy. In June of 2010, the lienor withdrew its claims in the Bankrupcty Court. In July 2010, the lienor moved in the Supreme Court to extend the notice of pendency nunc pro tunc (i.e., “now for then”, or retroactively). The defendants filed a cross-motion to cancel the notice of pendency. The Supreme Court denied the lienor’s motion and granted the defendants’ cross-motion to cancel the notice of pendency.

The Second Department affirmed the Supreme Court, finding that an expired notice of pendency is a nullity and may not be revived. Pursuant to CPLR 6513, the notice of pendency had to be extended before it lapsed. Here, the notice of pendency expired in October 2009 such that the application to extend it was untimely. Since the stay of the action did not appear to apply to the notice of pendency, notices of pendency should be extended before they lapse even when an action has been stayed. Even though you may not be able to prosecute your action or lien, you will have to incur legal fees to maintain your action alive even during a stay.

N.B. This decision applies to Notices of Pendency in connection with PRIVATE liens. Those in connection with PUBLIC liens are extended 3+ years; i.e., permanently. See Yula, 342 NYS2 673 and Belt, 457 NYS2 632 (3rd, 1982); 469 NYS2 1023 (lv. to app. den’d).

If you would like more information on this issue or any other construction issue, please contact Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP.

Court Of Appeals Upholds Insurance Carrier’s Right to Deny Coverage to Additional Insureds Based on Misrepresentation by Named Insured

One of our prior Legal Alerts addressed the pitfalls of simply relying on a certificate of insurance with respect to coverage under insurance policies. A recent decision by the New York State Court of Appeals in Admiral Insurance Co. v. Joy Contractors, Inc. No. 93, NYLJ 1202559115718, at *1. June 12, 2012, underscores the need to obtain and review a full and complete copy of any insurance policy in which you or your company are named as additional insured so that you can confirm that you are actually covered.

Joy Contractors, Inc. was working as the concrete superstructure subcontractor on a luxury high rise condominium project located at 303 East 51st Street in Manhattan. A tower crane operated by Joy Contractors, Inc. collapsed on March 15, 2008 causing seven deaths, dozens of injuries and the destruction of a nearby building. Pursuant to its subcontract with the general contractor, Joy Contractors, Inc. was required to name the general contractor and project owner as additional insureds under its comprehensive general liability and excess policies.

At the time of the collapse, Joy carried a comprehensive general liability policy provided by Lincoln General Insurance and an excess policy provided by Admiral Insurance. The general contractor and project owner were named as additional insureds under the insurance policies. Apparently Joy Contractors, Inc. identified it as a drywall installer that did not perform exterior work in its application for insurance coverage.

Following the crane collapse, the general contractor and project owner sought coverage under the insurance policies obtained by Joy contractors, Inc., including the excess policy issued by Admiral Insurance. Admiral Insurance denied coverage to the general contractor and project owner because, among other things, the insurance policy was issued based on representations by Joy Contractors, Inc. in its insurance application that it was a drywall installer that did not perform any exterior work.

Admiral Insurance filed a lawsuit seeking a complete rescission of its insurance policy to avoid responsibility for any claims arising out of the crane collapse because the accident occurred as a result of Joy Contractors, Inc.’s work as a concrete superstructure subcontractor and not a drywall installer.

Initially, the lower courts held that issues regarding coverage of Joy Contractors, Inc. did not affect Admiral Insurance’s responsibility to provide coverage for the additional insureds (the general contractor and the project owner) based on the longstanding principal that an insurer has separate obligations to each of the insureds, and that wrongful actions or misleading information of an insured might relieve the insurer of its obligation to that particular insured, but not of its obligations to other insureds.

However, the New York State Court of Appeals overturned the decision of the lower courts and upheld Admiral Insurance’s right to deny coverage to the additional insureds because of the misrepresentations by Joy Contractors, Inc. in its insurance application. The Court of Appeals held that because Admiral Insurance believed it was providing coverage insuring for the risks associated with interior drywall installation and not the obviously much greater risk presented by exterior construction work with a tower crane at a height many stories above grade, it was not required to provide coverage for the general contractor and project owner.

Certificates of insurance do not tell the full story about what is and what is not actually covered in an insurance policy. Those certificates only identify the name of the carrier and the limits of liability. The policy and the endorsements are the only documents that identify who and what are actually covered and the circumstances under which a carrier is required to provide coverage.

It is highly recommended that you consult with your construction attorney and insurance broker to review your contracts and insurance policies under which you are named as an additional insured to ensure that you are obtaining the coverage and protection you need to avoid being left without insurance coverage.

If you would like more information on this issue or any other construction related issue, please contact Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP at (914) 428-2100.

Liquidation of First Sealord Surety, Inc.

On February 3, 2012, the Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania ordered First Sealord Surety, Inc. (“FSSI”), a surety licensed to do business in NY, NJ, and CT, into liquidation. Pursuant to the liquidation order, any FSSI surety bond, surety undertaking or policy still in effect as of February 3, 2012 will continue only until the earlier of the following: (1) thirty (30) days after the entry of the liquidation order, (2) the expiration of the bond, undertaking, or policy by its own terms, or (3) the date when the obligee or insured replaces the surety bond, undertaking or policy with equivalent coverage in another reinsurer or surety, or otherwise terminates the policy. All claims against FSSI, along with proof of said claims, must be filed on or before October 5, 2012. Claimants are barred from commencing actions against FSSI after the date of the of the liquidation order, unless express approval is obtained from the liquidator, and pending actions against FSSI are stayed.

Additional information about this liquidation and a copy of the proof of claim form are available at:

www.portal.state.pa.us/portal/server.pt/community/offices___organizational_charts/9304/first_sealord/1088423.

If you have any questions about the information set forth in this Legal Alert, call us at 914-428-2100.

Contractor Not Liable for Unpaid Wage Claims of Subcontractor’s Workers

A general contractor is not typically considered an employer of its subcontractors’ employees and is not responsible for unpaid wages of the subcontractor’s workforce. There are situations, however, where a general contractor acted as a “joint” employer of a subcontractor’s employees, thereby owing unpaid wages to a subcontractor’s employees. In the case of Matter of Ovadia v Office of the Industrial Board of Appeals, the Court of Appeals, New York’s highest court, ruled on whether a general contractor is a joint employer of its subcontractor’s employees.

Background

In 2006, a real estate developer hired HOD Construction Corp. to act as a general contractor for a construction project. HOD entered into a subcontract with Well Built Construction Corp. for the project’s masonry work. Pursuant to the subcontract, HOD paid Well Built and, in turn, Well Built paid the wages of its workers. The masonry workers were employed and supervised by Well Built. While the owner of HOD visited the work site several times a day, he spoke only with Well Built’s supervisor or owner.

Because of apparent cash flow issues, Well Built periodically underpaid its laborers and, ultimately, it abandoned the job and ceased paying its workers altogether. Upon the filing of an unpaid wage claim, the Department of Labor conducted an investigation and issued an order concluding that the general contractor assumed the status of an “employer” of Well Built’s workers. DOL then ordered the general contractor to pay over $117,000, which sum represented past-due wages, along with penalties and interest. HOD sought an administrative review and after a hearing, the Industrial Board of Appeals upheld the DOL’s order. HOD commenced an Article 78 proceeding seeking to annul the Board’s ruling. The Appellate Division confirmed the Board’s determination. HOD appealed the decision to the Court of Appeals.

In holding the general contractor liable for unpaid wages owing to the subcontractor’s employees as a “joint employer”, the lower court relied on certain factors to determine whether HOD was a joint employer of the subcontractor’s employees: (1) the general contractor provided the work site and the materials to be used by the subcontractor’s workers; (2) the workers worked at the general contractor’s project for the duration of the contract; and (3) the general contractor conducted routine quality control inspections at the job site.

Decision

The Court of Appeals reversed the lower court’s decision. The Court stated the general rule that a typical general contractor is not an employer of its subcontractor’s employees. The Court held that the lower court’s reliance on the facts that the general contractor provided the work site and materials used by the subcontractor’s workers for the duration of the project and the general contractor’s routine quality control inspections “would likely render most general contractors the joint employers of their subcontractors’ employees-a proposition that does not reflect the actual relationships in the construction industry.”

The Court also noted that a general contractor is expected to conduct routine quality inspections and ensure that the coordination of the work proceeds on schedule. This fact does not render the general contractor an employer of all workers at the job site.

Comment

While the Court of Appeals recognized that the relationship between HOD and Well Built was nothing more than the usual contractor/subcontractor relationship, the Court cautioned that its holding does not mean that a general contractor in a construction setting can never be an employer of its subcontractor’s employees. The Court pointed out that there may be situations where the business relationship between a general contractor and a subcontractor may support a finding that the general contractor assumed the role of employer of the subcontractor’s employees.

Safety Policy: Employees’ Acute Carbon Monoxide Poisoning Gets Contractor “Willful” OSHA Violations, $112,000 in Penalties

A Chicago-area concrete contractor was charged with three “Willful” OSHA violations, following an incident in which four employees were sickened, and two diagnosed with acute carbon monoxide poisoning.

At trial before an administrative law judge, the employer succeeded in having one of the three citation items vacated, and the other two reduced in gravity from “Willful” to “Serious.”

On appeal to the OSH Review Commission, however, the Commission reinstated the dismissed item and affirmed all three citation items as “Willful.” The Commission imposed penalties totaling $112,000.00.

The project was the pouring of a concrete floor inside a commercial structure being added to a pre-existing building. The new addition was 90 x 75 feet x 30 feet high. It was connected to the existing structure by an overhead door, which led to a vestibule area. In addition to the overhead door, which faced west onto a parking lot, there was a man door near the newly-constructed, steel-frame addition. A second man door was located on the southwest side of the building, which opened onto a parking lot on the adjoining street.

Elliott Construction, the employer, had a “flat work” crew of twelve at the site, under the direction of foreman Michael Dynowski. In setting up for the pour, Dynowski deployed three fans to provide ventilation, as a gasoline-powered laser screed, power rake, and power trowels were to be used in the indoor space. He set up two large industrial fans, one at the man door opening to the outside parking lot, and the other at the overhead door that led to the vestibule. A small pedestal fan was placed at the other man door, to blow air in from outside. Dynowski had had safety training regarding carbon monoxide (CO), and knew that CO, as would be emitted by the gasoline-powered equipment, posed a potential danger to his crew members’ health.

In addition to exhaust from gasoline-powered equipment being used indoors, the size of the pour required a dozen concrete trucks to remain idling, while parked near one of the building’s few openings.

At about 10:15 A.M., Employee “A” complained to Dynowski of a headache, but attributed it to a sinus condition. Employee “A” took an outdoor break of 15-20 minutes, and returned to work. A few minutes after Employee “A” went outside, Employee “B” reported feeling ill, at which point Dynowski, as he later testified, realized that “there was a carbon monoxide issue.”

Despite that realization, Dynowski did not stop the pour, even after Employee “B” vomited, and Employees “C” and “D” also reported feeling ill. Despite Elliott’s policy, which was to get everyone out of the building and to contact Safety Check (an outside consultant) to perform CO monitoring, Dynowski did nothing more than permit the affected workers to take breaks outdoors. A pause in the work was taken only when the supply of concrete ran out, and the crew had to wait for more to be delivered.

When the additional concrete arrived, Dynowski took the crew (minus the four ill employees) back inside, to resume working. Fortuitously, an employee from Safety Check stopped by on a routine visit, and summoned medical assistance.

All four workers were administered oxygen and taken to hospital, where Employees “C” and “D” were diagnosed with acute CO poisoning. Adjusted for time of exposure and timing of the blood tests, the test results calculated that Employee “C’s” exposure level was 104.1 PPM, and Employee “D’s” was 80.5 PPM. OSHA’s maximum Permissible Exposure Limit (PEL) for airborne CO is a time-weighted average of 50 PPM.

Elliott was cited for three violations. One was for failing to maintain a program providing for “frequent and regular inspections” of the job site, by failing to conduct air monitoring for CO. The other two items were for exposing Employees “C” and “D” to levels of CO above the PEL.

In part because, four years previously, Elliott had been cited for exposing seven employees to CO, at levels up to 4.4 times the PEL, the Secretary characterized the violations as “Willful,” and sought penalties of $112,000. Elliott contested all items and the penalties.

At trial, Elliott pointed out that the OSHA standard requiring “inspections,” unlike several other OSHA airborne contaminant standards, does not specifically require that the employer “monitor” or “test” the air. That’s a plausible argument, under the rule of statutory interpretation that, if a requirement appears in one or more provisions directed to a common end, its omission in other provisions having the same purpose should be regarded as deliberate. Based on that argument, the ALJ vacated the first, failure-to-inspect citation item.

The employer was less successful in its challenge to the excess-exposure citation items, which was based on evidentiary issues and expert witness testimony attacking the methodology employed, in the absence of monitoring at the site, to calculate the CO exposures of Employees “C” and “D” by working backward from their tested blood levels of carboxyhemoglobin, a byproduct of inhaling CO that reduces the blood’s oxygen-carrying capacity.

This latter challenge failed, the ALJ sidestepping the methodology issues by relying on monitoring by the local fire department following the workers’ exposure, all four employees’ symptoms during and after their exposure, and the indisputably elevated levels of carboxyhemoglobin in the blood of Employees “C” and “D.”

However, while the ALJ affirmed the two excess-exposure items, she fund in favor of the employer on the “close issue” of willfulness. As a result, these items were affirmed as “Serious” rather than “Willful,” and only $14,000 in penalties was assessed.

On review, the Commission reinstated the “failure to inspect” item, finding that the absence of the terms, “test” or “monitor” could not be determinative, given that, because CO is colorless and odorless, the only way to “inspect” a worksite to ensure that the PEL for CO will not be exceeded is by air monitoring.

The Commission further ruled all three violations to have been “Willful,” and increased the penalties from the $14,000 imposed by the ALJ to $112,000 as originally sought by the Secretary.

Gasoline-powered equipment is more commonly used outdoors. The indoor use of such equipment (if not equipped with catalytic converters) should be avoided where possible.

Engineering measures (the use of fans) to keep CO levels below the PEL were not, as required, approved for that particular use by a competent industrial hygienist, or other technically qualified person. Neither were respirators used.

Those omissions were particularly important in the Elliott case, because the building where the work was being performed was barrier-tight, and had few openings to the exterior.

In ruling the violations to be “Willful,” the Commission relied also on the fact that Elliott had adopted, but later abandoned, the daily use of CO monitors following the prior incident.

The hallmark of a “Willful” OSHA violation is an “intentional, knowing or voluntary disregard” for the requirements of the OSH Act, or “plain indifference to employee safety.” Apart from heftier penalties, and potential damage to your ability to get work, “Willful” violations are harmful to your firm’s reputation, and to employee morale as well.