Skip to main content

Court Rejects Personal Liability Against Corporate Owner

A corporation has an existence separate and apart from that of its individual officers, directors and shareholders. The general rule is that individual owners of a corporation are insulated from personal liability for corporate debts, and that individuals may incorporate a business for the very purpose of limiting their personal liability.

In certain circumstances, however, corporate owners may be personally liable for corporate debt. In the recent case of PGC Construction Corp. v Fudge, a building owner attempted to hold a sole shareholder, officer and director of a construction company personally liable for the company’s obligations under a construction contract.

Background

PGC Construction was retained by the Fudges to construct a second floor addition and other improvements to their home for a fixed price, with progress payments to be made during the job. About halfway through the job, the homeowners terminated PGC for cause, claiming that PGC failed to adequately protect the home from rain, resulting in damage to the first floor. PGC filed a mechanic’s lien on the property, claiming that $67,493 was still owed to it for labor and materials. PCG ultimately sued to foreclose the mechanic’s lien, and the Fudges counterclaimed against PGC for the damages to the first floor, defective work and the cost to complete the project.

The homeowners’ counterclaim also included a suit against PGC’s sole shareholder, Peter Gmelch, claiming that PGC was under the sole control of Gmelch, was undercapitalized, did not hold regular corporate meetings, commingled corporate funds with Gmelch and otherwise failed to observe corporate formalities. As to the claim that PGC was undercapitalized, the homeowners argued that during the time that PGC was working on their home, they were informed by the HVAC contractor that PGC had bounced checks it had issued to him on prior construction jobs. They also claimed that an electrical subcontractor informed them that he agreed to work on their home “so that Gmelch would pay him the amounts that he owed in connection with the work that the electrical contractor had performed on a prior project.” They also argued that as the sole shareholder, officer and director of PGC, Gmelch is personally liable for wrongfully filing a “frivolous and willfully exaggerated” mechanic’s lien against their property.

Gmelch moved to dismiss the claims against him personally, arguing that the claims as to the underfunding and lack of corporate formalities are false, and that there is no legal basis for holding him personally liable. The homeowners opposed the motion, claiming that the evidence submitted by Gmelch was insufficient to establish that PGC was sufficiently capitalized, holds regular corporate meetings, does not commingle funds and otherwise follows corporate formalities.

Decision

The court dismissed all claims of personal liability against Gmelch. In doing so, the court noted that a business can be incorporated for the very purpose of avoiding personal liability. Nevertheless, a court may impose personal liability on its shareholders to prevent fraud or illegality, or to achieve equity. The court further noted that courts hold shareholders personally liable for the debts of the corporation when the shareholder exercised complete domination of the corporation with respect to the transaction at issue and abused the privilege of doing business in the corporate form to perpetrate a wrong or an injustice.

After discussing the high burden a party faces when it wishes to impose personal liability, the court held that the homeowners failed to state any particular facts as to how Gmelch abused the privilege of doing business in a corporate form to commit a wrong against them. The court also rejected the hearsay and conclusory statements of the homeowners regarding PGC’s dealings with other contractors.  

Comment

The very purpose of doing business in the corporate form is to avoid personal liability for corporate debts. As this case demonstrates, the burden to hold a shareholder personally liable for the debts of the corporation is high. However, that burden is not insurmountable. A prudent contractor would be well advised to follow corporate formalities and make sure that corporate funds are not commingled for personal use.

Beware of the “Paperwork Breach”; it Can Prove Costly

 It is widely acknowledged that record keeping on a modern construction project can often seem as tedious and as difficult as the principal construction itself. Unfortunately, as a result, there are contractors who let paperwork requirements slip, preferring to focus on the construction itself. The mindset is often that building a good product is the best way to avoid litigation. However, the recent decision of the Appellate Division in High Tech Enterprises & Electrical Services of NY, Inc. v Expert Electrical, Inc. (113 AD3d 546 [1st Dept 2014]) highlights that a failure to adhere to “paperwork” requirements—even when there are no resulting or related problems—can support a claim for breach of contract and absolve the non-breaching party from the responsibility to pay for work actually performed.

The dispute in High Tech Enterprises arises out of a 2006 project for the New York City Department of Parks and Recreation. The Parks Department hired Expert Electrical as its prime contractor for the reconstruction of an electrical substation in Queens. Expert Electrical subcontracted certain work to High Tech, which High Tech performed in mid- to late-2007. High Tech submitted three payment applications to Expert Electrical, only two of which were paid.

During the project, city inspectors had visited the project site. This prompted Expert Electrical to perform an internal audit of its records. During this audit, Expert Electrical determined that High Tech failed to provide proper certified payroll records1 (the reports provided were not complete and had discrepancies in both the number of hours worked and the wage rate classifications), and that it failed to pay its workers prevailing wage and proper supplemental benefits. As a result, High Tech withheld the third payment—although the work addressed in the third payment application had been accepted by the owner and Expert Electrical had been paid for this work.

As a result of Expert Electrical’s failure to pay, High Tech ceased its work, asserted a mechanic’s lien and payment bond claim and, ultimately, commenced a lawsuit. Expert Electrical asserted counterclaims seeking to recover the excess completion costs it incurred after High Tech unilaterally suspended its work. In 2012, both parties moved and cross-moved for summary judgment. In support of its cross-motion and in opposition to Expert Electrical’s motion, High Tech contended that it had, in fact, properly paid its workers, and that this proper payment was best evidenced by the undisputed fact that that in the nearly five years since High Tech ceased its work at the project not a single one of its employees had complained about any alleged failure to pay wages, nor had any administrative agency issued a determination regarding any alleged violation of the prevailing wage statute (Labor Law §220).

In its decision, the trial court found in favor of High Tech. In doing so, the court held that “nothing in the contract may be interpreted as permitting Expert Electrical to withhold earned payment from High Tech, as the result of High Tech’s failure to pay prevailing wages, in any circumstances”. The Appellate Division reversed, finding that the High Tech’s refusal to provide an affidavit stating that all labor and materials had been paid for in full was a material breach of the contract, and that such refusal justified Expert Electrical’s failure to pay. The Appellate Division reasoned that the contract made the provision of the documentation a condition precedent to payment, and that since High Tech never provided the required documentation, Expert Electrical’s obligation to pay never came into being.

High Tech Enterprises provides a warning to contractors that providing solid paperwork is often just as crucial as performing solid work. If the provision of certain paperwork is specifically set forth in a contract (here, certified payroll reports and affidavits of payment), it can be characterized as a condition precedent to payment. As was demonstrated in High Tech Enterprises, upon High Tech’s failure to meet the condition precedent in the contract, Expert Electrical’s obligation to make payment never arose, despite that: 1) the work was actually performed and accepted and paid for by the owner; and 2) the problem which the paperwork requirement was designed to guard against (here, failing to properly pay employees) never arose.


1Although not clear from either the trial court’s or the appellate court’s decision, it appears that the discrepancies with the certified payroll documents were only discovered after High Tech had been paid. Inasmuch as the requirement to submit accurate certified payroll documents is statutory, it ostensibly had an independent obligation to bring this to the Parks Department’s attention and refund the money it had been paid in reliance on those erroneous documents. It appears that both the trial and appellate court missed the inconsistency in permitting Expert Electrical to receive payment based upon the same incomplete documents that Expert Electrical used to deny High Tech its payment.

Contract Language May Affect the Limitations Period of a Bond

By: Rick Ward, Law Clerk, 3rd year law student at Pace Law School

Edited by: Thomas S. Tripodianos, Partner

The specific language of a performance bond can cause the limitations period for claims against the bond to run before the full contract amount is paid. In City of Yonkers v 58A JVD Indus., Ltd., the second department found that the performance bond claim accrued when final payment on a contract had been made, even though 1% of the contract price was still unpaid to the contractor. The City’s claim was dismissed.

In April of 2007, Yonkers contracted with JVD to perform the concrete and related work for its project, the McLean Avenue Streetscape Improvement Program. The contract required JVD to secure a performance bond in favor of the City, which it executed along with the Colonial Surety Company. The specific language of the bond included a limitation that claims on the bond must be made within two years after the date of Final Payment under the contract. JVD agreed to hold Colonial harmless for any claim arising out of the performance bond.

In October of 2007, the City notified JVD that several loads of concrete supplied for the project fell short of the contractual specifications. Notwithstanding this notification, in October of 2008 the city issued a certification that JVD was entitled to 80% of the retainage on the contract, and paid JVD accordingly.  By the terms of the construction agreement this was defined as final payment. The unpaid 20% of the retainage was withheld as security for faithful performance of JVD’s obligation pursuant to the terms of the contract. In March of 2009, the City informed JVD that portions of the project had rapidly and prematurely deteriorated and that the contract required JVD to repair, replace, restore or rebuild the affected areas. JVD failed to do so and the City filed a claim with Colonial, which Colonial rejected. In January of 2013, the city commenced an action against JVD and Colonial for breach of contract. JVD, as indemnitor of Colonial, moved to dismiss the action against Colonial on the ground that it was time-barred by the language of the bond.

The Supreme Court of New York initially denied the motion agreeing with the City that the limitations period did not begin to run until payment of the remaining 1% of the contract. However, on appeal, the Second Department reversed that determination. It found that two sections of Article 28 of the contract, when read together, establish that Final Payment under the contract occurred upon the City’s certification of the work as complete and tender of payment thereon. It also found that the October 2008 certification and payment indisputably met the contract definition of final payment, even though 1% of the contract price was still retained by the city pursuant to the security provision of the contract. Since the City brought its claim against the Surety more than four years later in January of 2013, the court dismissed the City’s claim.

Practice Tip: Contracting parties utilizing performance bonds must pay close attention to the detailed language of the bond and the contract, especially when dealing with time limiting language on a bond that incorporates a term defined by the underlying contract.

Personal Smart Phones for Work Email

Question.  Are there any issues with letting my employees use their smart phones to access work email?

Answer. Yes. 

Technology simultaneously makes life easier and more complicated.

Employers need to pay their non-exempt employees for checking and responding to e-mail (and texting and instant messaging, and also phone calls) during what would normally be the employee’s personal time.

Even if you have not requested the employee to do this if you allow it or if you know or have reason to believe that the employees are continuing to work and the employer is benefiting, proper wages must be paid.  That’s an easier argument to make when the employer is issuing the device or providing access to the employer’s servers and email after-hours.

This applies to all employees who are entitled to receive overtime.  Misclassification of an employee as exempt from overtime is a topic for another day.  Spoiler alert:  Misclassification does not turn out well for the employer.

It’s not enough anymore to simply have a policy that prohibits employees from working extra hours without permission. Be clear with employees that work includes e-mails and phone calls.  Establish clear rules about whether and when employees may work remotely.

The suits don’t just include time spent directly on email it includes booting up and shutting down the computer.  The time quickly adds up.

Aside from the wage issue consider security issues.  Mobile devices sync with your servers.  Emails are stored on them as well. Do any of those files contain sensitive or confidential information?  Do you think you can just remotely wipe the device’s memory if it’s lost or stolen?  Do you think the employee would be a little annoyed if you wipe their personal information as well from the device?  And what about the backups of those files that exist in the cloud or on the employee’s home computer?

These are all issues that the employer needs to speak to his IT consultant and lawyer about to formulate and implement a proper policy.

Contractor Allowed Recovery Under Account Stated Claim

An “account stated” is an agreement, express or implied, between parties who have prior dealings that a particular sum is due from one to the other. The agreement may be implied, for example, when a contractor sends regular bills or invoices to the owner and the owner keeps them without objecting to the invoices within a reasonable period of time. An objection to the invoices after litigation has been commenced is not made within a reasonable time.

In the recent case of A. & L. Construction Corp. v East Harlem Developers, LLC, the court allowed the contractor to recover monies due from the owner based on an account stated theory of liability.

Background

A&L, a general contractor, entered into a general construction contract with East Harlem, a property owner, to furnish interior framing, insulation and sheetrock. The work commenced in February of 2008 and ended in April of 2010. As the work progressed, A&L submitted periodic invoices to East Harlem, and East Harlem had submitted partial payments in response to some of those invoices. East Harlem never disputed the invoices. Nor did it claim any deficiencies in the work reflected on the invoices.

A&L sued and, ultimately, moved for summary judgment. In support of its motion, A&L noted the work it performed, the invoices it sent to East Harlem, partial payments made by East Harlem, and East Harlem’s failure to object to the invoices. For the first time in opposition to A&L’s summary judgment motion, East Harlem objected to A&L’s invoices and claimed that the work was inferior and defective. East Harlem also sought a counterclaim against A&L based on the claimed defective work.

Decision

The court granted the contractor’s motion for summary judgment, finding that the owner received and retained the contractor’s invoices for the work without making a reasonably timely objection. As for East Harlem’s counterclaim for defective work, the court ruled that East Harlem had not submitted sufficient evidence that it made any objection on that basis or any other basis upon receipt of A&L’s invoices or within a reasonable time thereafter.

Comment

If a series of invoices are sent that are not objected to within a reasonable period of time, they will be regarded as proof that the invoices stated the correct amounts. The debtor has a duty to examine the invoices to ascertain whether they are correct or not. Silence demonstrates that the debtor does not dispute the balance due. An objection to the invoices or a claim of defective work that is first made only after litigation on the account stated theory is not a defense to the account stated. An account stated claim is a useful legal remedy to collect monies due to a contractor, subcontractor or material supplier.

Leading the Way on Construction Safety

As lawyers to the construction industry, our firm counsels clients in how to prevent OSHA violations; how to negotiate with OSHA when citations occur; and, occasionally, in contesting citations and associated penalties.

Many articles in this series address nuts-and-bolts issues of OSHA compliance, and others are intended to acquaint readers with how things work procedurally, so that they will be familiar with inspection, citation, and contest procedures sufficiently to protect their rights.

It’s important, certainly, to try to avoid OSHA citations.  When they do occur, you’re entitled to insist on the rules being followed, and to contest a citation, if it lacks a proper legal and/or factual basis.

It’s important, however, not to become obsessive about OSHA citations.  Construction work is inherently dangerous.  The construction sector accounts for the single largest component of workplace fatalities in the U.S. each year, and the fatal injury rate for construction is fourth among industry sectors (agriculture, forestry, fishing and hunting has the highest rate, followed by the mining, quarrying and oil and gas extraction sector, the transportation and warehousing sector, and construction).

Construction injuries cannot be reduced to zero.  If you stay in business, you will be inspected by OSHA, and issued a citation every now and then, however hard you work at compliance and safety.  In other words, this is an issue you must grapple with, so long as you remain in business, but will never fully resolve.

Your primary objective, then, as the owner of a construction business, is to make your reasonable best efforts to get every one of your employees to comply with OSHA regulations applicable to your trade, and other safety laws and regulations.  If you do that, there’s a strong likelihood that the number of injuries among your employees, and the number of OSHA citations you receive, will be as low as you can hope for them to be.

And, while, of course, there are costs involved, citations can feel like a nuisance and OSHA, like every government agency I’m acquainted with, is occasionally guilty of arbitrary behavior, OSHA shares the credit for very substantial reductions in workplace mayhem over its 43-year history.  In the bad old days, prior to the enactment of the OSH Act, nationwide more than 14,000 American workers died from workplace injuries annually, nearly 2.5 million were disabled, new cases of occupational diseases were estimated at about 300,000 a year, and ten times more  man-days were lost to job disabilities than to strikes.

In recent years — employment nationwide having almost doubled since 1970 — fatalities have dropped into the low 4000s annually, and injury rates have been reduced on the order of two-thirds.

While not grounds for complacency, these results are also to the credit of employers — who, for the most part, have made appreciable efforts to comply with OSHA, train their workers, and operate their businesses safely.

Studies show that, overall, larger construction employers have better safety results than smaller ones, GCs do better than trade contractors, and union shops are safer than non-union shops.  Such results seem only reasonable, as GCs, by law, have greater responsibility for site safety, and larger companies are more likely to have full-time safety personnel, and greater resources to devote to health and safety concerns.

If yours is a smaller company, or one lacking dedicated safety employees, there are things you can do — things you need to do — to compensate, and to fight the good fight against safety hazards.  One thing small companies are doing well, studies show, is that they typically achieve a high degree of participation among employees in safety efforts.

Whatever the size of your company, you need to approach safety both from the bottom up, and the top down.

“From the bottom up” means that every field employee should be actively encouraged to share responsibility for their own and others’ safety on the job, to discourage one another from violating safety policies, and to report perceived dangers to their supervisors

“From the top down” means that management, including senior management, must exercise active leadership in this area.

From time to time, in representing clients concerning OSHA and other safety issues, we have detected a “disconnect” between what company management tells us they want from their field supervisors in stressing safety rules, and what the supervisors think management wants.

I recall, in particular, one meeting in the wake of an occurrence in which a worker had neglected to fasten his lanyard, and suffered grave injuries in a fall.  Everyone was shaken up by this accident, and management was more concerned with ensuring it not be repeated, than they were with possible repercussions from the accident itself.

In a meeting at which both management and the company’s field supervisors were present, the supervisors piously stated that they knew company policy required everyone to tie off 100% of the time when working on elevated surfaces, and that they strictly enforced that policy.

Later that same day, however, when the bosses were not in the room, one of the same supervisors confided that the policy was spottily enforced, except where activities were going on close to the edge of an elevated surface, and that both the supervisors and the rank-and-file believed that “strict enforcement” was something to be spoken of mostly when OSHA inspectors were present.  What they believed management really wanted was on-time performance, with safety concerns taking a “back seat,” anytime the two might be in conflict.

To avoid that kind of disconnect, ranking management personnel need to be at least somewhat “hands on” about employee safety, even if you don’t have the luxury of a full-time safety director.  You need to meet with field supervisors from time to time, and to assure them that the company’s commitment to safety is genuine.  When significant injuries occur, you need to take an interest, not just in supporting the injured employee and his or her family, but in making sure that steps are taken to determine how and why the accident occurred, where responsibility lies, and what needs to be done to minimize the likelihood of a recurrence.

Safety issues should also be a frequent element of your communications with your field supervisors, both general and job-specific.  While the OSH Act imposes considerable training responsibilities on employers to instruct the rank-and-file in all applicable OSHA standards, as a practical matter avoiding deaths and serious injuries necessitates considerable reliance on your field supervisors to know, and to enforce, the most critical standards which correspond to the largest numbers of fatalities and serious injuries on construction sites.  Those are:  fall hazards, excavation cave-ins, struck-by injuries, and electrocutions.

Quite simply, there should never arise a doubt in any of your supervisors’ minds, when they observe a worker who is not tied off, or who is entering an unshored trench to work even “for just a few minutes,” that such conduct is unacceptable to the people who own the company.  Poor safety practices are not just wrong, they’re bad for business, too.

Smaller companies that enjoy good safety records accomplish that by leadership, and by striving to involve every employee in identifying and abating hazards, and in making sure that the rules (especially those concerning the primary hazards relevant to your trade) are known, and obeyed pretty much all of the time.  If you’re one of the people in charge of the company, you have a critical role to play.

When a Corporation Changes Its Address, It Should Update Its Address with the NYS Department of State Twice

Yes, that’s right, TWICE!  We all know that whenever a corporation changes its address, it should notify the Department of State, so that the Department of State (“DOS”) will be able to forward to the corporation’s new address any process (lawsuits) it receives on the corporation’s behalf.  You can accomplish this update by filing a “Certificate of Change” with the DOS.

However, a “Certificate of Change” is used by the DOS only to make certain changes: 1) change of county location, i.e., from Westchester to Rockland county; 2) change the address to where the Department of State forwards process received on the corporation’s behalf and 3) change of information regarding the registered agent.

That’s it.  Oddly enough, the “Certificate of Change” will NOT change the location of the corporation’s new “Principal Executive Office”.  For the DOS to officially change this item of information, you have to request the corporation’s last “Biennial Statement” from the Department of State (e-mail: corporations@dos.ny.gov), update the information on that form and file it with the DOS. 

This is important to do because the DOS will mail Biennial Statements to the address of the corporation’s “Principal Executive Office”, regardless of where the DOS forwards process.  And, if the corporation fails to file its Biennial Statement, because it never received it, it faces dissolution by the DOS.

One last bit of information: it’s $30 to file the “Certificate of Change” and $9 to file the updated Biennial Statement.    

What a Bank Gives a Bank Takes Away

Everyone would love to obtain a mortgage with no personal liability for the debt ( a “non-recourse mortgage”). While at one time they were not unusual, those days are long gone. They are virtually unheard of in residential mortgages, and rare in commercial mortgages, where the borrower is particularly strong and/or the loan has a low loan to value ratio.

Even in those cases, however, it is not unusual for the bank to “carve out” certain scenarios in which the borrower and the guarantor may be personally liable, such as fraud, theft, collecting rents and taking the money without paying the obligations of the building or project. It is rare for a borrower to object to a provision rendering him personally liable for, in effect, being a crook, since he never intends to be one.

Needless to say, it is important to read those “carve out” provisions carefully, for the devil is in the details. A recent case in Michigan, Wells Fargo Bank, Na v. Cherryland Mall Ltd.1 demonstrates that even if a clause in a mortgage is entitled “Non-Recourse” it may not be. In that case the mortgage had the usual carve out provisions, and two other clauses which contradicted and cancelled out the non recourse language. In one, the borrower was required to maintain its status as a single purpose entity (meaning, it could only own this particular property, so financial difficulties in any other business would not drag this one into Bankruptcy or have it responsible for obligations outside of the particular project).  The other was an obligation to remain solvent, and insolvency would also violate the first provision.

In other words, if the mall lost some of its tenants and was unable to pay its bills due to market conditions and became insolvent, the guarantors would be personally liable for the debt, the very thing the borrower wanted to avoid in the first place. So, under that mortgage the loan was non- recourse provided it was paid in full; otherwise, it was fully guaranteed.

When the loan defaulted and the bank foreclosed, it sought a deficiency judgment against the guarantors for the difference between the foreclosure sales price and the amount due. The borrower and guarantors argued unsuccessfully that the provisions relied upon by the bank made no sense and were contradicted by the non-recourse provisions which were an integral part of the decision to give the mortgage in the first place. Not so said the lower Courts.

Luckily for the borrowers there was a new provision in the Michigan Statutes called the Nonrecourse Mortgage Loan Act which made such provisions unenforceable and the Act was found to be retroactive, so as to protest these defendants. We have no such Statute in New York. The moral is: do not assume because the Bank document calls the loan one thing that does not mean that other provisions make it something else. Your lawyer should read the loan documents very carefully to be sure tour non-recourse loan is just that.


1300 Mich. App. 361 (Court of Appeals 2013).

 

Can a General Contract Assert Claims against an Engineer Hired by a Sub-subcontractor?

Question.       Can a general contractor assert claims against an engineer hired by a sub-subcontractor under theories of negligence or that he was an intended beneficiary of the sub-sub-subcontract for engineering services?

Answer. Yes. 

General Contractor, a, entered into a contract to produce a hotel. General Contractor hired subcontractor, Sub FP Inst., to design and install a fire protection system for the hotel. Sub FP Inst. hired sub-subcontractor, Sub FP Design., to design the system, and Sub FP Design. hired an engineer, FP Eng., to provide engineering services in conjunction with the design. FP Eng., a licensed engineer in New York, affixed his seal and stamp to the designs produced by Sub FP Design., which neither complied with relevant codes nor adequately accounted for General Contractor's specifications. The faulty design caused property damage to the hotel, resulting in injury to General Contractor.

Negligence

The elements of a cause of action alleging common-law negligence are a duty owed by the FP Eng. to the General Contractor, a breach of that duty, and a showing that the breach of that duty proximately caused injury to the General Contractor. In general, a tort claim for negligence does not arise when the duty that FP Eng. owes to a General Contractor arises solely out of a contractual relationship. In order to state a claim for negligence in a case of economic loss, there must generally be some non-contractual duty of FP Eng., contracting with Sub FP Inst., to the General Contractor. However, in suits against professionals, including engineers, for negligent misrepresentations, the standard is somewhat different. In Ossining Union Free Sch. Dist. v. Anderson LaRocca Anderson, the New York Court of Appeals allowed suits for negligent misrepresentation to proceed against two engineers who knew that the plans that they produced would be used by the general contractor for a particular purpose. Here, FP Eng. knew the plans that he approved would be used by General Contractor to install a fire protection system.

Third-Party Beneficiary Liability for Breach of Contract

A professional engineer or architect that provides services to produce construction plans is liable to the owner that undertakes such construction under a third-party beneficiary theory. Third-party beneficiary status is granted more broadly to a party in contractual privity with a contractor when that contractor hires a subcontractor, here Sub FP Inst., to do work necessary to the completion of the contract between the party and the contractor.

Thus, General Contractor has a colorable claim as a third-party beneficiary.

This is not to say that either of these claims will ultimately successful.  There are multiple questions of fact that need to be resolved by a judge or jury.  It does however, mean that the engineer will have to defend the lawsuit.

A lien is not timely filed if the lienor performs supervision within eight months prior to the filing of a lien, but there is no construction work for the improvement of the property during that time.

On January 15, 2014, the Supreme Court issued a decision holding that a lien is not timely filed if a lienor performs supervision within eight months prior to the filing of a lien, but there is no construction for the improvement of the property during that time.[1]

In 8th Ave. Recoveries Corp. v 111 Stellar 8 Owner, LLC,[2] the plaintiff sought to foreclose on a mechanic’s lien that had been assigned to it by a general contractor after it was filed on filed on February 2, 2011.  The contract between the owner and the general contractor required the general contractor to ensure that the site was safe.  The owner established that the general contractor did not perfom any construction work for the improvement of the property after April of 2010.  However, the general contractor’s employee testified that in his role as “construction supervisor,” he had continued to go to the project site everyday between April and November of 2010 and spent the full day there.  His duties consisted of “walking around and looking at the Property.”  The general contractor had not billed for these services in its final requisition for payment, including retainage, which was dated September 2, 2010 for the period through March 26, 2010.  However, the general contractor maintained that the supervisory services were the basis for the timely filing of the lien.

After discovery was completed, the owner successfully moved for summary judgment to dismiss the complaint and vacate the lien on the basis that it was not timely filed.  The Court found that “[w]hile supervision of construction work may be the basis of a lien, where the property is not being improved, there is nothing to supervise and thus no basis for a lien.”  The decision was based upon prior case law where valid claims for supervision had been for construction work that improved the property.  The owner’s counterclaim for wilfull exaggeration of the lien was also dismissed because such a claim was precluded where the lien was found to be invalid for any other reason other than wilfull exaggeration.

Based on this decision, potential lienors should ensure that they file their liens within eight months after they have completed construction for the improvement of the property, even if they provide supervisory services at the site after they have completed construction pursuant to their contract.  Furthermore, assignees should investigate the validity of a lien before accepting its assignment. 


 

[1] The decision was rendered by the Hon. Carolyn E. Demarest, J.S.C., a justice of the Commercial Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York, Kings County.

 

[2] 2014 WL 169764 (Table), 2014 N.Y. Slip Op. 50027(U), 42 Misc 3d 1212(A) [Kings Co. Jan. 15, 2014].