Skip to main content

Mayor Adams to lift the NYC COVID-19 Vaccine Mandate effective November, 2022

“We’re removing the requirement to be vaccinated and to participate in sports and extracurricular activities. We’re removing that requirement for our schoolchildren,” Adams said. “We will also provide additional flexibility to business by lifting the private-sector mandate on Nov. 1. This puts the choice in the hands of New York businesses.”

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Thomas S. Tripodianos at ttripodianos@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6440

Court Reinstates Mechanic’s Lien To Permit Exaggeration Counterclaim To Proceed

This column has warned many times that it is always a bad idea to exaggerate the amount of a mechanic’s lien. While the exaggerating lienor may succeed in getting the owner’s or upstream contractor’s attention, the negative boomerang effects—such as having the lien declared void, being prohibited any recovery on the contract, being forced to pay the costs and attorney’s fees associated with the discharge of the exaggerated lien and, most importantly, being subject to an award of damages against the lienor in the amount of the exaggeration—greatly outweigh the shock value of a big number on the lien. There are instances where lienors try to have their proverbial cake and eat it too by asserting an exaggerated lien, and then withdrawing the foreclosure claim in the face of the exaggeration counterclaim. In Adria Infrastructure, LLC v Henick-Lane, Inc., an appellate court recently demonstrated the lengths that courts will go to prevent such chicanery, going so far as to not only deny a motion to amend a complaint to remove a lien foreclosure cause of action, but actually ordering the reinstatement of the lien—at a value of $0—so that it existed at the time of trial, as was required in order to pursue the exaggeration counterclaim.

Background

Prior to 2010, Henick-Lane entered into a contract with DASNY to serve as the general contractor on a public works project for the refurbishing of the courthouse on Staten Island. In January of 2010, Henick-Lane contracted with Adria Infrastructure to provide needed plumbing, steamfitting, and like work for the project. In 2013, Adria filed a mechanic’s lien against the project in the amount of $742,651, and in 2015 it commenced a lawsuit to foreclose that lien. Shortly thereafter, Adria filed a second mechanic’s lien against the project in the amount of $4,180,706, and it amended its complaint in the existing lawsuit to foreclose that lien. In 2016, Adria successfully moved to reduce its lien to $2,949,538, based on a prior partial settlement. After discovery (in which it became readily apparent that the liens were willfully exaggerated), Adria released its liens and moved for leave to file an amended complaint to remove its cause of action to foreclose those liens. In response, Henick-Lane moved to void the release of lien, and reduce the amount of Adria’s lien to $0.

Decision

The court denied Adria’s motion to remove its foreclosure claims, and granted Henick-Lane’s motion to effectively reinstate Adria’s lien at $0 value. In doing so, the court cited well settled law that although amendments to claims should ordinarily be freely granted, the purpose of the proposed amendment here was to evade the willful exaggeration claim—a result which the court would not countenance. Further, because the predicate of a successful willful exaggeration claim is the existence of a valid mechanic’s lien, the court voided the release of lien and valued the lien at $0 so that the willful exaggeration claim could proceed. On Adria’s appeal, the Appellate Division affirmed, finding, like the motion court, that the drastic remedies set forth in the Lien Law for a willfully exaggerated lien were “available only where the lien was valid in all other respects and was declared void by reason of willful exaggeration after a trial of the foreclosure action”, and that by releasing the lien, Adria attempted to deprive Henick-Lane of the ability to seek redress for the willful exaggeration.

Comment

Mechanic’s liens are a powerful tool because they not only involve the upstream contractor who is not paying, but they also attach to either the title of the property itself, or the public funds held by the municipal owner. Accordingly, in order to prevent abuse of this powerful tool, the state legislature put in a safeguard in the form of an award against an exaggerating lienor of not only the attorney’s fees incurred in discharging the exaggerated lien, together with the interest on monies deposited to discharge the exaggerated lien (or the premium for any lien discharge bond), but an amount of money equal to the amount of the exaggeration itself. While many exaggerating lienors try to avail themselves of the shock value of an exaggerated lien while later avoiding the ramifications, Adria Infrastructure is a reminder of the lengths to which courts will go to prevent such chicanery—even going so far as to reinstate a mechanic’s lien for $0 in order that a lien will be in effect at time of trial, as is necessary to allow the exaggeration claim to proceed.
Contractors should be forewarned of the bitter penalties that can be imposed if they exaggerate a lien. Those on the receiving end of an exaggerated lien should also fight back. Accordingly, one should consult with construction counsel to determine what legitimate methods are available to get an upstream contractor’s or owner’s attention, such as by also asserting a bond claim, by having a copy of the lien directed at the property’s lender, or the like; or, alternatively, learn how to counter-attack the exaggerating lienor. Regardless, contractors must keep in mind that exaggerating a mechanic’s lien is always a bad idea.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Thomas H. Welby at twelby@wbgllp.com or call (914) 428-2100

Companies Should Exercise Caution When Outsourcing Inspections to Third Parties for Equipment Maintenance

The matter of Secretary of Labor v. Henkels & McCoy, Inc. demonstrates how companies must heed their equipment’s manuals and be aware of the scope and extent of services provided to them from third parties to ensure proper equipment maintenance. This matter arose from a fatal workplace accident involving a crew leader who was operating an improperly maintained digger derrick. The crew leader was an employee of Henkels & McCoy, Inc. (H&M) which performs general utility maintenance. The underlying incident occurred on May 2, 2018, in Jacksonville, Florida where the crew leader and an apprentice were assigned to remove a utility pole when he was fatally injured.

H&M utilizes digger derricks for utility pole installation and removal. The digger derrick has a flatbed equipped with a boom and operator’s chair that sits atop a pedestal, which is attached to the truck’s frame and chassis. The digger derrick has eighteen rotation bearing mounting bolts that connect the gear ring, on which the operator’s chair and boom sit, to the flange atop the pedestal. The digger derrick’s manufacturer in their manual instructs owners to conduct annual torque testing with a calibrated torque wrench. A warning decal is also prominently placed on the pedestal repeating this instruction and warning that failure to inspect and properly torque the rotation bearing mounting bolts can cause structural failure and lead to death or serious injury.

H&M mechanics used to perform inspections of the company’s digger derricks that also included torque testing. However, in 2007, H&M entered into an agreement with third-party contractor, Diversified Inspections/ITL Inc. (“Diversified”) to provide semi-annual inspection services on the digger derricks. From 2011 to 2016, the companies further engaged in agreements setting forth the scope of Diversified’s inspections. Upon inspection, Diversified would complete a report noting any issues with the equipment and forward to H&M. In February 2018, Diversified’s inspection reports began including a disclaimer that it was not performing torque testing.

On the incident day, the crew leader was operating one of H&M’s digger derricks from the operator’s chair, while the apprentice was working on the ground when they both heard a “creak”. The crew leader stopped operating the digger derrick. Upon investigation, the apprentice found that one of the bolts had “sheared off” and was on the bed of the truck. The apprentice proceeded to check the other bolts and then informed the crew leader that they were tight. Upon resumption of work, the apprentice heard sounds and jumped off the truck and thereafter saw the boom falling and the crew leader being ejected from the operator’s chair to the pavement below. He would tragically succumb to his injuries.

OSHA investigated the incident and issued a citation alleging a serious violation of the Occupational Safety and Health Act’s general duty clause for exposing employee to struck-by and crushing hazards by failing to properly maintain the digger derrick’s bolts. Although, an Administrative Law Judge vacated the citation, the Administrative Law Commission reversed the decision, affirmed the citation and assessed a penalty of $12,934.

To prove a violation of the general duty clause, the Secretary (of Labor) must establish the following four elements: (1) a condition or activity in the workplace presented a hazard; (2) the employer or its industry recognized the hazard; (3) the hazard was causing or likely to cause death or serious physical harm; and (4) a feasible and effective means existed to eliminate or materially reduce the hazard.

As a preliminary matter, the Commission found that the manufacturer’s recall notice as to the digger derrick’s bolts had no bearing on the Secretary’s allegation in the citation as to H&M’s lack of maintenance of the digger derrick’s bolts to ensure that they are properly torqued. Therefore, it proceeded to analyze each element of the alleged violation with respect to the conditions as set forth in the citation, not in terms of the incident or design defect.

The Commission found that a hazard existed as indicated by the existence of the manufacturer’s decal and as per the testimony of the Secretary’s expert who opined that failing to torque test the bolts could result in fatigue failure, which could cause the bolts to “back out and fall out” from the connection and eventually cause the digger derrick to collapse. The existence of the manufacturer’s decal prominently displayed on the equipment and its inclusion in the manual was sufficient to establish industry recognition of the hazard. The Secretary further alleged that there existed a feasible method for abatement of the hazard by torque testing the bolts which as per their expert would uncover “worn out or deformed bolts” for replacement in a safe and controlled environment given that the manual called for replacement of all bolts if one breaks during testing.

The Commission also found that H&M had constructive knowledge of the hazard since H&M could have known about the condition through reasonable diligence. The Secretary argued that H&M failed to exercise reasonable diligence as they never required Diversified to torque test the bolts during inspection nor did they negotiate a price for that service. Further, the 2016 agreement between the companies did not include the service and in the months leading to this incident, Diversified’s reports specifically stated they were not performing such testing. Although, H&M argued that the torque testing disclaimer was self-contradictory because these reports stated that the inspections were performed in accordance with ANSI and OSHA standards, which would have included torque testing, the Commission found that although “the evidence relating to Diversified’s relationship with H&M and torque testing is not a model of clarity” it could have known that Diversified was not performing torque testing with the exercise of reasonable diligence. H&M had an obligation to determine how the torque testing was to be done for the safety of its employees and in fact had expertise in this area since it torque tested the digger derrick bolts prior to retaining Diversified while H&M’s mechanic continued to exercise day-to-day control over the machines.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Court Permits Petition To Extend Lien On Last Day

It is generally known throughout the construction industry that a mechanic’s lien, once filed, is good for one year from the date of its filing. Under many circumstances, a lien extension cannot be obtained by a simple filing, and must be obtained by court order (which requires the commencement of a special proceeding). Because of the wording of the statute, most contractors (and construction lawyers) often bring the proceeding well before the one year anniversary so as to be sure that the order is entered before the lien expires. Because of the vagaries of court calendars, some extensions are granted well before the expiration of the lien, effectively reducing the overall time available for the lien to be active. In the recent case of ABS Construction v Pardus, a trial court granted the extension where the special proceeding was only commenced the day before the lien expired, and the order was not entered until well after that expiration.

Background

In July of 2020, ABS Construction, Inc. performed some bathroom and kitchen renovation work in the home of Drew and Frances Pardus in Manhattan. ABS alleged that it was not fully paid, and was still owed $18,502 for its work; on February 5, 2021, ABS filed a mechanic’s lien against the Pardus’ home in that amount.

Because the lien was filed against a single family home, it could not be extended through the filing of a simple extension. Rather, the Lien Law requires that the lienor obtain a court order continuing such lien. On February 4, 2022, the day before the lien expired, ABS commenced a special proceeding to extend the lien for a period of one year. Because the court order would not be obtained the next day, ABS also requested that the Court extend the lien retroactively, so as to cover any period between the natural expiration of the lien and the entry of the court’s order. In its petition in support of the extension, ABS alleged that it had not extended or foreclosed its lien because it was attempting to resolve the matter without incurring the costs associated with either a foreclosure or a special proceeding to extend the lien.

The Parduses opposed the application to extend the lien, arguing that ABS was required to show good cause for failing to obtain the order of extension within one year of the filing of the original lien, and that it failed to do so.

Decision

The court granted ABS’s application and extended the lien. In doing so, the court held that “[t]here is no dispute that this proceeding was commenced before the subject lien expired. It is of no moment that this application was not made returnable before that date. Therefore, the court has the power to extend petitioner’s lien nunc pro tunc. Contrary to respondents’ contention, petitioner does not need to demonstrate good cause when the proceeding was otherwise timely brought.”

Comment

As mentioned above, general conservative practice has been that where a court order extending a lien is necessary, counsel would bring the proceeding well in advance of the expiration of the lien so as to ensure that the order extending the lien was obtained within the one year. The net effect of this practice permitted courts with less-crowded dockets to effectively reduce the overall period available to lienors. For instance, if counsel brought the proceeding eight months after the filing of the lien, and the court entered the order two months thereafter, the new expiration date of the lien is two months before its anniversary date. This reduction gets magnified in following years since following extensions of lien also need to be obtained by court order (which would likely be accomplished on a similar schedule).

The pragmatic effect of ABS Construction is that lienors and their attorneys will have more flexibility in timing their applications to extend their liens so that they get the full period of time envisioned in the Lien Law—without having to make any sacrifice to the uncertainties of a court’s docket. While it would enhance the certainty of this proposition of law if this ruling were from an appellate court and not a trial-level court, the relatively low value of the lien in ABS may deprive us of that appellate decision here. However, it will likely not be very long before we do have that appellate-level holding on the issue. In the meantime, lienors would be cautioned to consult with experienced construction counsel about how to renew their liens to be sure that they are effectively extended, and not relying on another trial-level judge determining that a demonstration of good cause is actually necessary. Or, stated more simply, don’t press your luck with statutory deadlines.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Thomas H. Welby at twelby@wbgllp.com or call (914) 428-2100

Adequate Training, Experience and Equipment are Necessary When Working Near Energized Lines

Secretary of Labor v. The L.E. Myers Co. shows the importance of adequate training, experience and equipment when working near energized lines. This matter arises from an unfortunate and tragic work-place accident involving a journeyman lineman for an electrical utility sub-contractor, L.E. Myers Co. (LEM) in Florida. On November 15, 2019, LEM assigned a four-man crew to transfer electrical distribution lines from an existing utility pole to a new utility pole. Due to the live electrical current, OSHA requires employers to determine the minimum approach distance (“MAD”) before its employees work near energized lines at a worksite. The MAD is the closest distance an employee may approach an energized or grounded object without taking specific safety precautions. At this site, the MAD was determined to be 2 feet, 2 inches.

The four-man crew arrived at the worksite around on the incident date and began to discuss their respective assignments. The crew consisted of the Foreman, two journeyman lineman (inclusive of the Decedent), and an apprentice. The Foreman conducted a pre-job briefing and had everyone sign a Daily Pre-Job Brief document. This document listed the steps for this assignment and included a checklist of the tools required. The document stated the assignment as “Move wires to new pole and hang arms and mac” and had a checklist for “PPE/Tools Required”. The Foreman checked of all tools on the required list including rubber insulating gloves and rubber insulating sleeves. The crew had two bucket trucks and one smaller “backyard machine”. The apprentice and Decedent were in these buckets, the JL in the backyard machine and the Foreman on the ground to observe.

The incident occurred when the Foreman called to the Decedent to lower his bucket to hand him a mac (a flexible wire with clamps at either end, used to bypass an area of an energized line so work can be done in the bypassed area). When the Foreman handed the mac to the Decedent, he did not notice whether or not the Decedent was wearing rubber insulating sleeves. The interaction was a couple of seconds and Decedent immediately raised his bucket back up to the height needed to determine if the mac length was acceptable. The Foreman, as the only eyewitness testifying, stated after he gave the Decedent the mac, the Decedent elevated his bucket and screamed down something along the lines of “that’ll work.” As the Foreman started to walk away to collect other macs just in case, the Foreman heard sizzling, popping and the jerking of the bucket. He looked up to realize Decedent was slumped over in his bucket. After cutting the mac, it was safe for Decedent to be lowered and receive medical attention. However, the electrocution resulted in Decedent’s death. The Decedent was found to be only wearing his rubber gloves, but not his rubber insulating sleeves. Two of OSHA’s compliance officers investigated the scene that same day, taking photos and interviewing individuals, but they did not conduct any measurements or simulations. LEM’s Foreman was discharged in December 2019. OSHA eventually cited LEM for three serious violations arising from the incident.

The ALJ found the Foreman’s testimony regarding the rubber insulating sleeve was sufficient as the Foreman was close enough to detect, with reasonable diligence, whether the Decedent was wearing the sleeve or not. In terms of assignment, the Foreman testified that he only wanted the Decedent to get close enough to measure the mac, which did not require the Decedent to breach the MAD. The Foreman explained that the task could have been done by not elevating the bucket to the height, however it probably would have been more difficult. He did not ask for the Decedent to install the mac, as installation would require all three crewmembers in position.

Item 1 of the Citation pertained to the Decedent not being trained or competent in the MAD skills and techniques in order to maintain a safe distance. Although recordkeeping of employment records is one way to keep track of an employee’s demonstrated proficiency, the ALJ here found that in fact the Decedent did have adequate training and proficiency by the evidence submitted and vacated this portion of the citation. Although, the Decedent had only worked with LEM for about two months, he had over 15 years of prior experience (via the apprenticeship and journeyman system) in his previous jobs, which required MAD training. Upon hiring, LEM provided the Decedent a New Hire Orientation Outline, which included the MADs and Decedent had received a copy of the Safety Manual which also addressed MADs. Furthermore, LEM’s Safety Engineer testified how they provide orientation and safety training for newly hired employees, periodic safety training, crew visits and onsite audits. Here, the Safety Engineer had interviewed the Decedent during his orientation to determine his knowledge and understanding of safety-related work practices, including MADs. Moreover, LEM’s supervisors including the Foreman were trained to closely observe new hires to ensure their proficiency, including on safety.

The other items of the Citation were based upon Decedent breaching the MAD without appropriate precautions and failures by LEM to ensure that no employee approaches or takes a conductive object closer to the exposed energy parts than the established MAD. LEM even had a “cradle to cradle policy” that stated that both the rubber insulating gloves and sleeves were to be worn when working on energized equipment on an aerial platform. However, the Foreman’s instruction to the Decedent was to perform work at a height not within the MAD. Only when the Decedent elevated his bucket to the height of the distribution lines and connected one end of the mac to the line did he breach the MAD. Since this occurred within mere seconds, the ALJ found that this fleeting moment did not establish a failure on the part of the Foreman to exercise reasonable diligence and supervision. The Foreman had worked with the Decedent for two months prior to the incident and never noticed any conduct that would alert him to heightened monitoring of Decedent’s safety practices. Therefore, these items of the Citation were also vacated.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Companies Should Always Conduct Careful Pre-Planning of All Hoisting Operations

Secretary of Labor v. S&R Enterprises, LLC demonstrates the importance of adequately pre-planning all hoisting operations especially in the realm of steel erection, preferably in writing and with clear instruction to all involved employees to avoid accidents. This matter arose in Savannah, Georgia in June 2019 involving the hoisting of a grappler (a giant steel claw) that weighed 10,500 lbs., which was intended as a decorative element for a hotel lobby that became displaced, causing serious injuries to three workers on site.

S&R Enterprises, LLC (“S&R”) is a steel erection contractor who had been a subcontractor on a renovation project for roughly two years prior to the incident. The project was to re-purpose a decommissioned power plant and transform it into a luxury hotel. S&R was asked by the hotel owner to hang an industrial grappler (a giant steel claw) to the new hotel’s atrium lobby, as a decorative element. This request was not a part of S&R’s original scope of work, but they agreed to do so. S&R determined it would not be possible to position a crane in the area to perform a conventional lift. Instead, they decided to use an air tugger consisting of a drum and cable. To perform the lift, a padeye (a steel plate with a hole in it used as an attachment point) was welded to the east and west girders. The grappler was supported by these two girders. The plan was to run the wire rope from the padeye of the east girder to the rigging attached to the grappler, up to the padeye on the west girder and down to the air tugger which would pull the rope to raise the grappler.

Prior to the commencement of the lift, S&R’s vice-president prepared a written, activity hazard analysis (AHA) based upon the assistant superintendent’s drawing of the proposed plan. The AHA identified the job steps, hazards and controls of the operation with numbered instructions. It specifically mentioned how no workers were to be under the suspended load at any point during the lift. During the operation, the padeye on the west girder tore away causing the weight of the grappler and rigging to fall. The weight of grappler dragged the wire rope against the personnel basket of the aerial lift, damaging the basket and injuring two employees and another employee who was struck by a wire, while supervising the lift. The fall resulted in serious injuries and hospitalization of three workers.

After the incident, OSHA’s compliance officer came to inspect the site. Upon investigation he determined that the assistant superintendent had done no metallurgical testing to ascertain the strength of the girders. The compliance officer believed the measurement could have been taken prior to the lift to get a better calculation of the load of the girders. His opinion resulted in a two-item citation of two statutes. The first statute cited was for failing to adequately determine the lift, thickness, and strength of the steel erection hosting operation given that “all hoisting operations in steel erection shall be pre-planned to ensure that the requirements” of the applicable standard are met. The second statute cited was for not adequately rigging the hoisted material (the grappler) to prevent displacement. The matter was brought before an ALJ for OSHA’s Review Commission. Here, the facts were not in dispute but rather the interpretation of the steel erection standard’s requirements and definitions.

Whether the cited statutes applied depended first upon whether S&R engaged in “steel erection” when it attempted to raise the grappler to the overhead crane hook. By definition of the subpart of the cited statute, steel erection is the “construction, alteration or repair of steel buildings, bridges and other structures, including the installation of metal decking and all planking used during the process of erection.” Steel erection activities include installation of miscellaneous metals, ornamental iron and similar materials. Therefore, the ALJ determined S&R’s activities fell within this standard.

Although S&R at the time was deemed to be engaged in “steel erection” activity, the Secretary failed to establish S&R was noncompliant with the cited statutes. Even though there was no written requirement to have a pre-plan of the hoisting, in writing, S&R had developed a written activity hazard analysis prior to the lift. The failing of the girder to sustain of the weight of the hoisted load was not considered/planned for by S&R. Although the failure to calculate load capacity was a significant omission, it was not addressed by the cited standard which required an employer to preplan the route of the suspended load so that no employee was required to work under it. Here, there were specific instructions in S&R’s AHA to not be under the load, but employees acted contrary to this instruction. How the lift was preplanned and how the lift actually transpired were separate issues and the ALJ found that the Secretary failed to establish that S&R violated the applicable standard and thus vacated this citation.

As to the second citation, in terms of failing to prevent displacement of the hoisted material, here the grappler, the ALJ inquired about the definition of “load” in this context and found that the structure that supports the weight being hoisted cannot, by definition, be a part of the load. Therefore, the west girder which caused the fall was not part of the materials being hoisted. Although S&R failed to accurately assess the load capacity of both east and west girder, that is not detailed in the cited statute for this violation and the “failure of the lift is not enough…to establish S&R violated the standard the Secretary chose to cite.” Evidence was not presented showing S&R rigged the load incorrectly or the equipment it used was faulty and therefore this citation was vacated as well.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Appellate Court Enforces Contractor’s Partial Waivers And Releases Of Lien To Bar Its Claim For Delay Damages

One of the most ubiquitous documents in construction is the partial waiver and release of lien, which is invariably a condition precedent to a contractor or subcontractor receiving its progress payment. While the most common question contractors have is whether signing the document before receiving payment actually waives the contractor’s right to receive that payment (it doesn’t), these documents can be a trap for the unwary because they will operate to waive claims for monies that are not specifically recited as being excepted from the partial waiver and release of lien (such as unpaid change order claims, delay claims, etc.). An appellate court, in the recent case of Pizzarotti, LLC v X-Treme Concrete Inc., reminded us of this state of affairs when it dismissed a contractor’s counterclaim for delay damages based on its execution of such monthly waivers.

Background

In September of 2015, Pizzarotti entered into an agreement to perform construction services for a residential construction project on West 27th Street in Manhattan. Pizzarotti subsequently entered into a subcontract with X-Treme Concrete for X-Treme to perform the concrete scope of work at the project. Of course, as part and parcel of the payment process, X-Treme signed partial waivers and releases of lien monthly, each one of which provided, in capital letters, that X-Treme “AGREES THAT THIS WAIVER OF LIEN AND RELEASE IS NEITHER A RECEIPT FOR PAYMENT NOR A CONDITION PRECEDENT TO PAYMENT, BUT A KNOWING AND WILLFUL ACKNOWLEDGEMENT THAT SUBCONTRACTOR HAS BEEN FULLY PAID . . . THROUGH THE ABOVE-REFERENCED DATE.”

Within months, disputes arose on both sides, with Pizzarotti alleging that X-Treme failed to remit payments to its subcontractors and suppliers, and X-Treme alleging that Pizzarotti failed to pay it promptly, and had delayed the job. Ultimately, X-Treme ceased working on the project (with X-Treme alleging that Pizzarotti improperly terminated it, and with Pizzarotti alleging that X-Treme abandoned the job), and X-Treme filed a mechanic’s lien against the project (as did several other of X-Treme’s subcontractors). Pizzarotti sued X-Treme for breaching the contract, alleging that it was going to incur excess completion costs as a result. X-Treme filed several counterclaims, each one of which alleged that X-Treme incurred significant damages as a result of Pizzaroti’s delays arising from its failure to provide complete project drawings, and that Pizzarotti improperly terminated X-Treme as a pretense to cover for its own delays, and in an effort to avoid liability for such actions.

After discovery, Pizzarotti moved for summary judgment dismissing X-Treme’s counterclaims, arguing that the partial releases and waivers of lien executed by X-Treme in exchange for monthly progress payments (eight, in total) barred its delay claim, which—unlike the recitation of unpaid retainage—was not excepted from the otherwise general release language. In opposition, X-Treme argued that the releases were only meant to document payments received to date (receipts, in essence), and not to release any unresolved change orders or delay claims.

Decision

The motion court dismissed X-Treme’s counterclaims, briefly citing the partial waiver and release of lien documents—and holding that X-Treme failed in its burden to demonstrate that the releases did not apply to its claim, or otherwise establish any equitable basis to vitiate their effect. The appellate court affirmed, citing the capitalized language of the partial waiver and release of lien in which X-Treme specifically acknowledged that the document was not a mere receipt but, rather, operated to release any claims not specifically preserved, including its delay claim (which existed prior to the execution of the latest release documents). The appellate court also noted the existence of a no-damages-for-delay provision of the contract, and found that as the incomplete drawings were specifically mentioned in the parties’ contract, they were contemplated and, therefore, not subject to one of the exceptions to the enforceability of such a clause.

Comment

Clearly, contractors are in the construction business to make money. However, this case should caution contractors that they should not simply sign any document put in front of them to get some money flowing in their direction. Setting aside, for the moment, that X-Treme’s delay claim was also barred by specific contractual language, the partial waiver and release of lien documents here serve as clear evidence that simply signing required documents for the sake of getting some money flowing can result in the foreclosure of other claims which may (or, here, may not) have merit. Accordingly, contractors would be well advised to consult with experienced construction counsel as to how to best preserve their right to collect on all of their claims, and not just the ones that will result in an immediate payment. Have your attorney review the partial release and waiver of lien document at the time of the very first requisition—not 8 months into the job, when the damage has already been done.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Thomas H. Welby at twelby@wbgllp.com or call (914) 428-2100

Companies Should Maintain Safety Programs and Work Rules that are Adequately Communicated and Enforced to Prevent Fall Hazards

Secretary of Labor v. Miller Insulation is an instructive case showing the need for safety programs that include proper training, guidance and communication for fall protection. This matter arose from an accident and tragic death of an employee of Miller Insulation, on April 19, 2019, in North Dakota, who fell from the edge of a mezzanine floor where the wooden floor met a drop ceiling with a nine-foot height differential.

Miller provides insulation services with approximately 600 employees. Here, Miller was to repair insulation on piping and valves and replace stained ceiling tiles at a school. Approximately, a month prior to the accident, Miller’s superintendent conducted a walk-through of the worksite with the superintendent of the general contractor. They both reviewed the punch list of items to be completed and took photographs. During the walk-through they climbed a ladder to enter a mechanical room on a mezzanine floor, above. The mezzanine had wood flooring that did not extend all the way to the walls at each end of the floor. Between the end of the wood floor and walls were thin tiles placed on metal grid, which served as drop ceiling for the hallway below. The superintendents spent about five minutes and did not identify a clear hazard, but Miller’s superintendent requested that the overall area have better illumination.

On April 19, 2019, Miller’s superintendent met with Miller employee, Mr. Andrade, and two workers to discuss the repairs and reviewed the punch list items and photographs. The superintendent could not go the site that day but rather instructed Mr. Andrade to meet with the GC’s superintendent to also go over the work and two look after the two employees. They arrived at the site, Mr. Adrade met and discussed the work with the GC’s superintendent and then directed the two employees to only complete the repair work depicted in the pictures. They were not to look outside this original scope and were to call a supervisor for permission to conduct additional work. After commencement of their work on the mezzanine, Mr. Andrade heard one employee yelling that the other employee had fallen and was injured. This employee would ultimately be taken to the hospital and would unfortunately pass from his injuries. Miller’s subsequent investigation revealed that Mr. Andrade had only partially completed a Job Hazard Assessment (“JHA”) before starting work because he “spaced out on it”. He was subsequently disciplined suspended. Accident reports were completed, photographs were taken, and it was determined that there was adequate lighting on the mezzanine, including in the area, where no work was scheduled to be performed and the deceased employee had been working. OSHA conducted their own investigation and determined that employee had been exposed to fall hazard next to an un-protected edge that had at least a nine-foot height differential from floor to the drop ceiling below and issued a citation for an OSHA violation. The matter was brought before an ALJ for OSHA’s Review Commission.

The cited standard required Miller to ensure that each of its employees on a walking/working surface with an unprotected side or edge, 6 feet or more above a lower level, were protected from falling by use of guardrail systems, safety net systems, or personal fall arrest systems. Here the record was clear that Miller’s repair work fell under OSHA’s definition of “construction work” and that Miller violated the applicable safety standard and that its employees had been exposed to a fall hazard.

However, Miller raised the “employee misconduct” affirmative defense and the ALJ found that the evidence showed that Miller did not have actual or constructive knowledge of the hazardous condition of the victim working from the mezzanine’s un-protected edge without fall protection. Miller’s superintendent nor Mr. Andrade had knowledge of the hazard as neither identified a clear hazard while either observing or working at the site. The fall area had no scheduled work, was 20 feet away, and partially barricaded by pipes from the work he was instructed to complete. Mr. Andrade’s never directed the deceased employee to work in the fall area since no work was required there.

Miller established that it had work rules and policies that communicated fall protection for employees working at or above a height of six feet, including in a safety handbook (providing specific fall protection rules and guidance), an employee handbook, a Work-Place Accident and Injury Reduction Act Program, a Risk and Hazard Assessment Program, Safety Manuals, all distributed to, and available to employees. They also conducted toolbox talks (including 30 in the prior incident year on fall protection alone), employee orientation tests, and provided safety handouts. Miller’s safety program required use of guardrails and barricade warning tape, along with fall protection while working near unprotected sides/edges. Miller adequately communicated its rules on fall protection through orientation videos, its work rules and distributed literature, as well as making its employees receive training through OSHA 10/30 trainings. Here, the record showed that both the deceased employee and Mr. Andrade were well aware of the work rules and Mr. Andrade had even provided the deceased employee hands-on training included direction to tie off any time when working six feet above ground away from an edge. Miller took reasonable steps to discover safety violations, employed six safety coordinators who consistently audited jobsites while safety superintendents would also visit jobsites at least once per week. Miller also incentivized employees to identify safety violations under a “good catch program”. Lastly, Miller took reasonable steps to enforce violations to its fall-protection rules that included write-ups and terminations for repeated failures. Here, Mr. Andrade’s failure to fully complete a JHA led to disciplinary action for his failure to follow the work rules and ultimately his termination. The ALJ found that Miller had met its burden of proof regarding the affirmative defense of unpreventable employee misconduct and vacated the OSHA citation.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445

Appellate Court Enforces Constructive Change Directive Provision, Grants Win To Otherwise Breaching Contractor

Construction projects are often expensive undertakings, with the expense increasing with the duration of the project. For that reason, owners and upstream contractors do whatever they can to stave off delays. One way they can stave off such delays is to include a provision requiring downstream contractors involved in a change order dispute to continue working pending the resolution of the dispute. An appellate court, in the recent case of McCarthy Concrete, Inc. v Banton Construction Co., reminded us that the violation of this type of provision constitutes an independent breach of the contract, and supports the imposition of liability the same as a breach of any other substantive provision of the contract.

Background

In the early 2010s, Amtrak undertook to expand its Empire Corridor trackage between its Albany-Rensselaer and Schenectady train stations by adding a fourth track. In April of 2014, Amtrak hired Middlesex Corp. as its general contractor which, in turn, retained Banton Construction Company to perform a specified scope of work in connection with the project. In October of 2014, Banton hired McCarthy Concrete to complete the concrete work for the platform extensions. This work included the structural concrete for the pile caps and inspection pits, and the concrete overlay for the platforms. The lump sum subcontract had certain enumerated exclusions, including concrete pumping and tactile work, and included unit pricing for the actual quantity of concrete used. As to claimed changes, the subcontract also contained a provision requiring McCarthy to “immediately perform the work as changed without delay”, and “pending resolution of any claim, dispute or other controversy, nothing shall excuse McCarthy from proceeding with prosecution of the work”.

In the summer of 2015, Amtrak ordered a suspension of the project, and Banton directed McCarthy to demobilize. Banton and McCarthy worked to resolve some then-outstanding payment issues, which ultimately resulted in a lawsuit in Connecticut. That lawsuit was settled with the understanding that Banton would pay certain of McCarthy’s claims, and McCarthy would return to work when Amtrak lifted the suspension. As a part of the resumption of work, Amtrak changed the plans which, as far as McCarthy was concerned, included the use of concrete pumping and the installation of tactile warning strips. Banton requested proposals for the changed work from McCarthy, and the proposals ultimately provided by McCarthy were not acceptable to Banton. In September of 2016, Banton directed McCarthy to return to work, stating that it was “willing to fund the alleged added costs for concrete pumping and added reinforcing, under a reservation of rights”. Banton also warned McCarthy that if it did not return to work, it would terminate McCarthy and retain a completion contractor. Ultimately, McCarthy never returned to the job, citing the lack of assurances of payment for the new work. Banton followed through on the termination and the hiring of a replacement contractor.

McCarthy sued Banton for some unpaid rebar left at the site, and to recover its unpaid retainage. Importantly, McCarthy also sued for its lost profits; the money it claimed it would have made but for the allegedly improper termination of its contract. Banton asserted a counterclaim, alleging that McCarthy breached the subcontract by failing to return to the job on account of the payment dispute, in violation of the subcontract’s work directive provision. The matter was tried to a judge, who decided in favor of McCarthy on its principal claim. The trial court awarded McCarthy a judgment in the total amount of $92,582.98, which was the value of the unpaid rebar, the retainage, and $28,500 in lost profits. Banton appealed, arguing that McCarthy’s breach of the contract by failing to return to the site, where the contract language required continued performance despite the existence of a payment dispute, excused it from having to pay McCarthy (or, at a bare minimum, was an offset against McCarthy’s claim).

Decision

While the trial court gave short shrift to the “continue working” provision, the appellate court found that the breach of this provision required reversal. The appellate court specifically noted that as “plaintiff had agreed, pursuant to the subcontract, to continue the work while pursing dispute resolution, its failure to perform the work amounted to a breach of the subcontract. Thus, we disagree with Supreme Court that Banton breached the contract based upon terminating the subcontract when plaintiff refused to perform absent an express agreement as to costs for the increased work. * * * Rather, we find that plaintiff breached the subcontract by refusing to perform the work as it was required to do under the subcontract and, as such, grant Banton’s counterclaim for breach of contract.” In doing so, the appellate court held that Banton was entitled to an affirmative recovery of $61,986.22 from McCarthy, which was Banton’s $106,068.22 cost to retain the replacement contractor, minus only the $44,081.93 in retainage owed to McCarthy; the appellate court held that McCarthy was not entitled to lost profits since it, not Banton, breached the contract (and also held that McCarthy had previously released the claim for the rebar).

Comment

This case is a reminder that those who live in glass houses should not throw stones; or, in the context of a breach of contract lawsuit, that the plaintiff must not first be in breach of contract itself. While, often, the withholding of work is the only leverage that an unpaid contractor has to ensure full payment, in the face of a prior agreement to continue working notwithstanding the existence of such a payment dispute, the tactic has been analogized to hostage taking—including by the appellate court here, noting that “Plaintiff’s refusal to perform the changed work without an express agreement as to increased costs had the effect of holding Banton hostage in that the work”. Accordingly, contractors would be well advised to consult with experienced construction counsel to determine what remedies they truly have, and what actions will only grasp defeat from the jaws of victory.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Thomas H. Welby at twelby@wbgllp.com or call (914) 428-2100

Companies Must Maintain Proper Work Rules and Processes for the Loading and Unloading of Materials

Secretary of Labor v. 84 Lumber Company shows the importance and need to have proper Work Rules in place that are adequately communicated to and known by employees for their safety and the safety of others, in the loading/unloading of building materials. Despite the tragic outcome and death of a truck-driver on November 19, 2019 during the loading of lumber bundles on a trailer-bed, the ALJ in this Texas case, found that the no OSHA safety standard was violated in this instance where the lumber company had in place proper work rules that had been communicated to its employees to never allow people to work under elevated loads or pass under the elevated loads of forklifts given the substantial evidence of employee training and the facts in this matter.

The Respondent, 84 Lumber Company (“84 Lumber”) was a vendor of building materials, primarily lumber, to contractors for construction projects, with multiple stores nationwide. 84 Lumber’s store (the “store”) in Houston, Texas, contracted with BLS Trucking (“BLS”) for the delivery of this store’s customer orders to respective jobsites. The same BLS drivers, approximately, seven to ten, generally were assigned to work at store. 84 Lumber had a “Work Rule” in place that instructed and communicated to its employees to not let anyone ever work under the elevated loads or pass under the elevated loads of forklifts.

84 Lumber employees would prepare and assemble the order into different bundles/loads of lumber. The next phase would involve an employee known as the dispatcher who would operate a forklift to load the lumber bundles onto the BLS trailer. At the time of the accident, BLS’s drivers were instructed to remain at the side of the truck, away from the operating path of the forklift, while the dispatcher operated the forklift and thus well outside the 180-degree radius comprising the “zone of danger” of an active forklift. Once a bundle was loaded onto the dispatcher’s forklift, the dispatcher would approach the BLS truck trailer and lower the bundle down to approximately four inches above the truck bed. At this point, the dispatcher would put the forklift in “neutral” and activate the safety brake. Following this, either the dispatcher, or the dispatcher with the assistance of the BLS driver, would, if necessary, place wooden dryers (to make it easier to insert the forks of the forklift under the bundle) under the slightly elevated bundle. The workers placed the dryers while standing on the ground to the side of the truck bed by sliding them under the slightly elevated bundle. Given the location of the bundle over the bed of the truck trailer, the workers passed behind the stationary forklift to place the dryers on either side of the bundle. Thus, at no point would the placement of dryers cause the dispatcher or the BLS driver to pass under either the forks of the forklift or the slightly elevated bundle (of about four inches) over the truck bed.

The circumstances leading to the underlying accident involved a BLS driver who after waiting between the semi-truck and the truck’s trailer while bundles were being loaded, approached the dispatcher and asked him if he could move a bundle to the other side of the truck bed so that the “strap c[ould] match up.” At this point in time, the BLS driver was standing in front of the front wheel of the trailer. The dispatcher obliged and loaded the requested bundle onto the forklift and then began to back away from the trailer. As the forklift was about two to three feet from the trailer the BLS driver “out of nowhere” ran underneath the forks of the forklift and the elevated bundle and told the dispatcher to get another “bite” on the load. The dispatcher yelled at the driver at least three to four times get out from underneath the elevated bundle and also honked the horn, but the driver did not listen and instead kept telling the dispatcher to back-up. The dispatcher continued backing up fearing that an abrupt stop would cause the bundle to fall or forklift to topple. After a matter of seconds, the bundle fell off the forklift onto the BLS driver, killing him. OSHA investigated and issued a citation based on the belief that 84 Lumber did not have a process in place to inspect or enforce its Work Rule. During the proceeding, BLS’s supervisor acknowledged that BLS trained its drivers to never work under a forklift’s forks or suspended loads and both BLS’s supervisor and 84 Lumber’s manager stated this Work Rule was common in the industry because of the obvious dangers.

Given the Work Rule in place and circumstances, there was no explicit permission for the BLS’s driver to have stood under the elevated load. However, the Secretary argued the practice of placing dryers under elevated loads as evidence of 84 Lumber’s implicit permission to walk under them. The ALJ disagreed as the evidence showed that the policy in place was that BLS drivers had to wait outside the zone of danger for an active forklift and dryers were only placed under the load when it had already been lowered three to four inches from the truck bed and from standing on either side of the now inactive forklift, and not on top or below the elevated load. Although workers were close, in proximity, to the load they were not implicitly permitted to be under it. Following the accident, BLS also instituted a new policy requiring drivers to now stand in a designated “muster area”, further away from the loading area.

If you would like more information regarding this topic please contact Costas Cyprus at ccyprus@wbgllp.com or call (914) 607-6445