Question.
This matter arises from the excavation work undertaken in anticipation
of the construction of a residential subdivision and golf course. Is the
Contractor’s surety responsible for the reimbursement of the Owner for
certain fees and costs the Owner paid to the Town, and additional fees
and costs the Owner may be required to pay to the Town, in connection
with the excavation?
Answer. YES.
The Owner is entitled to recover the excavation fees as the equitable
subrogee of the Town under certain bonds posted with respect to the
excavation.
The Owner entered into an excavation agreement
with Contractor1, pursuant to which Contractor1 undertook to perform
excavation work with respect to the Owner’s 186-acre development
project. The excavation agreement apparently was entered into in
anticipation of the conditional approval of the subdivision that
ultimately was granted by the Planning Board of the Town (hereinafter
the Planning Board). Among the conditions imposed in connection with
that approval was the requirement that the Owner implement certain
mitigation measures identified in a findings statement that had been
adopted by the Planning Board, in satisfaction of the requirements of
the State Environmental Quality Review Act (ECL art 8, hereinafter
SEQRA). One of those measures was the payment of fees required by the
Town Code.
The excavation agreement specified that
Contractor1 would be required to remove from the site and haul away
approximately 1.665 million cubic yards of material in accordance with
the SEQRA findings statement and the final engineering plan. It also
specifically obligated Contractor1 to pay “any municipal fee …
pursuant to the Town requirements,” making specific reference to the
Town Environmental Preservation Capital Reserve Fund. The agreement
also provided that Contractor1 “shall not over excavate any area.” With
respect to Contractor1’s compensation for its services, the excavation
agreement provided that the Owner would have “no financial obligation to
[Contractor1] other than [Contractor1] shall own any and all excess
material taken from the site in conformance with the approved plan.”The
excavation agreement further provided, however, that Contractor1 would
be paid $1.5 million to excavate the drainage and sewers for the
development. The excavation agreement was signed by Contractor1’s
principal.
The municipal fees to which the excavation
agreement referred (hereinafter the Environmental Fund fees) are imposed
by the Town Environmental Preservation Capital Reserve Fund Law. Prior
to commencement of the excavation, the applicant “must post a bond in
such form as shall be approved by the Town Attorney and in an amount to
be specified by the Planning Board to guarantee performance in
accordance with the approved site plan or the approved subdivision
plan”.
To satisfy its obligations under the excavation
agreement, Contractor1 entered into an oral agreement with the
Excavate-Co. According to Excavate-Co’s principal, Contractor1 agreed to
sell Excavate-Co approximately 471,425 cubic yards of excess fill at
$3.50 per cubic yard, or approximately $1.65 million, which Contractor1
would dedicate to the payment of the Environmental Fund fees due to the
Town. According to Contractor1, however, Excavate-Co was to make the
payments for the fill directly to the Town.
Surety issued a “payment bond” (hereinafter the
first payment bond) to the Town in the amount of $500,000. Executed by
Excavate-Co, the first payment bond recited that Excavate-Co, as
“Principal,” was obligated to provide a bond guaranteeing the payment of
fees to the Town for the removal of material from the site, and bound
Surety,” to pay those fees in the event that Excavate-Co failed to do
so. The first payment bond was amended on the day of its issuance to add
Contractor1 as a principal. According to Excavate-Co, however, the Town
rejected the first payment bond because the amount was insufficient.
Another “payment bond” in the amount of $1.5
million (hereinafter the second payment bond) was executed by Paving
Corp. as “Principal,” and Excavate-Co as “Sureties.” The second payment
bond recited that Paving Corp. has applied to mine property belonging to
the Owner at the same location and provided that the principal and
sureties “hereby undertake and become bound in the sum of $1,500,000 to
the Town for the payment of any sum due the Town by Paving Corp. for the
mining of property of the Owner, incidental to the development of said
site. According to Excavate-Co, the Town rejected the second payment
bond because it was not issued by a bonding company.
The Owner disputes Excavate-Co’s contention that the Town rejected the first and second payment bonds.
Contractor1 and Excavate-Co, as “Principals,”
and Surety executed a “Performance (Completion) Bond” (hereinafter the
performance bond). According to its terms, Surety was obligated to the
Town, up to the sum of $1.665 million, to satisfy the obligation of
Contractor1 and Excavate-Co to remove approximately 1.6 million cubic
yards of fill at The Owner site “in accordance with the construction
specification of the Town all in conformance with the plot and drainage
plan approved by the Town Planning Board and to the satisfaction of the
Town.”
According to Excavate-Co, the performance bond
replaced the first and second payment bonds, and was intended to comply
with the bonding requirement of Town Code, and was accepted by the Town.
The Town Attorney required, however, that the performance bond be
relabeled a “restoration bond,” and that the language of the bond be
modified to provide for Surety’s guaranty of the principals’ obligation
to remove the fill “in accordance with the construction specifications
of the Town and the Town Planning Board, as approved, pursuant to the
Town Planning Board’s Subdivision Grant, and Town Planning Board’s Site
Plan Grant, and furthermore, in conformance with the Plot and Drainage
Plan approved by the Town Planning Board and to the full satisfaction
of the Town .”
Surety made the requested change in a rider,
which was executed by Contractor1 and Excavate-Co, on behalf of
Contractor1 and Excavate-Co, respectively; the Town Board accepted the
performance bond.
According to Excavate-Co, Excavate-Co paid the
sum of $500,000 to the Town and the sum of $485,000 directly to
Contractor1 pursuant to its oral agreement with Contractor1.
Excavate-Co’s payments to the Town were made on its behalf by Paving
Corp. in the sum of $300,000.
By letter the Town advised The Owner of its
“concerns” with respect to a number of issues related to the project,
including the over-excavation of the property and the failure to pay
“all outstanding fees related to the excess materials application.”
The Town issued a stop-work order with respect
to the project, citing over-excavation of the property. In order to
resume work, The Owner paid the sum of $740,000 in Environmental Fund
fees to the Town, and agreed, in a stipulation dated to deposit with the
Town the additional sum of $250,000 with respect to the Town’s claim
for additional fees as a result of the claimed over-excavation. The
Owner also paid the sum of $50,000 to the Town for the engineering costs
the Town had incurred in determining the amount of the over-excavation.
The Owner seeks damages as equitable subrogee to the rights of the Town under the payment and performance bonds.
Equitable Subrogation
The Owner attempts to establish a contract
claim against Excavate-Co based upon Excavate-Co’s liability to the Town
under the payment and performance bonds. Although The Owner is not a
party to those bonds, it asserts that, having paid to the Town the
Environmental Fund fees and engineering costs guaranteed by the bonds,
it is entitled, as the equitable subrogee of the Town, to recover from
Excavate-Co the funds it has paid to the Town. Although The Owner’s
argument is a novel one, it is meritorious and The Owner is entitled to
judgment against Excavate-Co on this ground. The doctrine of equitable
subrogation “is broad enough to include every instance in which one
party pays a debt for which another is primarily answerable and which in
equity and good conscience should have been discharged by the latter,
so long as the payment was made either under compulsion or for the
protection of some interest of the party making the payment, and in
discharge of an existing liability
As an equitable doctrine, subrogation is
designed to promote justice, and thus, is dependent upon the particular
relationship of the parties and the nature of the controversy in each
case Considering the circumstances here, insofar as the first payment
bond and the performance bond are concerned, The Owner has satisfied all
the requisite elements of its equitable subrogation claim and thus
established its prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law
against Excavate-Co for the Environmental Fund fees and engineering
costs it paid to the Town.
In its capacity as a principal under the first
payment bond and the performance bond, Excavate-Co agreed that it would
pay the Environmental Fund fees and engineering costs directly to the
Town. “Surety bonds-like all contracts-are to be construed in accordance
with their terms” The first payment bond explicitly bound Excavate-Co
to pay up to the sum of $500,000 with reference to “fees for the removal
of materials” from the site. The performance bond expressly
incorporated by reference all of the terms, regulations, and conditions
imposed by the Town in connection with the construction and excavation
at the site, which necessarily included the obligation to pay the
Environmental Fund fees and engineering.
In satisfying Excavate-Co’s obligation to the
Town, The Owner acted “under compulsion or for the protection of some
interest” of its own. As the developer of a 177-unit residential
development, The Owner had an undeniable interest in the timely
completion and approval of the project. That interest was threatened
when the Town withheld certificates of occupancy and stopped work on the
project by reason of the alleged over-excavation. In order to address
this threat, The Owner paid the Town the sums of $990,000 in
Environmental Fund fees and $50,000 in engineering costs, and thereby
satisfied the Town’s condition for permitting development work to
resume. The payments were made, therefore, for the purpose of protecting
The Owner’s interest in the completion of the project.
Finally, the Environmental Fund fees and the
engineering costs were obligations “which in equity and good conscience
should have been discharged by” Excavate-Co. Excavate-Co agreed, both
as a principal on the performance bond and in its oral contract with
Contractor1, to pay the Environmental Fund fees and engineering costs
required by the Town. In return, Excavate-Co took possession of the
fill, a valuable commodity. Excavate-Co thus received the benefit of its
bargain. The Owner, by contrast, both paid the fees and costs required
of it and otherwise lost the ability to recover the value of that
commodity, which would thus enable it to recover the fees and costs it
had paid. In “equity and good conscience,” therefore, The Owner should
be able to recover the value of its payments to the Town from
Excavate-Co.
On this basis, The Owner thus established its
prima facie entitlement to judgment as a matter of law with respect to
claim sounding in equitable subrogation, insofar as asserted against
Excavate-Co on the first payment bond and the performance bond. The same
cannot be said, however, of The Owner’s claim with respect to the
second payment bond. Excavate-Co is not a principal under the second
payment bond; the principal on that bond is Paving Corp.. There is no
evidence as to the relationship between Excavate-Co and Paving Corp..
The Owner failed to carry its burden, therefore, with respect to its
equitable subrogation claim under the second payment bond.
In response to The Owner’s prima facie showing
with respect to the performance bond and the first payment bond,
Excavate-Co’s obligation, if it is to avoid the entry of judgment
against it, is to demonstrate the existence of a material and triable
issue of. Excavate-Co raised such an issue with respect to the first
payment bond, but has not done so with respect to the performance bond.
Generally, delivery and receipt of a bond
constitutes sufficient approval and acceptance of it Here, however, the
Town Code requires that the bond be “approved by the Town Attorney …
in an amount to be specified by the Planning Board”. Excavate-Co claims
that the Town did not accept the first payment bond.. Thus, Excavate-Co
raised a material issue of fact whether the Town Board had accepted
those bonds pursuant to the requirements of the Town Code
Excavate-Co did not raise a triable issue of fact, however, with regard to the Town’s acceptance of the performance bond.
Surety
Surety contends that the Town never accepted
the performance bond because it was renamed a “restoration bond” and
that, in any event, the performance bond only obligated it to pay the
cost of restoring the premises in the event of default by the
contractor. Contrary to these contentions, as shown above, the Town
Board issued a resolution adopting the performance bond which, as
amended, did not absolve Surety of its conditional liability as surety
for the payment of the Environmental Fund fees and engineering costs,
but rather expanded Surety’s obligations to include a requirement that
it restore the site in the event of breach by the principals. Surety
also argues that The Owner cannot recover under the doctrine of
equitable subrogation because it was satisfying its own debt when making
payments to the Town. As discussed above, however, the Owner was paying
the obligations of Contractor1 and Excavate-Co, obligations for which
Surety was conditionally liable as surety under the performance bond.