In each issue of the BAHV Newsletter, Thomas S.
Tripodianos, Esq. provides our members with answers to their commercial
litigation, real estate and construction law questions.
William A. Brenner, CPA provides members with
information on a variety of business management, profitability and tax
topics, intended to increase member awareness and stimulate thought
about issues that can greatly affect profitability, business growth and
quality of life.
Both Tom and Bill have often given the advice
that no one professional can properly satisfy all your needs. Rather, a
“Management Team” should be assembled to address the multitude of
issues facing your business. At a minimum your team should consist of
an attorney, accountant, and insurance professional.
In this special joint installment of their
columns Bill and Tom explore the pros and cons of the various
organizational forms available to business owners.
Choice of Organizational Form
Choosing an organizational form that best suits
the needs of a business and its participants is complicated. This
article presents a cursory introduction to the legal and tax
implications of the choice.
The Range of Organizational Choices
The organizational forms that they can be used
to structure a for-profit business exist along a continuum. Each form
can be manipulated to approximate the characteristics of the others.
Keep in mind that whatever structure you choose, it will not
significantly affect how you conduct your day to day business. The
organizational form determines legal relationships, responsibilities for
business debts, and tax liability.
The more common choices available to business owners are:
Sole proprietorship. A single individual owns
the business assets and is liable for any business debts;
Proprietorships usually are small, with few capital needs that cannot be
met from the owner’s resources and from lenders. There can’t be more
than one owner of a sole proprietorship.
General partnership. If you arrange to operate
the business with someone else, while sharing control and profits, you
automatically create a partnership. As partners, you are each
individually liable for all partnership debts. Partnerships are
prevalent in service industries – such as law, accounting, and medicine –
where trust must exist among the participants and capital needs are not
great.
Limited partnership. You can form a limited
partnership in which so-called limited partners provide capital and are
liable only to the extent of their investment. General partners run the
business and are fully liable for partnership debts. Since limited
partners need not be general partners, one person or entity could be the
general partner and both can be limited partners. Limited partnerships
combine tax advantages and limited liability.
Limited liability Company. (“LLC”) You could
form a limited liability company – an entity that is a hybrid between a
corporation and a partnership. Like a partnership, the members of an LLC
provide capital and manage the business according to their operating
agreement; their interests are not freely transferable. Like a
corporation, members are not personally liable for debts of the LLC
entity.
Corporation. You can form a legal entity called
a corporation. Shareholders provide capital, and directors and officers
manage the business. Unless there is fraud or inequity that justifies
“piercing the corporate veil”, corporate participants are not personally
liable for corporate debts; only the corporation is liable.
Corporations are the principal means of organizing businesses with
complex organizational structures and large capital needs. The corporate
form, however, works for any size business, including a one-person
“incorporated proprietorship.”
There are other variants. A joint venture is
basically a partnership with a defined, closed-end objective. In a
business trust, investors transfer property to a trustee who manages and
controls the property for their benefit. The investors’ beneficial
interests are freely transferable, and the beneficiaries generally are
not liable for trust debts. A professional corporation allows certain
professionals – doctors, lawyers, and accountants – to obtain some
advantages of incorporation without running afoul of ethical rules that
prohibit professionals from limiting their liability through use of the
traditional corporate form.
Choosing between a Partnership and a Corporation
If you want to share in the control and profits
of the business, you would likely choose between a partnership, limited
liability company, or a corporation. Although a business planner can
adapt each form to suit particular needs, some characteristics are
relatively immutable – formation, liability, and tax. Others require
planning – duration, management, and transfer of ownership interests.
Life Span – Formation and Duration
General Partnership. A general partnership is
created any time two or more persons associate to carry on a business as
co-owners to share profits and control. It requires no legal
documentation. Unless agreed otherwise, a general partnership dissolves
upon the death, bankruptcy, or withdrawal of any partner. Without
planning, there is no assurance that a partner will not withdraw and
demand that the business be liquidated.
Limited Partnership. A limited partnership
arises when a certificate is filed with a state official. A limited
partnership lasts as long as the parties agree or, absent agreement,
until a general partner withdraws.
Limited Liability Company. An LLC arises when
two members file articles of organization with a state official. Unless
otherwise provided for by agreement, an LLC dissolves upon the death or
withdrawal of any member.
Corporation. A corporation arises when articles
of incorporation are filed with a state official. Corporate existence
is perpetual, regardless of what happens to shareholders, directors, or
officers.
Management -Authority to Bind and Control the Business
General Partnership. Each partner is an agent
of all other partners and can legally bind the partnership, either by
transacting business as agreed by the partners (actual authority) or by
appearing in the eyes of third parties to carry on partnership business
(apparent authority). Unless otherwise agreed, a majority vote of the
partners decides ordinary partnership matters, but anything that is
extraordinary or contravenes the agreement requires unanimity.
Limited Partnership. General partners have
authority to legally bind the partnership as to ordinary matters.
Limited partners have voting authority over specified matters.
Limited Liability Company. Most LLC statutes
give broad authority to bind the LLC in much the same way as partners.
Management of the LLC business is decided in proportion to the members’
capital contributions, unless the members agree to centralize
decision-making by electing managers.
Corporation. The corporation has a centralized
management structure. Its business is under the management and
supervision of the board of directors. Officers carry out the policies
formulated by the board. Shareholders elect the board and decide
specified fundamental matters; they cannot bind the corporation.
Transfer of Ownership Interests-Free or Restricted
General Partnership. A partner cannot transfer
his or her interest in the partnership unless all of the remaining
partners agree, or the partnership agreement permits it.
Limited Partnership. A general partner cannot
transfer its interest unless all of the other general and limited
partners agree, or the partnership agreement permits it. Limited partner
interests are freely assignable.
Limited Liability Company. An LLC member cannot
transfer her LLC interest unless all of the other members consent. Some
LLC statutes suggest that under specified circumstances, the articles
of organization can provide standing consent to new members.
Corporation. Corporate shares are freely transferable unless there are specific written restrictions.
Liability – Unlimited or Limited
General Partnership. Partners have unlimited
liability. Their personal assets are at risk for all partnership
obligations, whether they are contractual or arise because of misconduct
(torts) of the partners or partnership employees.
Limited Partnership. At least one partner must
be a general partner, with unlimited liability. Limited partners are
liable only to the extent of their investment, so long as they do not
“participate in the control” of the business. Older statutes did not
define “participation,” and courts construed the term broadly. Limited
partners were said to participate in control if they shared in
operational decisions, retained control of financial matters, and
decided the general partner’s tenure. Modern statutes clarify that some
activities do not constitute participation in control. Limited partners
do not lose their limited liability merely by being officers,
directors, or shareholders of a corporate general partner, voting on
major business matters, or advising the general partner.
Limited Liability Company. In both their
capacities as capital contributors and managers, LLC members are not
liable for LLC obligations beyond their investment. Some statutes,
however, state that LLC members can become liable for LLC obligations by
reason of their own acts.
Corporation. Shareholders have limited
liability for corporate obligations. This is true also for directors and
officers acting on behalf of the corporation. Corporate participants
can lose only what they have invested unless there is fraud or an
inequity that justifies “piercing the corporate veil.” Often, large
creditors of small corporations will demand that corporate participants
personally guarantee the corporation’s obligations, thus reducing the
significance of corporate limited liability.
With any of these entities, if a partner,
member of shareholder personally guarantees debt of the entity, he or
she will be liable for that debt if the entity is unable to comply with
its repayment terms.
If you would like more information regarding
this topic, please contact Thomas S. Tripodianos at
TTripodianos@wbgllp.com, or by phone at 845-294-5500 x 317. Bill
Brenner can be reached at , or by phone at 914-949-2990 x 313.
Please understand that this column provides
general information only, and should not be construed as legal or tax
advice to anyone under any circumstances. While we encourage you to
contact us, you should not disclose to us any information that you
consider confidential unless and until we have formally established an
attorney-client or accountant-client relationship, and agreed to
represent you in your particular matter. The opinions expressed in this
column are of the individual authors, and not necessarily those of the
Builder’s Association of the Hudson Valley.
Thomas S. Tripodianos is a partner at the law
firm of Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP. Welby, Brady &
Greenblatt, LLP emphasizes the practice of Construction Law,
representing general contractors, subcontractors, sureties, developers,
owners, suppliers, engineers, homeowners and other entities connected
with the construction industry in transactions, litigation, arbitration,
mediation, public and private construction contracts, mechanic’s liens,
surety law and environmental law. Welby, Brady & Greenblatt, LLP
has its principal office in White Plains, New York, and also has offices
in New Jersey and Connecticut. Mr. Tripodianos resides in Orange
County.
Bill Brenner is a manager at the accounting and
consulting firm of Citrin Cooperman & Company, LLP. Ranked among
the top 40 accounting firms in the U.S., Citrin Cooperman provides
business consulting, tax and accounting services to business owners in
the Tri-state area and Hudson Valley. The Firm has offices in White
Plains, mid-town Manhattan, and Springfield, New Jersey.