Question. Can a lienor recover for work performed outside the contract even if the lien is deemed to be willfully exaggerated
Answer. YES.
This case gives us the opportunity to examine how and when a lien is
deemed “willfully exaggerated” under the Mechanics Lien Law.
Architect seeks foreclosure of a mechanic’s lien
and money damages based upon breach of contract, quantum meruit and
unjust enrichment. Owner counterclaims for damages based upon willful
exaggeration of a mechanic’s lien and breach of contract.
Architect entered into a written contract with
Owner whereby Architect agreed to provide architectural services to
Owner in connection with the construction of a multi-use building for
the sum of $50,000. Pursuant to the contract, which was drafted by
Architect, additional fees were permitted, for preparation of amendments
to conform to as-built conditions if required. Additionally, Owner was
responsible for all fees including filing fees, microfilming, and permit
fees. Pursuant to the agreement, Owner paid $74,555.50 to Architect for
services rendered and costs incurred. Architect’s invoices, which do
not seem to have been prepared or sent to Owner on a regular basis,
indicate that Owner still owed Architect an additional $68,664.21.
Several months later Architect added $46,200 to
Owner’s invoice for “coordination of plans and applications due to
excessive construction delays.” Then ten days later, Architect added an
additional $12,357.75, which represented 18 percent interest, to Owner’s
bill, even though the contract entered into between the parties made no
provision for interest. This increased the amount allegedly owed to
Architect to $127,938.96.
Eventually, an agreement was reached between the
parties whereby Owner would pay Architect an additional $20,000 in
settlement of all claims for services performed and fees incurred. As
part of this agreement, Architect agreed to remove the mechanic’s lien,
replace some documents in the file of the Department of Buildings and
obtain a final certificate of occupancy.
Owner paid Architect $15,000 and Architect filed a
satisfaction of mechanic’s lien. The final payment of $5,000 pursuant
to the agreement was to be made upon the issuance of a final certificate
of occupancy. During this time, however, Architect was being
investigated and was stripped of his ability to make any filings with
the Department of Buildings. Owner went to the Department of Buildings
and obtained a final certificate of occupancy and refused to pay the
final $5,000 to Architect.
Architect then added 18 percent interest
($8,470.42) to the invoice of Owner, and $5,000 for the filing of the
final certificate of occupancy. Shortly thereafter, Architect filed
mechanic’s liens in the amount of $126,409.38.
While the mechanic’s liens filed herein included
amounts which were not authorized by the contract between the parties,
the issue is whether any of the amounts charged were “wilfully
exaggerated” pursuant to Lien Law ¬ß39.
The burden of proving “wilful exaggeration,”
namely that the amounts set forth were “intentionally and deliberately
exaggerated,” is on the owner of the property. To be “wilful,” the
exaggeration cannot be based upon an honest mistake, inaccuracies or a
difference in opinion.
In this case, the parties did not memorialize most
of their conversations and any agreements subsequent to the written
contract. Although Owner paid Architect $39,555.50 more than the
contracted amount, except for the $15,000 toward the settlement, there
is no documentary evidence corresponding to or explaining any of these
additional payments. Although much of the work appears to have been
performed and necessary, some of the charges were clearly unilaterally
concocted by Architect without any reasonable explanation. These charges
include the $46,200 which was added right before the filing of the
first mechanic’s lien, and the seemingly random $12,357.75 and $8,470.42
of 18 percent interest charges. The interest charges were neither
authorized nor mentioned in the written contract which was drafted by
Architect. These interest charges cannot be claimed to be an honest
mistake since a similar interest charge was made and reversed seemingly
after Owner complained. Additionally, the timing of these charges
support the finding of willfulness since they were made either
immediately prior to the filing of a mechanic’s lien and/or so far
removed in time from when the charges accrued indicating that they were
retaliatory and/or merely to inflate the bill. Regardless of the motive,
the foregoing charges were added to Owner’s invoice without any
reasonable justification. Accordingly, Architect, prior to filing the
mechanic’s liens sought to be foreclosed knowingly, purposefully and
intentionally added unauthorized charges to Owner’s account in the
amount of $67,028.07.
Since Owner sustained it’s burden of proving
willful exaggeration of the mechanic’s lien, pursuant to ¬ß39 of the Lien
Law, Architect’s mechanic’s liens should be declared to be void and
Architect’s cause of action to foreclose is dismissed. Additionally,
Owner is entitled to damages in the amount of $67,028.17, the
exaggerated amount of the liens.
Even though Architect’s foreclosure action is
dismissed based upon its willful exaggeration of its mechanic’s lien,
it’s claims seeking to recover damages for unpaid work performed can
still be maintained.