Skip to main content

Author: Thomas H. Welby

Safety Policy: Confined Space Construction Standard May Soon Become Final Rule

As you probably know, OSHA has separate standards for general industry and construction. The general construction standards are Part 1910 of Volume 29 of the Code of Federal Regulations, and the construction standards are Part 1926.

Just because your company does what you regard as “construction work,” that doesn’t mean that the general industry standards never govern work that you do. Construction and modernization work generally fall under Part 1926, but maintenance and repair activities are governed by the general industry standards of Part 1910. It’s the nature of the activity being performed, not the primary line of work or other attributes of the employer, that governs.

For years, OSHA’s general industry standards have included rules for work in “confined spaces.” Such spaces are defined as:

  • Large enough, and arranged in such a manner, that employees can enter;
  • Having limited or restricted means of ingress or egress; and
  • Not designed for continuous employee occupancy.

A primary feature of the general industry rules is the “permit-required” confined space. This refers not to a permit granted by a government agency, but procedures whereby the employer restricts who may enter certain hazardous confined spaces, and with what precautions.

OSHA’s general industry standard defines a “permit-required confined space” as one with at least one of the following characteristics:

  • A hazardous atmosphere, or the potential to contain one;
  • Material having the potential to engulf entrants;
  • An internal configuration that could cause an entrant to be trapped or asphyxiated by inwardly converging walls, or a floor that slopes downward and tapers to a smaller cross-section; or
  • Other recognized, serious safety or health hazards.

Further features of the general industry standard include warnings to employees; the identification and control of hazards existing in permit-required confined spaces, and the necessity for a comprehensive, written confined space entry program. Since primary confined space hazards include too little oxygen, or the accumulation of toxic or flammable contaminants, atmospheric monitoring, isolation and ventilation may also be required.

The general industry standard requires employees entering or supervising entry operations to be designated, trained and qualified, and that contractors be informed of hazards posed by entry. Required, also, is an emergency response plan.

Although applicable to maintenance and repair work, historically the general industry standards have not applied to construction work. Construction standards for trenching, excavation and tunneling operations, although having similarities with the general industry confined space standards, are governed by ¬ß 1926.651 (trenching and excavations) and ¬ß 1926.800 (tunneling).”

At present, the primary construction standard that applies to confined spaces is § 1926.21, which requires in part that:

All employees required to enter into confined or enclosed spaces shall be instructed as to the nature of the hazards involved, the necessary precautions to be taken, and in the use of protective and emergency equipment required. The employer shall comply with any specific regulations that apply to work in dangerous or potentially dangerous areas.

The current construction standard defines “confined or enclosed spaces” to include, without limitation, “storage tanks, process vessels, bins, boilers, ventilation or exhaust ducts, sewers, underground utility vaults, tunnels, pipelines, and open top spaces more than 4′ in depth such as pits, tubs, vaults, and vessels.”

There exist additional, secondary construction standards that address confined space hazards in underground construction (Subpart S), underground electric transmission and distribution work (¬ß 1926.956), excavations (Subpart S) and welding and cutting (Subpart J). In the absence of a comprehensive OSHA construction standard, the CO’s accept compliance and training consistent with ANSI National Standard ANSI Z117.1-1989, “Safety Requirements for Confined Spaces” as satisfactory.

Things are expected, however, to change in the near future. After a glacial rulemaking process dating back to 1984, OSHA is expected within the next months to promulgate, as a final rule, a proposed new construction standard. The good news is that (in its “not quite final” form) on the merits, the new rule has much to commend it. The bad news is that it varies significantly from, and is more complex than, the ANSI standard which has been pretty much the de facto construction standard for decades. The proposed rule and explanatory material in the Federal Register ran to 49 pages (80 single-spaced pages, when printed out from the “Federal Register Online”).

OSHA’s rationale for having a distinct construction standard is based, among other considerations, on the evolving character of construction sites (with confined spaces changing, as the work progresses) and the characteristics of the construction workforce, with high turnover, employees performing short-term tasks, and working at multiple worksites.

While obviously I can’t fully describe the new standard fully (and significant last-minute changes could occur) some key differences between the new construction standard, in its current form, and the general industry standard are worth mentioning.

First, the construction standard is organized essentially in a chronological order, taking a step-by-step approach to assessing hazards, classifying the space, and how to safely enter it.

The new standard will require confined spaces to be classified as one of the following:

  • Continuous System Permit Required Confined Space (CS-PCRS);
  • Permit Required Confined Space (PCRS);
  • Controlled Atmosphere Confined Space (CACS); or
  • Isolated Hazard Confined Space (IHCS).

The PCRS is much the same as under the existing general industry standard. The CS-PCRS is one that is a part of, and contiguous with, larger confined space (such as a sewer) so as to require special precautions.

A “Controlled Atmosphere Confined Space” is one where ventilation alone should suffice to maintain atmospheric hazards at safe levels. The “Isolated Hazard Confined Space” is one in which all physical and atmospheric hazards have been “isolated,” which is to say eliminated or removed – such as by misaligning or removing sections of lines, pipes or ducts, installing guard rails, stairs or platforms to eliminate fall hazards, etc.

The proposed construction standard requires the “controlling contractor” to coordinate entry operations among contractors who have employees entering a confined space, even if the controlling contractor does not itself have employees who will enter it. Whereas the general industry standard provides for atmospheric monitoring “as necessary,” the new standard is more stringent, in that it requires continuous monitoring, unless it is affirmatively determined that periodic monitoring will suffice.

Employers will also be required to provide, calibrate and maintain PPE, as well as portable gas monitoring instruments, continuous air monitoring instruments for use during entry, air purifying respirators, self-contained breathing apparatus and supplied air systems, and entry and retrieval equipment for use by rescue teams in an emergency.

The new standard is more demanding, also, in that requirements for prompt rescue will require training and equipping on-site rescue teams, at locations where reliance on outside rescue professionals has hitherto been the norm.

This is a subject we’ll return to in future articles, but it definitely needs to be “on your radar,” even though its effective date has not yet been announced.

Safety Policy: Most Construction Employers Should Have Written Heat Stress Management Programs

With warm weather returning, you should be thinking of your company’s responsibility to protect employees against the dangers of heat stress. As most construction trades involve outdoor work and/or exposure to high temperatures, if you don’t have a formal, written program, you need to develop one. And, if you do have a program, you should review it to ensure its adequacy, and consider extra training for your workforce.

While heat stroke is the most acute danger associated with exposure to high temperatures and humidity, heat stress poses many additional dangers. It lowers physical performance and mental alertness, and promotes irritability, anger, and inattention. It can also complicate many medical conditions. A particular danger of heat stress is that it can go unrecognized, and affected persons will often attempt to shrug it off, with dangerous or even fatal consequences.

In Secretary v. Post Buckley Schuh & Jernigan, Inc., the employer was a consultant in engineering and architectural design. The job at hand involved “archeological field work,” or surveying a site for artifacts. A team, consisting of archeologists or anthropologists, clears an area of brush, and uses hand shovels to dig 1-square-foot holes about 3 feet in depth. The extracted soil is then screened for artifacts, and the results recorded.

This work was in preparation for the installation of a 100-mile long pipeline in Texas, south of San Antonio. Employee “C.L.” had missed discussion of protection against the summer heat at an initial orientation. On his first day, his supervisor had returned to her hotel after being stung by a bee. C.L. and a second new hire were not, therefore, given any instructions regarding heat stress, other than an admonition to “take it pretty slow and easy” and to work “at any pace they could.”

As the temperature climbed from about 84¬∞ (with 63% humidity) toward an afternoon high of 97¬∞, the team members set about performing their “shovel tests.” Ms. Hopwood, the archeologist filling in for the absent team leader, checked on C.L. at roughly 10:30 A.M. C.L. stated he was “not feeling well,” and was instructed by Ms. Hopwood to sit down, rest, and drink some water. The only available shade in the immediate area was provided by small mesquite trees.

About 15 minutes later, Ms. Hopwood again checked with C.L. and, when he reported that he still wasn’t feeling well, she told him to go sit in the company truck (some 300 feet distant, on the main road) with the air conditioning on.

About an hour later, C.L. returned, said that he had drunk some water and eaten some almonds while sitting in the air-conditioned truck, and that he felt much better. Later, Ms. Hopwood would say that she found C.L.’s “exuberance” rather strange, but dismissed it as C.L. was viewed as rather odd, generally, wherefore his behavior was not seen as a sign of disorientation.

As lunchtime was approaching, Ms. Hopwood had C.L. finish a shovel test, and then asked him to return to the truck, and drive it near to where the team was working, so that the water cooler, which was in the truck, would be nearby. When C.L. did not return promptly, team members dispatched to look for him found him driving the truck, much too fast, up and down the dirt road. He had been unable to locate the team, even though he had gone to and from the truck scarcely an hour before.

C.L. spent much of the lunch hour in the air-conditioned truck, but between 15 and 30 minutes outside, exposed to the heat. About 20 minutes after work resumed, Ms. Hopwood checked on him and found that, although instructed to clear brush only in a 1′ x 1′ area, C.L. had cleared an area about 5′ x 9′. She found this to be very strange, but merely instructed him not to clear so large an area.

Again checking on C.L. at around 3:00 P.M., Ms. Hopwood founding him standing some 20 yards away from his test area, holding grass in his hand. He reported that he was “not lollygagging but feeling a bit disoriented.” She told him to go sit in the shade and drink some water; later, it was determined that he did not take any water.

About half an hour later, Ms. Hopwood again encountered C.L., who was unable to respond intelligibly to a question. She told C.L. to go sit in the air conditioned truck, and that the rest of the team would join him upon finishing work for the day, in about 20 minutes. C.L. said he thought that would be a good idea, and headed off in the direction of the truck, some 300 feet away.

When the crew headed back to the vehicles at about 4:00 P.M., C.L. was nowhere to be seen. Team members went looking for him, and found him, face down and curled up in a ditch, about 300 yards down the road from the truck. He was unconscious, breathing heavily, and hot to the touch. Team members poured water on him and applied wet handkerchiefs, while waiting for the ambulance.

C.L. was removed to the hospital, and died there a few days later. The autopsy found that his initial core temperature was 107.8° F.

Because there is not an OSHA standard directly on point, the employer was cited for a “Serious” violation under the General Duty Clause. The only doubtful element of a General Duty Clause violation was the existence of a feasible and acceptable method to abate a recognized hazard. The Secretary proposed that a “heat stress management program,” including “threshold limit values” and “biological exposure indices” published by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists, and/or procedures set forth in a document entitled, “Working in Hot Environments,” by the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health was such a method.

The ALJ found that the test as to both documents was whether their standards (1) had been adopted by the Secretary as a regulation or a consensus standard, or (2) recognized by the industry. With the help of expert witness testimony from both sides, the ALJ found that the NIOSH document (but not the ACGIH guidelines) had gained recognition in the industry, and should therefore be seen as establishing the existence of an acceptable means of abating heat stress.

Briefly, the six elements (the first five of which are contained in the NIOSH document, “Working in Hot Environments”) (available online) are these:

  1. Acclimatize employees beginning work in a hot environment, or returning from absences of 3 or more days. Increments are not provided, but adjusting to heat generally takes 5-7 days.
  2. Development a work/rest regimen. How much rest following how much work is not stated, but the concept is that there should be rest periods at regular intervals, in lieu of requiring workers to ask for permission to rest. Brief, but frequent, rest periods are best.
  3. Provide cool water and encourage employees to drink 5-7 oz. of water every 15-20 minutes. Do not rely on employees’ drinking water only when they are thirsty.
  4. Provide for a cool rest area. A maximum temperature of 76° F. is recommended. The ALJ was troubled that, in the case before him, the air-conditioned company truck could take up to 15 minutes to reach on foot.
  5. Train employees regarding health effects of heat stress, symptoms of heat-induced illnesses, and methods of preventing such illnesses. In addition to training employees, you should keep written records, with the names of employees trained, and dates.
  6. Establish a screening program to identify health conditions aggravated by exposure to heat stress.

While the ALJ did not accept item (6) as recognized by the industry and the respondent (as the same does not appear in the NIOSH Document) the employer’s heat stress management program was found deficient as to all of items 1-5, and so the citation and penalty were affirmed.

The ALJ rejected the employer’s view that all elements of its program need not be in writing. “Without written policies to facilitate training…or to provide employees with the [employer’s] expectations, respondent cannot have an effective heat safety program.” This statement probably doesn’t have the full force of law, but your program will be more effective, and you will be better able to demonstrate compliance with the OSH Act’s training requirements, if your program is in writing.

Safety Policy: Getting the Most from Toolbox Meetings

The OSH Act imposes on employers a duty to train employees to recognize and avoid recognized safety and health hazards in the workplace.

Full-bore formal training for the rank-and-file in the dizzying array of OSHA construction standards is problematic. Studies have shown that even the OSHA 10-hour and 30-hour courses have limited effectiveness, among other things because these (as well as many programs designed by safety consultants) assume a higher level of sophistication than the attendees possess, and befuddle many of them with an excess of jargon, acronyms, and “buzzwords.” A further problem is that many construction workers, in the New York metro region as in many other parts of the country, have limited proficiency in English.

OSHA compliance is important, but the paramount goal of your company’s safety program is not to avoid OSHA citations, but to minimize injuries and job-related illness among your workforce. While there is no comprehensive “one size fits all” strategy, elements I recommend for consideration include the following.

First, without suggesting that you forego efforts to train all your workers, I believe it gets you more “bang for the buck” to hire, strive to retain, and train thoroughly field supervisors in OSHA compliance and construction safety.

Second, while you can be cited for any of scores of distinct construction hazards, a relative handful of dangers account for most deaths and serious injuries (and most OSHA citations, as well). Fall protection, scaffolding, excavations, “caught-between” and “struck-by” hazards, unsafe ladders and usage of ladders, and electrocutions are the primary construction safety issues. Nearly every construction employer will be cited by OSHA from time to time, but your employees’ onsite conduct, in recognizing and avoiding the hazards mentioned, is probably the best indicator of whether your company is a safe place to work.

Conversely, you can spend on glossy manuals and consultants, but if your employees work on elevated surfaces without tying off, or go down into unshored trenches, you’re not getting the job done.

An indispensable element to safety success is leadership. Everybody in your employ should be absolutely convinced that his or her safety is a major concern of ownership and management. This implies that supervisors will be knowledgeable concerning OSHA requirements, but also that they be encouraged to call out, and to discipline, workers who disregard safety rules.

A fundamental part of every company’s safety program is so-called “toolbox” (or “tailgate”) meetings, at which safety issues are discussed. Such meetings should not only not be neglected, but they can be done in a way that imparts important information, while stressing a genuine concern for worker safety, or in a way that suggests that you are just going through the motions.

Toolbox meetings should be kept short (5 to 15 minutes) but they should not be done perfunctorily. The beginning or end of the work day is generally the best time to have them. After everyone has clocked in on the morning of the first workday of the week is probably ideal. The meeting should be held in a comfortable area where the presenter can be heard, and extraneous noise and distractions are at a minimum. Whether to have such meetings with your entire workforce, or in small groups of workers who work together, or perform similar tasks, is a judgment call that should take into account many factors, to include logistics, scheduling conflicts, potential language issues, and the desirability of getting employees actively involved in the discussion.

Every toolbox meeting should be memorialized in writing, attendees’ names should be legibly recorded on a sign-in sheet, and the name of the presenter, and the subject(s) discussed, should be recorded (and don’t forget to write down the date!) These records should be preserved. One reason for them is to document training for purposes of OSHA compliance, but another is that critical topics – such as fall protection and the others mentioned above – need to be repeated, necessitating a record as to when each such subject was last discussed. Additionally, the regular presenter may be unavailable on a given day, or need to be replaced more permanently. His or her replacement should know which topics have been covered.

The best topics are, obviously, ones that are relevant to current working conditions. While hand-outs are a good idea, reading in a flat tone of voice from a manual is not. The presenter should review in advance, and understand, the topic to be discussed. Employees should be encouraged to ask questions, and to recount experiences or observations related to the topic. Questions to which the presenter does not know the answer should be checked into, and reported on at the next meeting. Each meeting should begin with a brief review of what was discussed at the preceding meeting, for the benefit of employees who may have been absent.

Certain topics (medical emergencies in particular) should be gone over briefly, not less than once a month. This will often include reminding employees as to the location of first-aid equipment, how to summon first responders, how to respond to electrical shocks, and the location of fire extinguishers.

In addition to the topics mentioned above, additional topics can be adapted from the OSHA 10-hour materials, or from a wide variety of commercial and online safety resources.

One resource I came across that looks highly useful is the website safetyawakenings.com. That site offers free access to a menu of about 300 safety topics, with short outlines in both English and Spanish. The topics include both general industry and construction topics (wherefore, not all 300 will be useful) and was compiled especially for use in California. Nevertheless, it’s a terrific source of ideas for meetings and hand-outs (and bilingual as well).

Brief toolbox meetings should complement, not substitute for, more in-depth safety training. They’re important, however, both for the information they impart, as well as being a frequent reminder that safety should be kept in mind at all times.

Safety Policy: Commercial Diving Employer Held Responsible to Assess Danger From Construction Operations

OSHA compliance can be doubly thorny whenever your company is working in collaboration with, or in proximity to, operations of another employer of the same “tier.” This is especially so, if the other company’s trade is one you don’t often work with. While you probably know that OSHA imposes a duty to protect your employees against hazards created by others, you may lack sufficient familiarity with the other trade to feel qualified to question the other employer’s procedures. Plus, obviously, you lack authority to direct the other employer’s activities, and may feel the need to defer in the interests of advancing the project.

The better practice in such situations, however, is to err on the side of safety, and to make all inquiries necessary to detect potential hazards to your employees from hazards created by others.

In Secretary of Labor v. Associated Underwater Services, the respondent (“AUS”) was a commercial diving company, and a subcontractor to British Petroleum in the construction of an oil containment boom off the coast of Washington.

Another sub, General Construction (“GC”) was installing metal pilings in the ocean floor, at a depth of 140 feet, as structural support for the containment boom.

Because the piles had to be installed at “slack tide,” and AUS’s hourly costs were higher than those of the GC crew, AUS arrived onsite only when GC employees had completed the work of taking each pile, by barge, to the place where it was to be installed, and lowering it into the water. Each pile was 22 feet long, and weighed about 8,600 lbs.

The piles were driven into the sea floor by one of two methods: an “impact hammer” and a “vibratory hammer.” On the day of the occurrence, it was the vibratory hammer that was in use. This device is secured to a crane on the barge, controlled by a network of hoses, and fastened by a hydraulic jaw to a “pad eye,” or steel plate welded to the top of the pile. The hammer, when activated, causes the piling to vibrate at 25 vibrations per second, while downward pressure from the weight of the hammer causes it to work itself into the sea floor.

Once the piling had been lowered in place, GC raised it by 1-2′, and an AUS diver, Chris Primeau, entered the water, and followed hydraulic control lines down to the location of the piling. His first task was to ensure that the area beneath the piling was free from obstructions.

The procedure was that, once the diver had determined that the place where the pile was to be driven was unobstructed, he would radio instructions to GC to lower the piling, until it reached its “point of refusal” in the ocean floor. This was the depth in the ocean floor that the piling would reach, through the force of its own weight, and the weight of the hammer.

Then, the diver would instruct GC to activate the hammer. During the approximately six minutes necessary to drive the pile to the required depth, the diver either had to remain in place near the base of the piling, or ascend a few feet to a position above the piling ? in which case, he periodically had to ask GC to stop the vibration of the hammer, to permit him to return to the base of the piling, to verify that it was being driven plumb. (Visibility at that depth is only about 3-4′).

If, at any time, the AUS diver observed any problem with the piling, he could transmit an “all stop” to the Dive Supervisor on the barge.

The vibratory hammer GC was using had jaws that opened to a maximum of 1.17″, but the thickness of the pad-eye, to which it was clamped, was 1.25″. OSHA later determined that GC employees had to “beat on it every time,” indicating that something was obviously wrong with the connection between the hammer and the 8,600 lb. piling. However, no evidence was presented that AUS was aware of any such “beating” of the hammer onto the piling, or should have suspected that GC would use a hammer .08″ too small to properly connect to the piling.

On the day in question, Primeau’s dive was preceded by the customary pre-dive “toolbox” meeting, which did not address any hazards associated with suspended loads, or diving near crane and pile-driving operations. A falling piling, both sides’ experts later agreed, is not a “general type of diving issue common to all diving.”

Once in the water and at the base of the pile, Primeau reported that too much of the cluster of hoses that control the hammer’s functions had accumulated in the water. While GC adjusted the hoses, Primeau, with the approval of his Dive Supervisor, disconnected a wire cable that GC had, for the first time on the project in question, affixed to the piling before lowering it into the water.

That accomplished, Primeau returned to the base of the piling, and gave the go-ahead to activate the hammer. Within seconds, Primeau radioed an “all stop,” and his video feed was lost. The pile had come loose from the hammer’s damaged jaws and had fallen on him, killing him.

Of three citation items that OSHA issued following this accident, the only one that came to trial requires a pre-dive assessment of the safety and health aspects of surface and underwater conditions and hazards.

The Secretary asserted that a reasonably prudent employer would have assessed hazards arising from GC’s pile-driving operation ? notably, the recognized hazard of a falling piling. GC’s written safety program called for employees to be kept clear of the fall radius, and the vibratory hammer’s operating manual cautioned that a safety line should always be attached to the pile, when extracting or hoisting it into position.

Indeed, a warning sign on the hammer itself, which AUS’s dive supervisor admitted he saw at the worksite, forbade the use of the hammer as a pile-lifting device, and cautioned that falling piles could result in serious injury or death.

At the trial level, the ALJ vacated the citation, agreeing with AUS that it was responsible only for assessing hazards from its own diving activities, and that it could not foresee that GC would use a hammer with damaged jaws, or jaws too small to securely grip the pad-eye.

On appeal, however, the Commission reversed and upheld the citation, finding that it was legally irrelevant whether the accident, or its precise cause, was foreseeable. The hazard was that the piling could fall, not that the jaws of the hammer were too small.

The Commission ruled that AUS had been assisting GC with work plainly within the definition of construction, and was therefore required to assess not only potential hazards unique to the commercial diving industry, but also construction hazards created by its fellow employers.

Had AUS inquired into procedures for installing underwater piles, it would likely have found that construction industry practice requires the use of safety lines between the piling and the crane. Especially where low-visibility conditions require the diver to carry out much of his work in close proximity to the pile, safety lines securing the pilings, until they were driven deep enough to stand on their own, are indicated (although, startlingly, they are not a consensus standard of the Association of Diving Contractors International).

The lesson here, of course, is that OSHA compliance, and protecting your employees from injury or death, requires that you make all necessary inquiries to detect and assess hazards to which your employees may be exposed, even if they are not peculiar to your trade, and are created by others.

Safety Policy: N.Y. Scaffold Law Not Quite a Strict Liability Statute

Most of you have heard of New York’s “Scaffold Law,” Labor Law ¬ß 240(1), which requires contractors, building owners, and their agents to provide adequate safety to workers subjected to elevation-related risks.

This statute is about as popular with New York liability insurers as, say, the memory of General Sherman is in Georgia. Unquestionably, it imposes a higher standard as to elevation-related risks (which include objects falling onto employees, as well as employees falling from heights) than the federal standard under OSHA.

The statute provides:

All contractors and owners and their agents . . . in the erection. . . of a building or structure shall furnish or erect, or cause to be furnished or erected for the performance of such labor, scaffolding, hoists, stays, ladders, slings, hangers, blocks, pulleys, braces, irons, ropes, and other devices which shall be so constructed, placed and operated as to give proper protection to a person so employed.

I’m a devout advocate of fall protection for construction workers. Falls are the number one cause of death and serious injury in construction. The lack of fall protection is the violation most commonly cited by OSHA.

The Scaffold Law, I nevertheless admit, steers hard in the direction of severity, as the negligence of the employee is generally not even a partial defense, where a violation results in injury. In part, I suspect, because the insurance companies like to depict a stringent law as being even more draconian than it is (with hopes of repeal, which hasn’t happened yet) it’s often said, and probably many believe, that the Scaffold Law is “strict liability statute.”

Which means, that if your employee, or your subcontractor’s employee, sustains injury in a fall, or other gravity-related occurrence, you will necessarily be held liable.

As protective as the Scaffold Law is, it’s not quite that categorical. This is illustrated by a recent interim decision by a federal judge, applying New York law, in Maher v. City of New York.

Maher, an ironworker, was working as a steel connector on a School Construction Authority job in Brooklyn. His direct employer was Glasmar Steel Erectors, headed and partly owned by Maher’s father. Glasmar was a subcontractor to Feinstein Iron Works, which in turn was a sub to Ahern Contracting Corp., the general contractor.

Throughout the day of the occurrence, Maher was wearing a harness with a six-foot lanyard. After connecting beams on the first floor of the building frame, he climbed a ladder, provided by Glasmar, to get to the second floor to connect another beam. Maher and the only other witness to the occurrence, crane operator Mark Jones, agreed that Maher was tied off to a safety line running along the second-level steel beam while performing this work.

After connecting the second-floor beam, Maher attempted to install a pentagonal brace and gusset to the intersection of a vertical beam running the height of the building, and a horizontal beam on the building’s second level. Maher testified he could not install the lower bolts on the gusset plate from the second-level horizontal beam, because the connection points were beyond his reach. Maher therefore detached his lanyard from the safety line, climbed down a ladder to the first level, and, after walking along the first-level horizontal beam, shimmied up a vertical column, to the bottom of the gusset place that he was attempting to install.

The parties disagreed as to whether the safety line was accessible to Maher at this point. Maher claimed that it was out of reach; the defendants that Maher elected not to use it. In any case, while attempting to secure the gusset plate, Maher lost his footing, fell 22 feet to the ground, and sustained multiple injuries.

Often, a Scaffold Law case will be decided in the plaintiff’s favor as to liability by motion for summary judgment. Not infrequently, the defendants simply concede damages, and dispute only the monetary value of the plaintiff’s injuries.

Maher’s Scaffold Law cause of action was conjoined with two additional claims: one under Labor Law ¬ß 200, which is essentially a codification of the common-law duty of an owner or general contractor to maintain a safe construction site, and one under Labor Law ¬ß 241(6), which requires all contractors, building owners and their agents to manage areas in which construction work is being performed, so as to provide reasonable and adequate protection to the construction workers, and others lawfully onsite.

The Maher case produced “dueling motions” for summary judgment as to liability. The magistrate judge (to whom the district judge referred the motions to hear and report) recommended that the court grant summary judgment in favor of the owner and general contractor on the Labor Law ¬ß 200 and common-law negligence claims. The magistrate found, and the district judge agreed, that the plaintiff had presented insufficient proof to establish that the owner and general contractor had the authority to supervise and control the work actually being performed.

Which is to say, that the common-law and Labor Law § 200 liability attaches only where the defendant controlled the manner in which the plaintiff performed the injury-producing work. It is not sufficient that the defendants had general supervisory authority over the construction site, including the authority to inspect the work, and stop work if required for safety reasons.

Turning to the Labor Law ¬ß¬ß 240(1) and 241(6) claims, the fact pattern in Maher was pretty much a “classic” for a case under the Scaffold Law. That is, the injured worker arguably took undue risks in unhooking his lanyard, walking along a beam while unprotected, and shimmying up a vertical beam to better position himself to install the gusset plate. If principles of comparative negligence applied, such conduct by the plaintiff would likely result in a diminution of any recovery, based on his own contributory negligence.

And, especially as a safety line was present on the second level, if Maher had found that installing the gusset plate required him to position himself in such a way that the safety line eluded his reach, arguably he should have called this to someone’s attention, and had the safety line moved, or an additional line installed, so that he could tie off while installing the gusset plate, rather than simply forging ahead.

What the magistrate judge and district judge found was that there were issues of fact, precluding summary judgment for either side and requiring a trial, as to whether the owner and general contractor had fulfilled their duties under the Scaffold Law (as well as Labor Law ¬ß 241[6]). The evidence was contradictory as to whether the safety line was within Maher’s reach as he tried to install the gusset plate. Significantly, the court found, too, that there was sufficient evidence of the availability of alternative safety devices (e.g., a ladder or a “beam buddy”) as to present an issue for a jury as to whether the actions of Maher, a well-trained, 20-year veteran who had not merely taken, but conducted, safety training, including fall protection, were the sole proximate cause of his injuries.

Thus, while the Scaffold Law is often referred to as a “strict liability” provision, a well-established exception may relieve the defendants of all liability, where the plaintiff’s own negligence was not merely a contributing cause, but the “sole proximate cause” of the occurrence.

Safety Policy: U.S. Court of Appeals Upholds “Failure to Train” Citation

In most cases, to prove an OSHA violation, the Secretary has the burden to prove four elements: (a) the applicability of the cited standard; (b) the employer’s noncompliance; (c) employee access or exposure to the violating condition; and (d) the employer’s actual or constructive knowledge (that is, that it knew or, with the exercise of reasonable diligence, could have known) of the violation.

29 C.F.R. § 1926.21(b)(2), the training standard, provides:

Each employer shall instruct each employee in the recognition and avoidance of unsafe conditions and the regulations applicable to his work environment to control or eliminate any hazards or other exposure to illness or injury.

Thus, to avoid violating OSHA, you need to keep your worksite free from hazards mentioned in the multitude of specific construction industry standards. In addition, under the General Duty Clause, you must protect employees from hazards recognized by the employer, or within the industry, as posing a danger of death or serious harm. Plus, you must train workers in the regulations, and to recognize and avoid relevant hazards.

I am something of a skeptic about the efficacy of attempts to educate the entire construction workforce in all of the intricacies of the construction regulations. I found troubling, therefore, a recent decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit, in Denver, exemplifying OSHA’s recent enthusiasm for failure-to-train citations, as well as arguably excessive judicial deference to administrative agency determinations.

In Compass Environmental, Inc. v. OSH Review Commission, the employer was constructing an underground slurry wall at a surface mine site in Colorado. A mobile excavator with a 75-foot boom was in use, to dig a trench for the slurry wall. The excavator crew consisted of the operator and a “trench hand,” whose tasks included checking the trench depth, greasing the excavator, and watching for problems that the operator could not see. To dispense grease, the trench hand used a rubber and metal hose, connected to the excavator, with a metal nozzle. The greasing was generally done after each cut, as other maintenance, including refueling, was performed.

The employer conducted a “Job Safety Analysis,” which identified as one hazard an energized 7,200 volt line crossing over one end of the site. The Job Safety Analysis prescribed that the excavator operator and trench hand be directed to maintain at least a 20′ clearance between the excavator and overhead lines. Because the trench hand was a late hire, he missed instruction regarding the power line, and while he received some individual training, it was unclear whether that included any concerning the power line.

While the employer did not prescribe procedures for refueling the excavator, the experienced operator’s standard procedure was to move the excavator at day’s end onto a compacted dirt work pad, and await the arrival, by forklift, of a 300-gallon portable fuel tank.

The excavator was operating about 200 feet from the power line, and the owner had been advised that it would soon have to de-energize it. For no obvious reason, the operator deviated from his practice of having the fuel tank brought to the work pad, and instead walked the excavator toward the tank, which had been left beneath the still-energized power line. The trench hand, walking alongside, with the grease line in his hand, was electrocuted, when the boom approached the power line.

OSHA cited the employer for working too close to the energized line, and also under the training standard. The test under the training standard is not the usual four-prong test stated at the head of this article, but focuses on whether a reasonably prudent employer would have recognized the hazard, and provided training to enable the employee to perceive and avoid it.

When Compass contested the citation, the ALJ vacated the failure-to-train item, based largely upon his finding that the trench hand’s exposure to the power line was not foreseeable. That decision was appealed by the Secretary of Labor to the OSH Review Commission, which reversed, holding that a reasonable employer would have anticipated the trench hand’s exposure to this overhead power line, and provided him with training necessary to recognize this electrocution hazard.

The employer petitioned the federal Court of Appeals to review the Commission’s determination. A 2-1 majority upheld the citation, in large part based on its determination that the employer’s recognition, in its Job Safety Analysis, of the hazard posed by the energized power line was evidence of the necessity to train the trench hand to avoid it. Accordingly, and utilizing the highly deferential, abuse-of-discretion standard applicable to administrative agency decisions, the majority affirmed the citation.

In dissent, Circuit Judge Gorsuch decried that administrative agencies’ interpretations of ambiguous statutes control, “even when most everyone thinks Congress really meant something else.” Their regulations bind, “as long and they can make the modest boast that they haven’t behaved arbitrarily or capriciously.” To overturn their factual findings, it must be shown that they “have not just erred, but clearly erred.”

Even so, the dissent argued, the Commission should not be able to impose penalties without some actual evidence the law has been violated.

The dissent pointed out that the Secretary had an evidentiary burden to show that reasonably prudent employers in the industry would have anticipated the hazard encountered, and provided the trench hand with more training than Compass did. The ALJ, in the dissenting judge’s view, had correctly vacated this citation item, for lack of evidence on this point. No witness could explain why the operator had “defied years of training and experience,” first by walking the Komatsu toward the power line, taking the trench hand with him, and in failing to maintain 20 feet of clearance. The Secretary had introduced no real evidence, the dissent argued, on the dispositive issue of whether Compass should have foreseen he would do so.

However much deference be given to agency determinations, Judge Gorsuch objected, reviewing courts must not be so ineffectual that they will accept “Delphic declarations” as to the practices of prudent employers, where evidence is legally required.

Nor should it be sufficient, the dissent argued, that the trench hand, a late hire, did not receive the training that others did regarding the power line. The standard doesn’t penalize an employer’s failure to follow its own internal procedures. Nor should it do so, as that would deter employers from exceeding OSHA’s requirements.

The dissent stressed, also, that the Secretary is not wholly constrained by existing industry norms. She can try to prove, for example, by sufficient evidence that prevailing norms are too lax to satisfy a “reasonably prudent” standard.

Alternatively, if the Secretary views an industry practice as too lax, by the rule-making machinery provided under the OSH Act, she can enact a new and more stringent regulation, placing everyone on notice of the need to meet a higher standard.”

Whether or not the dissenting opinion was correct in suggesting that the fatal accident in question was one so unlikely that even an entirely reasonable employer would not have anticipated or trained for it, I think Judge Gorsuch was correct, in agreeing with the ALJ that the Secretary’s assertions were not an adequate substitute for evidence.

And, while the administrative agencies’ specialized knowledge justifies a healthy measure of deference to their determinations, the powers of review given to the federal Courts of Appeals serve to avoid sloppy, and at times peremptory, administrative actions. However one views the outcome in the case discussed above, an unvarying resort to the “rubber stamp” would be an abdication of responsibility.

Town Violates Lowest Responsible Bidder Requirements

New York’s competitive bidding laws dictate that contracts for public works must be awarded to the lowest responsible and responsive bidder. In determining the lowest responsible bidder, a public agency investigates such qualitative factors as the bidder’s skill, experience, background and integrity. A bidder must also comply with the requirements of the bid specifications to be considered a responsive bidder.

In the case of AAA Carting and Rubbish Removal, Inc. v. Town of Southeast, New York’s highest court annulled the Town Board’s rejection of the low bidder because the second lowest bidder was considered “more responsible”.

Background

The Town Board of Southeast in Putnam County solicited competitive bids from qualified contractors to handle the Town’s waste removal needs. The Town prepared a bid request which set forth the qualifications that the Town required from the prospective contractor. Those qualifications included, among other factors, that the work of the contractor be done in a prompt, proper, and workmanlike manner, that the contractor provide operating and safety training for its personnel, that the contractor’s equipment be maintained in safe and sanitary condition, and that there is reserve equipment that could be put into operation within two hours of a breakdown.

The Town Board received three bids. AAA Carting and Rubbish Removal, Inc. submitted a bid for $1,210,500 per year, Suburban Carting submitted a bid for $1,496,205 per year and Advanced Waste Systems submitted a bid for $1,692,306 per year. After reviewing the bids, the Town Board undertook a due diligence procedure, which included visits to AAA and Suburban. The Board members prepared a report indicating that “AAA can reasonably be construed as being responsible in addition to being the lowest bidder”. However, the report also stated that Suburban’s “operations, cleanliness and professionalism and process are head-and-shoulders superior to that of AAA.”

The Town Board held a meeting and voted to award the contract to Suburban, the second lowest bidder. The Board members who voted in favor of the award noted that safety and reliability were determinative factors in their selection of the higher bid. However, at no time during the meeting, or at any other time prior to the vote awarding the contract to Suburban, was there any suggestion that AAA was not a responsible bidder or did not adequately fulfill any of the requirements as set forth in the bid request.

After its bid was rejected, AAA filed a petition with the court to set aside the award of the contract to Suburban and to direct the Town to award the contract to AAA. The trial court ruled in favor of AAA. The Town appealed, and appellate court reversed, ruling in favor of the Town. AAA was then granted permission to appeal to New York’s highest court, the Court of Appeals.

Decision

The Court of Appeals ruled in favor of AAA. The court noted that under the controlling public bidding law, all contracts for public work must be awarded to the lowest responsible and responsive bidder. This does not mean that a contract must be awarded to the more responsible bidder. The court pointed out that the record before the Town Board did not find that AAA lacked responsibility. The rejection of AAA’s bid was based on the Town’s finding that Suburban was more responsible than AAA. However, the criteria used by the Town to reject AAA was not contained in the bid specifications. Accordingly, the court ruled that there was no good reason to reject the low bid from AAA.

Comment

The general requirement that contracts for public works be awarded to the lowest responsible and responsive bidder has long been the law in New York. The purpose is to prevent corruption, favoritism, and potential influence, while obtaining the best possible contract price. However, as this case demonstrates, accepting a higher bid based on subjective assessment of criteria not specified in the bid proposal gives rise to speculation that favoritism may have played a role in the Town Board’s decision.

Safety Policy: Know All off the Elements of an OSHA Violation

Avoiding OSHA violations and related penalties is not the number one priority of your health and safety program. What you should be really trying to accomplish is to protect your employees, livelihood and bottom line, by your best efforts to reduce jobsite dangers.

If you’re in construction, from time to time you will be inspected by OSHA, and issued a citation. The silver lining is that a citation issued before anyone has been injured can be seen as a useful alert, and an opportunity to demonstrate to OSHA (who will be back around next year) that you are a safety-conscious employer.

Chances are good, though, that one of these days you will be issued an OSHA citation that should be vacated, because the cited standard doesn’t apply, or the condition existed only in an inaccessible location, or based on some other defect. In many such instances, a contest can be successful, even where the employer’s efforts fell short of perfection.

As an employer, in addition to being familiarity with the substantive standards that affect your trade, you should have a handle on the basics of what constitutes a violation, and what the Secretary of Labor is going to have to prove if you choose to contest your citation.

As an attorney whose firm represents employers in OSHA matters, I don’t want to dissuade you from consulting with experienced counsel concerning any OSHA citation. There are practical and economic reasons to pick your fights carefully, however, in deciding whether to contest a given citation.

For one thing, unless it’s a multi-item citation, or one that involves Willful or Repeat violations, the amount of money at stake is likely to be small. Unless (for example) your current citation may debar you from bidding on public jobs, and put you out of business, incurring thousands in legal fees, to contest a much lesser amount in OSHA penalties, will rarely be money well-spent.

A further consideration, among others, is that a decision to devote time and money to contesting an OSHA citation will seldom make sense, unless chances are good that you can have the citation (or many of the items, if it’s a multi-item citation) vacated.

There are three further things to keep in mind, when considering having an attorney represent you in an OSHA citation contest. First, there are not a lot of generalists with relevant OSHA experience. Because most citations are well-supported, and the penalties are (usually) modest, relatively few are contested and taken through trial. There’s just not enough volume to enable a private attorney to build a practice around fighting OSHA citations. Accordingly, excepting a few in-house lawyers at larger companies, nearly all lawyers who regularly handle citation contests are employed by the U.S. Department of Labor (or a state agency, in states having a “little OSHA” program).

Second, although self-representation will seldom be ideal, under the rules you can contest a citation without an attorney. The employer (or an officer of the employer) can appear and take part in a hearingpro se.

Third, beware the lawyer seeking to impress you with “scorched earth” aggressiveness. A measured approach generally works better with OSHA. Remember, if you stay in business, you can look forward to a future OSHA inspection. No offense will be taken at a contest having a reasonable basis, but taking a weak case to trial, with “guns blazing,” squanders goodwill as well as money. If the only bullets you have are specious arguments and far-fetched contentions, you will be better-advised to pursue settlement, or even to accept the citation, pay the penalties, and move on.

Sound decision-making requires some knowledge of the fundamentals.

First comes jurisdiction. To be cited for violating (federal) OSHA (which oversees private employers in New York, Connecticut, and New Jersey) you must be (1) an employer; (2) engaged in a business affecting interstate commerce.

As a practical matter, if you are in the construction business, you can forget defending based on a lack of effect on interstate commerce. While I have seen statements in the cases suggesting that Congress can regulate anything it likes (a questionable proposition from a Constitutional standpoint) in construction, it’s safe to assume the necessary nexus with interstate commerce. It’s pretty hard to imagine a project not using equipment or materials brought in across state lines.

A defense that occasionally finds some basis, although infrequently, is that the party cited must be an “employer.” Remember, under the “multiple employer policy,” you may be liable, even if none of youremployees are exposed to the violative condition. You can be liable if your control over the worksite was sufficient to make it reasonable to expect you to prevent or detect and abate violations. Plus, if you havecreated a violative condition, you can be held responsible, even if it is only employees of another employer who are exposed.

Nevertheless, to have OSHA liability you do need to be “employer,” which is to say a “person (including a corporation, LLC or other entity) engaged in a business affecting commerce who has employees.” While principals of the company may be deemed to be “employees” while providing services to the company, occasionally there are facts allowing this defense to succeed.

The elements that the Secretary must prove to establish any OSHA violation are: (1) the applicability of the cited standard; (2) noncompliance; (3) employee access to the condition; and (4) actual or constructive knowledge on the part of the cited employer.

Secretary v. Chenal Valley Construction involved a general contractor on a residential project who visited the site 3 times a week, but had no full-time presence. It was cited for violative conditions (involving fall protection and, mostly, scaffolding violations) created by Red Construction, its masonry subcontractor.

Chenal Valley, the GC, did not create the hazards, expose its own employees to them, or control thespecific hazards. It did control the overall worksite by reason of its supervisory authority, and thus had an obligation to inspect the work area, anticipate hazards, and take measures to prevent or correct them.

The administrative law judge found that Chenal Valley had fulfilled these obligations, albeit minimally, and vacated all of the citation items, based on a lack of knowledge of the conditions.

The ALJ declined to find actual knowledge, where the Compliance Officer could only speculate that the conditions had been in place long enough for the GC to have seen them two days before OSHA’s inspection. More convincing, the ALJ found, was the testimony of the GC’s witness, who pointed out from long experience that the scaffolds would have been moved from hour to hour, making it entirely plausible that the defects the inspector saw had not been seen by the GC during its last preceding site visit.

The ALJ also rejected the Secretary’s argument that “constructive knowledge” should be found, based on contemporaneous violations at different Chenal Valley worksites employing a different subcontractor, doing a different type of work.

Chenal Valley’s safety oversight was probably less than ideal, but it nevertheless succeeded in having all items on the Red Construction job vacated. If you have a command of the basics of what needs to be proved, whether you are assisted by an attorney or not, you will make better decisions to assess your prospects, and better chances of success if you elect to contest a given citation.

Safety Policy: First Principles of Fire Safety in Construction

Buildings undergoing demolition, renovation, or construction are particularly susceptible to fire. Construction sites are typically rich in combustible materials and, once started, fires often spread with extraordinary speed, putting lives in danger as well as the work in progress.

It’s a good idea to have a fire protection engineer involved with any substantial construction project from the design phase forward. This is required in some instances, and the benefits multiply as the project in question is large, complex, or unusual. Also, the expense of using a fire protection engineer may be cancelled out by insurance and other savings.

It’s highly beneficial, also, to involve local code and fire department officials in your project from the outset. Code enforcement authorities can assist your design team in incorporating required fire protection measures from the design phase onward – the most efficient and cost-effective time to do so – and to plan code compliance, both as to construction operations and the finished building.

Fires in partially-completed structures can be extraordinarily dangerous. Sprinkler systems and fire walls may not be in place. Portions of the construction may be inaccessible. Hazards obvious under normal conditions may be undetectable or unnoticed during an actual fire. By definition, buildings under construction are changing constantly. If responders have never before seen the jobsite, their task becomes all the more challenging.

Perhaps the most perilous situation can arise where a project is being occupied in phases. Obviously, in a fire situation, it’s critical to know which portions of a partly-completed project are occupied and which are not. In the planning phase, water lines, control panels and fire pumps can be located logically, to support the sequence in which portions of the project will be occupied. Locations for the unloading of materials and (especially) the storage of flammable materials, can be strategically placed, as well as means of egress, fire extinguishers, etc.

Once site work begins, an onsite command post should be established, and a fire protection program manager designated. The command post should have the drawings and plans for construction, emergency information, means of communications, keys and equipment for use by the program manager and emergency responders. This is the time to establish, and ensure compliance with, rules requiring the regular disposal of waste, and the safe storage of materials (especially combustible materials) in locations equipped with fire extinguishers and remote from operations, or local conditions such as wildfires that could increase the risk of combustion.

Formal pre-incident plans are highly desirable, and are required for some projects (whether by code, or as part of an insurance and risk-management program). While permission from the owner will usually be required, providing construction plans to local fire responders can aid them in their pre-fire planning. Data from construction plans can be stored electronically, and retrieved during an actual incident, to aid in dispatching resources in response.

In all events, frequent site visits by the fire department are invaluable in aiding both your fire program manager and emergency responders in developing and updating response plans, and creating a basis for more rapid and effective decision-making, should a fire occur.

The sitework phase is usually the best time, also, to plan for water supply and access, sufficient all-weather roads, and adequate means of escape ? not only from the building being constructed, but from the surrounding site. Multiple exits from the site perimeter are desirable, if practicable.

As construction proceeds past the sitework stage, progressively there will come onsite a host of fire hazards, for which precautions must be planned. These typically include welding operations, temporary heating equipment, electrical equipment, flammable and combustible liquids and gases, explosives, combustible materials such as formwork, and even things such as employees smoking.

One critical need is to properly store and label explosives and other highly hazardous materials. Firefighters may be killed or injured if unable to identify, quickly and reliably, where such materials are present. This should be coordinated with local authorities, as permits are often required, and measures taken to secure hazardous materials against terrorists, juveniles, disgruntled employees, and aspiring arsonists. Here again, a fire protection engineer can help reduce these hazards through planning, coordination, and liaison with code officials and emergency responders.

During building erection, additional considerations come into view. A lighted stair must be constructed for use by construction workers and emergency responders. It should have identification signs, and fire extinguishers on each level.

Functional standpipe systems are also essential in buildings under construction. In the case of taller buildings, local codes may require the availability of an elevator or hoist for fire services.

Another area of concern during erection is the combustibility of materials, notably formwork (which may be limited by code, or restricted to lower elevations) and materials used in erecting temporary enclosures. Non-flammable or fire-resistant materials should be used whenever practicable, and care taken to keep these items away from sources of ignition, and to ensure that they will not obstruct exits in the event of fire.

<p.as always,="" of="" course,="" during="" erection,="" plans="" must="" be="" reviewed="" frequently="" and="" kept="" current,="" to="" permit="" employees="" other="" occupants="" alerted="" in="" case="" emergency,="" allow="" them="" escape="" the="" structure,="" afford="" access="" emergency="" responders.

As construction advances to the upper stories, care must be taken to secure materials on upper floors which, in addition to posing hazards to construction employees, could be blown onto firefighters during a fire in windy conditions. Also, roof operations often present fire safety issues – such as where torch-applied roofing, or tar kettles, are employed.

Once interior trades are at work, and the building is to be enclosed, one critical coordination issue is that whereas the required stairway must be enclosed when the building exterior walls are in place, some jurisdictions permit the stairway to be enclosed in tandem with the exterior walls, on a floor-by-floor basis. Others require the stairway to be fully enclosed first.

Part of this phase will be the installation and testing of alarm, detection, sprinkler, standpipe and other fire protection systems. This generally requires coordination with items that must be installed and inspected before they are concealed, such as electrical work and fireproofing.

As work approaches the punch-list phase, special attention may be required to detect and to ensure safety, where alarm, sprinkler, or other fire safety installations remain incomplete, or may be inoperable.

Partial occupancy may also present issues governed by local codes, such as provisions governing what levels of completion other conditions will permit occupancy of building levels above and below levels still under construction.

Another key element in partial-occupancy situations is the completeness of exit enclosures and parts of the building required to gain access to them from the occupied portions.

The keys to success in minimizing risks from fire during construction are:

  • communication among all participants;
  • input from an experienced fire protection engineer, and local code and emergency response personnel;
  • integrating fire prevention into all phases of construction; and
  • keeping abreast of progress in the construction of the project, and updating your pre-incident planning accordingly.

Safety Policy: Bureau of Labor Statistics Reports Progress in Reducing Construction Fatalities

Each year, the federal Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) issues a “Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries.” The preliminary numbers are out for 2010, and there is some good news to report.

That good news is that, nationwide, construction fatalities were down sharply from 2009 to 2010. And, although much of the drop in fatal occurrences must be attributed to the “bad news” that construction employment also continued to fall, the number of deaths fell more than employment did. Thus, it appears that there have been modest, but significant, reductions that may be attributable to increased safety efforts.

The preliminary death count for all U.S. workers was almost unchanged from 2009 to 2010, as was the rate of 3.5 fatalities per 100,000 “full-time equivalent” workers in all occupational classes.

The gross total of fatal work injuries in the private construction sector declined by 10 percent in 2010, a rate roughly two-thirds higher than the drop in the number of hours worked, of about 6%. Fatalities in 2010 totaled 751, according to BLS’s preliminary figures, down from 834 in 2009, and 1,239 in 2006. The number of deaths has decreased every year since 2006-07, and last year’s number was the lowest overall total in 18 years. There were reductions in residential, commercial, civil and heavy highway work, and in most trades.

Construction deaths from falls numbered 260 in 2010, a 42% decline from 447 in 2007. “Struck-by” incidents accounted for 112 deaths; contract with electricity, 76; and trenching and other deaths from being caught between objects 39.

Trade groups were quick to applaud the continued reduction in jobsite fatalities, with many crediting a strengthened commitment to hazard identification and proactive training. While poor economic conditions, and perhaps reductions in employment that have fallen disproportionately upon the less-skilled, less-experienced, and less-conscientious employees who swelled payrolls during the construction boom, account for much of the diminished carnage, it’s undeniable that most people in construction are more safety-conscious than in even the recent past. Safety planning is now a given on most significant projects. While I have questioned the efficacy of employee safety training, certainly there’s a lot more training today than there was ten or twenty years ago. Many employers have gone from grudging efforts to keep OSHA at bay, to more earnest efforts to surpass minimal compliance, and to focus less on avoiding penalties, and more on actually keeping employees safe.

While construction-industry employment fell less last year than in either of the preceding two years, obviously there is far less work at present than in 2006-07. And, for all that the number of deaths has gone down even more than hours worked, or dollars expended, in the construction sector, construction still produces more fatal accidents than any other U.S. industry.

Plainly, while the safety results over the last few years are a silver lining of sorts in what has been, and continues to be, a very challenging environment for the industry, much remains to be done.

And, as the King said to the White Rabbit, it’s necessary to start at the beginning, which in construction isfall protection. Not only are fall hazards the #1 killer overall, but they are a hazard too often shown insufficient respect, with lethal results.

Whereas, certainly, there are facets of OSHA compliance that are technically challenging, and require considerable sophistication to detect, correct, or avoid, by and large fall protection (and associated OSHA standards) are pretty straightforward.

For example, the number of deaths from falls resulting from experienced, amply-equipped workers simply failing to tie off is dismaying. Gravity, and the effects on the body of hitting asphalt from 12 stories up, are understood by just about everyone. This cause of death and injury isn’t primarily a matter of training – as attested by the number of victims who hit the ground wearing serviceable harnesses, but did not bother to tie off. It’s primarily a matter of leadership, which is largely about communicating to your employees that you care sufficiently for their lives, and the well-being of their families, that small losses in productivity are meaningless, and not tying off completely unacceptable.

Of course, there is more to fall protection than personal fall arrest systems, and yes, training is required for employees to know how to use equipment properly, inspect it, and to understand its limitations.

But the list of the conditions in violation of OSHA (and the New York Labor Law) that lead to most fall-related accidents is not a long one. It includes, certainly, the following:

  • Improperly-erected scaffolds;
  • Defective, damaged, or improperly-used ladders;
  • Leading edges of steel-deck construction;
  • Holes in floors and working or walking surfaces;
  • Missing guardrails;
  • Open edges on floors;
  • Rooftop operations;
  • Open elevator shafts;
  • Skylights;
  • Fall arrest systems not used, or used improperly.

In addition to fall hazards being viewed too casually, a major element of the danger associated with fall hazards is the nature of the multi-employer jobsite: one employer may create a hazard, intending to correct it promptly, only to have the hazard remain in place, uncorrected, long enough for another contractor’s employee (for example) to fall through an uncovered hole in a floor or other surface.

Thus, guardrails around skylights, guardrails on scissors lifts, covers over floor openings, and restricted zones in roofing operations are examples of fall prevention measures that are governed by design requirements which, if requiring some homework in the OSHA regulations, are not among the most complicated of the construction standards.

There are, in life, problems that can be definitively solved, sometimes with the application of technology, and problems that never get fully solved, but must be wrestled with. While technology certainly has some role in improving construction safety, overall the problem is one I regard as falling within the latter category. We can’t eliminate all dangers, or reduce the serious accident rate to zero, but efforts made over the last few years are having a real, positive impact.

Are we at, or even near, the place where we might believe that increased efforts would produce little if any added benefit? Almost certainly not. But if the progress has been modest, it ought to be enough to convince us that the efforts made have been worthwhile.