Skip to main content

Author: Thomas H. Welby

“Hot Work” Safety in Construction

Welding, cutting and brazing present a host of safety and health risks, including fire, explosion, toxic atmospheres, ultraviolet radiation, and electric shock.  If you work on sites where “hot work” is performed, you need to be familiar with the relevant standards, even if your employees perform no such work themselves.  Let’s look at the basics.

Moving, Transport, and Storage of Compressed Gas Cylinders:  Cylinder valves must be kept closed when work is not being performed, when the cylinders are empty, or they are being moved.

A chain, cylinder truck, or other steadying device should be used to keep cylinders from being knocked over while in use.  Cylinders should be secured in a vertical position, when being transported in a vehicle.  Regulators must be removed, and valve protection caps must be in place, before cylinders are moved.  Employees should never lift cylinders by their valve protection caps.

Cylinders should be kept a safe distance from welding operations, or behind fire-resistant shields.  They must not be placed in confined spaces, or where they might become part of an electrical circuit.

Cylinders, full or empty, must not be used as rollers or supports.

Use of Fuel Gas:  Before being connected to a regulator, a cylinder valve should be “cracked” (opened slightly and closed at once) by a person standing to the side of it.  Do not “crack” the valve where the gas would reach welding work, sparks, flame, or another source of ignition.

Cylinder valves should always be opened slowly, and those on fuel gas cylinders opened not more than 1-1/2 turns.  If a special wrench is required, it must be left in position, to allow the fuel gas flow to be shut off quickly.  In the case of manifolded or coupled cylinders, at least one such wrench shall be kept close by.  Nothing should be placed on top of a fuel gas cylinder that might damage the safety device, or impede the quick shutoff of the valve.

Fuel gas should be used through devices equipped with shutoff valves only if the pressure is reduced through a suitable regulator attached to the cylinder valve or manifold.  Before a regulator is removed from a cylinder valve, the valve must always be closed, and the gas released from the regulator.

If gas is found to be leaking from the valve stem, the valve shall be closed, and the gland nut tightened.  If that does not stop the leak, the cylinder must be taken out of use, tagged, and removed from the work area.

If fuel gas is leaking from the cylinder valve, and cannot be shut off, the cylinder should be properly tagged, and removed from the work area, except if a regulator attached to the cylinder valve will stop the leak through the valve seal.

If a leak should develop at a fuse plug or other safety device, the cylinder should be removed from the work area.

Fuel gas and oxygen manifolds:  Fuel gas and oxygen manifolds must bear the name of the substance they contain in letters at least 1” high, painted on the manifold, or on a sign permanently affixed to it.  The manifolds must be in safe, well-ventilated and accessible locations (never within enclosed spaces).

Oxygen and fuel gas hoses must not be used interchangeably, and a single hose having more than one gas passage must not be used.  Hose couplings must be of a type that cannot be unlocked or disconnected without a rotary motion.  Boxes used for the storage of gas hose should be ventilated, and hose must be inspected at the beginning of every shift, and removed from use if damaged or malfunctioning.

  Torches:  Torches must be inspected at the beginning of each shift for leaking shutoff valves, hose couplings and tip connections.  They may be lighted by friction lighters or other approved devices, but not by matches, or from hot work.

Regulators and Gauges:  Oxygen and fuel gas regulators and their gauges must be inspected regularly, and kept in good working order.

Oil and Grease Hazards:  Cylinders, cylinder caps, valves, couplings, regulators, hose and apparatus must be kept free from oil and greasy substances, and must not be handled with oily hands or gloves.

Welding Cables and Connectors:  Use only cable without repair or splices within 10 feet from the cable end to which the electrode holder is connected.  Cables with standard insulated connectors, or with splices having an insulating quality equal to that of the cable, are permitted.  Cables in need of repair must not be used.

Safe Operation of Equipment:  All equipment should be operated in a manner consistent with the manufacturer’s instructions.  OSHA requires that, when electrode holders are to be left unattended, the electrodes must be removed, and the holders placed or protected so that they cannot make electrical contact with employees or conducting objects.

When the cutter or arc welder has occasion to leave his work, or to stop work for any appreciable length of time, or when the arc welding or cutting machine is to be moved, the equipment’s power supply must be shut off.

Whenever practicable, arc welding and cutting operations are to be shielded by noncombustible or flameproof screens, as protection from the direct rays of the arc.

Naturally, faulty or defective equipment shall be reported to the supervisor, and taken out of service until repaired, or determined to be in good operating condition.

Ventilation and Protection:  Hot work operations involving toxic substances must not be performed without adequate ventilation.  Employees exposed to the same atmosphere must be protected in the same manner as the welders and burners themselves.

Mechanical ventilation can be either a “general mechanical ventilation system” or a “local exhaust system.”  General mechanical systems must produce the number of air changes necessary to maintain welding fumes and smoke within safe limits (as defined in subpart D of 29 CFR 1926).

Local exhaust ventilation consists of freely movable hoods, placed as close as practicable to the work.  Such ventilation must remove fumes and smoke, so as to keep concentrations within safe limits. 

Local exhaust ventilation or air line respirators are required, when hot work is to be performed in an enclosed space, and involves lead (other than as an impurity), metals coated with lead-bearing materials, cadmium, or mercury.  Both local exhaust ventilation and air line respirators are required, when the work involves beryllium-containing base or filler metals.

 Contaminated air from a workspace shall be exhausted into the open air, or otherwise clear of the intake air source.  All air replacing that which has been withdrawn must be clean and respirable.

Oxygen must not be used for ventilation, comfort cooling, blowing dust from clothing, or for cleaning work areas.

Confined spaces:  Generally, the foregoing ventilation requirements must be observed whenever hot work is done in a confined space.

By way of exception, if ventilation cannot be provided without blocking the means of access, employees in the confined space shall be protected by air line respirators, with an employee outside the confined space being assigned to maintain communication with those working inside it, and to provide assistance in case of an emergency.

When an employee must enter a confined space through a manhole or other small opening, means (e.g., safety belts and lifelines) must be used, and an attendant, with a pre-planned rescue procedure, stationed outside, to extricate the welder or cutter should the need arise.

Protective equipment:  Employees performing hot work, or working nearby, must wear suitable eye protective equipment.  All who are exposed to radiation must be covered completely, to prevent harm from ultraviolet rays.

Fire prevention:  Articles to undergo “hot work” must be moved to a designated location whenever practicable.  No hot work shall be done where the application of flammable paints, or the presence of other flammable compounds or dust concentrations, creates a hazard.

For more complete details concerning safety and health requirements for “hot work,” refer to Subpart J of 29 CFR 1926, and the publications and other OSHA standards referred to in the same.

Excavation Deaths on the Uptick, OSHA Makes Trenching and Excavation Safety a Priority for 2018

Of the myriad OSHA standards that govern construction work, those directed to excavation hazards are among the most obviously needful to prevent deaths and serious injuries.

While some few of OSHA’s standards may lie on the esoteric side, it doesn’t take a high level of technical sophistication to foresee the probable outcome, if an employee, too careless to fasten his lanyard to an anchor point, falls from an elevated work platform.

No less obvious, we propose, is the inadvisability of a worker, ever, going down into an unprotected trench.  The incidence of such a thing happening in your company should be zero.  Excavation safety presents some technical issues (for example, differentiating among soil Types “A,” “B,” and “C”) but nothing you can’t handle.  An important calculation to keep in mind is that just one cubic yard of soil weighs about as much as a car.  Even when workers survive cave-ins, it’s often with gruesome and permanent, disabling injuries.  You don’t want an employee in an  unprotected trench, even for just a couple of minutes.  We have read of fatal cave-ins occurring almost instantaneously, after workers (or a single worker) had entered the trench, not to perform work, but only to shut off a valve, or retrieve a tool.

While there are additional hazards posed to employees working in or close to trenches (e.g., falls, falling loads, water accumulations, hazardous atmospheres, and incidents involving mobile equipment) it’s cave-ins that cause the greatest numbers of deaths and serious injuries.  As of 2011, about 2 construction workers a month were dying in cave-ins.  Alarmingly, in 2016, the number of fatalities in cave-ins had crept up to almost double the average figure for the preceding five years.  That led OSHA to make excavation safety a priority for 2018.  June 18-23, 2018 has been declared a “Trench Safety Stand Down” week.  So, while this is not our first installment on this subject, we think reminding our readers of its importance is in order.

It’s sometimes said that trenches less than five feet deep require no protective measures.  That’s not exactly correct.  The rule is that, unless built in stable rock, a trench five feet or more in depth will always require a protective system.  The condition for shallower trenches not to require special measures is that a “competent person” determine that none are needed.  In this context, a“competent person” is one capable of identifying existing and predictable hazards or working conditions that are hazardous, unsanitary or dangerous, soil types and appropriate protective systems, and who is authorized to take prompt corrective measures.

While we use the terms “excavation” and “trench” interchangeably in this article, technically an “excavation” is any man-made cut, cavity, trench or depression in the Earth’s surface made by earth removal, and a “trench” is a narrow excavation (in relation to its length). 

The most fundamental rules regarding trench safety are as follows:

  • All excavations must be inspected by a competent person before entry (i) at the start of each shift; (ii) following a rainstorm or other water intrusion; and (iii) after any occurrence that could affect conditions in the excavation.
  • Test any trench 4’ deep or deeper for hazards such as low oxygen, hazardous fumes, and toxic gases.
  • Keep heavy equipment away from the edges.
  • Spoils (excavated soil) and other materials must be kept at least 2 feet distant from the edges.
  • Don’t dig until you have ascertained where underground utilities are located.
  • Egress (e.g., ladders, steps, ramps) must be provided where the excavation is 4’ or deeper.  A means of egress must be located within 25’ of where employees will be working.
  • Don’t permit work beneath raised or suspended loads or materials.
  • Be on the lookout for any conditions that could affect trench stability.

If an excavation is to be 20’ deep or deeper, it must be designed by a licensed Professional Engineer, or be based on tabulated data prepared and/or approved by a licensed Professional Engineer.  Whenever an employer designs and implements a sloping or benching system, the underlying data must be in writing, contain explanatory information justifying the choices made, and identify the engineer who approved it.  At least one copy must be kept onsite during construction, and even after completion, the written information must be retained, and made available to OSHA on demand.

Soil classification is done by a competent person or a testing laboratory.  An excavation may be made in stable rock, or any of soil types “A,” “B,” or “C.”  As its name implies, “stable rock” is natural solid mineral matter, in which an excavation having vertical sides will remain intact while exposed.  Type “A” soil, the next most stable material, is cohesive soil, not fissured or previously disturbed (typically, clay, silty clay, and clay loam) with an unconfined compressive strength greater than 1.5 tons per square foot.

Type “B” soils include cohesive soil with an unconfined compressive strength less than 1.5 tsf but greater than 0.5 tsf plus granular and cohesionless soils (such as angular gravel, similar to crushed rock, silt, silt loam, sandy loam, and, in some cases silty clay loam and sandy clay loam).

Type “C” soils include cohesive soils having an unconfined compressive strength of 0.5 tsf or less, granular soils (gravel, sand, and loamy sand) submerged soil, soil from which water is seeping, unstable submerged rock, or material in a sloped, layered system with a slope of 4:1 or steeper.

In addition to protecting against a possible collapse of the sides of the excavation, the employer must also provide shoring, bracing or underpinning when necessary, to ensure that adjoining buildings, walls, sidewalk, etc. remain stable.  Excavation below the base or footing of any foundation or retaining wall is prohibited, unless the excavation is in stable rock, or a support system (such as underpinning) is provided, or a professional engineer has determined that the adjoining structure is sufficiently distant from the excavation that it will not be affected, and that the excavation will not endanger workers.

Whenever support systems are being installed or removed, such operations must be carried out in a manner that protects workers from cave-ins, structural collapses, and struck-by injuries.  Members of support systems must be securely connected, and not overloaded.  The removal of support systems must begin at, and progress from, the bottom of the excavation, and backfilling must progress concurrently with the removal of the support system.

Materials used in support systems must be examined by a competent person, to ensure that they are free from defects or damage. Materials must be used within their rated capacities, and consistent with the manufacturer’s recommendations.  If materials are found to be damaged, or a competent person cannot assure that they are suitable for use (and able to support the intended loads) they should be removed from service, until evaluated and approved by a professional engineer.

The hazards related to excavations in addition to cave-ins include, among other things, hazardous atmospheres, water-related hazards, materials falling or rolling into (or within) the excavation, mobile equipment too close to the edge, employees working at levels lower than the site of the excavation (and thus being exposed to material or equipment falling, rolling, or sliding onto them) and excavated materials falling or spilling, while being loaded for removal.

Critical to excavation safety is careful planning, that should begin even before you submit your bid.  It’s essential to familiarize yourself with the jobsite, and to consider not only soil classification, but (among other things) nearby structures, if any, surface and ground water, utilities, site traffic, fall protection needs, number of ladders needed, etc.

Virtually all cave-in injuries, the #1 hazard associated with excavations, are preventable.  No matter how many jobs you have done in the past that included excavation support systems, you should treat each new job as one presenting its own unique characteristics, and requiring particularized evaluation and planning.   

Protecting Female Construction Personnel from Sexual Harassment and Jobsite Injury

Approximately 800,000 women are employed in the U.S. construction industry.  About 200,000 of them wear hard hats, and work (mostly) as laborers and helpers, painters, carpenters, repair workers, electricians, drywall installers, truck drivers, HVAC mechanics, plumbers, and flaggers.  In addition, about 600,000 women work in administrative and office positions in construction businesses.

We will discuss below several nuts-and-bolts health and safety issues that affect, in particular, women working in the trades.  There are serious issues, however, of the mistreatment of women in the industry, which occur both on the jobsite (where some men are enraged by the sight of a woman wearing a hard hat) to the office (the workplace, generally, of men who feel entitled to indulge in sexual harassment, or sexual assault). 

While women in construction do not get as much attention as Hollywood actresses, construction accounts for more jobs, and is a larger component of the U.S. economy, than making movies.  You will, we hope, be horrified to learn that sexual harassment is every bit as bad a problem in construction, as it is in the movie industry.

Sexual harassment in construction is pervasive.  It ranges from being stared at or seeing “pinups” of unclothed women in the job trailer, to unwanted sexual remarks, lewd acts, inappropriate touching, and outright sexual assault.  A USA Today analysis of EEOC and Bureau of Labor Statistics data suggested that construction is the #2 industry in the country (behind mining) for the number of reported incidents of sexual harassment reported per thousand employees.  This, obviously, is unacceptable.

Even where the offensive behavior does not include fondling and assault, or sex as an express condition of employment, women in construction, as in most traditionally-male occupations, are frequently the targets of belittling remarks, and other so-called “microagressions.”  Often, they will be given “friendly advice” that career prospects will be enhanced by being receptive to sexual advances, or tolerating degrees of sexual misbehavior.

While obviously sexual harassment is objectionable on additional grounds, it would be a mistake to discount its impact on safety.  While having to see sexy photos in the trailer isn’t as overtly dangerous, obviously, as working aloft without fall protection, construction safety depends largely on mentoring, mutual trust, and workers looking out for one another and reporting unsafe conditions.  If women don’t get the same training and mentoring — whether as payback for not going along with sexual misconduct, or due to male resentment provoked merely by their presence in the trades — that’s a safety issue.  If women on your jobsite are more reluctant than men to report safety violations for fear of retaliation, that also affects safety, and is not merely a result of boys being boys. (We acknowledge, in passing, that fewer than 100% of the culprits in incidents of sexual harassment and assault are heterosexual men, and not every victim is female).

For some years, construction-industry organizations and employers have worked to increase the numbers of women working in the construction trades, as well as in management.  The results of these efforts have been valuable, but, on the whole, somewhat disappointing.  We suggest it will probably be a condition of achieving higher levels of success in recruiting women that the industry first acknowledge, and then take an aggressive leadership stance, in stemming sexual harassment.

The overall culture, clearly, is changing, Women, including flight attendants, restaurant servers, the armed forces, and the entertainment industry, are pushing back against being fondled, if not raped, and persistent belittlement as parts of the job description.  All indications are that, going forward, companies (and managers) who keep their heads in the proverbial sand on this issue are going to pay a price for doing so.

Turning to some of the nuts-and-bolts safety matters, we will note, first, that the primary causes of death for women in construction are “struck-by” incidents (think flaggers struck by vehicles) and other transportation accidents, homicide, and falls.

A widespread problem for women is the lack of PPE (personal protective equipment) in the smaller sizes generally needed to fit women.  The “protective” can vanish from “PPE,” if the respirator, protective clothing, etc. is too large, or does not fit properly.  A respirator that doesn’t fit is virtually useless.  Safety footwear that is too large can cause trips and falls.  Too-large clothing items can get snagged in equipment, resulting in serious injury.  PPE items often found to be too large for female users include, but are not limited to, respirators, fall-protection harnesses, safety shoes, gloves, coveralls, hard hats, and safety goggles.

Procuring PPE items in sizes that will fit smaller women will often require extra effort.  Some items are not regularly stocked by distributors, and others may not be widely manufactured in the United States (where people tend to be on the large side).  One resource is the International Safety Equipment Association, which lists companies and suppliers offering PPE, sized and designed for women.

Women suffer higher rates of sprains/strains and nerve conditions of the wrist and forearm than men.  The cause of this is not fully-established, but it may be a product of women, typically having less upper-body strength than men, being more commonly being assigned repetitive tasks leading to sprains/strains and nerve conditions.  Where women are expected to keep pace with their male counterparts in lifting heavy objects, back injuries are common, as well.

Hand tools are also designed in most instances for the average-sized male.  Women, typically, have slightly shorter hands and lesser grip strength than men.  Wrenches and other hand tools may be sold as “one-size-fits-all” but, actually, with many varieties of small tools, one size doesn’t fit all.  Many hand tools need to be made available in sizes that will fit women (and smaller men).

Efforts should be made to fight the perception (and such basis as it has in reality) that, since women are typically less senior in their trades in their male colleagues, they may be putting their jobs in jeopardy, if they raise concerns about substandard safety conditions (or sexual harassment).  This perception is probably even more acute when hazards complained of affect women more than men.

Two such hazards are reproductive hazards, and access to sanitary facilities.  More research is needed on potential reproductive hazards to both sexes from conditions on construction sites (including both impairment to the ability to get pregnant, and harmful effects on fetuses).  Polychlorinated biphenyls and hypothermia are two known hazards.  Ionizing radiation, to which hazardous waste workers may be exposed, is a third.  Agents such as lead, solvents, and pesticides have been identified as adversely affecting sperm development in men.

Prolonged standing has been linked to premature births, and strenuous activities, such as lifting and climbing, can be hazardous during the latter stages of pregnancy.  We think it qualifies as a “reproductive hazard,” too, that few construction employers offer pregnancy, family and medical leave to their employees.

A further hazard that affects women in particular is a lack of access to clean, private sanitary facilities on construction sites.  According to one study, 80% of women construction workers complained of facilities with filthy toilets, no toilets, or toilets in poorly-lit areas, or at an unreasonable distance from the work area.  Many toilets cannot be locked, and if located in poorly-lit areas, pose a special threat to women working at night.  Many women report taking measures to minimize having to use inadequate, dirty and unlocked unisex toilets such as holding their urine, and drinking less water while working, which can lead to heat stress, and kidney and bladder infections.

As to both sexual harassment and more mundane issues where women’s health and safety are at risk, all construction employers have both legal and ethical obligations.  The industry (particularly on the issue of sexual harassment) has some catching up to do.  That starts, we think, with the issues being acknowledged and discussed.

Reducing the Dangers to Workers from Asphalt and Its Fumes

Asphalt is used extensively in roofing, waterproofing, and, above all, of course, in roadway construction.  It comes in many varieties.  Typically, it contains less than 10% bitumen, a petroleum distillate, mixed with aggregates and solvents. 

The aggregates used may be natural (limestone, granite), artificial (slag aggregates) or recycled (demolition waste, glass, and road planings).  Asphalt may also be synthetic, or modified by the use of polymers, and may contain a wide variety of other components, including binders, hardening agents, bonding agents, crushed rock, and sand.  As it is a petroleum-based product, asphalt should not be confused with coal tar or pitch, a wholly different product, having its own qualities and hazards.  Additives used in recent years in paving asphalt, such as resins and recycled rubber, may present additional, less well-known hazards.

The two primary safety issues associated with asphalt products are the danger of burns, and dangers from respiratory or skin exposure to the product and its fumes.

Of these, the danger of burns from working with hot asphalt is the more obvious one, as paving asphalt is heated to temperatures of between 250 and 325 degrees Fahrenheit, and roofing asphalt may be used at temperatures in excess of 450 degrees.  Many asphalt “recipes” are highly flammable, and some are potentially explosive.

In addition, when heated, asphalt’s fumes not only smell bad, but dangerous in in greater or lesser degree (according to what is in the mix).  The solvents (e.g., naphtha, toluene, and xylene), binders, and other chemicals used in different asphalt products may be extremely hazardous.  Asphalt, especially when stored in unventilated containers, may give off hydrogen sulfide gas which, if inhaled, can cause dizziness, convulsions, coma or death.  Asbestos and silica in the rock and sand found in asphalt are associated with lung disease.  Styrene can cause nervous system damage.  Bronchitis, skin rashes, and eye irritation are further hazards.

Where hardened asphalt is to be cut, drilled, milled or planed, avoiding the inhalation of respirable dust becomes a concern. Aggregates in many asphalt mixes include crystalline silica (quartz) which, if inhaled over a period of time, can cause lung damage, silicosis, and other serious ailments.

Curiously, although a 5 mg/m3 limit was proposed as long ago as 1992 (and, as an average over an 8-hour shift, has the force of law under Cal OSHA, California’s state-administered program) until now federal OSHA has not seen fit to adopt a Permissible Exposure Level for asphalt fumes.  The American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists recommends a threshold limit value of 0.5 mg/m3 (as an 8-hour, time-weighted average) and NIOSH recommends the same level as a maximum per 15-minute, short-term exposure.  One risk assessment study estimated a significant risk of lung cancer, at levels as low as 0.2 mg/m3..

So, while (apart, perhaps, from the requirement to use PPE while working with asphalt) OSHA does not have construction standards that regulate working with asphalt per se, there are things you can do, as a health-and-safety-conscious highway or roofing contractor, to reduce asphalt-related hazards to your employees.

A first thing you can do is to get expert advice regarding which asphalt mixes, available in your area, are the least toxic, while suitable to the work you perform.  Of course, your contracts may prescribe that particular mixes be used, but you may be able to negotiate a substitution, if you can identify an equivalent product that is less toxic and therefore safer.

Since asphalt products differ from one another in their composition and their uses, it’s a good idea, also, to study and to circulate the manufacturers’ Material Safety Data Sheets for the products that you use.

A critical element of the safe use of paving asphalt, with both highway-class and non-highway-class pavers, is the proper cleaning, maintenance and periodic testing of the equipment.  NIOSH, as well as the equipment manufacturers, publishes detailed guidelines on how the equipment can be maintained, to minimize worker exposures.

As always, training your employees, and emphasizing safe practices, and the enforcement of safety rules and procedures, are critical.

Rule #1 for employees is probably to avoid breathing asphalt fumes whenever possible.  Workers should never stick their heads into an asphalt tank or mixing container, or lean over a kettle.  While asphalt fumes are generally not believed to be acutely hazardous while asphalt is being laid in open-air situations, the continuous inhalation of high-vapor concentrations — as may arise in poorly-ventilated, confined, or semi-confined spaces — is to be avoided.  Additional ventilation, and/or the use of respirators, may be required.

PPE (Personal Protective Equipment) should be used when working with asphalt.  Overalls and/or long-sleeved jackets and full-length trousers (without cuffs) should be worn to protect skin from burns.  Heat-resistant, impermeable gloves, and safety boots should be worn to protect hands and feet.  If there is any danger of product (including dust) getting in employees’ eyes, goggles should be worn.

Workers should never eat, drink, or smoke while working with asphalt, and, indeed, hands should be washed thoroughly, before handling or eating food or drink.  Asphalt should be kept away from ignition sources.  Asphalt can cause lung damage, or even death, if swallowed.

Workers should be instructed, and regularly reminded during toolbox talks or at other opportunities, that they should stop working, and consult a foreman, if they experience dizziness, or other symptoms associated with exposure to asphalt or its fumes.

In case of inhalation, the employee should be removed to fresh air immediately.  If the employee has trouble in breathing, seek medical attention at once.  If the employee has stopped breathing, administer resuscitation, and seek emergency medical assistance.

Burns should be flushed immediately with large amounts of cold water.  Except if necessary to allow breathing, do not attempt to remove anything from the burn area.  Bitumen should be removed under medical supervision.  Seek medical attention at once.

Apart from ingestion of the material (or the inhalation of dust where it is being cut, milled, etc., the primary dangers of asphalt (burns, fumes) have to do with the heating of the product.  In case of ingestion, if the person is conscious, he should rinse out his mouth, and be given water to drink. 

In case of fire, dry powder or foam (and not water or carbon dioxide) should be used to extinguish the fire.  Hydrocarbon fumes, as well as smoke, may be released during a fire involving asphalt products.  If first responders are summoned, advise them as promptly as possible that the fire may involve asphalt products, so that appropriate measures may be taken to protect the firefighters and other first responders.

There are many reasons for the perennial popularity of asphalt, especially for road surfaces and parking lots.  It’s durable, and can be milled for recycling and resurfaced.  It offers speed and cost savings in construction, as well as reductions in noise pollution.  Treated with the necessary respect, it’s an extremely useful material.  However, precautions must be taken not only against burns, but against the fumes and gases that the product gives off.

NYC Local Law 81 Expands Requirements and Duties for Construction Superintendents

Job-related fatalities in New York City are not constant from year to year (there were 191 such deaths in 1993, and just 56 in 2013) but, year after year, construction-related injuries and deaths run ahead of transportation deaths as the #1 and #2 causes of workplace mayhem.

Since the inception of OSHA (enacted in 1970) workplace fatalities have been reduced by about 60%, while the American workforce has more than doubled.  Those of you who imagine that an OSHA inspector lurks behind every lamp-post may be shocked to learn, however, that New York, the nation’s fourth most-populous state with more than 19 million inhabitants, was covered by just 66 federal OSHA inspectors statewide in 2015.

Construction-related fatalities in New York City rose from 17 in 2011, to 25 in 2015, and injuries on construction sites rose from 128 in 2011, to 435 in 2015 statewide.  The numbers of OSHA inspections in New York dropped every year from 2011 through 2015, with an overall reduction of 27%. 

While most construction employers take their safety responsibilities seriously, some, regrettably, do not.

One incident from 2015 involved a 28-year-old foreman on a high-rise construction jobsite in Manhattan.  This worker sustained severe injuries when rebar fell on his leg.  His employer sent a supervisor with the injured employee to the hospital, to report to the doctors, falsely, that the injury resulted from an off-site slip, trip, and fall.  The injured worker, a new father, was discharged just days following the incident.

Since anticipated budget cuts appear likely to bring about additional reductions in federal OSHA enforcement, state and local governments, and construction industry employers, are going to have to take up the slack.

Over the past several years, local authorities in New York City, notably the City Council, have taken a number of steps to try to stem the increases in the numbers of deaths and injuries accompanying the post-recession building boom in the City.

One such measure, which took effect in November 2017, is Local Law 81, which expands the role of the construction superintendent, while increasing the range of projects on which a superintendent is legally required.

Prior to the effective date of Local Law 81, a site safety manager was required only during the construction or demolition of “major buildings,” defined as those over ten stories high.  With the advent of Local Law 81, a construction superintendent is now required on buildings having less than ten stories (except one to three-family homes) that meet any of the following criteria:

  • new buildings;
  • demolition of an entire building, or more than 50% of the floor area over a 12-month period;
  • vertical or horizontal enlargement;
  • work requiring special inspections for underpinning;
  • work requiring special inspections for the protection of sides of excavations;
  • other jobs posing risks to the public or to property, as determined by the building commissioner.

Public Law 81 also assigns expanded responsibilities, many of them safety-related, to building superintendents.  Generally, the superintendent is now responsible for the following:

  1. Acting in a reasonable and responsible manner to maintain a safe job site and assure compliance with [the Building Code] and any rules promulgated thereunder at each job site for which the construction superintendent is responsible;
  2. To the extent that a registered design professional or special inspection agency is not responsible, the construction superintendent must assure compliance with the approved documents at each job site, for which the construction superintendent is responsible;
  3. Fulfilling the duties of a superintendent of construction assigned by Chapter 1 of Title 28 of the Administrative Code at each job site for which the construction superintendent is responsible; and
  4. Visiting each job site for which the construction superin­tendent is responsible each day when active work (with limited exceptions) is occurring.

During the construction superintendent’s daily visit, he or she must inspect all areas and floors where construction or demolition work, and ancillary activity, is occurring, and do all of the following:

  1. Verify that work is being conducted in accordance with sound construction/demolition practices;
  2. Verify compliance with the approved documents; and
  3. Verify compliance with Building Code § 3301, and any rules promulgated thereunder.

In addition, the construction superintendent has the following responsibilities under Local Law 81:

  1. Correcting unsafe conditions, giving notice to the person(s) responsible for creating the condition, and taking all appropriate action to ensure the condition is corrected.  The construction superintendent is also responsible to give notice to any design professional or special inspection agency with responsibility for the condition.
  2. The giving of notice to the Department of any conditions listed in Building Code § 3310.8.2.1.
  3. Immediately giving notice of any accidents or damage to adjoining property caused by construction or demolition activities at the job site.
  4. Designating a “competent person” to be present at the job site at all times active work is going on, to carry out the superintendent’s orders; identify unsanitary, hazardous or dangerous conditions; take prompt corrective measures to eliminate such conditions; immediately report to the superintendent accidents and damage to adjoining property; and effectively communicate workplace instructions and safety directions to all workers at the site.
  5. Keeping a log at each job site, each log to contain (at minimum) the date and time of the superintendent’s arrival at and departure from the site for the required visits; the general progress of work (and daily summary of work performed); the construction superin­tendent’s activities at the site, including areas and floors inspected; any unsafe conditions observed, and the date, time, and location the same were observed; orders given in respect of accidents, unsafe conditions, etc., with dates, times, responses, and follow-up actions, if any; violations, stop work orders, or summonses given by the Department; accidents; and the name and signature of any person acting as the “competent person” or successor competent person.

In part because of the complexity of OSHA construction standards, and the limited effectiveness of safety training of the rank-and-file, we have long advocated providing extensive safety training and substantial responsibility for OSHA compliance to superintendents and other field supervisors.  That approach is furthered by the increased responsibility for construction safety assigned to construction superintendents by Local Law 81.

The Expanding Use of “Virtual Reality” Technology in Construction Safety Training

As the cost of the applied technology drops, bringing it within reach of more potential users, “Virtual Reality” (VR) — a shockingly useful outgrowth of the video gaming industry — is finding an increasing range of uses in the construction industry.

VR employs hardware and software to create an artificial, computer-generated simulation (or re-creation) of a real environment.  Images and sound are used to make the user feel as if he were experiencing the simulated environment firsthand.  Ubiquitous in video games, VR has many other uses, one of them being in flight simulators, which exist both as recreational applications, and in advanced versions, used in training pilots.

A related technology is “Augmented Reality,” which adds a computer-generated overlay to something real.  One example is “historic street views,” where computer-generated simulations of how central London or Paris looked, or are thought to have looked, in times past have been created, based on available photographs, historical works and paintings.  These images are available for your smartphone as an “app,” and can be accessed via your phone’s camera, as you walk around the actual area, to see what it looked like long ago.

These technologies are not new, but are increasingly becoming affordable for a wide variety of purposes.  Novel items are coming to market all the time, including headsets with a dock for your smartphone, that can deliver VR or AR to any user within reach of a cellphone signal.

“Reality Technology” is already in widespread use in the construction industry.  As prices fall, it has the potential for enormous benefits in a wide, and expanding, range of construction-related applications.

VR technology is already at work in helping owners, design professionals, builders and other industry players address the perennial (and, often, costly) problems as arise on many projects when —as the work progresses, errors in design and execution become apparent — the technology enables clients, architects, and builders to don a head-mounted display to take a virtual tour of the structure, as first designed.  Then, as changes to the design are proposed, whether as matters of necessity, to address design deficiencies, imperfectly-coordinated drawings, etc., or as matters of choice, to accommodate client preferences, users can see what the structure, as modified, will look like, before any physical work to carry out the changes is performed.

This technology also permits project participants at diverse locations, anywhere in the world with landline or WIFI coverage, to view and discuss the evolving plans, as the same unfold.

Other uses for the technology involve the management of the jobsite, workforce, equipment, and receipt and storage of materials.  Similarly, it is simple to create an apparently life-size, visual depiction of the site (or set of depictions, as the software can be programmed to show what the site, or any part of it, looks like, or will look like, from any desired viewpoint.

As costs drop, and interfaces become easier to use, Augmented Reality technology (which allows the user to maintain full awareness of the “real world,” with additional information superimposed) may, within a few short years, transform drastically the way that construction workers perform their tasks.

While still in its initial stages, the use of this technology allows workers, wearing “smart helmets,” to receive, wherever they may be, safety and other information, as appropriate, in light of the specific tasks they are performing.  The technology can also be used to transmit visuals of project drawings for remote viewing.

The technology also allows for the immediate, and detailed, transmittal of information regarding the locations of other workers, vehicles or heavy equipment, emergent dangers, and the like.

One area of special promise for Reality Technology is in safety training for the construction workforce.

As we have said in this space before, while OSHA, and an increasing number of governmental authorities, prescribe employee training in safety and OSHA compliance, a range of factors limit worker comprehension of safety training, and the practical effectiveness of even well-designed safety programs to bring about habitual employee compliance with the full range of OSHA mandates.

Both studies and experience have shown that conventional safety training — even when done by OSHA, or by well-paid professional consultants — is of limited effectiveness in making the precepts understood, and even less effective in fostering conformity with OSHA’s rules.

Part of the problem is linguistic.  Most training materials are in English (or Spanish) but dozens of other languages are spoken by construction workers in the greater New York City area.

Another difficulty is that safety trainers are exceedingly enamored of acronyms, buzzwords, and technical terminology, that too often goes right over the heads of the intended audience.  We read of one study, in which the OSHA 10-hour course was but faintly understood by graduate students in engineering at Tulane University.  If graduate students don’t assimilate most of what’s in the 10-hour course, chances are your construction workforce won’t, either.

It’s not just a question of construction workers, or many of them, being not the most highly-educated demographic. It’s also that adult learning happens in several different ways.  Some people learn just fine by listening. Others do better by reading, by watching, or by doing.  While professionally-produced, site-specific “full bells and whistles” VT safety tutorials may still be too costly for many smaller companies, we expect that, within a few years, most mid-size and even smaller companies will be doing part of the production work for VT tutorials in-house, with safety consultants adding some higher-end enhancements at moderate cost.

Not long from now, the VR job walk/safety tutorial is likely to become a standard feature of most larger projects.  Such an “immersive” experience, as a complement or alternative to more traditional training modalities, will enhance the effectiveness of companies’ safety programs, providing safety instruction, more extensive and accessible site views (including views of how the site will appear as the work progresses) and allowing virtual access, and teleconferencing concerning site conditions, from multiple sites all over the world.

A further advantage is that the workers’ “smart helmets” can display images that walk employees through safe and OSHA-compliant ways to perform key construction tasks, as the same are being performed.  Unlike comprehensive safety manuals, VR “apps” for the “smart helmet” or smartphone can readily and inexpensively be updated, as regulations change, and new ones are enacted.

The cost of deploying VR technology for safety training, design changes, logistical and other uses will be offset, at least in part, by reduced travel, executive and employee down-time, and administrative costs and other savings.

And, as the expanded use of “Reality Technology” for safety-related purposes begins to have a positive impact on the number of significant jobsite injuries, reductions in lost profits associated with construction accidents will be a further offset.  These include not only obvious, direct costs (medical, hospital/rehab expenses, higher insurance and workers’ comp premiums) but the hidden costs, including such items as lost productivity in responding to and investigating accidents, the cost to train replacement workers, legal expenses, etc.

The use of Virtual Reality in construction may look like an expensive gimmick for the moment, but soon it will be indispensable.  It’s a tool to look at for purposes including your safety program.

Perils of the “Unpreventable Employee Misconduct” Defense

It’s best to resist the urge to take an OSHA citation personally.  Face it:  construction, especially medium- and large-scale commercial projects, is a complicated, and inherently-dangerous, affair.  It’s one of the most hazardous industries in America, and thus one rightly targeted by OSHA for energetic enforcement.  Most sites have six, or ten, or more trades working at any given time, and the cast of characters is usually fluid as the project moves along.  Some subcontractors, particularly smaller ones, and non-union outfits, may not have dedicated safety staff.  If you’re the general contractor, you’re responsible for the OSHA sins of all.  And, while many OSHA construction standards are fairly obvious matters of common sense, others are somewhat technical, and can be difficult to teach to employees.

In short, if construction is your business, unless you’re one of those fly-by-night outfits that works in the dead of night to avoid OSHA inspectors (and the immigration authorities) you’re likely to get inspected once in a while.  And, even if, overall, you strive to work by OSHA’s rules, a sharp-eyed Compliance Officer can usually find something to cite you for.

We have encountered some construction business owners, however, who see a citation alleging one or more OSHA violations as a stain on their personal integrity.  Their first impulse is to file a Notice of Contest, and fight every citation item to the very death.  Which, more often than not, is a mistake (we have addressed matters to consider in deciding whether to contest an OSHA in a prior article).

Another knee-jerk reaction we have encountered is that the business owner who sees himself as safety-conscious, and whose company has even a lukewarm safety program, assumes that the fault must lie with one or more errant employees, rather than with ownership.  Such an owner, if he has heard the term, “unpreventable employee misconduct defense,” may seize upon this, as a promising means to contest the citation.

Given the cost of preparing and trying the trial of a contest proceeding, we counsel caution before going down this path.

To be sure, OSHA does recognize a defense based on unpreventable employee misconduct.  If you have a pending citation, and after reading this article you think you may have a basis to assert this defense, by all means discuss it with your attorney.

Be aware, however, that since unpreventable employee misconduct is an “affirmative defense,” you will have the burden to plead and prove every one of its four elements, by a preponderance of the evidence.

Also, contrary to a misconception held by many, you will not sustain “unpreventable employee misconduct” just by showing that you have a safety program, provided training, and one or more employees broke company rules, resulting in the OSHA violation.

Alas, the requirements to establish “unpreventable employee misconduct” are stringent, and if this is “all you’ve got” by way of grounds to have your citation vacated, you are likely to be better off trying to negotiate on the monetary penalties (and, perhaps, the severity level of the citation item[s]), showing contrition for the violation, providing some extra training on the issues relevant to the citation, and moving on.

The exigencies of the defense are illustrated by Secretary v. Empire Roofing Company of Georgia, Inc.  In that case, the employer was charged with violations related to the fall-protection standards, detected when OSHA Compliance Officers, driving past a jobsite in Georgia, espied two foremen and two laborers working about 40 feet above grade on the roof of a hotel under construction. without any visible means of fall protection.

To make a bad situation worse, the workers, when ordered by the OSHA inspectors to come down off the roof, chose not to tie off while descending from the roof in an aerial lift, resulting in an additional citation item.

To digress, we can’t tell you how many OSHA cases we have seen in which employers were cited for fall-protection violations seen by OSHA inspectors from the street.  Not only are falls the #1 cause of construction fatalities (and OSHA citations) but they are singularly-obvious violations as well.  While of course there do exist some complex construction standards, nearly anyone can foresee the probable result of falling from a 40’ rooftop.  The fall-protection standard is one you should never tolerate being violated on your jobsites.

In Empire Roofing’s contest of the citation, the ALJ, based on OSH Review Commission precedent, rejected the employer’s argument that traveling in the lift, to and from the work location, did not constitute “working from an aerial lift” within the meaning of the regulation.  The ALJ rejected, also, the employer’s contention that the laborers (who testified that they had removed their harnesses on the roof only as their shift was about to end, about 15 minutes before the OSHA inspectors’ arrival) had been induced by the inspectors to descend, without tarrying to put their harnesses back on, and tie off to the lift.

The employer in Empire Roofing asserted, but failed to sustain, the “unpreventable employee misconduct” defense, which is recognized when “the actions of the employee were a departure from a uniformly and effectively communicated and enforced work rule.”

In order to successfully establish this defense, the respondent employer must show that it has (1) established work rules designed to prevent the violation; (2) adequately communicated those rules to its employees; (3) taken steps to discover violations; and (4) effectively enforced the rules, when violations have been discovered.  More rigorous proof is needed where, as in Empire Roofing, one or more supervisors were involved in the conduct constituting the violation(s).

The ALJ in Empire Roofing found that the employer had succeeded in showing three of the four elements of the defense.  First, it showed that it had rules addressing the need for fall protection while working at elevations above 6 feet, or in an aerial lift.  It established, too, that by various means (new hire training, a full-time safety manager, training in Spanish as well as English, toolbox talks, etc.) it strove to ensure that safety rules were communicated to its employees.

The third element — steps to detect violations of the employer’s safety rules — was also found to have been established.  The employer’s service manager visited the worksite at least three times a week, and an outside consultant made 10 random, unannounced inspections per month.

Despite all of the foregoing, the “unpreventable employee misconduct” defense failed, and the citations were upheld. The ALJ found that the defense was effectively negated by the participation in the misconduct of two foremen. In so doing, the ALJ cited Commission precedent for the proposition that “a supervisor’s breach of a company safety policy is strong evidence that implementation of the policy is lax.”

Although the employer’s “broad description of [its] enforcement efforts suggest[ed] a robust program,” the ALJ found, the heightened scrutiny required, due to the supervisors’ participation in the misconduct, uncovered failures and inconsistencies that the ALJ found negated the defense.  For example, the “job inspection check list” for the day of the inspection found that the foreman had checked “yes” for the use of a safety monitor, although the testimony was consistent that a personal fall arrest system was the form of fall protection used.

Another example was that one of the laborers was found to have signed a document indicating that he understood the hazards of chemicals being used on the Project.  This document, however, was in English, and the laborer who signed it did not know how to read English.  On the whole, the ALJ found the employer’s evidence of effective enforcement “unconvincing.”

Thus, if “unpreventable employee misconduct” is the linchpin of your defense to an OSHA citation, you and your attorney should scrutinize it closely, before going forward with a contest proceeding, because the ALJ certainly will, and good intentions and desultory efforts will not sustain it.